Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male entitlement in the John Lewis ad

315 replies

MardyBra · 15/10/2021 14:06

www.independent.co.uk/life-style/john-lewis-advert-boy-backlash-b1938929.html

Lots to deconstruct in this.
I have no problem with an exuberant boy in a dress (although I feel JL are trying very hard to show their target market how woke they are).

But the wilful destruction of the home his mum has put a lot of time and effort into offends my feminist (and middle-class!) sensibilities.

JL says it’s a ‘young actor getting carried away with his dramatic performance”, not “wilfully damaging his home”.’ He looks a bit old to be at the crayonning on the wall stage still.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Piapiano · 27/10/2021 16:50

It was the misogyny and child sexualisation that bothered me more than the fact that it was misleading. Oh well, at least the ad is off air now.

BatmansBat · 27/10/2021 16:39

I am gutted.

I was hoping to buy this insurance and a lot of arts and crafts. Then I was planning to have a cup of tea and not worry if they started to wreck the place, paint the walls and throw glitter everywhere.

Gutted I tell you.

DadDadDad · 27/10/2021 16:25

Thanks for sharing that. While the poor parenting on show in the ad is what grated to me, it did seem suspect that it was implying that deliberate damage by a child of this age would be covered by the insurance. FCA are pretty strict on selling of financial products and not misleading consumers.

steelseries · 27/10/2021 15:15

It took the FCA to tell John Lewis that if you depict someone deliberately trashing stuff in a home insurance ad, it's not great because their home insurance doesn't even cover accidental damage as standard, let alone wilful damage 🤦🏽‍♀️

Male entitlement in the John Lewis ad
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 17/10/2021 00:46

I'd give up if I were you @carrotsandbrocolli

The as if it were real comment was odd and irrelevant. Of course there are some people who can't tell fact from fiction. They are unlikely to be the ones on this forum. The outrage has got nothing to do with a detachment from reality. It's odd to defend such a bizarre comment. I can only think that the poster thought she was making some useful point but has just not managed to put it into any words which help others understand it.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 17/10/2021 00:37

It's an exuberant child making a big mess which we know the vast majority of adults would have stopped well before he did what he does.

And we know the vast majority of sisters wouldn't just sit there when their brother accidentally-on-purpose knocked their paints on the floor. What chance he'd even get as far as the dining room after that? I guess the world isn't ready to see a proper sibling fight in an advert. Even though the resulting mess would probably make an even bigger claim on the insurance.

Also it's not real.

But how much isn't real? Are John Lewis saying it would be covered under their "accidental damage" policy? Or are we supposed to know it's all one big made-up joke, including the insurance thing at the end?

I'm definitely overthinking this.

OldTinHat · 16/10/2021 22:05

I've commented on this before and the advert is dire and misleading. I'm just off to smash my household contents and rest assured that I'll be recompensed. (Strangely enough, I wasn't covered after my 'Greek Night' when I smashed everything in the kitchen because my ex didn't quite understand 'leave'. He got the message straight away after that.)

But I just want to say that the actor is fabulous

Derbee · 16/10/2021 20:27

@tsmainsqueeze

I love this advert , its just a young boy having fun ,totally unaware of what he's done whilst having the fun ! I don't know what the fuss is about , i bet there would still be complaints if it were a girl , the quiet child a boy and the parent was a man. It's an exuberant child making a big mess which we know the vast majority of adults would have stopped well before he did what he does.
@tsmainsqueeze he literally walks up to his sister who is minding her own business, and smacks her paints off the table. He is totally aware of what he’s doing
MarshaBradyo · 16/10/2021 19:48

I got it on Instagram probably because I mentioned it on here

Loads of comments similar to this thread

I wonder if they are happy with the outcome.

Personally I prefer ads that generate talk because they are good not highly irritating.

HeronLanyon · 16/10/2021 19:46

And being knowingly sexualised so young. It’s really really unpleasant. As for the girl and woman and what that says to us, well where do we start ?

Holothane · 16/10/2021 19:44

I hate I just see a spoilt brat ruining the home.

tsmainsqueeze · 16/10/2021 19:32

I love this advert , its just a young boy having fun ,totally unaware of what he's done whilst having the fun !
I don't know what the fuss is about , i bet there would still be complaints if it were a girl , the quiet child a boy and the parent was a man.
It's an exuberant child making a big mess which we know the vast majority of adults would have stopped well before he did what he does.

FluffyBooBoo · 16/10/2021 17:56

you have just admitted you said that “people are taking about it like the situation is real” - yes?

I hardly have to 'admit it'. It's literally what I said:

Quite a few people are talking about the behavior as if it was real

Well that’s the one and only thing I was originally disagreeing with!

You said I misunderstood. I haven't. Saying 'people are talking about it as if it's real' is not the same as saying 'people think it's real', which is what you seen to think I thought.

Anyway. I'm really over this, whatever it is you are doing. I'm pretty sure others will be too.

I'm hiding this thread. I have more interesting things to be doing.

Carrotsandbroccoli · 16/10/2021 17:42

@FluffyBooBoo All comments should be worthy of dissection!

I do feel that you’ve cleared things up though - you have just admitted you said that “people are taking about it like the situation is real” - yes? Well that’s the one and only thing I was originally disagreeing with! I didn’t see anyone doing any such thing. So I said so. I didn’t see anyone posting under that illusion at all! I’d ask for a citation from you to suggest otherwise but, well, it’s getting on now…

Glad we’ve sorted it.

Reviewer123456 · 16/10/2021 17:40

I like the advert from an entertainment POV but the underwriter would not pay out on this type of damage so very misleading and I would say jl are mis-selling the product.

FluffyBooBoo · 16/10/2021 17:33

The only thing I can see that you meant there was along the lines of “if you’ve read the thread you’ll have seen that people ARE discussing it as if they think it’s real.” Did you not mean that

I did mean that. Please take note of the 'as if they think it's real'

but you were directly suggesting that people on this thread had given you the impression that they thought it was real. And that having someone say “it’s not real” would come as a revelation to them

Not quite. But we've been through this. People are talking about it like the situation is real. My point was that if people do think it's real, in that specific scenario, it might be a revelation to them to discover it's not.

As I said, it was a wry observation.

I don't have anything to add. I stand by my post. It's not deep. It's not some tricky intangible comment. I've explained it more than once, and at one point you seemed to understand.

It really is not worthy of all this dissection.

BlancheB · 16/10/2021 17:28

Follow the money. Yep advertising is expensive and all this shit is insidious. Tiresome. Another one to avoid.

Carrotsandbroccoli · 16/10/2021 17:21

@FluffyBooBoo
I’m genuinely intrigued now. You did a rhetorical “have you read the thread” thing in your original post. The only thing I can see that you meant there was along the lines of “if you’ve read the thread you’ll have seen that people ARE discussing it as if they think it’s real.” Did you not mean that?

Of course it’s a possibility that some people think the scenario is real - rather a strong possibility given the range of people in the world - but you were directly suggesting that people on this thread had given you the impression that they thought it was real. And that having someone say “it’s not real” would come as a revelation to them. That’s very different from acknowledging that, in general, some people may struggle with fiction v reality.

When pressed on this you seemed to retreat behind the very general ‘it could happen’ facade.

But no one takes the trouble to join a thread just to suggest the vague possibility of something that they don’t actually believe.

I admit, I’m over-invested in this exchange now because it interests me when people argue against logic.

FluffyBooBoo · 16/10/2021 17:11

But I'm not redefining anything. In fact, you yourself paraphrased it in such a way that you seemed to finally get it. And then continued to try to attack me by saying I shouldn't have posted it because it wasn't definitive enough. It was merely possibility.

I think we see the issue though. You are looking for black and white. I posted grey. Grey is a legitimate colour. I stand by my post.

berlinbabylon · 16/10/2021 17:11

People don't think it's real! It's just like criticising a TV programme or a book!

Anyway it annoys me but it's not the most annoying ad out there. The Marc Jacobs ones (Daisy Daisy Daisy and I'm perfect perfect perfect) annoy annoy annoy annoy me more (and the British Gas TURN DOWN THE WATTS one).

Carrotsandbroccoli · 16/10/2021 17:07

Fine thanks. Just annoys me when people try to argue black is white. I’ve made naff points that can’t be defended before - I either admit it or scuttle off. I don’t keep trying to redefine what I originally said. Don’t know why it annoys me so much that you’ve done that.

FluffyBooBoo · 16/10/2021 17:02

@Carrotsandbroccoli

😂😂Then why bother to post?! Everything is ‘a possibility’ Confused
Are you ok?
Carrotsandbroccoli · 16/10/2021 16:55

😂😂Then why bother to post?! Everything is ‘a possibility’ Confused

FluffyBooBoo · 16/10/2021 16:51

The only point you were making was that some people seemed to be thinking it was real

Yes! Exactly that! Seemed As in, it's a possibility.

Carrotsandbroccoli · 16/10/2021 16:49

@FluffyBooBoo

Ye gods!! You literally said:
Have you read the thread? Quite a few people are talking about the behavior as if it was real... It might actually be a revaluation to some.

The only point you were making was that some people seemed to be thinking it was real!! Whether you suggested it, implied it, hinted it WHATEVER! Or were you making a different point that I’ve missed?

Swipe left for the next trending thread