Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My sister has said I've made things awkward but I disagree

360 replies

Robinson89 · 14/10/2021 17:36

I worked in child care for over 10 years, mainly as a nanny, and although I've changed professions completely now, I still occasionally babysit for some families during evenings and weekends. My rate is £10ph and has been for the last few years.

Last week my sisters friend (I don't know her personally) asked if I'd be interested in babysitting her children occasionally. I said yes and told her to pass my number on and let her know to ring me if she had any questions. Yesterday I received a text from the friend asking if I could babysit this upcoming weekend as she wanted to go on a night out for her friends birthday. It would be for around 6 hours until 11:30pm. I told her no problem, asked for her address and explained that my rate was £10. She replied shortly after explaining that she was looking to pay around £8.50 as that is all she could afford. I sent a polite text back to say I understood her position, but unfortunately my rate was £10 and it is what I charge all my families. I said if she changed her mind then to let me know and I'd happily babysit for her.

I never heard anything about it again until my sister phoned me this morning to say that her friend was really disappointed that she couldn't go on her night out and why would I expect £10 for basically putting the kids to bed and sitting on the sofa watching tv all night Hmm. I have no idea why my sister is even entertaining this, and frankly I'm a bit hurt. It has nothing to do with the fact that I'd be sat watching the tv whilst the kids are in bed. It's the fact that I'm giving up my weekend (I work full time myself) to babysit her children and not being able to spend time in my own home with my own family. I'm not desperate for the money so my down time is really important to me. I'm also a qualified trained professional who knows what to do in the event of an emergency. AIBU?

OP posts:
ILoveJamaica · 15/10/2021 11:33

£10 per hour for a professional nanny is very cheap

I don't think it's the norm for people to seek out a professional nanny every time they want to pop out for a few drinks though!

Gonnagetgoing · 15/10/2021 11:33

@ILoveJamaica

So you’d be perfectly happy. To allow a 17 yr old. To deal with your baby chocking? Or with a broken femur?

You need to think of extreme situations that such a person might find themselves having to deal with

What's with all the hysteria? The chances of your child choking or breaking a bone are vanishingly small.

A 17 year old is old enough to have children of their own.

Most parents don't have a First Aid certificate themselves.

When my children were small, it was completely the done thing to have a neighbour aged around 16 over to babysit. To demand that babysitters must be qualified in child care and first aid is ridiculous and right up there with the opinion that parents must never unclench and have a drink just in case they have to drive their child to hospital

I was trusted with kids from upwards of 3 years when I was 14/15.

However, I had babysat for a while so the parents knew me and I was usually fairly near my own house if anything went wrong.

At 15 I was studying for a GCSE in Childcare and also had to do a study so did one on a local toddler who I then babysat and did childminding in holidays for too (the DM had a baby after the toddler) but I learned about lots of things like reflexes, medical care, development etc and did a St John's Ambulance course etc and the only thing I ever had to do when the baby was born was put bonjela when he was teething. I mentioned to the DM that the baby thrashed around a bit when I took him out of his cot to feed (he was fine) and I was told not to worry, babies were normal and robust.

Approx 10 years later the Louise Woodward case was in the news and I recall being a bit Shock that a nanny could do this and that teenagers were allowed to babysit children with no qualifications. As far as I recall lots of my friends were asked to babysit children (usually 5 upwards) but nothing bad ever happened.

Marjoriesdoor · 15/10/2021 11:18

Sorry for my typos there!

Marjoriesdoor · 15/10/2021 11:17

£10 per hour for a professional nanny is very cheap. I used a childcare agency I used the other week and they charge £20 per hour plus mileage and actually I thought that was a fair price.

starrynight87 · 15/10/2021 11:09

£10 AH is very cheap for someone trusted and trained!

AryaStarkWolf · 15/10/2021 10:57

bahahaha, cheeky fucker, I love how it's a virtual strangers fault that she can't go out though. If she wants to pay £8.50per hour she's better off looking for a local teenager wanting some pocket money.....

ILoveJamaica · 15/10/2021 10:40

So you’d be perfectly happy. To allow a 17 yr old. To deal with your baby chocking? Or with a broken femur?

You need to think of extreme situations that such a person might find themselves having to deal with

What's with all the hysteria? The chances of your child choking or breaking a bone are vanishingly small.

A 17 year old is old enough to have children of their own.

Most parents don't have a First Aid certificate themselves.

When my children were small, it was completely the done thing to have a neighbour aged around 16 over to babysit. To demand that babysitters must be qualified in child care and first aid is ridiculous and right up there with the opinion that parents must never unclench and have a drink just in case they have to drive their child to hospital

MintyGreenDream · 15/10/2021 10:23

@ChargingBuck loving the Chinny 👌

ExConstance · 15/10/2021 10:21

Our "children" are now approaching 30. We were paying £50 for an evenings babysitting 25 years ago, also I had to leave a god supper for them which meant more expenditure at M&S. I used to use a qualified person because i couldn't relax and enjoy myself if I worried about things going wrong. OP, your rate is very reasonable.

LookItsMeAgain · 15/10/2021 10:21

What have you said to your sister since the original chat where she said you made it awkward and now her friend couldn't come on the night out?
What has your sister said to you since?

LampLighter414 · 15/10/2021 10:18

Attitude reminds me of those people on Facebay etc who refuse to pay/can't afford asking price for items and then make out that you have ruined their childs birthday or christmas because you won't sell the item to them on the cheap.

ejhhhhh · 15/10/2021 10:09

Of course you're not being unreasonable. Nobody is entitled to a service that they can't afford. If she can't afford you, she needs to find a cheaper babysitter or go without her nights out. But that's her problem, on no planet is it yours.

