Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is their any need to mention race of suspicious person? Facebook..

184 replies

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 18:33

I'm on our local community facebook group and some lady has mentioned that some black man was trying to offer her daughter sweets and was offering her back to his house.

I could understand if she had a real description but you can't just warn people of a black man? People are going to be terrified if they see a black man now.

AIBU or is that an ok way of describing someone to watch out for?

Not trying to cause a war here just curious on what people think.

OP posts:
Danzig · 16/10/2021 10:05

@AlfonsoTheDinosaur

OP: AIBU? MN: Yes, you are. OP: No I'm not.
Except from all the people agreeing with the OP.
Lokdok · 16/10/2021 10:01

Don’t be stupid. If the man was 6’10 wouldn’t you expect it to be mentioned they were tall in a description? Why leave you vital info that can help you recognise them. It’s not offensive at all, in fact if anything it would be more offensive to leave it out. (I am
Black).

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 16/10/2021 10:00

OP: AIBU?
MN: Yes, you are.
OP: No I'm not.

mustlovegin · 16/10/2021 09:04

stories like this go round on our local FB group quite often and then a message 48 hours later saying that actually it didn't happen

Well, that's awful, but it doesn't mean all incidents should be just ignored

mustlovegin · 16/10/2021 09:02

What victim?

Would you also have downplayed her victimhood if the little girl was non white and the man with the sweets was white?

Porcupineintherough · 16/10/2021 08:52

@mustlovegin cant answer for this case but stories like this go round on our local FB group quite often and then a message 48 hours later saying that actually it didnt happen. Latest one was about a woman being attacked and chased in the local woods. That ended up being a woman being suspicious of "a man in the bushes" - who turned out to be picking litter as part of the local environment groups work day. No attack, no chase, and he turned out to be white which was not how the story was originally reported.

torquewench · 16/10/2021 08:50

I once had to point out someone in my office to someone who was visiting from another branch. The person they were looking for was the only black person in the room. I dithered about how to describe her to the visitor despite the simplest way being blatantly obvious. Oddly enough I found I had no hesitation pointing out the only redheaded person in the room.

MissKeithsNeice · 16/10/2021 08:41

@mustlovegin

Why is everyone ignoring the fact that the person on FB completely made up the story?

Why would you not believe a victim?

What victim?
MissKeithsNeice · 16/10/2021 08:40

And obviously its so much more racist for being completely made up. Scarily so tbh.

Its also slightly terrifying that so many MNers read the OP and their first thoughts weren't pity/anger/disbelief at the twisted, bored twat who posted this on FB.

mustlovegin · 16/10/2021 08:38

Why is everyone ignoring the fact that the person on FB completely made up the story?

Why would you not believe a victim?

MissKeithsNeice · 16/10/2021 08:34

Why is everyone ignoring the fact that the person on FB completely made up the story? Hmm

Its literally the most obvious, biggest pile of bullshit ever.

Porcupineintherough · 16/10/2021 08:29

Fine. Then maybe dont claim that the UK is one of the most inclusive countries in the world, when really you mean in Europe. The world's a right big place.

EarPlugAfficionado · 16/10/2021 08:25

@Porcupineintherough

Hi, I’m afraid my knowledge doesn’t stretch past Europe on this subject and I wouldn’t want to assume. Hopefully someone with more expertise will come along to further this discussion.

Porcupineintherough · 16/10/2021 08:23

@EarPlugAfficionado those are all European countries, now do Africa or South America

EarPlugAfficionado · 16/10/2021 08:20

By all means @Porcupineintherough

“ As Max Fisher demonstrated at The Washington Post in 2013, it’s possible to roughly compare levels of racial tolerance by focusing on one question in the multinational World Values Survey that asks respondents which sorts of people they wouldn’t want to have as neighbors, and offers “people of another race” as an option. By this metric, intolerance appears more widespread in Hungary and Romania than in Spain, Germany, the United Kingdom, and much of Scandinavia, but levels of intolerance are higher in France than in Hungary or Romania. Tolerance levels seem to be about the same in Poland, Ukraine, and the Czech Republic as in Italy or Finland.”

www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theatlantic.com/amp/article/410800/

SaltySheepdog · 16/10/2021 08:17

Could have equally been a bald white man, a ginger haired woman,

Porcupineintherough · 16/10/2021 08:14

@EarPlugAfficionado of please back up that claim with some data.

Siameasy · 16/10/2021 08:13

It's likely race would also have been mentioned if it had been a white man looking through the window in country where the majority was non-white, as it would have been unusual?

