Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mild autism

144 replies

Sailorsgirl44 · 14/10/2021 17:50

My son is 8 and we were told last year that he has mild autism.. I've been browsing through posts on Mumsnet and have seen it said a number of times that this is no such thing?

The reason we put him through the assessment process was because he struggled a lot in his first year in school. He lashed out at other kids a few times and the teacher said he would find it hard to calm down after things like lunch break. In pre school he had fought quite a lot with another kid and had been bored a lot. In play centres I often had to leave early as he would have had enough of it and would go on and on at me until I left. At home he adores one sibling and is very easily irritated by the other.

I've noticed huge improvement in him over the years. For example we used to bring earphones to the cinema as he hated the loud noise at the start. The assessment team really focused on this issue. But after covid this didn't seem to be an issue in the cinema - we don't need the earphones any more. His behaviour with other kids is much better - he knows to walk away if there is a problem (as I've repeatedly taught him).

He does make eye contact, he can maintain conversations etc. He does sometimes make odd sounds - silly voices, etc. He also used to suck his clothing (around his neck) but seems to have largely grown out of that. He does hold his hands up in front of himself like a squirrel sometimes.. It seems odd. But if ever I say stop talking that way or put your hands down he will comply straight away.

He does have some class friends but due to covid I haven't seen him playing with them as much.

In school he gets a movement break every day from class. He's allowed to use putty if he wants to. And he is allowed to go to the back of the class to chill out if things feel overwhelming to him. I'm happy for him to have these supports in place. But I wonder if he was misdiagnosed?

OP posts:
picketingpanic · 16/10/2021 10:40

My DS can speak aloud, though it's primarily focused on his needs and demands. He can't have a two way conversation. He is fully continent and dry day and night.

He doesn't have a diagnosis of 'mild autism'. In fact, at the time he was diagnosed it was 'level two moderate, requiring significant support'. And trust me, he really does require significant support!

picketingpanic · 16/10/2021 10:37

@DeepaBeesKit

A friend has a DC with "classic" autism. Completely non verbal, incontinent in teens, no self care etc. She finds it frustrating that there is a move away from labels that are easily understood by the general population, that indicate just how great her DC level of need is.

Masking costs all autistic people a huge amount, but there's a key difference, many autistic people can mask (but clearly shouldn't be made to), her DC cannot, at all.

That's not 'classic' autism. There is no such thing as classic autism.
EmeraldShamrock · 16/10/2021 09:44

Sailorsgirl44

We're in Ireland. And the formal diagnosis was Mild Autism. This was based on a one hour meeting with him and a child psychologist, with a SLT sitting in. And a report from the school which was done in late September when he was 7 by his Teacher who had only known him a few weeks. And a two hour zoom session with me where I answered lots of questions about him.
You like many have been let down my AON.
If you'd like to pm later, I can offer some advice, been there, had the war and survived.
I'll give you a laugh my DS was diagnosed with moderate childhood autism and an emotional regulation disorder.
What's childhood autism? Grin
Does it disappear at 18?
DCA warriors on FB is an excellent source of information and support.

DeepaBeesKit · 16/10/2021 09:32

A friend has a DC with "classic" autism. Completely non verbal, incontinent in teens, no self care etc. She finds it frustrating that there is a move away from labels that are easily understood by the general population, that indicate just how great her DC level of need is.

Masking costs all autistic people a huge amount, but there's a key difference, many autistic people can mask (but clearly shouldn't be made to), her DC cannot, at all.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 16/10/2021 08:22

It’s ever so tricky to get your head around
My son was only diagnosed late summer

I only took him to see a private psychiatrist as he was school refusing and I couldn’t get my head around why this was so

Even now I’m confused
One the one hand he does have many apsie traits

  • taps hand and feet
  • social anxiety and can be seen as not having empathy
  • like a little encyclopaedia
  • obsessive
  • major emotional outbursts
  • triggered
  • very slow to leave house , get dressed , put shoes on (Jesus the shoes !!!)
But the piece that nailed it for me was the functioning If school literally makes him so anxious that it makes him ill , then I have to accept this diagnosis

Conversely he has a friend who is far more tangibly autistic , hilariously so at times ! Yet he attends school and thrives academically

Cheeseplantboots · 16/10/2021 01:32

@Sailorsgirl44

We're in Ireland. And the formal diagnosis was Mild Autism. This was based on a one hour meeting with him and a child psychologist, with a SLT sitting in. And a report from the school which was done in late September when he was 7 by his Teacher who had only known him a few weeks. And a two hour zoom session with me where I answered lots of questions about him.

I am happy for him to receive any support at all at school so would never suggest this be reviewed. But wouldn't any child benefit from these supports?

Part of the reason I would question the diagnosis is that there has been huge improvement at home too (including in our long summer holidays and lockdown time). I don't do any additional things for him (like putty or deliberate movement breaks) that I don't do for my other two kids.

I'm glad to say that I find him so much easier to deal with now than when he was young. He is a good listener and his behaviour is reliably good these days.

My son was diagnosed almost 20 years ago. He attended an assessment centre 2 hours a week for 11 weeks. There he was assessed by a SALT, an EP, an OT and a play therapist. There was also a tonne of paperwork, one set for me and one set for his dad. At the end of the 11 weeks there was a multi disciplinary meeting where all professionals had to agree on a diagnosis. He was almost 3 then and diagnosed as Autistic. Over the years the diagnosis has changed and he’s now described as severely autistic with severe learning disabilities. At 14 OCD and epilepsy were added. I’m surprised at how diagnosis are given these days.

Could possibly be a mis diagnosis but I don’t have any experience of autism at the other end of the spectrum to my son.

PickUpAPepper · 16/10/2021 00:16

^ It's often said that autism has a 'spiky profile', so you can't say where people struggle with what by looking at either them or a label. It's also possible to age, learn and develop cognition or greater tolerance. I think Sensory Processing Disorders are steadily taking a higher priority, but autism has been the general label applied for a long time. It is far easier to think in terms of needs than labels.

BlankTimes · 16/10/2021 00:07

This is one of the most insightful views I've read about using the term 'mild' to describe someone with autism, it's from this article neuroclastic.com/its-a-spectrum-doesnt-mean-what-you-think/

"People who can speak aloud and have reasonable control over their motor processing are often called “high-functioning,” and yet these autistics often struggle with employment, relationships, and executive function.
My doctor recently referred to my autism is “mild.” I gently pointed to my psychologist’s report which stated that my executive dysfunction as being greater than 99th percentile.
“That means I am less functional than 99% of people. Does that seem mild to you?” I asked her.
But, you see, I can speak, and I can look people in the eyes, so they see my autism as “mild.” My autism affects those around me mildly but my autism does affect me severely."

EmeraldShamrock · 15/10/2021 23:15

What’s the point though?
The point is it determines the level of support the DC receives, my DS has a fulltime SNA his autism impacts his life moderately, he needs charts, time-table, salt timer, help with coat, supervision around other DC but he is verbal with excellent memory, toilet trained, can sit for 25 minutes.
DD doesn't have a SNA she has resource hours and sits at an extra tuition table, her autism impacts her mildy, well until she became a preteen my heart breaks for her.
How does the label itself help. Mild and moderate sound like the same thing.
The level isn't about the label. A non verbal DC with no peer interaction, no awareness of toilet training needs more support.
Mild/moderate might sound the same but they're not in this home.

amusedbush · 15/10/2021 22:15

@DontSettleForMe

Essentially my understanding (and hey I’m no expert) is that everyone has traits that could be classed as “Autistic traits” but that it’s when an individual experiences traits to such an extent that it impacts on daily living and interaction with others. This is why people get wound up about the notion of “mild Autism”. I told a friend about being Autistic and she said “But only mildly”…Hmm you may experience my Autism mildly but it doesn’t mean I am mildly Autistic, just that I’m good at masking.
That’s exactly how it was explained to me: you don’t get diagnosed based on traits, you get diagnosed based on impact.

For example, one of my traits is that I don’t initiate conversation that isn’t about me. The impact is that I’ve lost all but one of my friends over the years because I don’t reach out or maintain relationships effectively.

With regard to my ADHD, a trait is that I get bored easily. The impact is that I’ve had 10 jobs in 13 years and I’ve spent a fucking fortune on equipment for hobbies I’ve dropped after two weeks.

The traits have to have a significant impact on a person’s life before diagnosis can be considered.

