Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male entitlement in the John Lewis ad

315 replies

MardyBra · 15/10/2021 14:06

www.independent.co.uk/life-style/john-lewis-advert-boy-backlash-b1938929.html

Lots to deconstruct in this.
I have no problem with an exuberant boy in a dress (although I feel JL are trying very hard to show their target market how woke they are).

But the wilful destruction of the home his mum has put a lot of time and effort into offends my feminist (and middle-class!) sensibilities.

JL says it’s a ‘young actor getting carried away with his dramatic performance”, not “wilfully damaging his home”.’ He looks a bit old to be at the crayonning on the wall stage still.

OP posts:
Journeyofthedragons · 15/10/2021 15:37

@Tedimhoardingrightsosaur

Thanks for clarifying DadDadDad.

Actually, your name has made me remember something else. It is highly unlikely they would have portrayed a father figure sitting there and passively watching the house being trashed. Only a mummy, because that's what we're supposed to do, let them "express themselves" or the poor wee mite will end up in adult therapy, blaming you for squashing their youthful spirit or some such bollocks.

Up until a few years ago the advert would likely have shown a hapless dad struggling to do anything whilst "mum sorts it out".
Empressofthemundane · 15/10/2021 15:36

John Lewis just isn’t what it used to be.
It and Waitrose used to be lovely stores that reliably sold decent quality goods and tended to refer to their clients as madam. Returns were easy.

Now, not so much so. Returns are more difficult. Stock, especially home stuff, looks tired and bland. And the middle class, southern English women who shop there seem to be subtly held in contempt.

LizzieSiddal · 15/10/2021 15:36

It's not very clever to piss off the mothers in the run up to Christmas. Study after study will tell them it's women buying the Christmas presents. Twats.

I agree, all the women I know who’ve seen it are bloody angry, most of them have said “who’ll be cleaning up that mess?!” They now think JL=No respect for women.

MsFogi · 15/10/2021 15:36

Boy in dress trashing house. One step to Man in dress trashing women's rights.
I'm fed up of corporates jumping on woke bullshit and not caring about the consequences to the wider community - in this case, I can't believe the number of teenagers "coming out" as trans (and in particular girls binding their breasts) and women being branded as transphobic for expressing misgivings about the way this is all going.
I have absolutely no problem with anyone wearing a dress (male or female), I do have an issue with condoning trashing a house or trashing women's rights. I won't be renewing my home insurance with JL (in the same way I won't spend money in Lush, the Body Shop etc etc) - I vote with my purse these days.

girlmom21 · 15/10/2021 15:33

He doesn't even look like he's enjoying himself.

fumfspos · 15/10/2021 15:32

Awful advert for all the reasons others have said already.
I absolutely can't stand the way the Mum is just sitting passively in the kitchen looking at her little darling trashing the place. Children are entitled to express themselves and to have fun but that stops when they are destroying other people's property and making a mess.

And no, I don't believe the insurance would pay out for that.
They'd start asking questions about how the accidental damage occurred and given the age of the child would probably say that he wasn't properly supervised. "Where were you when he broke the kitchen lights (or whatever else he broke)?" "Oh, I was just sitting there watching him as he was expressing himself dancing around in a dress and I didn't want to stop him in case it traumatized him for life/gave him a complex about his gender identity".

I have musical instrument insurance and the website for that gives very clear examples of what is and is not accidental damage. Cello bow, which resting on a music stand, falls on the floor at a rehearsal and breaks - accidental damage. Child drops violin case when carrying it and the violin is damaged - accidental damage.
Two children at youth orchestra play fencing with their cello bows (this was the exact example given) - not accidental damage, no pay out.

butterpuffed · 15/10/2021 15:29

[quote EspressoDoubleShot]@butterpuffed would this compel you to cancel a policy or refuse to use JL?
For JL and Ad agency it’s a Kerching! The ad has lit up Twitter, generated viewings[/quote]
It wouldn't make me stop using them for their normal products but no more than usual. However, I'd cancel my home insurance when it was due for renewal as I'd probably have to fork out a mid term cancellation fee Grin

Tedimhoardingrightsosaur · 15/10/2021 15:27

Thanks for clarifying DadDadDad.

Actually, your name has made me remember something else. It is highly unlikely they would have portrayed a father figure sitting there and passively watching the house being trashed. Only a mummy, because that's what we're supposed to do, let them "express themselves" or the poor wee mite will end up in adult therapy, blaming you for squashing their youthful spirit or some such bollocks.

CrystalBird · 15/10/2021 15:27

And they absolutely did not do this with the little girl dancing advert. She was so immersed in her very serious dancing that she didn't realise she was causing havoc. It was sweet and funny

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 15/10/2021 15:25

It made me cringe tbh..... It's very try hard and just makes the kid look like an arsehole. 🙄

Porcupineintherough · 15/10/2021 15:23

Tiny dancer was a great advert. This is not the same at all.

