Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is their any need to mention race of suspicious person? Facebook..

184 replies

tiredandfrumpy · 15/10/2021 18:33

I'm on our local community facebook group and some lady has mentioned that some black man was trying to offer her daughter sweets and was offering her back to his house.

I could understand if she had a real description but you can't just warn people of a black man? People are going to be terrified if they see a black man now.

AIBU or is that an ok way of describing someone to watch out for?

Not trying to cause a war here just curious on what people think.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Porcupineintherough · 17/10/2021 19:31

@mustlovegin that's right. The idea being that the gradual drip, drip, drip of, say, anti semitism or misogyny, add up and create a hostile and oppressive climate for victims which can be as damaging over time as outright acts of aggression or discrimination.

mustlovegin · 17/10/2021 18:53

More of a microagression

What exactly is a microagression? The term itself is an oxymoron - micro is something really minuscule, but still worthy of getting worked up about?

mustlovegin · 17/10/2021 18:50

the Financial Times

Off topic, but what's happened to the finance industry that has gone so terribly and unexpectedly woke? The Financial Times used to be quite an informative newspaper, not any more it seems

Beefmeupscotty · 17/10/2021 13:54

@MrsSkylerWhite

Tiredandfrumpy

I’m curious to know if you are black?

Comments from black posters are telling everyone that to describe them as black is not racist or in any way offensive.
Perhaps people should listen to them.

Are they????

Black as part of a description? Fine.
Black as the only "description"? Not ok. Definitely offensive because our skin colour is not the only thing that defines us. Racist? Potentially but not necessarily, depending on context. More of a microagression.

That is the general consensus.

Xenia · 17/10/2021 13:30

Yes, depends on common sense and context.

If you are trying to find a lost child in the village and it is the only black child who lives there I bet most of us would want the colour mentioned.

Apparently yesterday the only newspaper not to mention that the MP's alleged killer is a black Somali "terrorist" ( who appears to have planned the attack in advance) was the Financial Times which does not surprise me (I subscribe to the FT and its editorial line on these issues is utterly non-diverse and very woke). Today they have now added the description of the suspect.

MrsSkylerWhite · 17/10/2021 11:52

Tiredandfrumpy

I’m curious to know if you are black?

Comments from black posters are telling everyone that to describe them as black is not racist or in any way offensive.
Perhaps people should listen to them.

puddlebubble · 16/10/2021 13:45

@Heiferr None. Because as you've pointed out, we're talking about a young child. Would I then as an adult with an ounce of sense go posting that limited description all over Facebook? No, there would be no need because an adult with even the most basic understanding of how the world works would be aware what the consequences of that would be. Not that you'd know it from the racism deniers on this thread.

You have a very valid point and I do understand OP's point also which is the same and as I have said a few times now to people who obviously have not taken the time to read the full thread and want to stir division from a personal point of view.

It does depend on the situation and the population of where you live. 87% of British people are white. 4% are black, that is enough to narrow the field for a perpetrator. If it was a white man, the child being 4/5 isn't really going to add much either to pin it down, beard/hair/clothes.. all changeable within an hour, skin colour is a valuable descriptor?

But I understand it goes to racial profiling, I do get that, I don't really know what the answer is. I am in an area where it is white only and not in the uk and there is a similar circumstance with kids not being particularly safe. The perpetrators are all white, and so the descriptors to narrow it down are age and height which really does not help at all.

puddlebubble · 16/10/2021 13:30

@Porcupineintherough yes, still haven't read it have you

Why2why · 16/10/2021 12:27

@Toddlerteaplease

I once reported a really noisy party to the police. (It was ridiculously loud). The police asked for a description and the only thing I could think of was that they were all black. I felt really bad about it!
Why was their race relevant in that instance? They were people making noise and it’s the noise the police should be looking for. If there were white people in the mix, what would you have said? Would you have just said a bunch of people, maybe young people? What would you have said. Were there mixed race people or did all you see is black people?

Honestly puzzled by the relevance of their race and how you determined that there were no mixed race or other ethnicities there.

Toddlerteaplease · 16/10/2021 12:09

I once reported a really noisy party to the police. (It was ridiculously loud). The police asked for a description and the only thing I could think of was that they were all black. I felt really bad about it!

Cuddlyrottweiler · 16/10/2021 12:07

I thought I was going to say YABU but actually in this case I'd say it's coming from a racist place. I doubt she'd have said "some white man" if there'd been an actual description then obviously skin colour is a key identifier but skin colour alone is not an identifier.

