Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother or Birthing Parent

369 replies

thaigreen · 15/10/2021 12:25

Which term do you prefer?

YABU Birthing Parent
YANBU Mother

OP posts:
MurielSpriggs · 17/10/2021 10:45

@TheKeatingFive

Saying someone has passed away is not even remotely comparable to saying that you can change biological sex if you want to.

Of all the absolute nonsense I've ever read of this site, that one really takes the biscuit. Congratulations.

Thank you Grin
SorryAuntLydia · 17/10/2021 10:43

@MurielSpriggs are you suggesting that legal death certificates should be renamed certificates of he is wiv de angels now? Or passing on certificates?

As mothers, as women, as humans of course we are aware of sensitivities around some biological facts. Doesn’t change them. And we can’t mangle our legal and safeguarding policy frameworks because of hurty feelz.

If a woman wants to say she is a man despite being in the process of giving birth, that’s an individual choice anyone caring for her should support. Doesn’t change the facts or the law or reality.

TheKeatingFive · 17/10/2021 10:23

I mean, none of our legal, religious, medical or support language actually denies the reality of death, now do they?

TheKeatingFive · 17/10/2021 10:21

Saying someone has passed away is not even remotely comparable to saying that you can change biological sex if you want to.

Of all the absolute nonsense I've ever read of this site, that one really takes the biscuit. Congratulations.

MurielSpriggs · 17/10/2021 10:17

@TheKeatingFive

If a person born as a woman but then lives as a man has a baby with their partner then they'll want be called birthing parent.

They would still be the birth mother. No matter how they wanted to organise their domestic arrangements after that. Because you can't actually change biological sex.

And it really isn't marginalising someone to not deny basic biological facts just because they want you to.

It's more about being sensitive then denying biological facts.

Some people find it very difficult to say that their loved one is dead. They use all sorts of euphemisms, and find the word "dead" too painful. If you were talking to someone about her bereavement, and she always referred to her husband as "passing away" would you prefer to use the word "dead" to her, to make sure she understood the biological reality?

MazIsWin22 · 17/10/2021 10:17

Honestly I think it is personal choice. Both are valid and should be respected but it's personal choice on how people want to be addressed. Makes me sad that they have removed the term "mother" from maternity care in Scotland without a second thought.

TheKeatingFive · 17/10/2021 10:16

Isn't that a bit like having your cake and eating it?

Well quite

TheWeeDonkey · 17/10/2021 10:15

If a person born as a woman but then lives as a man has a baby with their partner then they'll want be called birthing parent.

How do you live as a man and become pregnant?

Isn't that a bit like having your cake and eating it?

TheKeatingFive · 17/10/2021 10:14

Eg those who are ‘non-binary’, those in same sex relationships - there at two ‘mothers’ so it’s a way of talking about the one who is giving birth. It’s not taking away the word ‘mother’ but adding an extra term in for situations that don’t fit the common narrative.

There's no need for an extra term.

There is absolutely no situation where 'birth mother' doesn't clarify immediately

The more complex implications of these situations would be much better and genuinely served by better education around women not always acting/looking in stereotypically 'female' ways. I am 100% behind this. Deciding we need an alternative term for mother totally flies in the face of this acceptance.

Why can’t we have a both/and situation?

Because the only reason we'd need to do this is if we were trying to deny basic biological fact.

Waitwhat23 · 17/10/2021 10:10

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-kent-52471697.amp

Sorry, that link didn't work

Waitwhat23 · 17/10/2021 10:10

@Justreadingtheforum3

If a person born as a woman but then lives as a man has a baby with their partner then they'll want be called birthing parent.

Especially if his partner is a woman. The woman in that scenario would be mom. The birthday parent would be dad.

Trans men are really marginalised.

If a transman has a baby, he is still the baby's legal mother -www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-kent-52471697.amp
Lostmarbles2021 · 17/10/2021 10:06

TheKeatingFive

See PPs describing situations where having a term other than ‘mother’ has been helpful. Eg those who are ‘non-binary’, those in same sex relationships - there at two ‘mothers’ so it’s a way of talking about the one who is giving birth. It’s not taking away the word ‘mother’ but adding an extra term in for situations that don’t fit the common narrative.

