Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at boots for this

111 replies

pleurotus · 14/10/2021 14:22

I have a 4 month old who is 95% breastfed. She has had the odd bottle of formula here and there to see if she would take it and so that I can leave her with her Dad should I want a night off or whatever and without having to stash our freezer full of breast milk.

I went in to boots today and tried to buy two bottles of ready made formula with my boots points only for the woman to say I wasn't allowed to use my points to pay for them. When I asked why she said 'because we encourage women to breastfeed'

AIBU to find this ridiculous? I felt a little shamed by her and judged. I almost said 'well I do breastfeed actually' but stopped myself because it's a frigen choice! And so what if I didn't breastfeed at all, it would still be my choice and nobody should be made to feel bad about that. I can't imagine not being able to use your points to pay for formula is hardly discouraging anyone from bottle feeding anyway!

However should I have wanted to spend all of my advantage points on dairy milk and coke that's absolutely fine apparently and boots encourage that Hmm

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Amymamabear89 · 15/10/2021 15:26

I knew about the boots points thing (tried to pay myself with points a short while ago) however the comment about breast feeding isn’t fair even midwives can’t push the subject now never mind anyone else. It’s personal choice, and sometimes we don’t even get a choice.

BoredZelda · 15/10/2021 14:45

I’m a huge advocate of breastfeeding but I think your insistence that you only use formula occasionally is actually pretty snooty to mums who've made it the perfectly valid choice to formula feed.

Or, the OP has been affected by all the messaging that a good parent breastfeeds and formula is sub-standard and finds it necessary to make sure people know she is a good parent.

Anytime anyone saw me breastfeeding, they would launch into a story of why they didn’t do it, even women who’s kids were then adults at the time. All I had done was feed my child but they felt it necessary to explain why they hadn’t. I couldn’t have cared less, but when parents 20 and 30 years on were still finding it important to explain themselves there is something going wrong with how we treat FF parents.

BoredZelda · 15/10/2021 14:41

maybe it's time we relaxed this law seen as we are out of the EU

Was a law in the U.K. long before it was a law in the EU.

holibobs12 · 15/10/2021 14:13

@Stuckhere2021

All this shit actually makes me angry. What if the mother died in childbirth/ was too poorly to feed? What if the baby was given up for adoption? What if the mother had a condition that could be passed on through breast milk? What if the mother was on chemo or medication which meant she couldn’t breast feed? What if the mother was ill / unconscious/ depressed and couldn’t breast feed? This is in addition to the mastectomy situation allied to in my earlier post. Note also - points can’t be used for stamps - what’s that about!!

But formula isn't forbidden it's just not incentivised. You can still buy it, so there's no point wondering about the mother who hypothetically died in childbirth.

Formula is still stocked

WheelieBinPrincess · 15/10/2021 13:57

Breastfeeding rates are shit because there is fuck all support in a lot of cases and too much of pedalling of how natural and easy it’s ‘supposed’ to be. When the reality is anything but for many, many women.

Patapouf · 15/10/2021 13:50

@vickyc90

What happened to fed is best! We all know times are tough for many maybe it's time we relaxed this law seen as we are out of the EU
Breastfeeding rates are shocking in this country, I don't think relaxing rules on marketing is a good idea at all.

If it's an issue of affordability we need to address the much bigger problem of shit wages in this country!

Patapouf · 15/10/2021 13:48

It's got nothing to do with Boots, it's just the law. No promotions on formula, end of.

Nobody cares whether you FF or BF and I doubt the boots shop assistant would have been interested in you breastfeeding 95%. It matters more to you than anyone else.

I'm a huge advocate of breastfeeding but I think your insistence that you only use formula occasionally is actually pretty snooty to mums who've made it the perfectly valid choice to formula feed.

BoredZelda · 15/10/2021 09:33

Woman need guided by either their own instincts or medical professionals and not by companies seeking profits

I agree with this to an extent, but my experience back in 2009 was the medical professionals were more interested in filling the forms and ticking the boxes so they could gain their gold badge in breastfeeding from whatever organisation thought this was a great idea. “Can you just sign this form to say I’ve encouraged and helped you succeed in breastfeeding” is just as bad for a struggling new mum as “buy this formula, it’s grrrrrreat”

BoredZelda · 15/10/2021 08:51

“guilt comes from within” is really quite a vile thing to say in this context. Victim blaming at its finest. Shame on you.

