Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

5yr old dropped baby

333 replies

MrsMummyMouse · 14/10/2021 16:27

Not really an AIBU but I am fuming and need help/calming down before I act (again)….but feel free to tell me if you think IABU if you so wish.

I was washing up in the kitchen while DD2 (3months) in her swing & DD1 (5) in the front room right opposite. I hear DD1 a couple of times say “and back down”, assuming she means the swing I pop my head back expecting to see them ‘playing’ as usual except I see DD2 slightly lifted by DD1 arms which she quickly removes sending DD2 flying back down in her swing. This is obviously what she was doing with the “and down again”, lifting her up and dropping her down!! I was so shocked/mad I screamed at DD1 and pulled her away to the stairs and told her I didn’t want to see her and she should go to her room. DD2 seems ok but god knows how many times she was dropped back Sad. DD2 is our long tried for/awaited rainbow baby so maybe I was too much and overreacted? I’m not sure though so need to know how I deal with DD1 now?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
2Two · 16/10/2021 23:02

[quote nanbread]@2two so you wouldn't tell the older sibling of a baby to be careful and gentle around them, not pick them up without asking?[/quote]
What a bizarre deduction.

yesterdayisinthepast · 15/10/2021 17:02

Yes I agree with you 100%. Unfortunately sometimes accidents do happen because the little ones can't resist the urge to play with baby etc but most have been made aware of how to be careful around them

nanbread · 15/10/2021 16:58

Yes I think we don't give children half enough credit for what they know they should and shouldn't do.

Now, having the self control / motivation NOT to do those things might mean they cannot always do what they should, but they know.

yesterdayisinthepast · 15/10/2021 16:20

[quote nanbread]@2two so you wouldn't tell the older sibling of a baby to be careful and gentle around them, not pick them up without asking?[/quote]
Exactly lol not really rocket science. All the parents in my family always explained what we should/shouldn't do around a baby. We were young but always knew we had to be careful around the baby and not do things like pick them up by ourselves.

I'm sure the OP would have reiterated this many times to her 5 year old

nanbread · 15/10/2021 16:16

@2two so you wouldn't tell the older sibling of a baby to be careful and gentle around them, not pick them up without asking?

2Two · 15/10/2021 16:12

@LittleMG

I think your 5 year old should have known not to lift up the baby on their own.
How many 5 year olds know anything whatsoever about precautions to be taken around babies?
nanbread · 15/10/2021 14:56

@Pancakeorcrepe there is a huge difference IMO in not minimising behaviour, and in making nasty shitty comments that will only make OP feel shame and not actually help her be a better parent.

Also, there are hundreds of parents on here recommending way more damaging parenting techniques than what OP has done - and these are people offering ADVICE!

Pancakeorcrepe · 15/10/2021 14:34

Well the point in different people giving their opinions is to bring the message home that it really isn’t on to react that way to a child! There are quite a few messages dismissing the whole thing and saying it is completely normal, which it isn’t. These posters also focus on the “spur of the moment” thing which does happen to everyone but this is not the case. Leaving baby unsupervised with toddler - - not really OK. Spur of the moment shout because you’re frightened - can happen. Shout that you don’t want to see your five year old? Not OK. Send her up to bedroom when she didn’t do anything wrong? Not OK. Posting on Mumsnet asking on how to deal with five year old? Well this is not a spur of the moment thing is it, it just shows an awful lack of awareness and makes you wonder what other treatment the five year old is given.
OP had an abusive father which is a horrible shame and I do feel for her. It is well known that growing up with abusive parents puts you at higher risk of being an abusive parent, therefore you’re not doing any favours by minimising the OPs behaviour. It’s all very difficult but this could be a watershed moment in OPs life but it doesn’t sound like she will actually take it onboard after doing the right noises for a bit. To everyone minimising this, would you like your own kids to be treated like this? Or nieces or nephews? Of course you wouldn’t and wouldn’t make these silly excuses for what is not at all a “spur of the moment”,”no one is a perfect parent” thing.

Fullyhuman · 15/10/2021 12:42

Hey OP, if you’re still reading. Great that you’ll read those books, talk to your HV etc.

My kids are older but I had a similar moment of realising I was massively overreacting, and I got therapy and read How to talk… etc. They helped. While of course I’ve made mistakes/shouted since then, I’ve not been ashamed of any of my mothering since.

I just wanted to say though, that while you can, and I’m sure will, be more the mum you want to be, it might not come naturally, quickly. New challenges with different stages will make your stressed brain react instinctively and while you will get competent at overriding that and responding appropriately, it may not feel natural for a long time and as new situations arise you may find again that grief that this isn’t easy, natural for you. That’s ime the painful legacy of parental abuse. My comfort is that my children will find it natural and easy, if/when they have kids.

Something I found and still sometimes
find helpful is to spend time with parents who don’t have abusive histories and who raise their kids instinctively, naturally, without worrying about it and who (mostly!) really enjoy their children.

While mine were little I even copied whole phrases, like a script, to replace my natural responses. At first this was weird but it was still better than the tools I had, and over time I got more natural and found my own words/ways.

Wishing you and all of us breaking this painful generational chain, luck and joy xx

ShaneTheThird · 15/10/2021 12:18

I screamed at DD1 and pulled her away to the stairs and told her I didn’t want to see her and she should go to her room.

That's exactly how a 5 year old interprets this. FFS

nanbread · 15/10/2021 12:15

@ShaneTheThird

Op I was ready to have a massive go at you until your updates. Don't let this one incident cloud the rest of their lives. It doesn't mean you will be abusive like your dad.

Just be really mindful of what you say to your dd from now on. Never say things like "I never want to see you again" as it really stays with a child and they believe it so easily.

Give dd a big hug and tell her you were just scared. Hope you and dd feel better this morning.

She didn't say she never wanted to see her again FFS
nanbread · 15/10/2021 12:14

Get some perspective people it was a bad overreaction. As if the lot of you are perfect 100% of the time.

Yep - kicking someone when they're down, calling them names, repeatedly criticising them, and ignoring their acknowledgement of their behaviour could be called abusive too.

CustardySergeant · 15/10/2021 12:13

@Member984815

She's only 5 for Gods sake, the poor thing . Why was she unsupervised with the baby in the first place. You have an apology to make
She apologised to her daughter yesterday!
SockFluffInTheBath · 15/10/2021 12:02

OP I hope you’re feeling better today. In that situation a lot of us would honestly have done the same. We might like to think we wouldn’t but it’s an instinctive, protective split-second reaction. It’s not the same as snapping all day about everything.

My dad was also abusive and it’s a stick that’s handy to beat ourselves with but the odd yell is not the same. I’d love to meet the perfect parents who have genuinely never raised their voices to their now adult children. Look after yourself OP Flowers

LittleMG · 15/10/2021 11:53

I think your 5 year old should have known not to lift up the baby on their own.

Katieandthekids · 15/10/2021 11:50

Yes you are being unreasonable poor kid.

Justcallmebebes · 15/10/2021 11:49

I don't think it's awful that you shouted, I'd also be furious (due to worrying/shock). Totally understandable

Really????

Member984815 · 15/10/2021 11:44

She's only 5 for Gods sake, the poor thing . Why was she unsupervised with the baby in the first place. You have an apology to make

ShaneTheThird · 15/10/2021 10:49

Op I was ready to have a massive go at you until your updates. Don't let this one incident cloud the rest of their lives. It doesn't mean you will be abusive like your dad.

Just be really mindful of what you say to your dd from now on. Never say things like "I never want to see you again" as it really stays with a child and they believe it so easily.

Give dd a big hug and tell her you were just scared. Hope you and dd feel better this morning.

Somethingsnappy · 15/10/2021 10:13

@CuteGirlsWatchMeEatEther

A lot of commenters here seem to have anger issues worse than your own, op. I don’t buy they’re the kind of people that keep their temper around children. If your baby wasn’t crying or distressed and your older daughter isn’t distressed at being yelled at then just move on. Download the resources others have posted, maybe speak to GP about referral for therapy.
Excellent point in your first paragraph!
Somethingsnappy · 15/10/2021 10:12

@BunnytheFriendlyDragon

You left them alone together which seems a bit irresponsible. You were wrong to shoot at your five year old.
Shoot at her!? I know the OP overreacted but I don't think there was anything to suggest she went that far... Grin
PumpkinsandTea · 15/10/2021 07:53

@MrsMummyMouse
DD1 is your step child isn't she?

JumperandJacket · 15/10/2021 07:45

@Pancakeorcrepe

I don’t understand why people are saying this is a pile on. Yes she reacted in the heat of the moment, but then came on here saying she is fuming and how to deal with her five year old! Zero awareness! And in the subsequent posts she doesn’t seem all that regretful or mortified so I don’t understand why people say “read the previous posts”. They don’t absolve of anything. I read the first post and was shocked at the treatment of the five year old and lack of awareness. Plus the favouritism. There are a lot of issues in one post. I’m glad OP will seek treatment, it’s necessary, and hopefully the impact on the five year old can be reversed. If it were a man acting like this, people would never minimise it this way with “heat of the moment” stuff. It’s a classic excuse for an abuser.
Once a point has been made hundreds of times, making it again doesn’t really achieve anything. There’s no possible benefit to the OP or her children. The only beneficiary is the poster who gets to act like a bitch while simultaneously feeling morally superior.
BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 15/10/2021 07:28

You left them alone together which seems a bit irresponsible. You were wrong to shoot at your five year old.

mummyh2016 · 15/10/2021 07:22

@Pancakeorcrepe

I don’t understand why people are saying this is a pile on. Yes she reacted in the heat of the moment, but then came on here saying she is fuming and how to deal with her five year old! Zero awareness! And in the subsequent posts she doesn’t seem all that regretful or mortified so I don’t understand why people say “read the previous posts”. They don’t absolve of anything. I read the first post and was shocked at the treatment of the five year old and lack of awareness. Plus the favouritism. There are a lot of issues in one post. I’m glad OP will seek treatment, it’s necessary, and hopefully the impact on the five year old can be reversed. If it were a man acting like this, people would never minimise it this way with “heat of the moment” stuff. It’s a classic excuse for an abuser.
No one is minimising it but there are 300 posts on this thread and I'd say 250 of them are criticising, and some of them are well OTT. Unless the OP doesn't have a brain I think she now gets she was out of order, what good do you think will do in keep repeating the same posts?
Swipe left for the next trending thread