Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother or Birthing Parent

369 replies

thaigreen · 15/10/2021 12:25

Which term do you prefer?

YABU Birthing Parent
YANBU Mother

OP posts:
JaninaDuszejko · 18/10/2021 12:12

Transmen are not just a small minority in maternity wards. There is literally just one transman who has ever given birth in this country: Freddie McConnell. It is very bad practice to change all the documentation around pregnancy, offending millions of women, for a single exception.

Stompythedinosaur · 18/10/2021 11:58

Of course trans people are a small minority - that is why they deserve consideration and protection by wider society.

If being a minority was a reason to be allowed to exclude or discriminate then we could stop providing wheelchair ramps or accommodating people with mental health problems or a whole other raft of situations.

I am obviously not in favour of erasing the words "woman" or "mother" but I do think we should be clear that services include minority groups.

secsee · 18/10/2021 11:28

@EishetChayil

Mother.

A transman who gestates and births a child is obviously not dysphoric enough to "invalidated" or "erased" by hearing the word mother.

This is basically all there is to it. If you can give birth as a man you can cope with hearing the words mother or woman

And if you're trans, you'll know that you are a very small minority. It's not a personal attack on you to call everyone else what they are

ErrolTheDragon · 18/10/2021 11:11

Some of you may find this piece in the Times today of interest - it's somewhat related to the subject of this thread. And as a bonus it's got the lyrics of a new Peggy Seeger song in the third section.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/failing-to-use-the-word-woman-puts-lives-at-risk-bz0s5wdl3?shareToken=7a91efe3951eb216b428e94806890d49

Marguerite2000 · 18/10/2021 10:55

drspouse I don't think they're assuming anything. They know full well that the vast majority of women want to keep the existing language, just like they know full full well that the vast majority of women want single sex toilets, changing rooms and other single sex spaces.
They simply don't care what women want. The only thing that matters to them is what they want.
It's becoming more and more obvious that this is about sexism and men's rights.

drspouse · 18/10/2021 09:53

@Morporkia

All it takes is a simple question from a midwife.... Do you prefer to be referred to as mother or would you prefer another term? .. put it on the paperwork and bobs your Aunty’s brother
Except that nobody is asking women. They are just putting out articles, publicity material, health education material, legal papers, and radio interviews where they don't ask the VERY LARGE group of women they are talking to what they'd prefer to be called, they just assume they don't want to be called "mothers" because a teeny tiny percentage of mothers don't want to be called mothers.
FOJN · 18/10/2021 09:26

A transman who gestates and births a child is obviously not dysphoric enough to "invalidated" or "erased" by hearing the word mother.

I agree with this but I really think the biggest driving force here is uncoupling sex specific terminology from the word woman so that it's easier for anyone to claim to be a woman.

hangrylady · 18/10/2021 09:21

What now?

FOJN · 18/10/2021 09:19

If this had been mooted on Mumsnet 10 or 15 years ago, people would have been all over the idea of dismantling the gendered implications of the terminology in favour of a term that doesn't flag up gender. No one would have been pretending that a midwife with her hand up a vulva would be confused by the term 'birthing parent'.

Mother is not a gendered word, it is a sexed word and relates to females who either give birth or parent a child. People are rejecting terms which obscure sex and reinforce the concept of gender and more specifically give gender primacy over sex. Without acknowledgement of sex there are no sex based rights.

Morporkia · 18/10/2021 09:06

All it takes is a simple question from a midwife.... Do you prefer to be referred to as mother or would you prefer another term? .. put it on the paperwork and bobs your Aunty’s brother

buckeejit · 18/10/2021 08:52

I'm a mother not a birthing parent Envy

thiscountryisdotdotdot · 18/10/2021 08:51

Sorry that ^ should have been in bold. It’s that in a nutshell basically.
(Thanks @ Piapiano)

NOT using ‘mother’ and saying ‘birthing partner’ is far MORE offensive to women. When will people WAKE UP?!

thiscountryisdotdotdot · 18/10/2021 08:46

It is just so crazy that 50% of the population are having their identity as a woman erased in language so that a transman who chooses to carry a child for 9 months and give birth isn't "offended" by being referred to as a mother? It's delusional.

BlueberrySugar · 18/10/2021 07:42

Mother!
I am a human woman who gave birth to a child.

The term 'birthing parent' is just some made up BS to yet again degrade women.

God forbid we can do something a male can't.

Clymene · 18/10/2021 07:33

It's got nothing to do with anyone feeling traumatised by being called mother and everything to do with trying to impose gender ideology.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 18/10/2021 07:12

I always find it interesting that on the one hand we are told language really isn’t that big a deal & objecting to giving up words like mother is us being tiresome

Whilst simultaneously being told that not using the right pronouns or not saying trans women are women is literal violence and denying trans people their existence

It’s almost as if there’s one rule for one group and one for another isn’t it. Odd that

Piapiano · 18/10/2021 06:02

@EishetChayil

Mother.

A transman who gestates and births a child is obviously not dysphoric enough to "invalidated" or "erased" by hearing the word mother.

Exactly. How is being called a mother somehow offensive if you've chosen to get pregnant and give birth?

It is just so crazy that 50% of the population are having their identity as a woman erased in language so that a transman who chooses to carry a child for 9 months and give birth isn't "offended" by being referred to as a mother? It's delusional.

TheKeatingFive · 18/10/2021 05:21

Does it ever occur to you that you might be focussing on the wrong issue, or misunderstanding the implications?

No, not at all. I don't want to see females being erased from language used around birth, even if it doesn't bother you.