Using both is more inclusive than one or the other. I identify as a woman and a mother and am in a heterosexual marriage etc so it’s easy for me. The language currently used fits for me and doesn’t leave me feeling excluded. But I can see that for some the language can feel excluding, or not quite right, so having an alternative helps to make sure that the policies and literature are inclusive of those for whom the word ‘mother’ isn’t as straight forward. A friend who had ‘Adoption Leave’ rather than ‘Maternity Leave’ felt quite ‘othered’ by that - it wasn’t a big thing for her but she is ‘othered’ in lots of ways and so it all adds up. Having a sense of belonging and not being ‘the other’ is a really important part of our wellbeing. So why not have both terms to include everyone?

As a woman and mother I don’t want to lose that identity and be called something different - but also I want the world to be inclusive of, and accepting of, difference. Why can’t we have a both/and situation?

TirednWorried · 17/10/2021 09:51

How xan a birthing parent not be mother?

Clymene · 17/10/2021 09:46

@Justreadingtheforum3

If a person born as a woman but then lives as a man has a baby with their partner then they'll want be called birthing parent.

Especially if his partner is a woman. The woman in that scenario would be mom. The birthday parent would be dad.

Trans men are really marginalised.

Living as a man and having a baby is an oxymoron
TheKeatingFive · 17/10/2021 09:44

If a person born as a woman but then lives as a man has a baby with their partner then they'll want be called birthing parent.

They would still be the birth mother. No matter how they wanted to organise their domestic arrangements after that. Because you can't actually change biological sex.

And it really isn't marginalising someone to not deny basic biological facts just because they want you to.

Rubyupbeat · 17/10/2021 09:42

Birthing parent sounds like being an incubator.
I'm so fed up with these stupid terms.

Justreadingtheforum3 · 17/10/2021 09:31

If a person born as a woman but then lives as a man has a baby with their partner then they'll want be called birthing parent.

Especially if his partner is a woman. The woman in that scenario would be mom. The birthday parent would be dad.

Trans men are really marginalised.

SorryAuntLydia · 17/10/2021 09:26

Why can’t it just be mother/birthing parent?

Because we don’t need a new descriptor; mother works just fine.

This mangling of the English language is a really tiresome trend. Anyway I must go, my barking domesticated companion mammal needs to utilise his moving implements. Grin

TheKeatingFive · 17/10/2021 08:31

Why can’t it just be mother/birthing parent? It hopefully captures everyone then

Again I ask, what's this situation people are talking about where the person giving birth isn't a mother?

334bu · 17/10/2021 07:11

Forgive me if I don't find a thread on Mumsnet to be a representative sample when it comes to issues involving transgender people...!

I thought this was a thread concerning women and their right to be consulted on the language used to describe themselves and their right not to be described as a series of body parts.

Lostmarbles2021 · 17/10/2021 06:53

I get why it is more inclusive to have a term that captures all situations, but, that could be an addition rather than a replacement. I work with families and mostly it’s parents but families come in all shapes and sizes. Aunts, foster carers, grandparents etc sometimes are in a parent role but they wouldn’t perhaps call themselves the child’s parent. So we refer to ‘parent/carer’ in our literature. Why can’t it just be mother/birthing parent? It hopefully captures everyone then. As long as in direct work I check the terms the family want to use and use them, I think that’s fine.

maddening · 17/10/2021 01:36

Happy to use the whole term "mother or birthing parent", but mother should always remain the prominent part.

ErrolTheDragon · 17/10/2021 01:08

A thread on Mumsnet is probably a pretty representative sample of parents in general, female ones in particular.

Alektopteryx · 17/10/2021 01:05

[quote blubberyboo]@peachgreen

Forgive me if I don't find a thread on Mumsnet to be a representative sample when it comes to issues involving transgender people

Pray tell what representative sample of women did the Scottish government, or stonewall consult before pushing forward these ideals? Cos I wasn’t consulted[/quote]

Indeed. Nothing about us without us; isn't that how it goes?

Alektopteryx · 17/10/2021 01:02

I find it surprising that the misogynistic and utterly offensive 'birthing parent' scores as highly as it does in your poll, OP. Still, it's heartening to see the majority of women have retained their self respect.

Mother or Birthing Parent