Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Actually we are all 'real' women living in the 'real' world

34 replies

Bumpitybumper · 15/10/2021 09:12

I am fed up of people declaring that because someone has some form of privilege or is different than the majority that their experience or very existence isn't 'real'.

The idea that 'real' women are a certain size is ridiculous. We are all human females that are alive and therefore are 'real'.

We all live in planet earth and therefore exist in the 'real world'. Some of us have an existence that is more representative of the majority or has more contact with difficult and hard parts of society but that doesn't make it more 'real'. It's just such a easy lazy way of dismissing different opinions and people's lived experiences. Kate Middleton is just as much of a part of the 'real world' as you are. Equally your experience of the world is as valid as someone born in the most deprived areas on Earth.

Basically my point is we all are part and in many ways form the 'real world'. It's not only reserved for those that feel that they have had enough struggle or difficulty in their lives to justify their place. You may struggle to give advice and bond with people with different life experiences but this doesn't mean you don't live in the real world.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bumpitybumper · 15/10/2021 12:23

Sorry I mean huge differences DO exist Confused

OP posts:
Bumpitybumper · 15/10/2021 12:22

@VladmirsPoutine

I think that's a very facile way of looking at it. Of course we are all in the 'real' world but there's absolutely no denying that the material reality between different groups of people is so huge as to render them existing in two different worlds. I know someone who forgot a bit of his uniform and had the family pilot fly it to him. His parents owned a private jet in the same way mine owned a car.
I don't deny that huge difference doesn't exist between groups of people for so many different reasons and in so many different ways. In a way that's my whole point, if there is so much difference then who decides what the 'real' world is and who is and isn't part of it. You might say this clearly quite rich person was outside your definition of living in the 'real' world, but I'm sure there are lots of other people on this planet who would say the same about you. We can acknowledge difference and privilege without having to dismiss people for not living in some fuzzy concept of a singular definitive 'real world' that is normally defined by your own terms of reference of what you view as normal.
OP posts:
Enterifyoudare · 15/10/2021 12:19

Nope, I am convinced that some people on here are at best, deluding themselves or at worst, purposely spouting nonsense about how wonderful they and their lives are (whilst literally sitting in disaster).

VladmirsPoutine · 15/10/2021 12:13

I think that's a very facile way of looking at it. Of course we are all in the 'real' world but there's absolutely no denying that the material reality between different groups of people is so huge as to render them existing in two different worlds. I know someone who forgot a bit of his uniform and had the family pilot fly it to him. His parents owned a private jet in the same way mine owned a car.

grapewine · 15/10/2021 12:01

we might all be in the same storm, but we are in vastly different vessels.

Exactly. People who don't have to worry about whether to turn on heating or buy food, because both isn't possible, does not share my reality. That's how it is.

Bumpitybumper · 15/10/2021 11:56

Precisely @SickAndTiredAgain, who decides what not living in the 'real world' looks like. I think when people use this term they mean someone living differently than them and often (but not always) with more privilege.

People can suggest it's just a turn of phrase etc but I think it's more insidious than that as it's used to ridicule and undermine people's views and invalidate them.

OP posts:
SickAndTiredAgain · 15/10/2021 11:25

@Glitterybug

I'm not going to accept Kate Middleton pretending that we are all in this together for eg lockdown when she's got an army of nannies, cleaners, cooks, drivers, gardeners to do all the grunt work for her. She's never had a proper job and she lives off hoarded wealth that she hasn't earned, firstly her parents and now her equally over privileged husband. I'll happily say she's got no idea about the real world. She hasn't got to worry about fuel shortages, or gas price rises, or the cost of school shoes when your kids grow out of them. She can get to fuck pretending she's just like the rest of us.
I guess OP’s point (that I think I agree with if I’ve understood it correctly) is that who decided that worrying about fuel shortage, gas price rises and the cost of school shoes is “the real world”. DH and I are ok, financially. Not rich, but as things stand, don’t have to worry about whether we can buy DD new shoes. Are we not living in the real world? And there are people in the world who don’t care about gas prices rising because their home doesn’t have gas or electric. And they don’t worry about their kids outgrowing school shoes because their children don’t go to school, or have shoes. There are people who would look at your problems and think “you don’t know you’re born” in the same way you look at Kate Middleton and think it. Which group of people are living in the real world? You seem to have decided it’s people like you, with problems like yours, when people worse off than you might think you’ve got no clue what you’re talking about.
ikeepseeingit · 15/10/2021 11:18

Interesting perspective. I think saying that others aren't living in the 'real world' most often is just a phrase to show how out of touch people like the rich elite/ government are. It's just a turn of phrase to communicate that others do not live in the same way they do. They lack empathy and are not being considerate of the needs of people of lower socioeconomic standing.

As you said, we all live in bubbles, but some people's bubbles actively rule over and dictate the others'. THAT is what they mean when they say 'you're not in the real world'. Whether or not you think the context it was used in was offensive is another matter 😆

Chikapu · 15/10/2021 11:05

The idea that 'real' women are a certain size is ridiculous. We are all human females that are alive and therefore are 'real'

I absolutely agree with this, the whole 'real women have curves' thing makes me want to scream. I've never had curves, I'm a skinny little thing and always have been, it's just the way I am. Am I less of a real woman because of it?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 15/10/2021 10:59

You’re absolutely right OP. And actually it explains why many people, such as members of the current government, are so callous. Johnson and the like.

