Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male entitlement in the John Lewis ad

315 replies

MardyBra · 15/10/2021 14:06

www.independent.co.uk/life-style/john-lewis-advert-boy-backlash-b1938929.html

Lots to deconstruct in this.
I have no problem with an exuberant boy in a dress (although I feel JL are trying very hard to show their target market how woke they are).

But the wilful destruction of the home his mum has put a lot of time and effort into offends my feminist (and middle-class!) sensibilities.

JL says it’s a ‘young actor getting carried away with his dramatic performance”, not “wilfully damaging his home”.’ He looks a bit old to be at the crayonning on the wall stage still.

OP posts:
Balonziaga · 15/10/2021 17:03

@Rosiesmydog

It’s fucking annoying. A. Because it’s ‘woke’ B. Because the mum and sister are portrayed as passive and accepting of the boys behaviour C. Because the kid is an entitled little shit and needs proper boundaries
^this^

And

D: Because there is no way this is accidental damage that would get a pay out so they are actually mis-selling their product.

SleepingStandingUp · 15/10/2021 17:00

I think the issue for me is tho isn't an exuberant child not noticing what he's doing and he doesn't seem joyful. It's a pouty child being a brat

beigebrownblue · 15/10/2021 17:00

Just to add to the mix.

That is a middle class, upper class home depicted.

If a kid did that in a lower income home someone would call social care and accuse the parents especially the mother of child abuse and neglect.

How and why is that an acceptable scenario for anyone?

ClareBlue · 15/10/2021 17:00

The absolute worst thing for an insurance company is paying on deliberate damage. So trying to be whatever they are trying to be, has gone pear shaped. Hoisted by your own petard comes to mind.
Did they think showing a boy in a dress was ground breaking or inclusive? Actually, what were they thinking.

Gufo · 15/10/2021 17:00

@Stompythedinosaur

I have no issues with a boy wearing a dress or dancing around.

I have a massive problem with the portrayal of a boy as "taking up space" while a girl sits quietly "being good". It is a sexist trope.

THIS.
lazylinguist · 15/10/2021 16:55

Where does it indicate that the child is trans? All I see is a boy being gender non conforming. He’s still a boy.

Indeed he is, because clothes don't make you change sex, however you 'identify'. However, it would be hilariously naïve to think that John Lewis made this advert with a boy in a dress and make-up with no intention of a nod to trans issues.

AllFanjoAndNoSnickers · 15/10/2021 16:55

Maybe not so genius as all it does is remind me that John Lewis have lost the plot all around, and provokes me to rant about it.

What I want, in case any JL people are reading, is:

Shops in our cities. I did not want you to close the shops you closed, and I resent you for it. I am not shopping at John Lewis Online: I am shopping elsewhere because I am so fucked off with you. I don't want to buy a fridge online when I've not seen it in real life, never mind clothes. And if I'm not able to go to look at fridges, you are also missing out on all the other random stuff you previously sold to me (mothballs, ironing board covers, men's socks, gloves, teapots - just random stuff which all adds up).

Because I am fucked off with you, I will not buy your home insurance or your car insurance regardless of whatever woke shit the adverts involve about boys in dresses (especially not when they also involve mysogynistic crap about nice passive girls and their nice passive mummies). Leaving aside the wokeness, boy in a dress, etc, most parents would just think "WTF?" if they came across a child who behaved like that while the parent just sat there watching. They wouldn't think "Ooh, my insurance will cover the fact that we've never tried to discipline our child." Or is JL the only insurance provider in the world which covers deliberate damage?

I am fucked off completely and utterly with your wokeness.

I am also fucked off with your "inclusivity". I had some email marketing aimed at me, about how your bras fit all women of all sizes. Only when I looked, the only bra in my size was a "starter bra" in the schoolwear department. So stop peddling the 'inclusive' line, too, because you are not inclusive.

Most of the stuff you sell is made in China, which is a black mark against any company in my book.

I have been a die-hard JL shopper for 50 years, if you count being ferried there from birth onwards. I am now never buying anything from JL ever again unless there is absolutely no alternative. This includes white goods, as there is a local supplier whose business is booming now that you have closed our local shop. Which is at least one good thing!

I'm also fucked off with you for installing a "John Lewis" aisle in my Waitrose - a whole aisle! Wow! - because all it does is remind me of how cross I am that you closed the stores, and this in turn makes me cross about being in Waitrose and go to M&S instead. I also hate the way that you think that you can choose that the one mug I would choose to buy from your entire china department is one that says "Best Nanna" on it. Not even "Best Granny"!

I would cancel my JL credit card but as the limit was set on it pre-divorce, I'm not inclined to as I'd never get that level of credit with any alternative now. If I could, I would.

inferiorCatSlave · 15/10/2021 16:52

Isn’t it essentially a version of their advert where a little girl also did it a few years ago?

No as there no wilful destruction in that one - and while sibling looks bemused by girl dancing dancing girl when they are coming down the stairs there isn't deliberately destroying an activity siblingis quietly engaged in.

Journeyofthedragons · 15/10/2021 16:52

What if it was a Turkish rug costing £20,000?

More fool for the parents for letting their daughter use the coffee table placed on it for painting, I could guarantee my kids would have spilt it on the floor anyway. Grin

AutumnAlmanack · 15/10/2021 16:50

Little brat - I know what I would do with him!

HebalGerbil · 15/10/2021 16:50

Another thing.

Have these advertising creative types got no original thoughts.

That child looks like a cross between the cute spectacle wearing kid from Jerry Maguire and the cross dressing cute funny little brother called booger from the Rachel McAdams/Rob Schneider film "The Hot Chick". Only the child actor playing Booger pulled it off better.

The dance act is rip off off of Maddie Zeigler in the video for Sia's Chandelier.

It also looks like they have taken their inspiration more from an episode of Drag Race than from the real lived experience of trans women. That's not very "woke" at all. That's a tad exploitative in my view.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 15/10/2021 16:49

@Stompythedinosaur

I have no issues with a boy wearing a dress or dancing around.

I have a massive problem with the portrayal of a boy as "taking up space" while a girl sits quietly "being good". It is a sexist trope.

Yes this is what bothered me too.
NumberTheory · 15/10/2021 16:48

I don't find the strutting and pouting particularly off putting. Lots of kids do that. They copy music videos and TV programs. I sort of find it cute - in a kids copying adults way. And I sort of don't - as I wish there was a lot less of that sort of posing and pouting by women (and drag queens) on TV. But I can't get worked up about it in the sense of "the kid's too young". He isn't doing it on stage at a bar for dollar bills. Kids do practice all sorts of sexualised actions at home when they are quite young, that's exactly the place they should be doing it.

placemats · 15/10/2021 16:46

Extremely wealthy people do have expensive items in their home and also children. They are allowed to do this.

placemats · 15/10/2021 16:45

@girlmom21

What if it was a Turkish rug costing £20,000?

If you have a £20,000 rug with two young children you can afford to claim on your JL home insurance Grin

But in this instance would you be lying about accidental damage?
FWBNC · 15/10/2021 16:44

@Gardenlass

The advert has got people talking about it, that was the whole point. Newspaper coverage, Mumsnet. So a massive success from the advertiser's point of view.
No, no it's not.

Plenty of people, like me, have said that not only will they not be buying home insurance from JL, but that they won't be buying anything from them.

Not all attention is good attention.

girlmom21 · 15/10/2021 16:42

What if it was a Turkish rug costing £20,000?

If you have a £20,000 rug with two young children you can afford to claim on your JL home insurance Grin

placemats · 15/10/2021 16:42

[quote Simonjt]Isn’t it essentially a version of their advert where a little girl also did it a few years ago?

[/quote] What was wilfully broken in that advert?
placemats · 15/10/2021 16:41

@Journeyofthedragons

I've just watched it again and whilst he did create a big mess the only actual damage is spilt nail varnish on the dressing table and bannister (which you have a good chance of getting off with remover), a picture frame and a broken lightbulb at the end. The girls paint is likely water soluble and after a bit of a clean is unlikely to show up on the dark rug even if you can't get it all off.

I wouldn't personally put in a claim for this.

What if it was a Turkish rug costing £20,000?

I wouldn't clean it. It would have to be sent to a specialist cleaners.

But he was playful so John Lewis will pay out. It's an expensive insurance cover anyway.

Obviously, I would have to lie to the insurance company about this.

Simonjt · 15/10/2021 16:41

Isn’t it essentially a version of their advert where a little girl also did it a few years ago?

DevonTF · 15/10/2021 16:39

I think the narrative can be agreed - but I think it is a massive own goal.

Highlights - Male in dress, takes what he wants, does what he wants - and the women must stay silent.

Trans activism summed up in a JL ad.

EmKayEm · 15/10/2021 16:38

If I or my brother had ever behaved like that we would have been living in a tent in the garden and feeding on worms for an extended period of time...

placemats · 15/10/2021 16:37

www.gov.uk/age-of-criminal-responsibility

TubeOfSmarties · 15/10/2021 16:37

There are two things about this ad that really irritate me.

  1. Exactly what you say, male entitlement. Boy old enough to know better trashing the house while his mum and sister just watch and let him crack on

  2. the fact that he's wearing his mum's frock and make up is clearly meant to poke the kind of people that consider there's anything at all problematic and / or unusual about that. To create talk. don't mind that in itself (though it's a bit cynical), but what i do mind is that anyone who thinks it's missed the mark because of point 1 is just getting lumped in as "anti-woke" or disapproving of boys in dresses.

Journeyofthedragons · 15/10/2021 16:36

I've just watched it again and whilst he did create a big mess the only actual damage is spilt nail varnish on the dressing table and bannister (which you have a good chance of getting off with remover), a picture frame and a broken lightbulb at the end. The girls paint is likely water soluble and after a bit of a clean is unlikely to show up on the dark rug even if you can't get it all off.

I wouldn't personally put in a claim for this.