If you weren't so quick to presume that our experience of homophobia was 'strange' you might be better placed to acknowledge that it's real.

I 100% acknowledge that homophobia is real. I just think you're conflating this particular experience with the wider issues around language and I honestly don't see how erasing female language is supposed to address the homophobia you experienced. In fact, it'll do the exact opposite.

ViperHalliwell · 18/10/2021 03:55

The word mother has been removed from Scottish government maternity policies.

"Mother" does not appear, but neither does "birthing parent". The current version of the policy on the ScotGov website uses language which is so "inclusive" it includes people who aren't actually eligible for the entitlements described. It's unclear and potentially misleading.

Apparently (according to Stephen Nolan, anyway) ScotGov was coached by Stonewall to "remove gendered language" from the policies. Now we have "an employee having or adopting a child", "eligible employees having a baby", "employees", and "parents in a surrogacy arrangement".

From the "Maternity Leave" section: "Eligible employees having a baby can take up to 52 weeks' maternity leave" and "Employees must take at least 2 weeks after the birth (or 4 weeks if they're a factory worker)."

And in the "Paternity Leave" section: "Employees may be eligible for Statutory Paternity Leave if they and their partner are:
having a baby
adopting a child
having a baby through a surrogacy arrangement"

So if I'm pregnant, my partner and I EACH get to take BOTH Maternity and Paternity Leave because we're "having a baby"? Great! Grin I'm Moving to Scotland....

Except ... Maternity Leave is for "eligible" employees, and in the Paternity section, "employees MAY be eligible". How on earth can we find out if we're eligible? Confused

Well, how we find out is we click through the very helpful embedded links to ... the UK Government site. Where we discover that in order to claim "maternity" leave and/or pay, I must prove I'm pregnant. Non-pregnant partners of any sex, despite the fact that they're "having a baby", are not eligible. Hmm

Ah, well - on to "Paternity Leave", for which "Employees must be one of the following, the:
father
husband or partner of the mother (or adopter)
child’s adopter
intended parent (if they’re having a baby through a surrogacy arrangement)

OK, so: the pregnant person gets Maternity Leave, the partner gets Paternity Leave. Thank you, UK Government, for having an adult write your policy docs Smile even though they sneaked some "gendered language" in there Sad.

One thing still puzzles me, though: if we're supposed to remove "gendered" references and that includes "mother" and "father", then how is it OK to have "maternity" and "paternity" leave in the first place? Shock Or... if "paternity" is now gender neutral (if I'm pregnant, my partner can claim it without having to be a man), then what is wrong with "father" ... or even "mother"? Halo

SorryAuntLydia · 18/10/2021 01:00

You can cope with finding language 'tiresome'.

@SarahAndQuack if you are a MN regular you will be aware of the many many mothers who have suffered birth injuries and trauma. You will be aware of the many many women who succeeded in becoming mothers against difficult odds, struggling for years, investing money and emotional energy to become mothers. You will be aware of the many many women desperate to become mothers. And all of us have the right to be called that.

Just because one tired overworked midwife momentarily assumed you were mum to be, you want all of us to put aside our wishes, our needs, our rights and the legal framework of maternity rights, in order to make you feel a bit less sad. And your suggested solution won’t even solve your issue, just confuse the staff more. Sorry, I’m afraid I do find that tiresome.

SarahAndQuack · 18/10/2021 00:32

@TheKeatingFive

I have watched my partner give birth, and no, the term 'birth mother' didn't clarify anything.

Honestly, neither would birthing partner and all that would have been achieved was further reinforcement of the idea that females act/look a certain way.

There must have been something pretty strange about your midwife that she didn't notice which of you was pregnant. Clearly further education around how to approach lesbian couples when one's in childbirth is needed.

But you are focusing on the wrong issue here. And the scary thing is you don't seem to understand the implications of it.

There were several midwives, and multiple medical professionals involved - it was a very long labour. And, as I said, I also know of other lesbian couples who had similar experiences.

Perhaps, instead of claiming that our midwife was 'strange', you should believe us?

Does it ever occur to you that you might be focussing on the wrong issue, or misunderstanding the implications? If you weren't so quick to presume that our experience of homophobia was 'strange' you might be better placed to acknowledge that it's real.

SarahAndQuack · 18/10/2021 00:29

@EishetChayil

(How do you put a hand up a vulva? It's a piece of skin? I think you mean vagina)
A vulva refers to a woman's external genitals, including the lips of the labia. Often people use 'vagina' as a synonym, but actually, the vagina is the internal passage. A midwife or other health professional would put their hand through the vulva before entering the vagina.

If you are thinking of a piece of skin, I'm not sure what you're meaning? Neither the vulva nor the vagina is a piece of skin.

CecilyP · 18/10/2021 00:23

Maybe we should all ask for a label to be put round our necks, just in case they get it wrong.

Surely not needed as the woman giving birth would be the woman named in the notes. If a midwife can’t distinguish which of 2 women is about to give birth, the clarifying the name would clear up the confusion.

334bu · 17/10/2021 23:33

God I hope that any midwife would know which woman in front of her was the one about to give birth, even without her hand up a vagina. Maybe we should all ask for a label to be put round our necks, just in case they get it wrong.

azimuth299 · 17/10/2021 23:31

I don't really understand how the term "birthing parent" would help in that circumstance.

Many, many women bring in another woman as a birthing partner. Sometimes a life partner, sometimes another relative or friend.

I don't see how there could be anything beyond a brief moment of confusion, easily corrected, as to which woman is heavily pregnant and labouring and which woman is in a supportive role.

And how would changing mother to birthing parent help?