DadDadDad · 15/10/2021 15:21

@Tedimhoardingrightsosaur - I didn't read the reference to actor as referring to the actor employed by the ad agency (who as you say, is presumably following direction), but that the boy being portrayed in the ad is a budding actor who is getting carried away performing with the paint, glitter etc. (sorry, hard to explain without sounding confusing - basically, an actor is playing an "actor" and it's the latter that JL is referring to).

But I still think it's a ridiculous ad. Even if you did think as a parent watching your child destroy your property that it will all be claimed back on insurance (and with no excess to pay), does that mean you would happily sit there and let them create a situation which is going to create the hassle of making the claim, finding the replacement items etc?

Kotatsu · 15/10/2021 15:21

What an incredibly naughty child!

He's really not. He's just doing what he has been asked to do by the people making the advert.

err, yes, we realise that the actual child is just doing as they were told, we're talking about the character he is portraying. We don't have an issue distinguishing reality from fiction, nor immersing ourselves in the story line.

Which is a terrible one. It doesn't look like a child getting carried away in a performance, even if you wanted to go with that line, it looks like a child who's planned and wilfully chosen destruction as part of his performance. Getting carried away is something anyone who's had an excitable child would be familiar with, and that is not what is portrayed at all.

Whoopsmahoot · 15/10/2021 15:21

I don’t give a monkey about the fact it’s a boy in a dress - so what. I don’t give a monkeys about him having an exuberant good time. What I seriously object to is wilful destructiveness and disregard to the sister while the mother just looks on. It’s a stupid advert made all the more so cos insurance would never pay out.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 15/10/2021 15:20

Whoever came up with this doesn't like women very much.

starfishmummy · 15/10/2021 15:20

I especially dislike the pout-and-strut. Very obviously sexualised behaviour.

And draping himself over the countertype. Very distasteful

Tedimhoardingrightsosaur · 15/10/2021 15:19

@Cinderss

They did this exact advert a few years ago with a female child To ‘tiny dancer’
No they didn't. The girl in Tiny Dancer is dancing in her own world, and at times accidentally - not deliberately - knocks or grabs certain objects. Nothing is actually damaged. There's a father at the beginning, but they are not seen passively sitting there watching a destructive scene. There's a sibling, but she does not interfere in his activity and destroy it. She is not sexualised, she's doing ballet moves, not strutting, pouting and hip thrusting.
EspressoDoubleShot · 15/10/2021 15:19

@butterpuffed would this compel you to cancel a policy or refuse to use JL?
For JL and Ad agency it’s a Kerching! The ad has lit up Twitter, generated viewings

Porcupineintherough · 15/10/2021 15:18

It's about enjoying life

Because of course its impossible to do that unless you are trashing someone else's stuff. Hmm

CrystalBird · 15/10/2021 15:18

Woke, pouty, almost 'sexualised' in parts. Male wrecking his sister's quiet pastime. JL wouldn't cover this claim anyway as it's all deliberate damage

Those are my thoughts.

Bitofachinwag · 15/10/2021 15:18

@Holly60

Are you ASSUMING it was his mother who decorated the home??? Oops Grin
Well, she's the only adult in the ad and I can't imagine it was decorated by the boy! We know his decorating style. Could have been the sister of course (assuming the girl in the ad is his sister).
NumberTheory · 15/10/2021 15:17

@MardyBra

The JL insurance premiums must be sky high if they pay out for this type of shit. Wink
^^ This is what I thought!

I don't want to be subsidising parents who won't stop their kids from trashing the house.

Also YY to the comment the Indy quoted:
“The John Lewis advert of a young boy being the centre of attention for trashing everything while his sister obediently sits and paints in a corner is sexism encapsulated in 60 seconds.” With an added - and girl puts up with boy wrecking her activity knowing it's pointless to complain.

Marelle · 15/10/2021 15:16

FFS. It's about enjoying life.
I guarantee that if my child did that he would not be enjoying his life for a VERY long time!

Comedycook · 15/10/2021 15:15

@DownToTheSeaAgain

FFS. It's about enjoying life. It is about the feeling of freedom from worry that being insured engenders. It is about not needing to care and living for the moment because you can.
I thought the bit where he tipped his sister's paint over seemed really spiteful...unless I'm missing something Confused
DownToTheSeaAgain · 15/10/2021 15:14

FFS. It's about enjoying life. It is about the feeling of freedom from worry that being insured engenders. It is about not needing to care and living for the moment because you can.

Swipe left for the next trending thread