Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male entitlement in the John Lewis ad

315 replies

MardyBra · 15/10/2021 14:06

www.independent.co.uk/life-style/john-lewis-advert-boy-backlash-b1938929.html

Lots to deconstruct in this.
I have no problem with an exuberant boy in a dress (although I feel JL are trying very hard to show their target market how woke they are).

But the wilful destruction of the home his mum has put a lot of time and effort into offends my feminist (and middle-class!) sensibilities.

JL says it’s a ‘young actor getting carried away with his dramatic performance”, not “wilfully damaging his home”.’ He looks a bit old to be at the crayonning on the wall stage still.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 15/10/2021 16:36

If it had been flamboyant, just a rip off of tiny dancer, then maybe better

But thinking about a boy just casually wrecking the place and his sister’s stuff makes me really irritated

HebalGerbil · 15/10/2021 16:36

Strip everything else out and it's false advertising.

John Lewis are saying their accidental damage home insurance add-on will pay out if a child wilfully smashes the house up while it's parent encourages such behaviour.

Let's say a fourteen year old likes to "express themselves" by smoking weed, getting pissed on cheap cider and kicking the doors and windows in.

Mm mm mm...lovely insurance pay out.

I bloody doubt it very much.

Or is unhindered destruction okay if you're doing it because you're *fabulous". Will they pay out then. Yeah, err, no, don't think so.

Complaint to the advertising standards body about that, maybe.

placemats · 15/10/2021 16:35

You can be charged with murder and certainly criminal damage from the age of 10 in this country.

Polkadots2021 · 15/10/2021 16:33

Jesus, spoilt brat alert, and what, the mum has to then schlep around cleaning all that crap up? Terrible advert.

DadDadDad · 15/10/2021 16:33

The conclusion on whether this would be covered by the insurance appears to hinge on whether this was intentional damage or not.

If a one year-old put their hands in some paint and crawled across the carpet that seems pretty clearly unintentional, but a boy aged 7 or 8(?) would surely know that kicking a shoe at a light, throwing heavy objects across a room or smearing paint etc could cause some kind of mess that could be costly to fix or clean?

ancientgran · 15/10/2021 16:33

@shakehandswithdanger

Horribly annoying ad, but "male entitlement" isn't the first thing to pop into my head. I think it would be just as completely obnoxious if it had a girl behaving that way.
I remember a "friend" of DDs trashing DDs bedroom when they were about 10. Heard crashes and DD shouting and ran upstairs. Girl had demanded something of DDs and DD said no she just flipped screaming that it wasn't fair. Everything went flying, curtains pulled down, lamp broken.

I can confirm that it is just as obnoxious if a girl does it even if she didn't do as much damage.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 15/10/2021 16:31

@Tigerwhocameforsupper

It’s a boy in a dress trashing his home. Doesn’t hit the right note for me at all.

I get what they were aiming for… child gets carried away and causes damage. However this just looks like a kid on a deliberate rampage and is over the top.

It does look very deliberate.

He isn't ver-excited, or imaginatively involved and unaware of what he is doing, or in a strop, or upset, or throwing a wobbler - he quite cooly, it seems, sets out to disrupt and destroy.

Not a good message.

placemats · 15/10/2021 16:29

According to John Lewis on twitter it was a playful depiction of accidental damage.

Excuse me? I have eyes.

The damage would have run into the thousands, especially the carpet!

I could never imagine claiming insurance for this. Son was playful and caused considerable damage to the house. Can you pay out?

SunflowersInTheShade · 15/10/2021 16:29

My kids did a lot of damage... DD still does - I guess I need to switch to JL and get them to pay for the next thing she breaks? Or get them to paint the walls again?

Hmmm - if that's what they are saying - then I'm all for it.

ClareBlue · 15/10/2021 16:29

@DiamondBright

Would they actually pay out for deliberate damage?
No. But they will have to now. So we can all get our houses redocorated at their expense. Not sure if the inclusivity message really works for me. Cost, customer care, effeciency are my criteria. If they put something into local communities that adds. That's it rrall
Tedimhoardingrightsosaur · 15/10/2021 16:23

@OneTC

My viewing of it was that this wasn't intended to show a concerted drive of destruction but was rather making a ballet of all the petty acts of destruction that happen separately

I didn't see the mum as a passive observer, we only saw her for a second, she might be just out of shot about to rugby tackle the little glittering shit off the table

The dress itself I have no issue, the strutting though is pretty off key

You see the mum for longer than a second. She's in it in the background from 43 seconds as he smears the kitchen cupboards with paint. He then knocks a pan that knocks over a beaker next to a laptop at 44 seconds. The laptop is right in front of the mother. We then get a direct shot as her head turns to follow him. Then you can clearly see her again at 49 seconds twisted in her chair looking back at the boy as he's dancing on the dining table throwing glitter everywhere. He would not have made it onto the table in my house. He certainly would not have gone on to jump on the sofa covered in crap at the end.
shakehandswithdanger · 15/10/2021 16:22

Horribly annoying ad, but "male entitlement" isn't the first thing to pop into my head. I think it would be just as completely obnoxious if it had a girl behaving that way.

