Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My sister has said I've made things awkward but I disagree

360 replies

Robinson89 · 14/10/2021 17:36

I worked in child care for over 10 years, mainly as a nanny, and although I've changed professions completely now, I still occasionally babysit for some families during evenings and weekends. My rate is £10ph and has been for the last few years.

Last week my sisters friend (I don't know her personally) asked if I'd be interested in babysitting her children occasionally. I said yes and told her to pass my number on and let her know to ring me if she had any questions. Yesterday I received a text from the friend asking if I could babysit this upcoming weekend as she wanted to go on a night out for her friends birthday. It would be for around 6 hours until 11:30pm. I told her no problem, asked for her address and explained that my rate was £10. She replied shortly after explaining that she was looking to pay around £8.50 as that is all she could afford. I sent a polite text back to say I understood her position, but unfortunately my rate was £10 and it is what I charge all my families. I said if she changed her mind then to let me know and I'd happily babysit for her.

I never heard anything about it again until my sister phoned me this morning to say that her friend was really disappointed that she couldn't go on her night out and why would I expect £10 for basically putting the kids to bed and sitting on the sofa watching tv all night Hmm. I have no idea why my sister is even entertaining this, and frankly I'm a bit hurt. It has nothing to do with the fact that I'd be sat watching the tv whilst the kids are in bed. It's the fact that I'm giving up my weekend (I work full time myself) to babysit her children and not being able to spend time in my own home with my own family. I'm not desperate for the money so my down time is really important to me. I'm also a qualified trained professional who knows what to do in the event of an emergency. AIBU?

OP posts:
mountbattenbergcake · 15/10/2021 17:53

OP, if she ever does ask you to babysit, make sure you get paid in advance. People like this will try to pay you less than the agreed amount or will have an excuse for not paying that day and then drag it out.

mountbattenbergcake · 15/10/2021 17:51

@ILoveJamaica

No one would be happy to pay a Babysitter £60 for one night. You can't compare your hourly rate to other jobs, as it's not the same.

I look after dogs for people when they are at work. I charge £17 per day, per dog. If I tried to charge £10 per hour, that would make it £90 per day, per dog, and no one would pay that.

Why not? Is it because it's mainly women who are babysitters and any job done by women is of low value and therefore should be low paid and below minimum wage?
Clusterfckintolerant · 15/10/2021 17:51

Not BU at all. That's your rate. She can pay it or find someone else.
Nothing awkward about that unless your sister has created an expectation, in which case that's her problem.

lljkk · 15/10/2021 17:49

yadnbu

Bonbon21 · 15/10/2021 17:48

If £9 decides whether she can afford the night out or not she needs to stay home and save up more pennies.
And your sister needs to butt out.

Jenpeg · 15/10/2021 17:45

@BestZebbie

As an adult £8.50 is under the current NMW - which makes it especially cheeky given it is a weekend evening and you are experienced.
Spot on!!
Chocolatehamper · 15/10/2021 17:44

@someofusdontknowwhy

She was quibbling over £9? If her budget is that tight that £9 is the difference between a night out or not then I think she needs to look at her priorities
Just going to say exactly this!
Yogalola · 15/10/2021 17:44

Expecting you to give discount on your hourly rate saving her £9 for the evening is a bit of a cheek as no doubt she’ll be spending a lot on drink that evening. How tight can people be

Ellejay67 · 15/10/2021 17:43

So roughly a £12 difference on the night? She could have sat out a few rounds....

Galdos · 15/10/2021 17:42

Agree with all the 'not unreasonable's. Haven't used babysitters for years, so out of touch with rates. However 50 years ago as a teenager I was paid 50p for a whole evening with three kids under 5 ...

maddening · 15/10/2021 17:41

Tell dsis that she is more than welcome to pay the shortfall for her friend.

CSIblonde · 15/10/2021 13:27

Friend is BU. She is thinking more along the lines of what what you'd pay a mature, responsible teen, not a qualified Nanny . I had a great group of parents I babysat for at 18. I made v good money .

Dutch1e · 15/10/2021 13:03

Very inexpensive at £10 ph and I'd likely increase your rates if I were you. They're too low which means you'll get cheap CFers like this one trying to haggle on pennies.

The people who are prepared to pay decent rates know that they're not paying for a body on the couch, they're paying for the what-if skills that can mean the difference between life and death if a one-in-a-million situation comes up.

