Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you don’t have kids, do you care about climate change?

118 replies

Blankspace4 · 13/10/2021 22:20

I’m genuinely interested

YABU - I still care about climate change even though I don’t / can’t have children

YANBU - It doesn’t affect me - I don’t really care

I know the vote will polarise but also interested in comments. I can’t have children (long struggle, finally come to terms). I do try and act in the interests of the planet but frankly I am sick of the “think of your children and grandchildren” prevailing rationale - what does that mean for those of us who can’t have that?

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 14/10/2021 07:53

It could be argued that the child free care more about climate change as having children is the single most damaging thing we do to the planet.

That could only be argued if that's the reason they're not having children. Otherwise it's got literally nothing to do with caring about the issue.

jonhammsmistress · 14/10/2021 07:52

@TheChip

Places were meant to be under water years ago. Its like the boy who cried wolf effect to me. "If we don't do this we will die" has been around for a very very very long time.

I definitely don't think it matters whether you have kids or not to care.

That doesn't mean the things they suggest aren't beneficial for the planet, so I don't disregard them just because I think its like the boy who cried wolf.

Where was meant to be under water tears ago?

You're right in that this has been talked about for years, but this is because people were aware of the possibility of it coming. Its here now and its going to get a lot worse.

I don't have any children, in part due to climate change. Children being born into this world now are very frightened of what lays ahead for them.

Glitterybug · 14/10/2021 07:46

I don't think the average person recycling their yoghurt pots has any effect whatsoever on climate. We need massive far reaching worldwide cooperation, we need giant cocks to stop firing giant cocks into space and we need to stop building over every bit of green space. We have plenty of empty houses, use those first.

It all seems very very pointless to tell individuals they're not doing enough until the bigger things are addressed.

Hummingbird18 · 14/10/2021 07:46

Yabu - climate change is happening right now. It's not something that will only happen to future generations.

bogeythefungusman · 14/10/2021 07:45

It could be argued that the child free care more about climate change as having children is the single most damaging thing we do to the planet.

DappledThings · 14/10/2021 07:42

@Forgetaboutme

I can't lie. I have kids but still don't give climate change a single thought or worry about it in the slightest Blush
Me too. I'm aware of it and I do my recycling and we don't have the heating on too much and wotnot but I don't lie awake worrying about it.

There was a thread a while ago where the OP was astounded that not all women were regularly checking their breasts. That's a bit similar for me. I know I'm meant to and it's not like I have any objection to it or don't believe the science about both breast cancer and image change it's just that both fall off my mental radar very quickly. So even since that thread I have not remembered once to check my breasts and despite all the news I don't really think about the climate that often. I probably should think about both!

Theworldisfullofgs · 14/10/2021 07:41

I do have kids and I care about climate change as a much wider issue, about society in general.

Tbh your post sounds much more about your own issues about not having children (which I'm sorry for) - it sounds like a why should I give a f**k. But this is about you as a member of society nit just as an individual.

TheChip · 14/10/2021 07:36

Places were meant to be under water years ago.
Its like the boy who cried wolf effect to me.
"If we don't do this we will die" has been around for a very very very long time.

I definitely don't think it matters whether you have kids or not to care.

That doesn't mean the things they suggest aren't beneficial for the planet, so I don't disregard them just because I think its like the boy who cried wolf.

Brefugee · 14/10/2021 07:34

of course people who don't have children care about things

my eyes have rolled so far back in my head, OP.

torquewench · 14/10/2021 07:31

@Catflapkitkat

I have kids but later in in life. I do my bit. I haven't eaten meat since the age of 12, I don't personally drive (but DH does) I recycle and grow my own veg but I can't get that fussed about climate change. It has become hysterical of late.

The 80s were full of stories about disappearing ozone layer. I stopped using spray deodorant and hairspray because of CFCs. Now the ozone layer is healing. In 1957 The Thames was declared biologically dead - a stinking drain and unable to support life. In 2021 there are 125 different fish varieties and a thriving seal population. When I think back to my 70s childhood, the pavements were covered in ring pulls from cans, cigarette butts and dog poo. It's much better nowadays. It's not perfect but just small examples of how things can change.
A good many people are working hard behind the scenes to make a change. My trust is in them.