Why2why · 16/10/2021 12:06

The black man must have others things to him beside the colour of his skin. Did he have hair, was it close shave, tall, short, old, young?

Just identify his race only is ridiculous unless you think it’s okay for all black men to be under suspicion. By all means mention his race but if that’s all you can see and take note of, then there is a problem. One black man is not all black men.

I am fairly sure that if it was a white man, we would have been told more than just “a white man”. We would have heard about his hair colour, or his height, etc. We would be told a young blond man, etc.

Heiferr · 16/10/2021 12:05

[quote puddlebubble]**@Heiferr* Is it ok to use ONLY the skin colour of a person when describing someone that the community should be wary of? No*

Absolutely yes when the person describing is 4 or 5 years of age and the population is beyond heavily white. Of course it is ok. What 'other' terms are you going to give them?'[/quote]
None. Because as you've pointed out, we're talking about a young child.

Would I then as an adult with an ounce of sense go posting that limited description all over Facebook? No, there would be no need because an adult with even the most basic understanding of how the world works would be aware what the consequences of that would be. Not that you'd know it from the racism deniers on this thread.

Porcupineintherough · 16/10/2021 12:04

Of course you'd tell the police, but theyd be (hopefully) trying to find the perpetrator/suspect. The question is what are the general public supposed to do with this information? How does it help them keep their children safe?

lovescaca · 16/10/2021 12:00

So if all the info they have is the person is black they shouldn't warn others? Can you report the person is black to the police? If you dnt have any more info should you just let it slide?

Feedingthebirds1 · 16/10/2021 11:57

I think this is about difference, and we're talking about a child (age unspecified). If the child was black, but the offender (if he exists) was white, I suggest that white man would have been part of their description and may well have been said on Fb.

Porcupineintherough · 16/10/2021 11:54

@puddlebubble this isnt a criticism of a small child ffs! It's asking questions about how useful that particular descriptor is when pasted all over Facebook as a warning.

puddlebubble · 16/10/2021 11:49

@MamsellMarie again not in a society where approx 87% are white and the child is 4 or 5. Cop on.

MamsellMarie · 16/10/2021 11:46

Just to say a black man is a bit pathetic.

You wouldn't say a white man, partly because if someone said a man was at the gate, in most places there are many more white men so people would assume 'a man at the gate' is white.

But just to say black man when there are many but not predominantly black men is a bit off - I would think any description would include more info - a black man with a blue jacket, or a white man with a scottish accent, or a white man with a beard. So I would lean to saying it is racist.

EmeraldShamrock · 16/10/2021 11:40

Except from all the people agreeing with the OP.
Exactly.

picklemewalnuts · 16/10/2021 11:06

I see lots of posts about suspicious behaviour (admin a community page).
They often include video from ring doorbells etc. The videos get posted regardless of the skin colour of the person. The sex is mentioned if it's a female. They generally only mention race if they are black/eastern European looking and don't mention it if the person is white. They tend to mention if the person is middle aged or older.

It's because in this area, suspicious people are generally younger white males. Females, older and black descriptors are used as they are less usual in such situations.
It's not bias against people of colour, women or older people.

Of course bias exists- but not in this situation.

puddlebubble · 16/10/2021 11:06

@Porcupineintherough I have already said I understand the OP's point. RTFT. I can't bear it when people just don't fucking read what was said and want to proselytize. READ IT.

Porcupineintherough · 16/10/2021 10:38

So @puddlebubble if youd read that Facebook post how would you use the information given to protect your child? Would you:

  • tell them to beware of all black men?
  • tell them to beware of all black men offering them sweets?
-tell them to beware of all men offering them sweets?

If you spotted a black man in the neighbourhood the next day would you have been extra wary because he might be the one?

puddlebubble · 16/10/2021 10:23

@Heiferr Is it ok to use ONLY the skin colour of a person when describing someone that the community should be wary of? No

Absolutely yes when the person describing is 4 or 5 years of age and the population is beyond heavily white. Of course it is ok. What 'other' terms are you going to give them?'

georgarina · 16/10/2021 10:13

If he is white you could maybe also point out his hair and eye colour, if black then you don't need to say 'black man with black hair' etc. Also it was a child so maybe she didn't remember how long his hair was or anything else.

If they were white I would expect to hear 'white man around (age)' with other identifying details if there were any. It's not racist to mention race.