Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GPs should do their job

579 replies

Wotnokids · 14/10/2021 06:35

Just heard the news that £250million is to be made available to GPs to 'increase the amount of face to face appointments'. AIBU to think this is just extra cash for doing their job?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Maverickess · 14/10/2021 09:56

They were able to see patients prior to covid so why not now? Why extra money? To get a nice coffee machine and biscuits no doubt.

I'm not sure you realise, but a novel virus came to town a couple of years ago, and no one had any immunity to it, so lots of people got sick and continue to do so.
This increased the workload of the people who look after the sick, when there already weren't enough of them in a lot of places to start with, and then they came up with a vaccine that the people who look after us when we're sick were asked to vaccinate us with, on top of an increased work load due to this little virus. People also found themselves in bad situations due to the fall out of this little virus, and needed treatment and support to get through it. Services for other illnesses were stopped in order to make room for this little virus, and caused a backlog of people waiting for treatment.
And two years later, there's now a proposal to give extra funding to address that increased workload.

🤦

Changednamehere56 · 14/10/2021 09:55

@maybemu ASD and chronic anxiety mean I can only do the phone triage with one known GP.

maybemu · 14/10/2021 09:49

These type of threads make me laugh so much. Firstly they are doing their jobs. They have actually made their jobs far more efficient. You don't need a face to face appointment. Too many people use this service for a chat with someone. It is not there for that. Most problems can be solved over the phone. There is no need to go in and see someone. It is a new way to triage people and you need to get used to it. It won't go back to how it was. If anyone can give me a good reason as to why they can't start with a phone call and see if you need to be seen face to face other than you want to I'll listen.

1990s · 14/10/2021 09:48

[quote DrManhattan]@1990s
I'm asking questions on a forum (that's what they are for) calm yourself down before you make yourself ill. Xxx[/quote]
Not sure if those kisses were meant to be passive aggressive - but they were!

This topic is absolutely worth getting riled up about for me.

Mummydoctor · 14/10/2021 09:48

@Cryalot2 the job I trained to do isn’t what the job has become. I am a highly trained professional but I am also human, that’s what makes me a good GP.

I want to do the best by my patients. But I can’t do that with the current system. I am not complaining for me, I am unhappy with the service the government are funding/providing as my patients are suffering. If I also burn out and leave, who will advocate for my patients then?

borntobequiet · 14/10/2021 09:45

They were able to see patients prior to covid so why not now? Why extra money? To get a nice coffee machine and biscuits no doubt.

Assume that’s tongue in cheek, otherwise it’s the most stupid thing I’ve read in a time of reading very stupid things every day.

Mummydoctor · 14/10/2021 09:43

@Maverickess 🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽

Cryalot2 · 14/10/2021 09:42

Gps choose their jobs, so know the score.
So many people are being neglected, wrongly diagnosed and others die because of the system. How many people have to die before anything is done?
Not everyone can afford to go private.
It's just like the honours. People get honours for doing the job they are paid to.
We used to have one of the best practices there was. Now the local death rate is high.
Many people avoid ringing the drs as there is nothing to facilitate those with hearing lose, then should you get through (almost impossible ) you get a frosty receptionist who demands to know if you really need a dr and what is wrong. ( she has no triage training) if you have personal or mental health problems you certainly do not want to tell her.
I had to send photos last year and overheard a receptionist discuss it socially. I did nothing as dh said to leave it as he depends on the practice .
They were able to see patients prior to covid so why not now? Why extra money? To get a nice coffee machine and biscuits no doubt.

Maverickess · 14/10/2021 09:38

My GP surgery is not great, they weren't pre pandemic either, but that's probably because it covers a geographically really large area and there's 3 GPs and a practice nurse. It's a rural area, but socially pretty deprived with towns and villages etc.
Is it frustrating when I've got my employer breathing down my neck for a sick note? Yes.
Is it frustrating when I need treatment or a referral for treatment and I can't even get through on the phone? Yes.
But we're all aware that funding has been cut in the NHS, yet due to a little virus doing the rounds and a big upsurge in mental illness (not to mention long covid, and everything else that people get sick with) need has increased. How can any service be run effectively on less resources and more demands? It doesn't matter how hard the people who deliver that service work, or what they get paid, they can't bend time to create more and they don't stop needing things like sleep and down time.
Trying to ensure services are safe as can be where covid is concerned causes delays to that service, and if time is already at a premium, then phone consults are enabling more people to get some help sooner rather than none at all for an indefinite amount of time. But people are increasingly refusing to accept that things have, and have to, change to accommodate this. Refusing to accept that doesn't mean it still doesn't need to happen.

I feel like GPs are in a similar situation to many in healthcare, provide good service to fewer people, leaving many without a service at all, or more people a worse service but at least they're getting something.
If the NHS isn't going to be funded and managed properly, then we need to adjust expectations, but as it is they're just increasing.
GPs are not the ones deciding on funding or managing the service as a whole, they're trying to work with what they've got - the government are the ones deciding the funding and the management of it, and are quite likely people who've never touched a patient in their lives.
But while we keep up this argument that GPs are the ones at fault, nothing is going to change because the GPs can't change it, we're blaming the wrong people who are already under a lot of pressure and are (despite popular opinion) humans that don't just exist to treat our illnesses. Instead of demanding the people who can do something actually do it, we're adding that pressure to people who can't - and that's going to have the knock on effect of losing them from the service all together, which isn't going to improve things, rather the opposite.

