Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is it with twins?

117 replies

FabacrombieAndBitch · 15/10/2021 16:55

I have 6 month old twins. Everyone with almost no exception tells me I need to separate them at school. These aren't even parents of twins either, just random people
AIBU to tell them to just bugger off 🤬

OP posts:
Africa2go · 15/10/2021 20:36

God, this winds me up so much Angry

What is it with twins that everyone feels they can give "twin advice" even though they've never had twins / been a twin. Once having a friend who was a twin or twin cousins once removed makes you an expert on how they should be treated at school Hmm?!

Keeping twins in the same class DOES NOT mean you don't want them to be treated as individuals. Similarly, separating them DOES NOT mean you'll ruin the twin bond forever or they'll grow into independent children.

And god knows why anyone is commenting on that when they're 6 months old Shock.

You'll know what's appropriate for your children as they grow up and no-one else's opinion (other than their father Grin) is relevant!

Rant over Smile. Twin and parent of twins Wink

Blondeshavemorefun · 15/10/2021 20:18

Tbh twins do tend to do better when split in primary as they learn to make own friends

But also much harder to split at 11 if diff sec schools

Primary schools usually suggest to parents they split their Twins if more than one class but obv will support parents view

We have 3 sets in our year. 2 have been split. One is together at insistence of mum

RoyKentsHairyBack · 15/10/2021 20:17

My aunts were kept together. My bils were separated (they were a little pair of shits and encouraged each other). My cousins twins are together as are my friends twins.

Mine were together until y4 then friendship issues and Dd2 struggling a bit socially meant we tried to separate them which had mixed success. Dd1 is less academic but more social and thrives without feeling people compare her. Dd2 sort of likes the academic comparison when they are together (as she does better) but has lost too many friends to her sister.

They are yr 7 now and separate but have a similar friend group plus Dd2 has mates through her sport. Both doing well on both social and academic basis. Bicker like a pair of dogs but still very close too.

We roll with the punches tbh.

NumberTheory · 15/10/2021 19:53

I have twins.

One thing I found was that they spend so much time together it's really hard for them to branch out to find their own niches if they aren't in separate classes and easier for one to fall under the other's shadow. It's easy to think of them as needing each other more than other siblings, but there's no truth in that. They have all the faculties and abilities of other children, and the same need for diversity of experience and opportunity if they're going to find their own footing.

I've also found that teachers and other kids parents (but not so much other kids) tend to treat them as a natural pair. Mine are currently in the same class as the school is one form entry. At first I had to constantly remind the teachers not to pair them up together and not to put them at the same reading/math/whatever table if their scores didn't indicate they should. I found this a bit odd as when talking to the school before they went I was assured they wouldn't lump them in together by default. But few of their class teachers seemed to have had that memo.

Of course everyone's different. There may be some for whom the world of school is a bit much on their own. Kids who otherwise wouldn't thrive at school. They may do better together (or one of them may do better) than if they were on their own. And for many kids, maybe the majority, it won't make much difference in the long run anyway.

What YADNBU about is that 6 months is not the time to be considering this.

DeliaOwens · 15/10/2021 19:46

I have twins. We did not split them in Junior school as Montessori pre-school told us they always had separate friends so didn't cling to each other.

They enjoy being in each other's company but have separate friendship groups.

You know your children best-ignore the armchair experts!

ThirdElephant · 15/10/2021 19:44

[quote FabacrombieAndBitch]@Icytundra I don't mean now! But people tell me I need to do it when they are 5. Why would I need to split them up? It will be all they know![/quote]
We usually split twins in classes because:

  1. It allows them to develop and be recognised as individual people rather than just being one of 'the twins'
  2. It gives them different friendship groups, meaning they can fall out with their sibling and have a friend to confide in about it.
  3. If there's a dominant twin, it forces the other one to be more independent and encourages them to begin to trust themselves more, rather than allowing their twin to speak for them all the time.
quitefranklyabsurd · 15/10/2021 19:40

When you have twins there is always someone close by with an unwanted opinion.

My twins - I always thought one would benefit from being separated the other from staying together - they go to a one form entry so we didn’t have to decide!

OxanaVorontsova · 15/10/2021 19:39

Meant to add, people do seem to think they’re entitled to comment or opine on twins more than singletons.

Rrrob · 15/10/2021 19:39

Bizarre that they say this now. My twins are 18months and no one has ever said this to me. I get plenty of are they twins, are they identical, double trouble etc. though!

OxanaVorontsova · 15/10/2021 19:39

My twins are now 18, I’ve always let them do their own thing. At primary it was single form entry so they were together, with two other sets in their class. At secondary there were some twins who wanted to be in the same form but mine didn’t. Is at sixth form they will travel in the same bus but walk to the bus stop separately! They’d still defend each other no matter what though. They are their own people, and that has nothing to do with their class in early years education.