They’ve no need to know about or understand peoples much more difficult lives. Their world is their real world and the only one they will ever live in.

Wazzzzzzzup · 15/10/2021 10:48

I think people should stop talking about standard level of schooling, not using food banks etc as "advantage and privilege". Kind of makes it sound like it shouldn't be a standard and acceptable standard is shite education and no food at home...
Bit off topic.

groundhoglet · 15/10/2021 10:46

Easy come, easy go

Underhisi · 15/10/2021 10:44

I think it is reasonable to use it when someone is refusing to accept that other people's real world's are different from their own and everyone doesn't have the advantages they have.

Hont1986 · 15/10/2021 10:20

No such thing as a 'real' woman other than a human female over the age of majority. Same for men.

Bumpitybumper · 15/10/2021 10:13

@CorrBlimeyGG

What isn't ok is to dismiss anyone on the basis they don't live in the 'real' world.

If you're trying to preach to someone in a far worse situation than yourself (and that's what is coming across from your posts), then it's fair to ask you to shut up.

I'm not but I agree with your sentiment fully but would extend it further and say anyone preaching to another person can shut up. That includes someone who perceives themselves as living in the 'real world' preaching to someone that they perceive isn't. Nobody has the right to preach to anybody else!
OP posts:
ChristieMalry · 15/10/2021 10:10

Caught in a landslide, no escape from reality.

HarrietsChariot · 15/10/2021 10:09

Everything that can be imagined is real. Dragons, unicorns, ghosts, aliens are all real because people can understand the concept of what they are and build up a picture of them without having personally seen them.

Just because something doesn't exist or isn't true doesn't mean it isn't real. There are legal definitions of truth, but truth isn't the whole reality. A made up fact like John Lennon enjoyed torturing puppies is as real as saying he wore silly glasses and had long hair. It wouldn't have stood up in court because there was no evidence to prove it, but that doesn't make it any less real.

What's different is the individual perception of reality. You might think you look great, another person might find you repulsive. Both views are correct, both are real, as is every other possible opinion of your appearance.

ChristieMalry · 15/10/2021 10:08

I agree with you, OP. After all, didn't Jesus Himself say: is this the real life? Or is this fantasy?

appleturnovers · 15/10/2021 10:07

This is one of my absolute pet peeves.

One of my SILs basically thinks anyone who hasn't had the exact life experience she has had "hasn't lived in the real world". Teachers don't live in the real world, as far as she's concerned. Most graduate-level jobs "aren't the real world". Anyone who is a member of a union "doesn't live out here in the real world".

Her own work experience mostly consists of being a shop assistant in nice department stores plus some waitressing, but she talks as though she's more qualified to talk about business/economics/politics than any of us because her work experience has been "in the real world" whereas working with disadvantaged teenagers day in day out for 20 years (as a teacher) is "living in a bubble" and "never properly entering the adult world". Drives me mad.

And yes, it is valid to talk about privilege, or how some people's experiences give them knowledge that other people won't have (and that applies to everyone to be honest), but I just wish it wasn't phrased as being "real" or "not real".

Glitterybug · 15/10/2021 10:06

I'm not going to accept Kate Middleton pretending that we are all in this together for eg lockdown when she's got an army of nannies, cleaners, cooks, drivers, gardeners to do all the grunt work for her. She's never had a proper job and she lives off hoarded wealth that she hasn't earned, firstly her parents and now her equally over privileged husband. I'll happily say she's got no idea about the real world. She hasn't got to worry about fuel shortages, or gas price rises, or the cost of school shoes when your kids grow out of them. She can get to fuck pretending she's just like the rest of us.

qualitygirl · 15/10/2021 09:57

@dottiedodah but being rich and having NO financial concerns don't always come hand in hand. The more you have, the more you gave to lose surely.
I am in a good place financially, albeit not mega rich but I still have worries about money at times.

CorrBlimeyGG · 15/10/2021 09:55

What isn't ok is to dismiss anyone on the basis they don't live in the 'real' world.

If you're trying to preach to someone in a far worse situation than yourself (and that's what is coming across from your posts), then it's fair to ask you to shut up.

Bumpitybumper · 15/10/2021 09:48

@3scape

Oh dear. Have you been distressed by someone suggesting some people are incapable of grasping the realities of others situation? Or do you think that everyone automatically can empathise but choose not to?
I think we are all incapable of truly grasping the reality of other people's situations. I think we are all capable of showing empathy and as much understanding as possible.

What isn't ok is to dismiss anyone on the basis they don't live in the 'real' world.

OP posts:
CorrBlimeyGG · 15/10/2021 09:48

I think the actual truth is very different but the echo chamber we often surround ourselves reinforces this view.

You seem to be disagreeing with your original post? We don't know what other people go through in life. You can experience different cultures but you don't live their lives.

dottiedodah · 15/10/2021 09:47

I think everyone has issues yes.However the difference between very rich and privileged people with no worries financially ,makes life a lot more comfortable than living in a rented home with all the financial worries on top!

Swipe left for the next trending thread