Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people don't realise...

88 replies

OhNoHelloSnow · 14/10/2021 09:59

That there's way more healthcare professionals who can help them other than just the "GP or A and E NOW " options?

Seen so many threads recently where people haven't been able to get an appointment with a GP so think A and E is the only option left but are unwilling to try GP Nurses, Nurses Practitioners, Pharmacists, Rapid Response Care Teams (where available and if applicable), Self Referrals to services like Podiatry, or Physio, or IAPT (where applicable), 111, Out of Hours Hub GPs etc.

Just feeling like this all contributes to our over stretched GPs and A and E departments at the moment.

OP posts:
user1471447863 · 14/10/2021 14:45

Heres a radical idea - instead of having all these disparate services scattered all over & people unaware as to what exactly is and isn't available in their area let alone where it is or how to access it, how about we group them under one roof and make it a single point of access. Phone the reception and get triaged and booked into the most appropriate service, then if they determine otherwise they can post you to the next most appropriate. It could be something like a 'Heath Centre'

SirenSays · 14/10/2021 14:39

That's an excellent reason to never use that sort of invasive uncontrollable contraception. At least you can stop taking a pill whenever you like

Not everyone can just take a pill. Hormonal contraception isn't great for everyone.

Bigassbeebuzzbuzz · 14/10/2021 14:24

At our drs you just phone up ask for an appointment and the receptionist tells you if you need a nurse or doctor.
Not a chance am I asking a pharmacist anything in the middle of a busy pharmacy nor am I asking for a private chat.
I dont think we have any walk in centres around here only drs or a&e

hashbrownsandwich · 14/10/2021 14:21

I am lucky that my surgery where I work has been doing Dave to face appointments all through the pandemic for those who need them.

Every incoming request for help we receive is triaged by the medical team but the reception team have clear training on certain areas. I like to refer to it as patients being able to 'help us help you'.

We always ask what patients have done to try and help themselves. For example, sore throat or rashes (having checked the obvious menengitis and sepsis signs), have you seen a pharmacist?

It still amazes me people think they need to see a Dr rather than nurses, HCAs, pharmacists etc. We really do need the NHS to educate people on this.

DeepaBeesKit · 14/10/2021 14:15

The problem is many of the alternatives to the GP are services that are through your GP surgery as gatekeeper.

Luckytattie · 14/10/2021 14:03

When people say "call the GP" i take that to mean call your practice and you'll be directed to the appropriate person..

SickAndTiredAgain · 14/10/2021 14:02

@bigbluebus the point that you don’t know the details still applies though. We once had an ambulance come for DD when she was a few days old. I’d called 111 just for some advice on an issue I thought was not serious, and they sent an ambulance. The paramedics checked DD over and were happy that she didn’t need to go to hospital, so they left. If you’d seen it from down the street maybe you’d have thought that we were wasting resources because they didn’t take anyone to hospital, but we hadn’t called them!

WorryMcGee · 14/10/2021 14:02

@bigbluebus

Where I live the Pharmacies all shut at 5pm (I think the 'late' one on rota might be open until 6pm). The MIU is only open 9-5 Monday to Friday. The nearest supermarket with a pharmacy is 15 miles away . So it's not really surprising that people don't use resources other than GPs or A&E. I also held on for 20 mins the other day to my GP surgery just to make an appointment for me & DH to have our flu jabs - I rang between 4 & 5 which is what they say is their quiet time, so goodness knows what it's like at busy times! No idea what the response time is on 111 as I haven't used it recently.

I have used the Pharmacist for advice (which was you need to see a GP today!) and have used private physio for me and private podiatrist for DS (the latter resulting in needing an op on the NHS), but we are lucky enough to be able to afford to pay. I know plenty of people who ring the GP for every little thing and the number of ambulances I've seen in our street that leave without taking a patient or the patient walks unaided to the ambulance when there's a car on the drive and a driver in the house never ceases to amaze me.

