Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother or Birthing Parent

369 replies

thaigreen · 15/10/2021 12:25

Which term do you prefer?

YABU Birthing Parent
YANBU Mother

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 16/10/2021 09:57

There are loads of examples of late of 'women' being replaced by various functional or anatomical descriptions, with little comparable alteration re men. The recent Lancet cover, campaigns about 'people with cervices'... that's not 'inclusive' language.

One of the more egregious examples in the the context of motherhood was something talking about 'black birthing bodies'.

Once you've started seeing it you can't unsee it.

CreepingDeath · 16/10/2021 09:50

HermioneKipper

Ask yourself who is driving this.

And I’ll bet my bottom dollar it isn’t the one trans man who’s given birth.

It’s part of the calculated plan to erase the word woman so that all our spaces, boundaries and sports can be violated

Exactly. If this was about being inclusive of trans people, there would be a equivalent attack on the word man. But there very clearly isn’t. We aren’t seeing the terms ‘prostate havers’, ‘ejaculators’, ‘penis havers’ are we? No.

What’s really happening is a concerted effort to decouple the word ‘woman’ from female biology, so that males who wish to do so can appropriate the word woman, along with women’s spaces, despite the fact that they don’t have the corresponding biology.

HermioneKipper · 16/10/2021 09:36

@SarahAndQuack

I don't think it is part of any current drive to erase the word woman. Sorry, but I really don't.

I take your point that, if this were misogynistic, it would be perfectly fair to focus on this in preference to other aspects of misogyny.

But I really don't think this is misogynistic. It's just an inclusive form of wording. It could actively help some women get better birth care.

Well you’re wrong.

Ask yourself who is driving this.

And I’ll bet my bottom dollar it isn’t the one trans man who’s given birth.

It’s part of the calculated plan to erase the word woman so that all our spaces, boundaries and sports can be violated

TheKeatingFive · 16/10/2021 09:31

That's a great line

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 16/10/2021 09:28

Line taken from another forum (one that cannot be named). Men can’t give birth… even if they write for the Guardian.

KittenKong · 16/10/2021 09:26

My sisters friend and her girlfriend have a child. Both are ‘mum’ - why wouldn’t they they be?

TheKeatingFive · 16/10/2021 09:24

I do understand that lesbians are discriminated against (one of the reasons why I am GC) but I don't think erasing the word mother would in any way reduce this

Exactly

mustlovegin · 16/10/2021 09:24

I don't think it is part of any current drive to erase the word woman

Then just say the word. Woman

TheKeatingFive · 16/10/2021 09:24

We need language that acknowledges that there is not a perfect correlation between 'person who is giving birth' and 'mother'

Birth mother (and other variations) are already in parlance so that seems covered off.

The issue with the term 'birthing partner' is that it attempts to remove a correlation between giving birth and being biologically female. We ALL know, whether we admit it or not, that only biological females can give birth.

Piapiano · 16/10/2021 09:23

I don't have time to provide evidence but there is a massive drive at the moment to take the words women and mother out of official literature and even legislation.

I do understand that lesbians are discriminated against (one of the reasons why I am GC) but I don't think erasing the word mother would in any way reduce this. What's wrong with birth mother?

TheKeatingFive · 16/10/2021 09:21

It could actively help some women get better birth care.

How could it?

SarahAndQuack · 16/10/2021 09:19

@Piapiano

But it is part of the drive to erase the words woman and mother, whether you believe it or not.

How on earth would it help women get better birth care?!

That's not an argument. I don't see anyone struggling to use the word woman, so no, I don't believe you, and you've given no evidence to convince me.

It helps women get better birth care because - despite the hilarity with which some people seem to dismiss the idea that lesbians get discriminated against - actually, same-sex parents routinely do face discrimination and poor care. Explaining who is the 'mother' in the middle of active labour is not practical. We need language that acknowledges that there is not a perfect correlation between 'person who is giving birth' and 'mother'. We also need language that helps prompt health professionals to reconsider their ingrained assumptions about what their patents might be, or look like. I truly believe 'birthing parent' helps do this. It just gives a subconscious cue that you might need to look beyond 'ooh, there is a woman in a dress, bet she's the mum'.

My DP is one of quite a few lesbian mums I know who got shit care, because health professionals insisted on assuming the more feminine-looking woman was the woman giving birth (or the woman who'd just given birth).

Piapiano · 16/10/2021 09:14

But it is part of the drive to erase the words woman and mother, whether you believe it or not.

How on earth would it help women get better birth care?!

SarahAndQuack · 16/10/2021 09:13

I don't think it is part of any current drive to erase the word woman. Sorry, but I really don't.

I take your point that, if this were misogynistic, it would be perfectly fair to focus on this in preference to other aspects of misogyny.

But I really don't think this is misogynistic. It's just an inclusive form of wording. It could actively help some women get better birth care.

Piapiano · 16/10/2021 09:09

@SarahAndQuack "I get that there are real concerns people have over women's spaces and women's rights, but I find this debate really silly. The literature around pregnancy is full of harmful gendered language - I've seen leaflets that talk about how dads might 'help' with the baby, or imply dads need special cookies to do anything with their own babies. Concentrating on 'birth parents' as language seems to me a kneejerk way of distracting us from actual structural misogyny, which is rather harder to solve."