TravelLost · 14/10/2021 09:35

@southcarolina, do you know that some newspapers managed to say that the shortage of HGV drivers was ALSO the GP fault ?

TravelLost · 14/10/2021 09:34

@tealandteal

The extra funding is not for individual GPs, but for the practice to fund getting a locum in or perhaps a paramedic/physio to take on some work so that the GP can see more patients face to face.
I’m actually wondering what they will do with that money tbh.

If there are thousands of GP missing, where can you find a locum?
If paramedics are stretched to the limit, where can you find more paramedics to work in go surgeries?

Putting money in is a good thing (even though i suspect this is just a drop in the ocean), but I’m wondering where all those people are going to magically appear from

Hesperatum · 14/10/2021 09:33

The constant bashing of GPs by the Daily Mail and the media in general is horrific. I know of several who are about to leave general practice because of the inhuman demands made upon them. We need a health minister who has some medical knowledge, understands the pressures and just doesn't spout provocative headlines to appease the masses.

southcarolina · 14/10/2021 09:32

I'll post this again as I do on all these threads

To think GPs should do their job
BananaBlue · 14/10/2021 09:31

@brittleheadgirl

My job is 'endlessly exhausting' I'm an early years teacher, in a large, very diverse inner city school. I'm paid at least, half maybe a third what a gp earns. The public are tired of gps still not returning to 'normal' and still not offering face to face appointments. I'm not surprised that people are angry. I like many have worked face to face throughout the pandemic and for a large part of it I was unvaccinated too.
The irony of this.

It’s not so long ago teachers were being heavily criticised in the media for teaching remotely and concerns on we their health.

Look how they lied about teachers, you think they aren’t lying about GPs too?

In the past ten years this country just points fingers at every one but those who have the power to make change.

And we all suffer for that.

Fanacapan · 14/10/2021 09:29

The money isn’t going to go into the pocket of GPs, it will go into practice management of increased pressure on services. It goes to practices not individuals. There is an increasing scarcity of GPs, and it will only get worse so anyone moaning about them should be aware they are contributing to the inevitable collapse of the whole system. You’ll miss them when they’re gone!

ilovesooty · 14/10/2021 09:29

Sadly this government has played a blinder.
No wonder with the ignorance of the electorate.
Some practices will have handled patient care better than others but there is no way all patients could routinely be seen face to face without a triaging system just because that's what they want.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/10/2021 09:28

Tories slash and burn anything NHS or public sector.

Mummydoctor · 14/10/2021 09:27

@Moraxella I completely agree. The medical schools are increasingly taking female students (which they should if done on merit) but where is the workforce planning? Who’s responsibility is that I wonder? 🤔

Just like the government have know for years that something like 1/3 of the GP workforce was due to retire - again complete lack of planning…see the pattern anyone??

southcarolina · 14/10/2021 09:27

You can push all the cash at training GPs you like, very few of us junior doctors will do it because it's a thankless slog which for the last year (and in my opinion for the foreseeable future) will include taking constant abuse and ridicule from members of the public who don't know what they're talking about and think that a GP 'day' is anything less than 14 hours, and carries more responsibility and unmeetable expectation than any one human should have to manage.
TLDR no one wants to be a GP because it's shit and you can earn the same money in hospital.

DrManhattan · 14/10/2021 09:24

@1990s
I'm asking questions on a forum (that's what they are for) calm yourself down before you make yourself ill. Xxx

Moraxella · 14/10/2021 09:22

Exactly @TravelLost
People want women to work full time, and look after their kids full time. And chastise them for putting them in someone else’s care while they have a career. We can never win. The DM waging war on part time medics is a war against female workers.

tealandteal · 14/10/2021 09:22

The extra funding is not for individual GPs, but for the practice to fund getting a locum in or perhaps a paramedic/physio to take on some work so that the GP can see more patients face to face.

StrawberrySquash · 14/10/2021 09:21

The GP service is too often not good enough. But that's the fault of successive governments and the crap conditions GPs work under, not the GPs themselves.

supermoonrising · 14/10/2021 09:19

GPS are doing their jobs, they're also leaving in droves. The Daily Mail whipping up hatred has been the last straw for many. Be careful what you wish for

A lot of British people have a weird attitude to public sector workers, presumably thanks to the incessant mantra of the right wing dominated media the last 3/4 decades.

Makes me think of this stat: “Statistics published by the DfE reveal that of teachers who qualified in 2014, just 67.4 per cent were still in service after five years in 2019”.

And yet somehow the answer to shortages and recruitment issues of GPs and teachers is just lecturing.

Moraxella · 14/10/2021 09:19

@Mummydoctor I’m with you! I’m ltft in hospital, but stupidly didn’t wait till after training for kids. The daily mail raging at part time doctors annoys me. Increasing % of graduate medics are female, this is going to be a workforce issue into the future. Why isn’t medicine as attractive to men anymore I wonder?

Swipe left for the next trending thread