Shame on her, and on your sister.

madisonbridges · 15/10/2021 13:03

@ILoveJamaica

I know £10 per hour sounds reasonable, but also I'm really shocked that people would pay £60 to a sitter. Maybe I'm just behind the times.
I totally agree with you. I used to babysit when I was at school. I don't think the parents would spend the equivalent to that on themselves going out, so they definitely wouldn't have given it to me. You just got given a set amount. I didn't have training etc. I mean if you left your child at a kids party, or at your mums house, or they went for a walk with your sister, would you expect them all to be trained with St John Ambulance for emergencies? All that being said, the op can charge what she wants and the prospective client is entitled to say yay or nay.
Justilou1 · 15/10/2021 12:20

You are not responsible for your sister’s friend’s social life. Your sister doesn’t get to decide how valuable your time is.

Howshouldibehave · 15/10/2021 12:18

If they don’t want to pay then stay home 🤷‍♀️. They never seem to begrudge the cost of the meal or their taxi but it’s apparently outrageous paying for care of their most precious family

This x 100!

Bogofftosomewherehot · 15/10/2021 12:05

YANBU. In fact, I pay a level 3 nursery nurse £12.50ph.

If you can only afford to go out for 5 hours instead of six then so be it. It's not your place to subsidise this.

I wonder if she would have got the bar and ask for 15% discount as she wanted 6 drinks but could only afford 5!! - can you imagine the looks she'd have got!

Gonnagetgoing · 15/10/2021 11:56

@ILoveJamaica

Approx 10 years later the Louise Woodward case was in the news and I recall being a bit Shock that a nanny could do this and that teenagers were allowed to babysit children with no qualifications. As far as I recall lots of my friends were asked to babysit children (usually 5 upwards) but nothing bad ever happened

Well, quite!

Bear in mind as well though, that most PARENTS don't have the kind of qualifications that they seem to think are an absolute necessity for their babysitter to have.

Very true re the parents not having kind of qualifications which they think are a necessity for their babysitter to have.
tcjotm · 15/10/2021 11:54

Always makes me laugh how people feel entitled to be able to go out and are outraged that babysitters won’t spend the evening in their home for free 😂. I babysat for the money, not because I wanted to spend an evening sitting on someone’s uncomfortable sofa listening out for kids who I can’t shout at even when they come down for the fifteenth made up reason. And you know you’ll get the stink eye if they aren’t asleep when their parents come home. It’s not at all relaxing. And some kids - omg, I would’ve paid to leave early.

If they don’t want to pay then stay home 🤷‍♀️. They never seem to begrudge the cost of the meal or their taxi but it’s apparently outrageous paying for care of their most precious family. Think of it this way -they pay for the opportunity cost of the babysitter’s time (no matter how delightful they think their living room) AND avoid being charged with neglect or worse if they left them alone and they burned the house down. A bargain really.

OP is totally not unreasonable.

ellyo · 15/10/2021 11:44

I think she was chancing her arm.

Firstly, if she can afford £51 (6 hours at £8.50) plus the cost of going out, then the additional £9 is not an unreasonable ask.

Secondly, if she can't stretch to £10 p/h for 6 hours, then she could still go for 5 hours. If she can't afford to pay the money then she could reduce her expectations of your time in order to be able to afford it.

Claiming that you stopped her from enjoying a night out because she chose not to do either of those things is just ridiculous.

ILoveJamaica · 15/10/2021 11:38

I know £10 per hour sounds reasonable, but also I'm really shocked that people would pay £60 to a sitter. Maybe I'm just behind the times.

godmum56 · 15/10/2021 11:37

Actually what others charge for what and what others think is fair to pay is not really relevant. The OP isn't desperate for work, she was asked to give a price and she did. Basically take it or leave it, its not an invitation to negotiate. And its not up to the OP's sister to suggest that the OP would do mates rates.

ILoveJamaica · 15/10/2021 11:37

Approx 10 years later the Louise Woodward case was in the news and I recall being a bit Shock that a nanny could do this and that teenagers were allowed to babysit children with no qualifications. As far as I recall lots of my friends were asked to babysit children (usually 5 upwards) but nothing bad ever happened

Well, quite!

Bear in mind as well though, that most PARENTS don't have the kind of qualifications that they seem to think are an absolute necessity for their babysitter to have.

Gonnagetgoing · 15/10/2021 11:35

@ILoveJamaica

£10 per hour for a professional nanny is very cheap

I don't think it's the norm for people to seek out a professional nanny every time they want to pop out for a few drinks though!

On lots of childcare apps like Bubble etc though there are qualified nannies etc looking to make extra money.
Gonnagetgoing · 15/10/2021 11:34

oh and £10 per hour is cheap for childcare and your sister should mind her friend's kids if she's that bothered about her missing out on a night out.