HipTightOnions · 15/10/2021 16:21

If you watch this advert and imagine a girl in the place of the boy...

Yes, absolutely.

ancientgran · 15/10/2021 16:20

@MMM2

Not exuberance, just a brat wilfully destroying things, would JL insurance really pay out if you sent them that clip as evidence of damage.?
Yes my thoughts were "What a brat" didn't seem relevant that it was a boy in a dress, being a brat was the issue.
ancientgran · 15/10/2021 16:19

@Wazzzzzzzup

This is how i imagine families with the "i let them express themselves. Wouldn't want to kurb their character... Like all the others" 😁 It's shite ad
I met a family like that when we were homing educating ours. Couldn't ignore child if they interrupted you, couldn't stop them doing damage. Mother told me if he climbed on the roof she'd be cheering him on but she'd never tell him no. I asked if she'd cheer him on when the police took him away for shoplifting (another thing she wouldn't stop him doing.)

I didn't fit in with that group and I don't think they were sorry when I didn't go again.

MMM2 · 15/10/2021 16:18

Not exuberance, just a brat wilfully destroying things, would JL insurance really pay out if you sent them that clip as evidence of damage.?

SammyScrounge · 15/10/2021 16:15

@flowersmakeitbetter

It's hugely irritating.

I've already told Waitrose (in a customer satisfaction survey) that they need to concentrate on selling me groceries and forget all the woke shite. It's all getting a bit tiring.........

So true. Even Dreamies came decorated with a rainbow flag and a pledge of allegiance a while back. My cat isn't interested in the flag and he pledges allegiance to no one. So I bought another brand.
fromdownwest · 15/10/2021 16:11

All I see is an annoying brat willfully destroying a lovely family home because he chooses to, without any challenge to this behaviour.

risefromyourgrave · 15/10/2021 16:11

If you watch this advert and imagine a girl in the place of the boy, doing the same poses, pouts, etc, it would rightly be piled on for sexualising children. So why is it different if it’s a boy in a dress?

I do see a slippery slope of normalising sexualising young boys with the amount of teen/pre teen ‘drag queens.’

You’ve just got to read this link to see the problems.
www.gaystarnews.com/article/mom-disturbed-pedophile-lust-drag-queen-son/

GingerBeverage · 15/10/2021 16:11

I read someone comment that if you imagine it set in a run down council house it has very different connotations.

OneTC · 15/10/2021 16:10

My viewing of it was that this wasn't intended to show a concerted drive of destruction but was rather making a ballet of all the petty acts of destruction that happen separately

I didn't see the mum as a passive observer, we only saw her for a second, she might be just out of shot about to rugby tackle the little glittering shit off the table

The dress itself I have no issue, the strutting though is pretty off key

Tedimhoardingrightsosaur · 15/10/2021 16:10

On JL's Youtube, in answer to the questions:

Are JL saying their home insurance covers wilful damage by a family member? According to their own t&c’s this kind of damage is excluded.

and

Does JL insurance really cover you for willful damage???? Horrendous advert

and

He deliberately kicks his shoes towards the lights. Is that really covered?!

The stock JL answer is:

^With our Accidental Damage Home Insurance add-ons for buildings or contents, you’re covered for a range of home disasters including unintentional breakages caused by children. More detail here: www.johnlewisfinance.com/insurance/home-insurance/accidental-damage-insurance.html^

They don't seem to understand their own advert.

Porcupineintherough · 15/10/2021 16:09

@WineAway

The child is not being gender non conforming though is he?

He’s wearing a dress but he being boys will be boys type boy. Boys are tough & tumble.

His sister is being passive & ‘nice’. Confirming to a female stereotype.

It’s a destructive brat of a male with 2 passive cowed females.

^ Exactly this
LittleMysSister · 15/10/2021 16:09

@Marelle

The only thing that irritated me about it the blatant nod to the fashionable topic of the moment...being transgender Where does it indicate that the child is trans? All I see is a boy being gender non conforming. He’s still a boy.
I am not saying that boy is specifically identified as trans, but the sentiment behind this ad is quite clear, especially given the current climate and how much attention is currently on this topic.
mateysmum · 15/10/2021 16:06

Says a lot really doesn't it - male performing sexualised "feminine" posturing gets away with what the hell he likes, however destructive, whilst the females just have to sit there and accept it all passively.

A parody for our times me thinks.

I read a comment from JL that supposedly the boy doesn't realise the impact of what he is doing . Well fuck that. He is quite old enough to know that tipping your sister's paint over the carpet deliberately is wrong regardless of insurance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread