Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother or Birthing Parent

369 replies

thaigreen · 15/10/2021 12:25

Which term do you prefer?

YABU Birthing Parent
YANBU Mother

OP posts:
EishetChayil · 17/10/2021 23:24

(How do you put a hand up a vulva? It's a piece of skin? I think you mean vagina)

EishetChayil · 17/10/2021 23:23

Mother.

A transman who gestates and births a child is obviously not dysphoric enough to "invalidated" or "erased" by hearing the word mother.

TheKeatingFive · 17/10/2021 23:16

I have watched my partner give birth, and no, the term 'birth mother' didn't clarify anything.

Honestly, neither would birthing partner and all that would have been achieved was further reinforcement of the idea that females act/look a certain way.

There must have been something pretty strange about your midwife that she didn't notice which of you was pregnant. Clearly further education around how to approach lesbian couples when one's in childbirth is needed.

But you are focusing on the wrong issue here. And the scary thing is you don't seem to understand the implications of it.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/10/2021 22:51

SarahAndQuack
No one would have been pretending that a midwife with her hand up a vulva would be confused by the term 'birthing parent'.

Or confused as to who was giving birth!

If you have two women, one obviously very pregnant and the other not, it really ought not to be impossible to work out which is the mother and which the mother's partner.

SarahAndQuack · 17/10/2021 22:28

@TheKeatingFive

Eg those who are ‘non-binary’, those in same sex relationships - there at two ‘mothers’ so it’s a way of talking about the one who is giving birth. It’s not taking away the word ‘mother’ but adding an extra term in for situations that don’t fit the common narrative.

There's no need for an extra term.

There is absolutely no situation where 'birth mother' doesn't clarify immediately

The more complex implications of these situations would be much better and genuinely served by better education around women not always acting/looking in stereotypically 'female' ways. I am 100% behind this. Deciding we need an alternative term for mother totally flies in the face of this acceptance.

Why can’t we have a both/and situation?

Because the only reason we'd need to do this is if we were trying to deny basic biological fact.

This just isn't true.

I have watched my partner give birth, and no, the term 'birth mother' didn't clarify anything.

I am absolutely behind the idea we should educate people about the idea that women don't always look 'feminine'.

But if you have two women who look equally feminine, and they're still hitting problems because midwives have been primed to look for 'the mother' or 'the birth mothe,' then clearly, educating people about how 'feminine' women might look isn't enough.

Referring to 'the birthing partner' is a sensible, practical, helpful option. It primes midwives and healthcare professionals to stop thinking in gendered terms, which is helpful given that gender is a construct.

If this had been mooted on Mumsnet 10 or 15 years ago, people would have been all over the idea of dismantling the gendered implications of the terminology in favour of a term that doesn't flag up gender. No one would have been pretending that a midwife with her hand up a vulva would be confused by the term 'birthing parent'.

SarahAndQuack · 17/10/2021 22:19

@SorryAuntLydia

Why can’t it just be mother/birthing parent?

Because we don’t need a new descriptor; mother works just fine.

This mangling of the English language is a really tiresome trend. Anyway I must go, my barking domesticated companion mammal needs to utilise his moving implements. Grin

No, it doesn't. I'm sorry. It may work beautifully for some heterosexual women. But if your main complaint is that you find different language 'tiresome,' well ... grow up.

You can cope with finding language 'tiresome'.

Justgivemewine · 17/10/2021 20:21

@Justreadingtheforum3

If a person born as a woman but then lives as a man has a baby with their partner then they'll want be called birthing parent.

Especially if his partner is a woman. The woman in that scenario would be mom. The birthday parent would be dad.

Trans men are really marginalised.

But someone having a baby isnt really living as a man are they because, well, you know, sorry for staying the bleeding obvious, but men don’t/can’t get pregnant and give birth.
YouSetTheTone · 17/10/2021 18:14

I am an adult human female - a woman. I gave birth to my children and I am their mother. I have a mother.

Maternity/ mother are important words in a legal sense as well as ones which are understood around the whole world in most of the major languages. Losing those words bit by bit from common usage or government policies or government documents will have an enormous impact - and that impact will be absorbed by women, to our detriment.

I am a woman and a mother, hear me roar!

Hemingwayscats · 17/10/2021 16:49

I’d correct anyone who tried to call me a birthing parent or a menstruator or a cervix owner.

Alektopteryx · 17/10/2021 16:42

I found this blog post by the child of an older trans parent on the subject of mothers very thought provoking childrenoftransitioners.org/2019/08/29/the-invisible-mother/

KittenKong · 17/10/2021 15:05

They can get their child to call them whatever they like: mum, mam, mom, mommy, mama, Kitten, Mrs Kong... like we all do. No one is making their child call them ‘mummy’, so why is there a move to ‘erase’ mother’s?

TheKeatingFive · 17/10/2021 14:50

A transman giving birth is biologically female and legally a mother. Why are we having to overhaul language norma to facilitate a delusion that a male body can give birth? That is biologically impossible and everyone knows it.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/10/2021 14:36

How do you have maternal/maternity services without the maters? The word maternal means "of mothers", not "of birthing people". These language-vandals need to try harder.

www.etymonline.com/word/maternal
www.etymonline.com/word/maternity

Clymene · 17/10/2021 14:22

This is from the home page of Birthright - a charity which campaigns for better childbirth.

They have replaced the word women with people. This is a massive issue because if we cannot talk about our rights, we cannot defend them. Pregnancy and maternity are specifically protected under law as impacting only women. The moment we wipe away words that make it clear that only women are impacted by birth and breastfeeding, we risk eroding our rights.

Mother or Birthing Parent
Clymene · 17/10/2021 14:17

@MurielSpriggs

I'm assuming that medical professionals would only use the term for mothers who were uncomfortable with being called mothers, ie almost only in the case of transmen?
You would be wrong

www.newsweek.com/biden-admin-replaces-mothers-birthing-people-maternal-health-guidance-1598343

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/0431a0e6-e890-11eb-baaa-861dba20d87a?shareToken=e5fd6416bbe99226375a1db71d497b5a

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/10/2021 14:14

I have both my legs. A few people have one, or none. That people who do not have two legs exist does not stop the human species as a whole being classified as "biped".

Now, I challenge you, come up with a word meaning "with no, one, two or three legs" which is still of any particular use when referring to a biped?

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/10/2021 14:13

@MurielSpriggs

I'm assuming that medical professionals would only use the term for mothers who were uncomfortable with being called mothers, ie almost only in the case of transmen?
I think your assumption may be flawed. The complaint as I read it was that misguided medical professionals are using "birthing parent" instead of "mother" in all the literature; the vast majority of people giving birth are not transmen who have stopped taking the hormones in order to be able to become pregnant.

(Isn't taking the hormones part and parcel of living as a man anyway?)

In order to pander to the feelings of a vanishingly small proportion of a large part of the population, they are being stupid.

Waitwhat23 · 17/10/2021 14:04

@poetnojo yep. The posters on another, intensively monitored and moderated board on MNHQ have repeatedly been told that they are 'transphobic' for holding the 'extreme' view that human beings cannot change sex. Maya Forstater had to go through an employment tribunal after being forced out of employment for stating that there are only two sexes, though fortunately the judge ruled that such statements are 'worthy of respect in a democratic society'. Elected representatives will not openly state that there are two sexes when asked by their constituents.

These are all apparently 'extreme' views.

And just to address the tiresome, oft repeated 'echo chamber' trope, this is often repeated as fact by posters used to Twittter, where you can block, 'only mentioned' or simply delete comments you disagree with. On Mumsnet, you can't edit comments, can't delete comments. You actually have to stand by what you've said and have it commented upon. That's why there are so often 'plopper' posters on this topic.

Poetnojo · 17/10/2021 12:57

@RuggerHug

Asking a well established echo chamber known for having a lot of extreme opinions is not verified polling. But you knew that.
Saying a woman is a woman and a man is a man is now considered "extreme"?!?! Shock
MurielSpriggs · 17/10/2021 12:39

I'm assuming that medical professionals would only use the term for mothers who were uncomfortable with being called mothers, ie almost only in the case of transmen?

bumblingbovine49 · 17/10/2021 11:27

romdowa

I'd probably laugh at any professional who referred to me as the birthing parent. I'm the mother and ill be insisting that they use my preferred term.

Then use mother and birthing mother . Both if them are mothers

Sorry replied to wrong post BlushBlush

bumblingbovine49 · 17/10/2021 11:26

@romdowa

I'd probably laugh at any professional who referred to me as the birthing parent. I'm the mother and ill be insisting that they use my preferred term.
Then use mother and birthing mother . Both if them are mothers
ErrolTheDragon · 17/10/2021 11:10

@Clymene

The word mother has legal meaning

Call yourself whatever you like but if you give birth to a child, you're that child's mother.

Yes.

The problem arises in the space between on the one hand legalities - the letter of the law, official documents etc - and the terms each individual might prefer to have used in relation to themselves.

It's in the documents produced by bodies such as the health services and charities where there's been this unilateral move towards a change in language which may sometimes be reasonable enough 'inclusive' addition but in many is dehumanising 'functional' or anatomical descriptors, which may also tend to obscure clarity thus being decidedly non inclusive.

Clymene · 17/10/2021 10:46

The word mother has legal meaning

Call yourself whatever you like but if you give birth to a child, you're that child's mother.

MurielSpriggs · 17/10/2021 10:46

@MurielSpriggs are you suggesting that legal death certificates should be renamed certificates of he is wiv de angels now? Or passing on certificates?

Hi Aunty,

For what I'm saying, see my post above!