How is it "really silly" to object to the erasure of the word mother in the maternity context? It's part of the current drive to erase the word woman, which is deeply misogynistic. The fact that other things are also misogynistic doesn't mean we should just let this harmful change happen without protest.

SarahAndQuack · 16/10/2021 08:46

@CecilyP

You say this, but I was literally in the labour ward with DP and they still kept mixing us up! And in postnatal.

That doesn’t inspire much confidence in HCPs! But you still had to explain who was who one way or another in ways that would best suit yourselves, and that’s fine.

Actually, it wasn't particularly fine at all!
HermioneKipper · 16/10/2021 08:11

@Marvellousmadness

Birth parents is what adopted kids sometimes say to refer to their biological parents.

In any other circumstance the word birth parent is weird really . I am a mum. Not the birth parent of my kid

Birth parents are what they might call their biological mother and father. Not specifically their mother
CecilyP · 16/10/2021 08:10

You say this, but I was literally in the labour ward with DP and they still kept mixing us up! And in postnatal.

That doesn’t inspire much confidence in HCPs! But you still had to explain who was who one way or another in ways that would best suit yourselves, and that’s fine.

TheWeeDonkey · 16/10/2021 07:55

@HappyDays40

I didn't give birth to my son so mum is fine do people's kids call them birthing parent ir am I missing something. At the moment I just get bro ir bruv and he is 5Grin
I think it depends on if they want money/a lift to town or not, although I did go through a phase of being called cuz 😂
SarahAndQuack · 16/10/2021 07:42

@CecilyP

But as has already been pointed out, with a lesbian couple it can make it easier to be clear which mother is actually giving birth.

If they are actually giving birth, I’d assume it would be pretty obvious to anyone in the vicinity; no words necessary!

You say this, but I was literally in the labour ward with DP and they still kept mixing us up! And in postnatal.

(I'm not sure terminology would have helped, but maybe!).

I get that there are real concerns people have over women's spaces and women's rights, but I find this debate really silly. The literature around pregnancy is full of harmful gendered language - I've seen leaflets that talk about how dads might 'help' with the baby, or imply dads need special cookies to do anything with their own babies. Concentrating on 'birth parents' as language seems to me a kneejerk way of distracting us from actual structural misogyny, which is rather harder to solve.

HappyDays40 · 16/10/2021 04:05

I didn't give birth to my son so mum is fine do people's kids call them birthing parent ir am I missing something. At the moment I just get bro ir bruv and he is 5Grin

Marvellousmadness · 16/10/2021 03:29

Birth parents is what adopted kids sometimes say to refer to their biological parents.

In any other circumstance the word birth parent is weird really . I am a mum. Not the birth parent of my kid

Waitwhat23 · 16/10/2021 01:39

@BoredZelda

Basically I feel as if the trans rights lobby want to have the terms woman and girl for themselves, and a vocal and nasty minority are forcing this on the majority.

So they are "forcing" this language on everyone else (except they aren't) as some sort of bait and switch and then they will do a "tadaaaaaa" we are reclaiming the word woman all for ourselves?

I think it IS dehumanising to refer to us as birthing bodies or uterus-havers or menstruators, or any of the other terms that have been dreamt up to replace woman and mother.

And this has been done directly to you, by a HCP?

You seem to have overlooked the last point mae by the poster's comment you replied to re: Scottish Government's maternity policy. Here's an article about it - "Scotland’s civil service deletes ‘mother’ from maternity policy after Stonewall pressure" www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2021/10/15/scotlands-civil-service-deletes-mother-maternity-policy-stonewall/

It describes how, revealed through a FOI request, Stonewall have lobbied the Scottish Government to remove the word mother from policies relating to maternity.

Uses of words such as 'people with a cervix' "‘Anyone with a cervix’ in cancer screening campaign ‘puts women at risk’ | Scotland | The Times" www.thetimes.co.uk/article/anyone-with-a-cervix-in-cancer-screening-campaign-puts-women-at-risk-bbs776drw and 'menstruators' or worse, 'people who bleed' a"New row over Tampax ‘people who bleed’ tweet | The Independent" www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/tampax-tampons-menstruation-people-who-bleed-jk-rowling-trans-row-b1337497.html?amp and are now routinely used by health services and women's products. The same doesn't happen with services or products for men though. The sole example of men's language being changed to be more 'inclusive' that a previous thread were able to find is Prostate Cancer UK who have a list of those people who have a prostate (but use the word men throughout the rest of their website). Men aren't called ejaculators or sperm producers. It's only women's language that is being changed.

bengalcat · 16/10/2021 01:19

Mother

PineappleCakes · 16/10/2021 01:12

@Buttons294749

Let's face it this isn't to make Transmen feel comfortable when going through pregnancy. It's to placate people who will never be mothers by removing that option altogether.

Is transman/NB person wants to be the birthing parent of course we should humour them
. But they are not at the forefront of policy making because they are of the "unimportant" sex

I agree with @Buttons294749 ^

Women are reduced to their bodily functions whilst anyone with a penis can call themselves a woman. Under His Eye.

Swipe left for the next trending thread