I totally agree @bigbluebus but just wanted to mention something about people walking to ambulances - last year my husband had a seizure out of the blue (turned out to be caused by a brain tumour) I called an ambulance during the seizure and they took him to hospital, but he did walk the few steps from the door to the ambulance. Not only did he want to move around (which I now know is common post-seizure) it was easier given our awkward door/position of the staircase. They didn’t even mention me driving him, but I wouldn’t have wanted to in case he had another one en route - and besides, I wasn’t really in any fit state to do it, I was barely holding it together. Loads of people definitely take the piss with ambulances but not every walking, conscious person is ❤️
bigbluebus · 14/10/2021 13:51

@WoodchipNightmares

I know plenty of people who ring the GP for every little thing and the number of ambulances I've seen in our street that leave without taking a patient or the patient walks unaided to the ambulance when there's a car on the drive and a driver in the house never ceases to amaze me.

The ambulance leaving without the patient doesn't mean that calling the ambulance was unnecessary.

A couple of examples from my own family

  • frail elderly relative started to look acutely unwell with a known UTI. Called the GP. The GP called us back very quickly and told us to call an ambulance as it may have been sepsis. Paramedics spent about an hour assessing her, determined that it wasn't sepsis, and that there was nothing that could be achieved in hospital that couldn't be done at home. They left without her.
  • a different elderly relative who fell over fairly frequently, and was confused. They couldn't get themselves up off the floor, and nor could the spouse, nor could the son living nearby. Ambulance was the only option - even if it was only to pick the relative up off the floor and check no damage had been done.
My street is full of young families though not elderly people!
Dotoallasyouwouldbedoneby · 14/10/2021 13:44

@PodgePie

I have been struggling with a displaced coil for months now - despite numerous trips to the GP, scans etc (and intense pain), I was told there was a six month referral time to be seen by gynaecology. I saw my GP again yesterday as I have been bed bound all week with nausea, dizziness, cramping and severe pain. She told me to go to A&E as there wasn't anything she could to do expedite the process for me. I went to A&E last night where I saw various nurses who couldn't do anything to help but they did refer me to gynaecology and this morning I finally had the coil removed. It is depressing that the only way to get immediate help (and relief) is to go straight to A&E, but I can understand why people do it if the normal channels aren't working.
That's an excellent reason to never use that sort of invasive uncontrollable contraception. At least you can stop taking a pill whenever you like.
PodgePie · 14/10/2021 12:52

I have been struggling with a displaced coil for months now - despite numerous trips to the GP, scans etc (and intense pain), I was told there was a six month referral time to be seen by gynaecology. I saw my GP again yesterday as I have been bed bound all week with nausea, dizziness, cramping and severe pain. She told me to go to A&E as there wasn't anything she could to do expedite the process for me. I went to A&E last night where I saw various nurses who couldn't do anything to help but they did refer me to gynaecology and this morning I finally had the coil removed. It is depressing that the only way to get immediate help (and relief) is to go straight to A&E, but I can understand why people do it if the normal channels aren't working.

WoodchipNightmares · 14/10/2021 12:09

I know plenty of people who ring the GP for every little thing and the number of ambulances I've seen in our street that leave without taking a patient or the patient walks unaided to the ambulance when there's a car on the drive and a driver in the house never ceases to amaze me.

The ambulance leaving without the patient doesn't mean that calling the ambulance was unnecessary.

A couple of examples from my own family

  • frail elderly relative started to look acutely unwell with a known UTI. Called the GP. The GP called us back very quickly and told us to call an ambulance as it may have been sepsis. Paramedics spent about an hour assessing her, determined that it wasn't sepsis, and that there was nothing that could be achieved in hospital that couldn't be done at home. They left without her.
  • a different elderly relative who fell over fairly frequently, and was confused. They couldn't get themselves up off the floor, and nor could the spouse, nor could the son living nearby. Ambulance was the only option - even if it was only to pick the relative up off the floor and check no damage had been done.
Marelle · 14/10/2021 11:53

Other services aren’t directly accessible though. Regardless of whether you need GP, nurse, podiatrist, physio, they would all be accessed by calling the GP surgery and getting referred. Obviously I would go direct to dentist, optician or pharmacist.

