Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GPs should do their job

579 replies

Wotnokids · 14/10/2021 06:35

Just heard the news that £250million is to be made available to GPs to 'increase the amount of face to face appointments'. AIBU to think this is just extra cash for doing their job?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LemonTT · 17/10/2021 09:16

@Awalkintime

It wasn't a bizarre comment when it happened. They are cuts when the services are no longer there. Not cuts to funding but cuts to physical services. Labour also cut beds in hospital - they had to have wards at 95% capacity under labour and they couldn't have overspill wards they previously had for pressure points in the year. Prior to that there was extra capacity but Labour changed that - as in, cut services available (beds).
That was a change in how funding was invested not cuts. They spent more, just in different ways. And you are injecting this comment into a debate about primary care when investment was not cut during that period. Anything but.

The continued diversion of money into hospitals when it should be spent on primary care is a long standing problem. It’s better to prevent the reasons why people are in hospital by investing in primary care. That’s not even a debate.

Unfortunately anytime this is put into action, vested (hospital) interests whip up emotional sentiment by screaming cuts. I seem to recall Andrew Langsley was part of those protests about “cuts”. He subsequently halted the strategic policies aimed at improved primary and community services and implemented a disastrous restructuring.

It’s a significant problem in the NHS that people with vested interests block all change and improvement by screaming cuts. Even when that wasn’t the case as it was under new Labour.

Awalkintime · 17/10/2021 08:55

It wasn't a bizarre comment when it happened. They are cuts when the services are no longer there. Not cuts to funding but cuts to physical services. Labour also cut beds in hospital - they had to have wards at 95% capacity under labour and they couldn't have overspill wards they previously had for pressure points in the year. Prior to that there was extra capacity but Labour changed that - as in, cut services available (beds).

LemonTT · 17/10/2021 08:45

[quote Theworldisfullofgs]I worked in the nhs when labour came in, in 1997. The sense of optimism was amazing. And we got funding, we could actually do stuff. So I'm not sure wher you got that from Awalkintime. Any facts to go with the statement? And btw I'm fairly agnostic when it comes to political parties.

Thought some might enjoy this.

twitter.com/LBC/status/1448962003989635096?t=F5L7VdwpquUFe9fsWOjFOg&s=19[/quote]
Yes that was a most bizarre comment. Funding for GPs was particularly generous during the 2000-2010 period. I think most media highlighted that UK GPs among the highest paid in the world. And that the then new GP contract was money for old rope.

Unfortunately a few GP partners did just back pocket the extra funding and even got rid of previously directly NHS funded nurses. This small number of practices aren’t good places to work, then and now. Salaried GP, nurses and trainees elect to go elsewhere. That’s why there is excellence and dross in GP provision.

And what happens when they try to get rid of the dross? People complain and scream cuts. When it is anything but.

julieca · 17/10/2021 00:02

I remember about 20-15 years ago when the NHS services were way better because they were properly funded. I have a rare illness where I get occasional really bad flare-ups. About 15 years ago I had one and went to the GP. The next day the nurse visited me at home to do an assessment of my home needs. Hospital appointment a week later, followed up weekly and some nurse appointments.
I had a flare-up again about 5 years ago. Gp appointment and referred to a clinic I waited a month to attend. Then monthly follow-ups with a nurse. I mean I did get better. But the level of care was like chalk and cheese and it took longer. I was actually a bit shocked the second time to wait a month to see someone. Yes, I could have gone back to my GP but he doesn't know any more about my illness than what he can read on the internet. I needed a specialist.

I only share this to say it doesn't need to be like it is currently in the NHS. It was way better and it takes money. But if you cut the NHS constantly, GPs retire early, it gets harder to persuade people to become GPs, and care gets worse.

An insurance scheme terrifies me. I have to pay a lot for holiday insurance and cant get life insurance. I also at times have a lot of appointments, and even when things are okay, I probably have an appointment about every two months. I think I would have to quit working so any insurance costs were covered by the state.

Awalkintime · 16/10/2021 21:52

I didn't say they spent less, I said they made cuts to services.

Awalkintime · 16/10/2021 21:51

It is in Lancashire. Burnley, Chorley and Rochdale A n E were closed.

I know that is somewhere spectacularly different to the rest of the UK and largely ignored in politics. My local A n E closed. The nearest one is 30 minutes away. The old one was 5 minutes away. No paediatrics either near us now. They closed the wards in our area and so there are no services now unless its a drive out of town. No it isn't bullshit BelindaBumcrack Labour were just as shit as Tories.

BelindaBumcrack · 16/10/2021 21:42

@Theworldisfullofgs

What area do you live in the UK *@Awalkintime*? Because unless you live somewhere spectacularly different to the rest of the country that's not true,
Honestly, I wouldn't bother. It's all bullshit.

Labour did not make further massive cuts to the NHS.

NHS Labour Spending

Theworldisfullofgs · 16/10/2021 21:30

What area do you live in the UK @Awalkintime? Because unless you live somewhere spectacularly different to the rest of the country that's not true,

BelindaBumcrack · 16/10/2021 21:29

That just sounds like your local trust was shit. It wasn't the same everywhere. You can't really blame the Labour government for your trust spending funds they were given in the way they did. If they had specified where the money had to be spent they'd have been vilified for that.

The government gave them money. They didn't spend it in the right areas. I don't see how that is down to the government to be honest.

Awalkintime · 16/10/2021 21:23

They might've increased funding but they weren't spent on the right things. They were spent on managers to manage the managers. The frontline services didn't get it. They cut ALL A n E services near my area and cut countless other services such as maternity and paediatrics. There were huge issues in my area as a result so yes it is fact based.

BelindaBumcrack · 16/10/2021 21:17

@Awalkintime

I agree, they are running it into the ground but Labour did the same, massive cuts to services and new policies to cover their arseholes so they are all a much of a muchness.
That is not true at all. Can you please provide some evidence to support your post?
BelindaBumcrack · 16/10/2021 21:15

@julieca

And God help us then.
Absolutely.

The average monthly premium for medical insurance in the USA is $495. Which equates to about £360. How many people in the UK can afford to pay that every month?

Whilst some US citizens get medical cover as part of their employee benefits many do not. I haven't got a spare £700 a month for me and DH. Do you?

And then you are in the position where employees in an insurance company get to decide whether the treatment your consultant recommends is approved. Life saving treatment can be refused based on costs rather than clinical outcomes.

Giving birth in the USA costs about $13k - Birth Medical Bill Here in the UK I didn't pay a penny more than I did in tax and NI. Is this really where we want to go?

Stop falling for the government propaganda about GPs. They are doing their absolute best whilst the government starve the NHS of funds. Do you really want us to move to the US system? Have you got £8K spare each year to pay for the medical insurance for you and your OH? And do you really want someone in an insurance firm having the deciding vote as to whether your DC can have the life saving treatment that their consultant recommends?

This is exactly where we are heading and this is exactly what this government wants. We have to resist this.

Theworldisfullofgs · 16/10/2021 21:05

www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-may-not-telling-the-whole-story-on-nhs-funding

@Awalkintime nhs funding grew under labour - see under claim 2.

Theworldisfullofgs · 16/10/2021 21:01

I worked in the nhs when labour came in, in 1997. The sense of optimism was amazing. And we got funding, we could actually do stuff. So I'm not sure wher you got that from Awalkintime. Any facts to go with the statement? And btw I'm fairly agnostic when it comes to political parties.

Thought some might enjoy this.

twitter.com/LBC/status/1448962003989635096?t=F5L7VdwpquUFe9fsWOjFOg&s=19

Awalkintime · 16/10/2021 20:53

I agree, they are running it into the ground but Labour did the same, massive cuts to services and new policies to cover their arseholes so they are all a much of a muchness.

julieca · 16/10/2021 20:40

And God help us then.

BelindaBumcrack · 16/10/2021 20:38

Our GP surgery has held face to face appointments throughout the pandemic. Yes, they were triaged, but anyone who needed a face to face appointment got one.

My Mum needed two. One for vaginal bleeding- she's 78 - and another for suspected DVT when her leg swelled up. She was given same day appointments and referred to hospital for both issues. The care she was given was excellent. Absolutely no complaints.

I however had a phone consultation for HRT. I didn't need to be seen in person. Spoke to the GP and submitted my blood pressure reading via email. No problem.

My son is under the care of a consultant endocrinologist following thyroid cancer and previous childhood cancer, which caused the thyroid cancer. He has regular phone consultations. His care hasn't been compromised in the slightest by his appointments being held by phone. He's currently on a new medication regime that was all arranged via phone consultation.

The simple fact is that we don't have enough GPs. No amount of government breast beating or trying to blame current GPs for the situation changes that fact. It is the government that has underfunded the NHS and that wants to privatise it.

Wake up people. This is exactly what the Conservative government did to the rail industry when it was publicly owned. Underfunded it, ran it down until it became a national joke and then privatisation was the great solution. This is where we are headed with the NHS.

julieca · 16/10/2021 20:23

@Badbadbunny GPs need to decide to do what works best for them. Just as schools and other services do. I would be against a one size fits all.

Badbadbunny · 16/10/2021 20:17

[quote TravelLost]@FAD2016 did these people know how the NHS app is working and what you can do with it?

Pre covid, my surgery was using a different system which was made redundant with covid. You could book appointment, look at your test results etc…
I assumed this had just disappeared with covid until I read on here that the nhs app had basically replace the old system for most the stuff. But I haven’t seen any article, any information at the surgery (posters etc…) about it. How can we then expect people to just know???

Maybe the first step is to do a campaign of information before telling everyone they are time wasters.[/quote]
Many GP surgeries simply don't use all the facilities available via the online systems. All I can do on any app, whether it;s "patient access" or the NHS app or "my GP" is order repeat prescriptions. Nothing else has been activated by the surgery, no way of sending messages nor booking appointments. That's the problem really, the lack of consistency between GP surgeries, in that some have embraced the apps and let you book appointments, send messages, etc but others havn't.

julieca · 16/10/2021 20:13

I know receptionists dont triage. I phoned for an appointment and said it could wait, was given an appointment in three days time. Half an hour later the GP rang to ask me about my symptoms and then said she needed to examine me in person, could I come in. It was the GP that triaged and decided to ring me back.

welliesarefuntowear · 16/10/2021 20:07

I think and correct me if I'm wrong the funding roughly equates to £8000 per practice for the year. That would roughly equate to a £1 per patient where I work. I suspect the money will be used to improve online services and that is where the push will be.

Parker231 · 16/10/2021 18:33

Fudgein - the money won’t improve the numbers of GP’s. The population has increased, GP’s are leaving in every increasing numbers, it takes 10 years to train as a doctor and become a GP and the government have failed (repeatedly) to recruit the numbers promised from overseas.

Fudgein · 16/10/2021 18:16

I think this is a great idea, more GPs can only benefit society as a whole. I think the way they have been operating during COVID hasn't been explained to the public very well & has caused resentment. People also seem to think GPs should know every diagnosis for every illness on the planet. Really pleased to hear they will recieve more funding.

MyGhastIsFlabbered · 16/10/2021 18:05

@Wotnokids GPs do so much more than face to face appointments - it's not that simple. I doubt very much that any of this money is going to go directly into GPs pockets.

tradition · 16/10/2021 17:54

Please listen to this. It will give you an insight to what is happening in GP land at present.