I'd echo this. Acid rain was going to completely strip the world's forests bare. And also, when you see photos of large buildings in cities maybe 40 - 50 years ago, they were all black with pollution because back then everything was heated by coal. People seem to have short memories.

Personally, I think the best thing we can do for the environment is produce fewer people.

I can't really take the current popular "we"re all doomed" narrative being pushed each time I turn on my TV or radio seriously, as my local city council has declared a "climate emergency" in the city, yet is pleased that there will be 107 cruise ship visits to the city, and thanks to our former mayor, all available green space in the city cente is being developed - huge multi storey towers for mixed use, all of which requiring tons of concrete, all needing aircon running all day etc. The former 1980s garden festival site is being developed into a housing estate with planning for 1500 homes on what was originally the city dump. The ex (disgraced) mayor deemed the green parkland and open space in the city suburbs a "barren wasteland" because he was desperate for another brown envelope legacy. Interestingly, local air quality readings were available online until about 10 years ago. I used to look at them regularly. Readings from various parts of the city all of which were always in the acceptable range. My ex can remember the shoreline of the river being coated in thick black stinking oily stuff, now it's clean, people are always down there fishing, and porpoises were spotted there earlier this year.

Another thing I can't understand here. I work in a building that's about 10-15 years old. Floor to ceiling windows. Plenty of natural light, all day every day, yet when people are in the office and moving about, the lights are on constantly and there's no switch to turn them off. Massive waste of energy (It's like Blackpool Illuminations 😁) but apparently its a "green' building. 🤔

Fourandtwentymilliondoors · 14/10/2021 07:23

I don’t have children because of climate change and environmental impacts.

Oblomov21 · 14/10/2021 07:20

I agree with a lot of what Gerbil writes. I make an effort, but most of what I put in my recycling bin goes to landfill. All my tiny efforts are pointless because huge corporations do little, and no one addresses the big factors such as oil and gas companies.

Do young people care. Clearly not, not Greta, if the rubbish and mess at Reading festival, lots of young people, was anything to go by, disgusting.

lazylinguist · 14/10/2021 07:14

There just seems to be so much emphasis on ‘future generations’

Future generations doesn't mean 'your own specific children/grandchildren'. If you can't summon up any feeling about the fate of children (or adults) who aren't related to you, or for animals, then I don’t know what to say really...

Facilitatingdarkness · 14/10/2021 07:01

@FOJN

I don't have children, I don't eat meat, I don't fly, I drive less than 5k miles a year and I am very rarely wasteful. I grew up in a household without central heating, a car or the money for international holidays.

I try to look for ways to reduce my carbon footprint. I don't think my individual actions are making a difference to climate change but I am sending a clear message that I understand humans need to make significant changes to the way we live and I'm prepared for the inconvenience those changes may bring.

I'm pretty fed up of being told to think of the children by people who have four of them, tumble dry everything, go on a couple of foreign holidays a year, buy fast fashion and have a half a dozen tech devices in every room of their overheated homes. Live your life the way you want but don't bend my ear about how useless the government are on climate change and what that means for your children when you are still driving your teenagers less than half a mile to the bus stop everyday. FFS

Quite.
Facilitatingdarkness · 14/10/2021 07:00

I care deeply about climate change. Definitely one of the reasons that I don't have kids.

Are you asking because you are wondering whether childfree people are less inclined to care because they don't have children or grandchildren to worry about? If so, it's definitely not the case my end!

FOJN · 14/10/2021 06:57

I don't have children, I don't eat meat, I don't fly, I drive less than 5k miles a year and I am very rarely wasteful. I grew up in a household without central heating, a car or the money for international holidays.

I try to look for ways to reduce my carbon footprint. I don't think my individual actions are making a difference to climate change but I am sending a clear message that I understand humans need to make significant changes to the way we live and I'm prepared for the inconvenience those changes may bring.