Nocutenamesleft · 15/10/2021 10:06

@ILoveJamaica

She cancelled it because the baby sitting is nine quid more than she wished to Pay. Which is indeed a couple of drinks

Ha, I realised that just after I posted. I still wouldn't pay £60 though. The most I ever paid when the kids were little was about £25 for the night. She needs to find a teenager or someone at Uni who would do it for less. The babysitter it literally doing her own thing after kids got to bed, £60 is insane.

So you’d be perfectly happy. To allow a 17 yr old. To deal with your baby chocking? Or with a broken femur?

You need to think of extreme situations that such a person might find themselves having to deal with

I’ve got a friend who is a professional nanny. Like many. She’s certified up to her eyeballs and has dealt with almost all situations you can possibly think of.

That’s what you pay a professional for.

Isn’t your child your most prized and loved person in your whole life?!?

MimosaFields · 15/10/2021 10:06

@EineReiseDurchDieZeit

That is, if I'm understanding you correctly OP that you asked for £10 total not per hour?
No, EineReiseDurchZeit, she clearly means per hour. It would be ridiculous otherwise.
mbosnz · 15/10/2021 10:00

My friend's paid my daughter £10 an hour - an unqualified, then 16 year old - but who is extremely capable, and manages to keep the two siblings from each others' throats.

Oh, and the two beagles.

BoredZelda · 15/10/2021 09:43

If she is quibbling over a tenner, she can’t afford a night out.

Nocutenamesleft · 15/10/2021 09:33

Nope

I’d just ignore. It’s not just sitting on the sofa. It’s the years experience you’ve got. I imagine you’ve got first aid etc. Which is what I’d hope an experienced babysitter would have and I would pay accordingly. Or if my child choked. You’re paying for them to be able to address that situation if it ever arose. Etc.

Not just say on your backside watching television!

Livpool · 15/10/2021 09:33

@itsallgoingpearshaped

YANBU.

People pay their cleaners more without question.
People pay the people who mow their lawns more hourly without question.

But gasp at the very idea of paying a decent hourly rate to someone who is watching over the most important things in their lives, their children!

Completely agree
dottiedodah · 15/10/2021 09:24

She is being a CF I think. Trying to get your services cut price because of your DS! I would just tell DS thats your going rate.You cant change it to suit one person.If only it were just "putting kids to bed and sitting on the sofa!" I used to babysit as well (Nursery School Teacher). One familys child had a Nosebleed, anothers 2 boys would not go to bed .A thirds little boy was deaf, and I had to translate everything through his Sister!(They were very well behaved though and sweet!)Just ignore DS(unless she wants to babysit of course!

itsallgoingpearshaped · 15/10/2021 09:20

YANBU.

People pay their cleaners more without question.
People pay the people who mow their lawns more hourly without question.

But gasp at the very idea of paying a decent hourly rate to someone who is watching over the most important things in their lives, their children!

User112 · 15/10/2021 09:18

£10 per hour is totally reasonable. If they don’t need a qualified professional, ask your sister to do it for them?

Why won’t your sister “help” her own friend? Cheeky mare !!

MaxNormal · 15/10/2021 09:12

I look after dogs for people when they are at work. I charge £17 per day, per dog. If I tried to charge £10 per hour, that would make it £90 per day, per dog, and no one would pay that

So how would it work in practice caring for multiple children in their own homes at once then? Thinking about it, do you reckon it would be safe and socially acceptable?

roseinthedark · 15/10/2021 09:00

When we were finding a babysitter for our then 18 month old to go on our first evening out since before her birth, I found a childminder I was happy with and told husband that her rate was £10 per hour. He balked and said, surely that’s too expensive can’t you find one who will do it for £5 or £6? I said, do you realise that’ll be a teenager without any childcare qualifications, maybe some experience, but definitely won’t be a trained professional adult who would know what to do in an emergency? Would you be happy leaving her with them? He soon bowed down. You were completely in the right!

Howshouldibehave · 15/10/2021 08:58

I think the point here is that on a Saturday night, at the end of a long week-most people want to do their own thing.

If you want someone to look after your children instead of doing that, you’ll need to make it worth their while. The OP already has a job and has decided that to give up on that spot of free time, she wants £10 an hour for it. I completely understand-I wouldn’t want to do it either-often Saturday nights is the only time I get to sit down with DH and a few glasses of wine. This isn’t a friend or family member that she loves and wants to help out-it’s paid work which she is prepared to do if it’s worth her while, but not otherwise.

I would imagine the sister’s friend could have found a local 15 year old to babysit at a cheaper rate, but preferred an older, more experienced person to care for her children instead. I wonder why that might be?

You can’t choose the ‘older experienced’ option but decide you’ll only pay the ‘15 year old’ rate!

I blame the sister here as well though-why did she think the OP would want to do this for cheap?!

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 15/10/2021 08:46

@ILoveJamaica

She cancelled it because the baby sitting is nine quid more than she wished to Pay. Which is indeed a couple of drinks

Ha, I realised that just after I posted. I still wouldn't pay £60 though. The most I ever paid when the kids were little was about £25 for the night. She needs to find a teenager or someone at Uni who would do it for less. The babysitter it literally doing her own thing after kids got to bed, £60 is insane.

No. She's not doing her own thing. She's in someone else's house keeping an eye on their children. She couldn't go for a walk or go out and meet friends.