Wow, such a harsh knee jerk reaction there.

It is correct that people can’t make you feel guilty about something unless there is already self doubt. They can play on that and work it up and bring it out but they can’t place a guilt when someone is confident in their choices.

The real question, as @YourFinestPantaloons further explained is what brings women to question their choices. The answer is often other women which is hideous, and in this case it is also the massive marketing machine behind the misguided “breast is best” messaging. It started with a decent intention but has resulted in those who don’t breastfeed for whatever reason, feeling they have to explain themselves.

YourFinestPantaloons · 14/10/2021 23:37

I actually think you should write to Boots OP and ask them to make their staff aware of the rules around formula, she maybe genuinely didn't know! And they need to word their reasons more accurately because TBH 'we encourage breastfeeding' isn't just wrong but a bit weird to say to someone who presumably isn't breastfeeding and can't just suddenly take it up

BFCfairy · 14/10/2021 23:30

I'll correct my prior post - boots lady should have said "by law we can't accept points" so op is not bu by thinking boots lady meant boots policy.

However to all the posters saying it shaming and what about babies who can't bf. I think we need to take a step back and look holistically at society not anecdotally.

I don't think the law shames woman at all.

As a whole it protects society from companies who want to make money from new mothers and actively seek to undermine them.

Facts are and not limited to

Formula companies aggressivly market formula and it has detrimental effects on BF. Numerous cases of this through the years. U.S hospitals with separate baby sections. formula in countries with no clean water. It's law like the one we have that protects us from both aggressive and deliberately subversive methods used.

Government want to promote / encourage socierty as a whole is better off when BF rates are higher. Woman need guided by either their own instincts or medical professionals and not by companies seeking profits

There is not enough £ put into supporting woman to bf.

Woman should have a choice how to feed however there are many different groups of woman such as

Woman who want and can easily bf

Woman who want to bf find it hard and need support so they can carry on

By helping the above you help bf % increase as the % who try at day 0 plummet over the course of a few weeks. So you target issues as to why they stopped.

Then there is the group of
Woman who might not see bf as the "norm" who could be educated and supported through the early days

You are then left with

Woman who want the choice and choose not to - at which point it is their choice to buy formula

And finally those who can't for many different reasons who should again be supported and could argue be helped with prescription milk.

So in short it comes down to money on all sides. the law is free to implement and curb companies who still got around it by inventing follow on milk. So I agree with the law.

I know that wasn't the question but unless that £350m a week is ploughed into bf then not sure how woman are protected at a vulnerable time in life.

YourFinestPantaloons · 14/10/2021 23:27

@Stuckhere2021

All this shit actually makes me angry. What if the mother died in childbirth/ was too poorly to feed? What if the baby was given up for adoption? What if the mother had a condition that could be passed on through breast milk? What if the mother was on chemo or medication which meant she couldn’t breast feed? What if the mother was ill / unconscious/ depressed and couldn’t breast feed? This is in addition to the mastectomy situation allied to in my earlier post. Note also - points can’t be used for stamps - what’s that about!!
You can still buy plenty of formula. You just can't use your points. Access to formula is not restricted by any means in this country
YourFinestPantaloons · 14/10/2021 23:22

But what about babies who cannot be breastfed for reasons I’ve mentioned?

What about them?

Let me explain, I should have elaborated...I don't care how people choose to feed, more power to women having a choice I say! But let's not pretend that the cashier at Boots is judging us. Or anyone for that matter. The whole "feeling guilt" gubbins is spun to women (for a reason) as if we should always be second guessing our choices, but it's a lie. It's not real, and no one cares how randoms feed their baby. But corporations have a vested interest in women feeling insecure and guilty about their choices. If you feel guilty it's because it comes from within, rather than anyone else's real feeling, and we all need to stop telling ourselves there's anything to feel guilty about! Not just regarding feeding, but every parenting choice.

