Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is their any need to mention race of suspicious person? Facebook..

184 replies

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 18:33

I'm on our local community facebook group and some lady has mentioned that some black man was trying to offer her daughter sweets and was offering her back to his house.

I could understand if she had a real description but you can't just warn people of a black man? People are going to be terrified if they see a black man now.

AIBU or is that an ok way of describing someone to watch out for?

Not trying to cause a war here just curious on what people think.

OP posts:
Heiferr · 16/10/2021 01:56

I'm not understanding what's so difficult to understand here so it can only be wilful ignorance.

Is it ok to use a persons skin colour when describing them? Yes

Is it ok to use ONLY the skin colour of a person when describing someone that the community should be wary of? No

Very straightforward.

puddlebubble · 16/10/2021 01:51

I understand your point of concern OP, completely. It is however a young child, if I say a white, that is 87 percent of Britain, if I say black that is 4 percent. That is their reality, and it is very simple. But the fact that she couldn't discern any other features of the person is an issue if the child could see a similar white man doing the same and give extra information. But can she? Is it the child or the parents? It was relevant to that child.

A woman was pushed into the path of a subway train last week in NYC and suffered serious enough injuries. They were looking for her attacker on bulletins and offered up everything that she was wearing beforehand, carrying and age, height... never once mentioned her race or skin colour. 13 million people, the skin colour is a major descriptor and one they are obviously afraid to include now. (She was found and charged). There is a middle ground.

tiredandfrumpy · 16/10/2021 01:14

@MrsSkylerWhite I never said you did hate black people. No your not understanding I am not talking about police reports. You always tell them of the race of the person. I don't want to keep repeating myself it's getting boring.

@YearsSinceISawYou your missing the point too. No one cares about being described as black all I am trying to so say is if you are warning people of a suspicious PERSON THEIR SKIN COLOUR ALONE IS NOT SATISFACTORY AS A DESCRIPTION OF THE INDIVIDUAL.

I am not replying to this thread anymore it's exhausting.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 16/10/2021 01:12

YANBU. The vilification of black men is such that I've spent countless hours lecturing my nephews on how to conduct themselves in all manner of situations.

YearsSinceISawYou · 16/10/2021 01:07

Being black is nothing to be ashamed of and therefore it is not an insult to describe someone as black if they are.

The way some carry on, you would swear that to describe someone who is black as black is an insult.

Thank you very sodding much!

MrsSkylerWhite · 16/10/2021 01:01

I absolutely do not hate black people, tiredandfrumpy. I don’t hate anyone. Most people don’t because they’re not ignorant. Am I/we supposed to dodge the question though, if I/we are assaulted by someone who is black and are asked for a description of the assailant.
I’m sorry but I just don’t understand how stating fact is offensive ?

wafflyversatile · 16/10/2021 00:55

If it was a white man they probably would have just said a man.

From a warning the locals point of view the important part is someone was approaching children offering sweets and for parents to remind their children not to go with strangers not what colour the man was.

tiredandfrumpy · 16/10/2021 00:53

@MrsSkylerWhite my whole point of this thread was that I wouldn't run to warn a community about a black man if that was the only description I had off him. Facebook is already full of hate and this is fuelling a fire giving people more of a reason to be racist and wary of black people. Including his race with other details off him yes that's fine I wouldn't even give it a second thought.

As I said it's caused nothing but racist comments it wasn't helpful in the slightest.

It's doesn't sit well with me that parents are going to be warning their children now of local black men in the area. We live in a diverse area they can't be worrying about every black man that's comes in there proximity.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 16/10/2021 00:49

MrsSkylerWhite

Today 00:46 EmeraldShamrock

Why is that in any way, shape or form offensive?
Because it is "white woman“

Actually, that’s offensive. What’s wrong with describing a black person as black?

MrsSkylerWhite · 16/10/2021 00:47

Today 00:46 EmeraldShamrock

Why is that in any way, shape or form offensive?
Because it is "white woman".

Don’t be ridiculous.

EmeraldShamrock · 16/10/2021 00:46

Why is that in any way, shape or form offensive?
Because it is "white woman".

EmeraldShamrock · 16/10/2021 00:44

I think it's ridiculous that you are more worried about how a potential predator will feel about being described by his race than for the safety of children in your community.
Can you really not see a problem with the description.
I would definitely describe someone by their skin colour in this situation including peach/white but I'd include their hairstyle, approximate height, clothing, approximate age.
Around here the mysterious sweet giver is usually a EE man in a van, stories that don't make the papers not even the local rag or involve the police only FB.
Not saying your neighbours experience isn't real.

MrsSkylerWhite · 16/10/2021 00:41

I really don’t understand why you would think I was bating the OP, tiredandfrumpy? (if you meant me, apologies if not).

Skin colour is a pretty basic part of someone’s description. Isn’t that just obvious? Height, hair, skin colour, dress?

Why is that in any way, shape or form offensive?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/10/2021 00:33

@Why2why

It’s really not though.