I can’t think of somewhere in the world where white people are a minority and where white men are stigmatised as aggressive and dangerous resulting in non-white people (including the police) being scared of “whites” and over-reacting to them. That’s why it’s irresponsible and I believe, deliberate. Being white is not loaded in the same way.

Its not what you say it’s how you say it.

EarPlugAfficionado · 16/10/2021 08:12

@Skittles98

The UK is far more racist than I imagined. Jesus, this thread is unbelievable.

If the scenario was true, which I highly doubt because people just post these ridiculous suspicions for attention, how the hell does it even help anyone? Surely children should be wary of anyone offering them sweets, no matter their skin colour??

If another black man offered a different child sweets, it could be a completely different man?

You people who don't get this need to have a good look at yourselves. You're all racists and the reason this country is rife with inequality.

The U.K. is one of the most inclusive countries in the world. Try going to Spain or one of the Baltics and you’ll soon see this.
EarPlugAfficionado · 16/10/2021 08:10

@Zarene

We have lots of this on NextDoor.

I’ve never, ever seen a post saying ‘White man acting suspiciously’.

Which leads me to conclude that white mens’ behaviour is less likely to be seen as suspicious, and/ or people are using ‘black’ as a warning not as a description.

So yes, I suspect the majority of people posting in this way are racist.

Not true at all.
mustlovegin · 16/10/2021 07:56

Perhaps the FB post should have read 'the suspect is a black man. Apologies, but I have no further details at this stage'? Would it have made it sound better?

She described the man as a black man. That’s it! How useful is that information and what was the motive behind it?

There was no motive. It was all the information the daughter had provided

she woke up to see a black man looking through the window

It's likely race would also have been mentioned if it had been a white man looking through the window in country where the majority was non-white, as it would have been unusual?

A woman was pushed into the path of a subway train last week in NYC and suffered serious enough injuries. They were looking for her attacker on bulletins and offered up everything that she was wearing beforehand, carrying and age, height... never once mentioned her race or skin colour. 13 million people, the skin colour is a major descriptor and one they are obviously afraid to include now

This is awful. We absolutely cannot get into a situation where offenders remain at large because victims cannot provide (or the police cannot publish) basic and critical details of their appearance

Kanaloa · 16/10/2021 07:53

@Roguehair

OP I share your frustration with some of the responses on this thread. What is it that people aren’t getting? She described the man as a black man. That’s it! How useful is that information and what was the motive behind it? It’s almost like she felt that it was all she needed to say, you know “a black man, nudge nudge wink wink. We all know what they’re like”. (See also Eastern European). Nobody is saying that you aren’t allowed to mention skin colour, just that if he had been a white man that wouldn’t even had been mentioned, other descriptors would be used. Why couldn’t she have used other descriptors as well as skin colour? What use is just skin colour? All black men are the same are they?
The child may not have been able to remember or explain any other identifiers. Not many small children are likely to say ‘yes it was a Caucasian male, late 30s to early 40s, green eyes, about 6’2.’ But they could say ‘he had brown skin/he had long hair’ etc.

And nobody is suggesting all black men are the same, what an odd suggestion. Simply that in this case a woman has suggested her son was approached inappropriately by man who happened to be black.

Siameasy · 16/10/2021 07:42

People ought to be responsible in how they mention someone’s race if the person is black because society is biased against black people particularly young black males. As I said earlier, the papers used to report like this in the 80s - “she woke up to see a black man looking through the window” - and it cannot have failed to have conditioned minds.m ie that a black man is an extra scary sort of man.

Roguehair · 16/10/2021 06:52

OP I share your frustration with some of the responses on this thread. What is it that people aren’t getting? She described the man as a black man. That’s it! How useful is that information and what was the motive behind it? It’s almost like she felt that it was all she needed to say, you know “a black man, nudge nudge wink wink. We all know what they’re like”. (See also Eastern European). Nobody is saying that you aren’t allowed to mention skin colour, just that if he had been a white man that wouldn’t even had been mentioned, other descriptors would be used. Why couldn’t she have used other descriptors as well as skin colour? What use is just skin colour? All black men are the same are they?

Skittles98 · 16/10/2021 02:00

The UK is far more racist than I imagined. Jesus, this thread is unbelievable.

If the scenario was true, which I highly doubt because people just post these ridiculous suspicions for attention, how the hell does it even help anyone? Surely children should be wary of anyone offering them sweets, no matter their skin colour??

If another black man offered a different child sweets, it could be a completely different man?

You people who don't get this need to have a good look at yourselves. You're all racists and the reason this country is rife with inequality.