I feel guilty about nothing, I refuse to buy into that BS

Darceyhemingway · 14/10/2021 23:15

Just read some more replies. Okay good I'm glad it's not boots on rule but the way the cashier said it made it sound like it was

Darceyhemingway · 14/10/2021 23:14

Or don't want too. It is a choice! Disgusting behaviour from
Boots

Darceyhemingway · 14/10/2021 23:14

That's absolutely disgusting I'd be complaining! I'm pregnant and would so so love to BF but if my milk dosent come in or I just can't I don't want to be shamed but I know I will!

Stuckhere2021 · 14/10/2021 23:14

@YourFinestPantaloons - “guilt comes from within” is really quite a vile thing to say in this context. Victim blaming at its finest. Shame on you.

BoredZelda · 14/10/2021 23:14

will just point out though, they don’t actually let you use your points for partial payment of anything, it has to cover the whole amount. You can’t use them towards anything.

Is this new? You used to be able to use partial points off your boots card and pay the cash balance.

Stuckhere2021 · 14/10/2021 23:11

@YourFinestPantaloons

Not just Boots, everywhere does it. A bit like how you can't buy a lottery tickets or fags with points.

The woman was wrong about the intentions tough. She should just have said legally we can't because laws that protect breastfeeding.

I actually agree with the law. Formula companies spend billions in advertising, and will try shady tactics to circumvent regulations and rules. Give these places an inch and they'll take a mile. Whereas no one really advocates for breastfeeding - theres limited NHS funding and charities/organisations may run campaigns but can't stack up against the money formula companies have. I think we need to support any opportunity to ensure it's a more level playing field. And stop lying to ourselves that anyone is trying to make women feel guilty. Guilt comes from within

But what about babies who cannot be breastfed for reasons I’ve mentioned?
Stuckhere2021 · 14/10/2021 23:09

All this shit actually makes me angry. What if the mother died in childbirth/ was too poorly to feed? What if the baby was given up for adoption? What if the mother had a condition that could be passed on through breast milk? What if the mother was on chemo or medication which meant she couldn’t breast feed? What if the mother was ill / unconscious/ depressed and couldn’t breast feed? This is in addition to the mastectomy situation allied to in my earlier post. Note also - points can’t be used for stamps - what’s that about!!

YourFinestPantaloons · 14/10/2021 23:03

Not just Boots, everywhere does it. A bit like how you can't buy a lottery tickets or fags with points.

The woman was wrong about the intentions tough. She should just have said legally we can't because laws that protect breastfeeding.

I actually agree with the law. Formula companies spend billions in advertising, and will try shady tactics to circumvent regulations and rules. Give these places an inch and they'll take a mile. Whereas no one really advocates for breastfeeding - theres limited NHS funding and charities/organisations may run campaigns but can't stack up against the money formula companies have. I think we need to support any opportunity to ensure it's a more level playing field. And stop lying to ourselves that anyone is trying to make women feel guilty. Guilt comes from within

Happyhedgehog20 · 14/10/2021 23:00

I had this exact same rage at Boots about this. Was told the same thing and told that it is illegal for them to promote formula in anyway in order to encourage breastfeeding. I was a new mum at the time struggling to feed my child and felt very shamed by it.

Stuckhere2021 · 14/10/2021 22:59

Another example of taking a sledgehammer to crack a nut and blaming women for problems caused by multinational companies. Take an extreme case - a mother with bilateral mastectomies - why should this mother be shamed because companies put profits before people. And without being too feminazi (although I am happy to be) most of the CEOs are men.

dementedpixie · 14/10/2021 22:59

Were you buying other products as the T&Cs say they can't be used for infant formula?

Vouchers are the property of Tesco Stores Limited and have no cash value. They are not for resale / publication and valid in the UK and IoM only. Defaced / copied vouchers will not be accepted. Valid for use only by the recipient, age restrictions apply. Excludes tobacco, Esso fuels, lottery, bureau de change, prescriptions, e-top up, infant formula milk, saving stamps, postage stamps, online delivery charges, in-store cafes, Tesco and branded gift cards and the Tesco Outlet eBay shop.

alexio · 14/10/2021 22:54

@dementedpixie no it was aptamil 1. Bought it on several occasions with Clubcard vouchers

Swipe left for the next trending thread