“Suspicious person offered candy to local child today, male, young, he was wearing red shoes, grey hoodie, dark hair, brown eyes”

Or
“ Suspicious person offered candy to local child today, male, young, black, he was wearing red shoes, grey hoodie, dark hair, brown eyes”

Or
“ Suspicious person offered candy to local child today, male, young, white, he was wearing red shoes, grey hoodie, dark hair, brown eyes”

Now with each description, which ones will be most helpful?

Substitute “Bev” with “Suspicious person” and it’s the same thing.

tiredandfrumpy · 16/10/2021 00:30

@Why2why im going to bed 🤣 i am not entertaining this one.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 16/10/2021 00:26

Today 00:22 tiredandfrumpy

@MrsSkylerWhite it's not good enough and if you think it is you need help.“

Don’t be ridiculous. If he was white, would you have a problem with that description? A dwarf? 6ft 5? One leg?

I don’t need help at all. If someone who is doing something dodgy is black, white or any shade in between then the victim needs to describe them.

Why2why · 16/10/2021 00:25

@tiredandfrumpy can’t you see this person is bating you?

tiredandfrumpy · 16/10/2021 00:22

@MrsSkylerWhite it's not good enough and if you think it is you need help.

OP posts:
Why2why · 16/10/2021 00:19

@saltinesandcoffeecups

Have you ever watched someone tie themselves up in knots trying not to mention race?

“Go talk to Bev, she’ll have the answer”
“Which one is Bev?”
“Umm she’s the older one…I mean the one who works with Bob, umm she wore a green sweater last week…you know Bev?!”
“Oh, Bev from accounting “
“No the other Bev”
“There are 3 Bev’s that work here which one?”
“You sat next to her at all hands meeting 2 years ago, she won that award about something”
“I still don’t know which one you’re talking about”
“Bev! She’s got 2 kids and a ferret, oh, yeah and she normally fields these questions, dark hair, she wears it pulled back, she wears fancy earrings, has a mole on her left hand, she’s about ‘yeah tall’, wears brown shoes most days”

It’s actually kind of comical to watch unfold in real life. Seriously, I’m pretty sure Bev knows she is a different race, it’s not going to be a surprise. Just as it wouldn’t be a surprise if all the Bev’s were the same race and you described the one who wears glasses to differentiate them.

But this is very, very different Confused
MrsSkylerWhite · 16/10/2021 00:19

Today 00:09 tiredandfrumpy

@MrsSkylerWhite let me guess you think that's a good enough description“

Oh don’t be precious. It’s a bloody good start.

Lavanderrose · 16/10/2021 00:19

I agree with you op, their post was lazy and inconsiderate and they should have stated estimated age, height, clothing, etr not just the persons race.

Why2why · 16/10/2021 00:17

[quote tiredandfrumpy]@Why2why to be honest I expected much worse than this. Some people are open at looking at things in a different light some just aren't and will close it down right away. Yes I could go to an all black platform where we would all agree and be disgusted but what change will come from that. It's good to have discussions.

[/quote]
Is it your job to point out the obvious that there isn’t equality?

How can any reasonable person not see that simply saying a black man cast suspicion on all black men and given the bias of society all black men in the area will be treated as pariahs.

If it was a white man, he would not have simply been described as white.

The problem this also creates is that many have a false sense of security around white men vs black men. However, more often than not, women are assaulted by someone other than a black man. So whilst they might be busy being scared of all black men, they may be lured into thinking it is safer to trust a man who isn’t black.

Changechangychange · 16/10/2021 00:12

We had a spate of “sightings” end of last summer term. Police ended up releasing a statement, which they asked the school to forward to parents, saying it was all made up.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/10/2021 00:10

Have you ever watched someone tie themselves up in knots trying not to mention race?

“Go talk to Bev, she’ll have the answer”
“Which one is Bev?”
“Umm she’s the older one…I mean the one who works with Bob, umm she wore a green sweater last week…you know Bev?!”
“Oh, Bev from accounting “
“No the other Bev”
“There are 3 Bev’s that work here which one?”
“You sat next to her at all hands meeting 2 years ago, she won that award about something”
“I still don’t know which one you’re talking about”
“Bev! She’s got 2 kids and a ferret, oh, yeah and she normally fields these questions, dark hair, she wears it pulled back, she wears fancy earrings, has a mole on her left hand, she’s about ‘yeah tall’, wears brown shoes most days”

It’s actually kind of comical to watch unfold in real life. Seriously, I’m pretty sure Bev knows she is a different race, it’s not going to be a surprise. Just as it wouldn’t be a surprise if all the Bev’s were the same race and you described the one who wears glasses to differentiate them.

Peoniesandpeaches · 16/10/2021 00:10

@Zarene

We have lots of this on NextDoor.

I’ve never, ever seen a post saying ‘White man acting suspiciously’.

Which leads me to conclude that white mens’ behaviour is less likely to be seen as suspicious, and/ or people are using ‘black’ as a warning not as a description.

So yes, I suspect the majority of people posting in this way are racist.

I agree or they omit the race if it’s a white man as if it’s the default. Even if they provided one more piece of description like wearing white trainers or close cropped hair it wouldn’t feel as racist. On my local page we also get posts warning of traveler sightings that are really loaded with bigotry.