SentDeliveredRead · 14/10/2021 11:49

[quote lovecamealong]@SentDeliveredRead Some people don't have 28 pence room in their budget. Especially with the cost of living soaring and the government cutting UC. There's a facebook group called 'food surviving on 50p a day' for a reason.[/quote]
I was waiting for a comment like this. My answer was in relation to the OPs question. It costs the NHS money for prescriptions, more than 28p. That was my point 🙄
I have every sympathy for people who are struggling

DumplingsAndStew · 14/10/2021 11:45

GP Nurses - via GP surgery
Nurses Practitioners - via GP surgery
Pharmacists - I use these as often as possible
Rapid Response Care Teams - not available
Podiatry - no self referral, referral via GP
Physio - no self referral, referral via GP
IAPT - not available
111 - I use where necessary, typically out of GP hours.
Out of Hours - appointment must be made via 111 or GP
Hub GPs - not available.

Not everyone has access to the same services, in the same way as you.

Yes, some people misuse the NHS in general, and the GP service more specifically, but there is also a breakdown in communication between people and services.

A few months ago, I contacted 111 after my daughter was suffering from an accident she had a few days earlier. The pre-recorded message said if it wasn't an emergency to call GP. I called the GP surgery who said it was a Minor Injuries Unit thing. I asked if I needed to get an appointment via 111 for that, and the receptionist said no, it's just drop in, 24 hours a day. I got there to find out that it's appointment only - can be made via 111 or GP - no walk ins, and they are only open set hours. Thankfully they weren't busy so were able to see DC, but they were very irritated with the incorrect advice being given out.

lovecamealong · 14/10/2021 11:39

@SentDeliveredRead Some people don't have 28 pence room in their budget. Especially with the cost of living soaring and the government cutting UC. There's a facebook group called 'food surviving on 50p a day' for a reason.

Britneyb · 14/10/2021 11:35

Not around here you don’t. It’s GP or A&E. 111 are no more help than Google and the pharmacist won’t look at certain things.
What’s needed is a walk in centre for everything open 24/7 and staffed by doctors and other HCPs. They could then refer people to the right pathway. Most people don’t need ongoing GP care just somewhere to go with acute illnesses and minor injuries.

Picklypickles · 14/10/2021 11:19

I've been looking for information about other services in my area but not had much luck in finding out via google etc so will probably have to call the GP Surgery and speak to the receptionist to find out! I have an ingrowing toenail, my mum used to fix it for me as she was a registered chiropodist but sadly due to her health she can't do it any more. I'm on ESA and can't even afford my bills let alone £30 odd for a private chiropodist and I don't know if this is something that can be seen to on the NHS or not!

userxxuser · 14/10/2021 11:18

Also in the UK we have been conditioned to think that the GP is the gateway (or rather gatekeeper) to all other health.
In other countries, you book appointments directly with gynaecologist, paediatrician etc. In the UK you have to have GP agreement and referral.
Hence the NHS and GPs have created this situation by years of wanting GPs to control all access to all healthcare.
Now they are bored and tired and feel overworked and despite earning more than almost anyone else in the NHS they want patients to find their own way to healthcare and medication.

breakforthewest · 14/10/2021 11:18

This came through my door recently. .its brilliant. ,details all local services. I learnt about cues...community urgent eye care services. ...already used it bypass gp and a&e....seen very quickly too.

To think that people don't realise...
To think that people don't realise...
userxxuser · 14/10/2021 11:16

basically feels like GP is saying please go away and find someone else, I am not interested.

HitchhikersGuide · 14/10/2021 11:15

Yanbu but people also need to take a lot more responsibility over their own health. As a society we are far too unhealthy and constantly rely on 'easy fixes' - pharma, 'diets' etc. Eat less processed food and move more would be a good start.

userxxuser · 14/10/2021 11:15

And it's not like the dentists are at a loose end either - mine says it will take 18 months to clear waiting list and not taking on any new patients. Obviously if it's toothache, I'll go to the dentist. But if I have a growth or serious infection, this is something I would expect a GP to help with. Ditto eyes and feet.

SirenSays · 14/10/2021 11:14

It's great in theory but that's about it. I've just spent so much money on pointless products from the pharmacy because I couldn't get an appointment with anyone at my GP practice.

userxxuser · 14/10/2021 11:13

My GP has changed its messaging to say basically don't contact with any problems with your eyes, teeth or feet.
OK, sure some problems can be dealt with by opticians and dentists, but these areas are also key areas for cancer, infections requiring prescription medication, emergent diabetes etc.
So even more life-threatening conditions going undiagnosed and untreated....
Just do your job GP. You are highly trained and highly paid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread