Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at boots for this

111 replies

pleurotus · 14/10/2021 14:22

I have a 4 month old who is 95% breastfed. She has had the odd bottle of formula here and there to see if she would take it and so that I can leave her with her Dad should I want a night off or whatever and without having to stash our freezer full of breast milk.

I went in to boots today and tried to buy two bottles of ready made formula with my boots points only for the woman to say I wasn't allowed to use my points to pay for them. When I asked why she said 'because we encourage women to breastfeed'

AIBU to find this ridiculous? I felt a little shamed by her and judged. I almost said 'well I do breastfeed actually' but stopped myself because it's a frigen choice! And so what if I didn't breastfeed at all, it would still be my choice and nobody should be made to feel bad about that. I can't imagine not being able to use your points to pay for formula is hardly discouraging anyone from bottle feeding anyway!

However should I have wanted to spend all of my advantage points on dairy milk and coke that's absolutely fine apparently and boots encourage that Hmm

OP posts:
LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 14/10/2021 19:31

It’s the law, not Boots fault. Sainsbury’s nectar points are the same.

TuckMyWin · 14/10/2021 19:29

It’s a blanket rule because the formula companies have behaved appallingly in the past, and continue to do so in parts of the world. Think, aggressively marketing formula, giving out formula samples for free in hospitals, making promotions available to new mothers and then, when their own supply has gone, and they have no choice but to use formula, dropping all those promotions. This leads to people not being able to afford formula but not having a choice, so watering it down or using sugar-water substitutes, which leads to malnutrition in babies. As a result there is an international code, which the UK has signed up to, to ban marketing and promotions of first stage baby milk. Not being able to use boots points on it is a side-effect.

It’s not meant as a judgement on those that do choose to use formula for whatever reason. Just to protect people so they have a choice.

Sounds like the woman in boots explained it very badly though!

user1471447863 · 14/10/2021 18:52

While I agree with the reasons behind the rules (basically formula companies couldn't behave ethically when left to their own devices) I do think some of the rules are stretching the original intent a bit far.
I doubt any woman would give up breastfeeding to spend a fortune on formula to be able to collect a handful of extra tesco clubcard points (that you can barely spend on anything interesting these days either). Nor have any said I'll give up this breastfeeding malarky as I've a couple of thousand nectar points built up so I'll bang a tub of formula in the trolly and cash them in to pay for that, but I'm sure there has been more than the odd parent whose out of money till next payday/benefits payment who is running out of formula and would like to dip into their safety net of saved up nectar points/clubcard vouchers etc to buy a tub so they can continue feeding their child. There's a difference between not promoting/not incentivising it and penalising those that have already made that choice (or had that choice made for them for any number of reasons).

riotlady · 14/10/2021 17:47

No need for the lady to phrase it so judgementally though

LIZS · 14/10/2021 17:23

It is a legal obligation not to promote or discount first formula, not a Boots rule.

pleurotus · 14/10/2021 17:21

@lescompagnonsdeloue I meant the government

OP posts:
lescompagnonsdeloue · 14/10/2021 17:20

@pleurotus

Why not use the same law with sugar and processed foods then I wonder...
Obvious. Because Boots has a choice about that, but they don't about this. But the assistant should have just made it clear that it wasn't allowed.
44PumpLane · 14/10/2021 16:58

@FictionalCharacter sorry to hear of your experience too Flowers

WheelieBinPrincess · 14/10/2021 16:55

@Totallydefeated thank you! It’s still a bit raw (like my nipples 😅) but absolutely I’m complaining. Unfortunately all I could do at the time was cry and then I was told I had the baby blues to boot. But I’ll definitely be taking it further.

londonrach · 14/10/2021 16:54

Op it's the gov decision not boots...boots aren't legally allowed to give points on formula...think it's the silliness gov decision ever but that's not the point. Yabu as it's not boots fault..you find it in ever single shop...no point s on formula

Decaffe · 14/10/2021 16:54

This has been the policy for two decades at least. And, it’s not Boots’ decision.

FictionalCharacter · 14/10/2021 16:50

@fantasmasgoria1

They like the profit from formula milk though!
Indeed! They’re allowed to sell it, it’s women who get bullied.

The shop staff should be trained properly so that they explain that it’s the law, not talk about “encouraging” as if women need to be chivvied into it.

I had premature twins and a very traumatic birth. I very much wanted to bf but it just wasn’t happening despite a lot of effort. I managed to pump a bit but nothing like enough to feed them. There was just no alternative to formula. Despite all my effort and distress I was treated horribly when I asked advice from LLL and NCT. They never accept that some women just can’t bf.

Like you @44PumpLane I finally gave up after 12 weeks. HV was relieved and told me I was doing the right thing. I cried for days at my “failure”.

The babies are now healthy teenagers.

Totallydefeated · 14/10/2021 16:50

He has a tongue tie and mashed up my boobs so much I was hospitalised a week later with an infection. Still got told I needed to toughen up and persevere and the tongue tie was a convenient excuse.

That is absolutely appalling.

I’m so sorry you went through all that and (and still are), then got treated so callously and judgementally. Please complain, if you’re up to it.

Twizbe · 14/10/2021 16:47

When these threads pop up I feel a little history of formula is useful. Plus a reminder that formula companies don't make it out of the kindness of their hearts.

Before formula babies either breastfed, had a wet nurse, drink cows milk mixed with sugar (I have a recipe for this in a 1950 baby book) or they died.

Formula was a lifesaver when invented. Powdered milk specifically tailored to the nutritional needs of babies is amazing!

BUT it relies on safe drinking water and sterilising of bottles. It was (and still is) expensive. When first introduced it was really expensive when considering average incomes. All fine if you have the money to buy it and to live somewhere with clean water.

Still formula companies were free to advertise as they chose. Slogans such as 'feed your baby with science' came out. Promises that your baby would be clever, sleep better, be more attractive etc.

After a while the issues caused by using unclean water / bottles / watering it down to make it last longer started to become apparent. The claims made about formula were scientifically disproven and general feeling baby nutrition needed to be a bit better controlled.

So 2 things happened. First was putting lots of rules around formula, how it's made, what goes into it and requirements for proof to back up claims.

Second was the ban on advertising first formula. This included all the other reward schemes etc that are included here.

It was because of this ban that 'follow on milk' was created - they can advertise that one.

The person in the shop was sloppy in how she explained it to you. Likely they are not really aware of the rules and why they are there.

Wineandroses3 · 14/10/2021 16:42

As others have said it’s got nothing to do with Boots, it’s the law they cannot be seen to be promoting formula over breastfeeding because from a purely health point of view breast milk is better for a baby than manufactured formula.

WithMyEncyclopedia · 14/10/2021 16:37

As everyone else says. There was even (it might be folklore!) some issue of someone not getting free parking at a store when they went in just to buy formula. (So the equivalent of parking in Tesco's car park but not buying anything in Tesco - doubt anyone really gives a crap).

Basically you can't 'benefit' in any way from buying formula.

You shouldn't feel shamed, it's a weird kind of consequence of a policy decision elsewhere. Flowers

dementedpixie · 14/10/2021 16:35

@lemmein

I can understand the thinking behind promotions (so you don't switch brands) - but not being allowed to collect or spend points on first year formula seems punitive and loaded with judgement.
Its not so you don't switch brands It's in case you bought formula at a discount and then the price goes up and you are then tied into a higher price unless you go chopping and changing milk all the time. Once you start giving formula its harder to go back to breastfeeding.

It only applies to 1st milk so follow on milk isn't subject to the same restrictions (which is why follow on milk was invented!)

Osrie · 14/10/2021 16:34

@pleurotus

Why not use the same law with sugar and processed foods then I wonder...
Excellent point OP . I think you should provide constructive criticism to Boots . Imagine someone who gets totally knocked back by such a thoughtless comment. No need to say when or name the person but definitely something they can improve immediately!
CaledonianSleeper · 14/10/2021 16:33

@pleurotus

Why not use the same law with sugar and processed foods then I wonder...
Because society uses the full force of the law to judge women and their choices. Everyone else can do more or less whatever they want. Grin
SunshineCake1 · 14/10/2021 16:32

Boots have never allowed points to be used for formula.

lemmein · 14/10/2021 16:32

I can understand the thinking behind promotions (so you don't switch brands) - but not being allowed to collect or spend points on first year formula seems punitive and loaded with judgement.

dementedpixie · 14/10/2021 16:29

There's lots of things you can't spend them on (i just had a look)

Points cannot be spent on prescription and selected dispensary items, Pharmacy services, selected medicines, infant milks (up to six months), gift cards, postage stamps, mobile phone top-up cards, gift boxes, delivery charges, charitable merchandise, at our ‘third party sites’ Boots Kitchen appliances, on Boots Opticians products and services, Boots Hearingcare or on Travel Services and Boots Insurance, bootsphoto.com, bootsdesignersunglasses.com and bootspersonalisedgifts.com

Member984815 · 14/10/2021 16:26

It's a well known policy I thought. Just pay cash for them and nevermind her, it won't be a judgement on you at all

Pesimistic · 14/10/2021 16:23

It's not a judgement of boots staff or any company, formula isn't allowed to be 'promoted' or discounted its actualy a good thing, or we would probably have an even worse breast feeding rate than we already do

fantasmasgoria1 · 14/10/2021 16:22

They like the profit from formula milk though!

Swipe left for the next trending thread