Cantthinkofaname21 · 15/10/2021 19:34

Far too early to be even thinking about that! Random why people feel the need to pass on ‘advice’
I went to school with twins they had the same friends at school so would be unfair to have split them - but they are very different people!! Other friends set of boy/girl twin and the girl went onto marry her brothers best friend!! They had different friends, and completely different academically so took different paths in school and uni.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 15/10/2021 19:30

Most parents of twins I know have had them in separate classes. One mum didn’t (kept them together) and by yr 6 regretted it - they’re yr8 now so I’m sure it no longer matters what happened in primary! I say the mum, because I’ve no idea of her partner’s view on it.

DroopyClematis · 15/10/2021 19:28

I was a TA in a primary school, most years in KS1 and , although it was advised to split twins, triplets, if parents demanded ( and I used that word deliberately) then they'd be put together in the same class.

It did cause some issues but they were generally easy to deal with.
Most parents wanted twins/triplets separated.

Had fraternal twins in a class once. Both had behavioural difficulties that involved stopping teaching. It was very difficult.

TheUndeadLovelinessOfDemons · 15/10/2021 19:26

I've been to school with 3 sets of twins, DS1 has been to school with 1, none of them were separated. With one set, it wouldn't have made any difference anyway, as they did their homework separately and still got identical answers.

esloquehay · 15/10/2021 19:25

My twins are non-identical girls, who will be starting single form entry next September. They have a great bond, but are like chalk and cheese, and have different friends already. One is blonde, the other brunette, so people don't treat them as one entity, thankfully.

RandomUsernameHere · 15/10/2021 18:46

Do they mean separate them into different schools or different classes? Either way it's none of their business!
My two did a mixture of different classes/same class to begin with (this was an option as school mixed the classes up every year). Now at year 3 they're in different schools, but only because they've gone to single sex schools. I really don't think it's a big deal whether they're together or not though.

Notafootballfan · 15/10/2021 18:26

I'm a twin and I love my sister with all my heart, but if I'd have had twins I would have dressed them differently and if possible put them in separate classes. They are individuals in their own right, not part of a set.
I'm probably projecting my own experience here. We are still known 50 years later as 'the twins'. One of us is described as the quiet one, the other the huffy one. The one with the fatter face.
Our teacher who couldn't tell the difference, to hide his embarrassment meshed our two names together and called us the two Jans.

TillyTopper · 15/10/2021 18:26

I have twins, they are now 19. I split them up deliberately so they could be individuals and form their own friendships and relationships. Otherwise they can rely on each other too much and create a co-dependency imo.

Battleofwhocouldcareless · 15/10/2021 18:22

The school I teach in is one form entry so all twins stay in the same class, there is no choice. They will have a very special relationship and school may spilt them up but it doesn't have to happen. Just ignore!

Kb2942 · 15/10/2021 18:20

There's twins at my kids school. One school in the village, one class per year group so impossible to separate. My close friend has twins, boy and girl who are always together at school and it works well.

Not a parent of twins but I wouldn't agree with separating myself (but what do I know...) but secondary school might be different. At my secondary school there was twins girls who were glued at the hip and another set - a boy and a girl who I didn't even know were twins until year 11 - it wasn't made obvious. With different sets or lessons more likely to be separate. I would definitely keep them together at primary.

Gilly12345 · 15/10/2021 18:17

I can’t believe that people are telling you how to raise your children.

I have twins and they went to the same schools and university (different degrees) and are perfectly fine.

middleager · 15/10/2021 18:16

I was somewhat strong armed by school into separating my none IDs in year 1.

The teacher called me in for a meeting - failing to mention that the HT, and 2 other teachers would be there, all stating that it's best to separate twins.

I reluctantly took their advice. I don't know if it made any difference at primary tbh.

They were always fairly academic and well behaved and ended up in sets together anyway.

Now, they are at senior and attend different schools, but that's another story!

In short, I found people are insistent almost on splitting twins when actually, parents should be left to make thst choice without feeling pressured.

Pottedpalm · 15/10/2021 18:09

My two were in a one form entry kindergarten and up to year 2. When they were moving on to a different, two form entry, school in year 3 there were allocated to different classes. I rang the head and asked for them to be put together and they were. It worked fine; they have different strengths.
When they moved up to the seniors ( same school) the head asked what we wanted and we all decided together it was time to be in different classes. They were happy; DS would wait for DD after school to help her carry her many bags etc. and would often buy her chocolate from the tuck shop at break and look for her round school. I’m pretty sure she never reciprocated 😄
All grown up now, they are still great friends and meet up regularly

TheAverageUser · 15/10/2021 18:07

My sister has twins and decided to separate them at school so that they could forge their own friendships and identity outside of 'being a twin'. I'm definitely not saying that's not possible being together but just to give you her reasoning.

Lawnpop · 15/10/2021 18:06

I think twins trust did some research on this and their conclusions were that there is no right answer! I did decide to put mine on separate classes because actually they wanted time apart from each other. It’s really been the best thing for them

Swipe left for the next trending thread