I'm pretty fed up of being told to think of the children by people who have four of them, tumble dry everything, go on a couple of foreign holidays a year, buy fast fashion and have a half a dozen tech devices in every room of their overheated homes. Live your life the way you want but don't bend my ear about how useless the government are on climate change and what that means for your children when you are still driving your teenagers less than half a mile to the bus stop everyday. FFS

FatsoGatso · 14/10/2021 06:57

Like others - climate change is one of the reasons I don't have children. I still care, because I care about nature and don't want to think about it destroyed or damaged. That said, whenever I read a prediction about an upcoming doom (eg within 50 years all the whatsits will be gone) I do a quick check and if I think I'll be dead and gone by then, I feel relieved.

Whilst I want things to last long after I'm gone, I particularly want them to last until then.

Santastuckincustoms · 14/10/2021 06:57

@SturminsterNewton

When I see oblique aerial views of London and how low it is, it makes me sad to think two thousands of years of history and culture underwater and lost. And that's just one city in one country.

And having to move the centre of government, finance, transport and hundreds of thousands of people out somewhere else, how would that even be done?

It already has been done. Most civil servants who were working in Westminster are only in the office 1-2 times a week now. Many of the big banks have gone almost completely remote working.
Santastuckincustoms · 14/10/2021 06:53

@NiceGerbil

I have noticed for a long time that here, the do this or kill the planet things. Seem usually to be things that realistically will mainly impact women esp ones with children.

Like-
Use washable nappies
Switch to washable/ reusable sanpro
Washing pushed to go cooler temperatures which imo is often less effective AND means using more powerful detergents (polluting) to get things clean/ not still smelly
Ditto really long washing/ dishwashing cycles
Lower powered electrical goods often less effective and more effort/ time to do job
Constant media society sniping about women driving school run
Etc

While. Men don't get targeted like this.
They drive around plenty.
At work it's the women who have bags on hand for lunchtime shopping/ buy lunch while men carry on as usual.
And so on.

And what impact will this have? Really?

Fuck all in the scheme of things.

What needs sorting is a global issue related to trade, capitalism/ market, big industry, destruction etc getting cheap materials.

Currently in news lots of yay! Brilliant. Reporting of mega rich men having the ultimate 'mine's better than yours' and blasting passenger vehicles into the upper atmosphere. Where iirc any pollution impact is multiplied due to atmosphere etc. Vast amounts of fuel etc essentially for men to play my toy car is faster like children. (Torn as Kirk going up great but... The things I just said).

What about bitcoin mining using as much electricity as a medium sized country?

But no. It's all. Women! Do this that.

No thanks.

I don't have enough bells to put on this.
JudgementalCactus · 14/10/2021 06:50

@grapewine

YABU. I'm childfree not sociopathic.
Seconded!
ArblemarchTFruitbat · 14/10/2021 06:48

@VodselForDinner

Climate change is one of my reasons for remaining childfree.
This.
Canii · 14/10/2021 06:42

Also, having kids is the number one biggest contributor to climate change. Therefore, I opt out.

Canii · 14/10/2021 06:40

Caring about climate change is WHY I don’t have children. It’s going to be awful.

SturminsterNewton · 14/10/2021 06:40

When I see oblique aerial views of London and how low it is, it makes me sad to think two thousands of years of history and culture underwater and lost. And that's just one city in one country.

And having to move the centre of government, finance, transport and hundreds of thousands of people out somewhere else, how would that even be done?

OnlyCans · 14/10/2021 06:24

Interesting thought possibly but when I read the title I assumed you would have kids and were wondering if people who didn't have kids, who some would describe as having no investment in the future were concerned about it. Which I thought was a weird and unfair question.

I completely agree with you. I do have children but I am fed up of this rhetoric. It's unfair to people who dont have children and We should all care about the future. I personally think you either do or you don't and it has nothing to do with your ability or choice to have children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread