Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male entitlement in the John Lewis ad

315 replies

MardyBra · 15/10/2021 14:06

www.independent.co.uk/life-style/john-lewis-advert-boy-backlash-b1938929.html

Lots to deconstruct in this.
I have no problem with an exuberant boy in a dress (although I feel JL are trying very hard to show their target market how woke they are).

But the wilful destruction of the home his mum has put a lot of time and effort into offends my feminist (and middle-class!) sensibilities.

JL says it’s a ‘young actor getting carried away with his dramatic performance”, not “wilfully damaging his home”.’ He looks a bit old to be at the crayonning on the wall stage still.

OP posts:
Wheresthebeach · 15/10/2021 15:14

Not a good look IMO. Kid rampaging isn't going to be covered by insurance. Its on the woke bandwagon with a boy being over the top, in a dress etc. The fact that they think it's okay to have a boy trashing the house while the 'wimmin' look on, including trashing his sisters paints tells us all about the state of society.

Journeyofthedragons · 15/10/2021 15:13

When I first saw the add, I thought they were about to play Bootylicious. That would have sent the pseudo paedo needle off the scale.

😅

butterpuffed · 15/10/2021 15:13

@EspressoDoubleShot

Having said that,job done for JL and ad agency. We are all talking it’s getting noticed
And many will be not considering/cancelling their home contents insurance with them.
Tedimhoardingrightsosaur · 15/10/2021 15:11

JL says it’s a ‘young actor getting carried away with his dramatic performance”, not “wilfully damaging his home”.’

Which is disgusting, because they are throwing the child actor under the bus. The director, editor, advertising creatives who came up with the concept are to blame for this, not some kid, who would not have chosen his costume, the set, the surrounding circumstances of the situation depicted (the set, the mum/daughter reactions) or had a say in overruling any one of the adults involved in this ad.

JaninaDuszejko · 15/10/2021 15:10

The comparison with Tiny Dancer is interesting, the boy in this ad wilfully damages things and e.g. tips over his sister's paints whereas the girl does not deliberately damage anything and her brother watches her bemused. I think the ad tells us a lot about male entitlement though.

Comedycook · 15/10/2021 15:10

@HerRoyalWitchyness

If DS2 knocked over DDs paints like that I'd have a full scale war on my hands. She wouldn't just sit and let him do it.
Yes it would be ww3 in my house if my ds did that to my dd!

Anyway I've just watched the advert and I thought it was just awful

Porcupineintherough · 15/10/2021 15:09

Yay, another suggestion that boys who dance must be feminine. Just what we need. Hmm

Cinderss · 15/10/2021 15:09

They did this exact advert a few years ago with a female child To ‘tiny dancer’

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 15/10/2021 15:08

Aaargh, this is awful. Passive, helpless mother doing boring, quiet stuff. Ditto sister. Boy sashaying around at will being an attention hoover, with an undercurrent of violence and entitlement in his actions thrown into the toxic mix!

Tedimhoardingrightsosaur · 15/10/2021 15:06

@Journeyofthedragons

I think we can all agree that Stevie Nicks - Edge Of Seventeen is a banger though.

Kelly, can you handle this?
Michelle, can you handle this?
Beyoncé, can you handle this?
I don't think they can handle this?

When I first saw the add, I thought they were about to play Bootylicious. That would have sent the pseudo paedo needle off the scale.
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 15/10/2021 15:05

JL says it’s a ‘young actor getting carried away with his dramatic performance”, not “wilfully damaging his home”.’

I feel sorry for him because he's going to have to clean it all off again, you can almost see his mother revving up.

And yes I really want to know exactly what that insurance policy covers. It seemed too unlikely it would pay out and since the John Lewis USP is "reliable" that makes me doubt them, not just for insurance but for everything.

GatoradeMeBitch · 15/10/2021 15:05

Can someone try claiming on their John Lewis home insurance that you need to replace a rug and a couple of vases because your son was expressing his identity? Let us know how that goes...

Journeyofthedragons · 15/10/2021 15:04

I think we can all agree that Stevie Nicks - Edge Of Seventeen is a banger though.

Kelly, can you handle this?
Michelle, can you handle this?
Beyoncé, can you handle this?
I don't think they can handle this?

621CustardCream438 · 15/10/2021 15:03

“ On the other hand, it is the opposite of sexist because it allows the boy to express himself wearing non-gender conforming clothes and mimicking feminine body language and behaviours.”

Regarding feminine behaviour and clothes, I think it’s really interesting how he is dressed and behaves compared to the girl in Tiny Dancer. I don’t think he’s behaving or dressed like a typical girl at all.

Tedimhoardingrightsosaur · 15/10/2021 15:03

@Gardenlass

The advert has got people talking about it, that was the whole point. Newspaper coverage, Mumsnet. So a massive success from the advertiser's point of view.
Only if people buy their product.

There's some suggestion that JL will pay out for any damage caused by children. If they do indeed pay out in the circumstance shown in this ad, then they are opening the floodgates for mass insurance fraud. Want a new living room suite? Let your "exuberant" child loose do do his worse. If they don't in fact pay out in circumstances of wilful and deliberate damage, carried out in full view of a parent who does nothing to intervene - well then that's a matter for advertising standards. Anyone tempted to buy JL's product better read the small print - these products are created by the usual nasty ole insurance companies who will do their best to fuck you over if you try to claim, not cuddly old JL, which is just the selling front.

Nocutenamesleft · 15/10/2021 15:03

@MardyBra

And how does this count as accidental damage until their insurance policy?
Actually. Someone needs to ring and quote

So if my son runs around drawing on the walls and breaking stuff on purpose.

Am I covered? Otherwise it’s false advertising.

Getyourownback · 15/10/2021 15:00

I loved the Tiny Dancer one because all her damage was accidental with her heavy-footedness. This kid is wrecking his home.

MattDillonsEyebrows · 15/10/2021 14:59

I agree with PP who are saying it shows wilful, obvious damage on the boys part.

It’s a massive disparity between this advert and the one with the girl dancing, where she was clearly dancing away, in her own world, having a lovely time, and accidentally knocks a vase over, you can quite imagine her being quite shocked that she’s knocked it over.
If they’d have done the same thing with the boy in a dress, I’d have loved the advert, but to show him purposefully damaging stuff is awful.

NichyNoo · 15/10/2021 14:57

I viewed it as a spoilt boy wrecking the house and his mum is going to have to pick up the pieces - whether that’s through cleaning or (laughably) trying to submit an insurance for failing to control her brat.

Melroses · 15/10/2021 14:57

Smacks of luxury beliefs to me.

You have to be well-cushioned to afford the premiums for that sort of damage, and to be able look on at your child 'expressing themselves' all over it as a bit exuberant.

Pices · 15/10/2021 14:56

You could see it as a win for JL as we are talking about it but it's offensive enough that it has actually put me off JL. It's not very clever to piss off the mothers in the run up to Christmas. Study after study will tell them it's women buying the Christmas presents. Twats.

Tedimhoardingrightsosaur · 15/10/2021 14:56

These were points made on another thread:

Why a boy in a dress? If it had been a boy in a football kit and muddy boots "expressing himself" would that have been seen as cute?

What about class? If it had been a child in a council flat trashing the place while his overworked, underpaid mum looks on passively, would that be cute?

What about the sister? Why is it ok for the dancing boy to express himself in a way that destroys what she's doing? What sort of message is that for male/female dynamics?

What about kids who live in violent, chaotic households, who may have witnessed adults "expressing themselves" by trashing the place, while they have to sit back quietly and passively, and the only other adult in the room does similarly and does nothing to help them? What message is there for that poor kid?

Why is the child being sexualised with makeup, pouting, hip thrusting and preening? The Tiny Dancer had none of that.

Marelle · 15/10/2021 14:55

The point is that JL are suggesting this sort of behaviour should be tolerated, even celebrated, and the aftermath should be covered by insurance with no punishment for the child. When in fact this sort of behaviour in the real world would lead to severe punishment and the insurance wouldn’t pay out.

EspressoDoubleShot · 15/10/2021 14:54

Having said that,job done for JL and ad agency. We are all talking it’s getting noticed

Thatsplentyjack · 15/10/2021 14:54

@GoodnightGrandma

I just see a spoilt brat wrecking the house. I will turn it off if I see it just because of that.
Exactly what I was thinking. I would go mad if I caught one of my kids wreking my house like that on purpose, not just sitting there with a wtf look on my face. Also who claims their insurance for some paint on the walls and a broken vase and lamp? Stupid advert all round.
Swipe left for the next trending thread