PumpkinsandTea · 15/10/2021 20:35

I've just finally had my DD's diagnosis for Autism overturned! I was completely mis-quoted and much of what was said in the parent interview was taken wildly out of context or just plain fabricated. They also put down one of their deciding factors being that she was "closely inspecting her fingers" during the in-clinic observation.

She had come straight from school (was in Reception then) and had PVA glue peeling off her fingers..... 🙄🤦🏼‍♀️ - This was one of 5 deciding factors given, which were absolutely false.

Finally had it re-looked at by the Autism assessment team at my local hospital's CDC (they couldn't re-observe her or have the school write another statement, but they did agree to re-score her based on my corrections) and they found her to not make the criteria for a diagnosis after all. This was only done due to me contacting the Patient Experience Team (sometimes referred to as PALS)

DontSettleForMe · 15/10/2021 20:21

Essentially my understanding (and hey I’m no expert) is that everyone has traits that could be classed as “Autistic traits” but that it’s when an individual experiences traits to such an extent that it impacts on daily living and interaction with others. This is why people get wound up about the notion of “mild Autism”. I told a friend about being Autistic and she said “But only mildly”…Hmm you may experience my Autism mildly but it doesn’t mean I am mildly Autistic, just that I’m good at masking.

TractorAndHeadphones · 15/10/2021 19:41

@DontSettleForMe

I’m Autistic, diagnosed as an adult after self-referring. I can mask pretty well but I have to ensure that I have recovery time because masking is tiring. I was diagnosed in 2016 with “Asperger’s”. My assessor at the time said that she knows the term has fallen out of favour as such but she felt it was the right “fit”. Now I know more about Asperger I’d rather not be associated with him! I generally just say I’m Autistic and if someone wants to know more, I explain how I am and how it affects me.

I stimm, especially when I’m nervous but I find myself stimming without thinking, it’s a self/regulation thing. I feel comforted with sensory feedback. Everyone stimms, it’s just more prevalent in Autism. This is a helpful video by Joe James about stimming on Facebook but there’s lots of videos online fb.watch/8FvjceedSY/

OP you might also find this helpful in aiding your understanding of the spectrum: the-art-of-autism.com/understanding-the-spectrum-a-comic-strip-explanation/

I do think it might be helpful for you to do a course on ASD to get more insight into the spectrum and how your DS presents and his needs. No two people on the spectrum are alike but there are fundamental aspects it would be useful to know.

What fundamental aspects are these exactly?
TractorAndHeadphones · 15/10/2021 19:38

@EmeraldShamrock

Surely the criteria using either the DSM V or ICD 10 don't change depending on which country you are in though? No but it is labelled different. Mild, moderate or severe.
What’s the point though? How does the label itself help. Mild and moderate sound like the same thing.
EmeraldShamrock · 15/10/2021 19:30

Surely the criteria using either the DSM V or ICD 10 don't change depending on which country you are in though?
No but it is labelled different.
Mild, moderate or severe.

DontSettleForMe · 15/10/2021 19:12

I’m Autistic, diagnosed as an adult after self-referring. I can mask pretty well but I have to ensure that I have recovery time because masking is tiring. I was diagnosed in 2016 with “Asperger’s”. My assessor at the time said that she knows the term has fallen out of favour as such but she felt it was the right “fit”. Now I know more about Asperger I’d rather not be associated with him! I generally just say I’m Autistic and if someone wants to know more, I explain how I am and how it affects me.

I stimm, especially when I’m nervous but I find myself stimming without thinking, it’s a self/regulation thing. I feel comforted with sensory feedback. Everyone stimms, it’s just more prevalent in Autism. This is a helpful video by Joe James about stimming on Facebook but there’s lots of videos online fb.watch/8FvjceedSY/

OP you might also find this helpful in aiding your understanding of the spectrum: the-art-of-autism.com/understanding-the-spectrum-a-comic-strip-explanation/

I do think it might be helpful for you to do a course on ASD to get more insight into the spectrum and how your DS presents and his needs. No two people on the spectrum are alike but there are fundamental aspects it would be useful to know.

MakingM2 · 15/10/2021 18:57

@Fluffypastelslippers It is diagnosed using three levels of increasing severity in some places.

MakingM2 · 15/10/2021 18:55

@Sailorsgirl44

Thanks for all the feedback so far. Another question.. The silly voices or having his hands like a squirrel are more often at times when he is relaxed. I get that someone with autism may stim to help themselves prevent getting stressed. But would they do the stimming at a time when they are at home in a chilled environment?
My son stims when he’s excited and having a good time. It’s not a distress thing for him at all.
Biscoffee · 15/10/2021 18:45

@Rhubarblin

I've found your thread really useful OP. I'm just at the start of this journey with my 3yo with GDD and possible ASD.

I'm in England and I have heard 'severe autism' used by professionals as during one appointment they asked if there's anyone in my family with autism or if I have any experience of it. I explained my friend's tween has autism, she is non-verbal, incontinent, has some very challenging behaviour and has just moved to residential care. They (the paediatrician) described her as 'severe'.

In the ‘old’ days which aren’t that very long ago your friends daughter would probably been given the same diagnosis as my son - Classic Kanners Autism. It’s autism as described by Leo Kanner and I’m of the opinion that people abbreviated it to severely autistic in order to make it easier for people to understand. Far easier to say someone is severely autistic than to say what the diagnosis is and then have to explain it.

My son is a grown man now and I’ve lost count of (and interest in) all the names his type of autism has been called over the years when someone else has a ‘good’ idea and decides to change things and confuse people even more. Is it incorrect to say someone is severely autistic? No. It’s not because it doesn’t take away from a persons situation the way ‘mildly’ does.

Fluffypastelslippers · 15/10/2021 17:57

@EmeraldShamrock

There are different levels diagnosed in Ireland. Basically the impact it has in each area of every day life. There is a huge spectrum of traits and how they impact the person individually. My DC are totally different.

Surely the criteria using either the DSM V or ICD 10 don't change depending on which country you are in though?

To meet the diagnostic criteria a person must show deficits in certain areas, that's not about the 'traits' shown at all. Of course the traits information help to gather a fuller picture overall but they are not diagnostic criteria alone.

Clymene · 15/10/2021 17:57

The spectrum is a wheel - it's not linear with mild at one end and severe at the other.

A child who is at mainstream school might struggle with being in a noisy crowded place just as much as one who is non verbal and is in a specialist residential school. The difference is in how much they are able to mask. And of course tolerance levels differ.

Rhubarblin · 15/10/2021 17:44

I've found your thread really useful OP. I'm just at the start of this journey with my 3yo with GDD and possible ASD.

I'm in England and I have heard 'severe autism' used by professionals as during one appointment they asked if there's anyone in my family with autism or if I have any experience of it. I explained my friend's tween has autism, she is non-verbal, incontinent, has some very challenging behaviour and has just moved to residential care. They (the paediatrician) described her as 'severe'.

TractorAndHeadphones · 15/10/2021 17:34

@EmeraldShamrock

There are different levels diagnosed in Ireland. Basically the impact it has in each area of every day life. There is a huge spectrum of traits and how they impact the person individually. My DC are totally different.
Exactly - it's too individual to make a broad judgement. The extent to which behaviour can be changed, the need for it to be changed, there is no one sized fits all answer. Masking for example - forcing eye contact etc is unnecessary and causes a lot of stress. But being flexible or avoid saying things that hurt others (and yes, this others includes other neurodiverse people as well, not just NT's) is necessary.

Anecdotal example but DP is autistic , so is the majority of his video game group . None of them want to play with a particular autistic boy who is very rigid and always wants the game his way, or is very blunt to the extent of being insulting (he called DP fat and me ugly).

It's not all 'NT's vs ND's. Never mind the fact that 'ND's are not a homogenous bunch. I have ADHD and traits that are the complete opposite of DP :D well mostly

TractorAndHeadphones · 15/10/2021 17:19

*ofc by professionals meaning what the combination of specific traits are.

TractorAndHeadphones · 15/10/2021 17:19

OP the whole argument related to labels and 'mild' autism is that people who have only 'mild' or 'high' functioning autism are not deemed to need much support. When in fact they need a lot more than what is currently given.
This however doesn't change the fact that there are people who will never - no matter how much support is given - be able to lead an independent life.
The labels 'low' and 'high' functioning were actually made to reflect the above.
It has now become a point of contention because people are angry. When the real issue is that needed funding has been cut across the board.

Listen to what the professionals tell you and don't get too hung up on what other people say about labels.

Swipe left for the next trending thread