Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you don’t have kids, do you care about climate change?

118 replies

Blankspace4 · 13/10/2021 22:20

I’m genuinely interested

YABU - I still care about climate change even though I don’t / can’t have children

YANBU - It doesn’t affect me - I don’t really care

I know the vote will polarise but also interested in comments. I can’t have children (long struggle, finally come to terms). I do try and act in the interests of the planet but frankly I am sick of the “think of your children and grandchildren” prevailing rationale - what does that mean for those of us who can’t have that?

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 14/10/2021 09:04

@lazylinguist

It could be argued that the child free care more about climate change as having children is the single most damaging thing we do to the planet.

That could only be argued if that's the reason they're not having children. Otherwise it's got literally nothing to do with caring about the issue.

Seems to me this is the same argument in reverse for having children that some use “our children will be future bum wipers/cancer cure finders/pension payers and taxpayers” but that is not the reason anyone has them.

I’m childless (not by choice but that’s ok) but I do care about climate change.

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 14/10/2021 08:55

@grapewine

YABU. I'm childfree not sociopathic.
Perfectly put.
zonkyzonky · 14/10/2021 08:54

I do know of a few individuals who 'used' for want of a better word the excuse of 'care about the environment too much' for not having children... when behind closed doors they were too grief stricken and needed a reason to tell others (as didn't feel comfortable explaining that they were involuntarily childless)... Or maybe the environmental reason over time became a passionate cause they cared about

bogeythefungusman · 14/10/2021 08:54

Clueless, I was a little Hmm when a woman I know, currently pregnant with her fourth, said her large family wouldn't be environmentally damaging because her sister didn't want children she was basically using her sister's quota - a bit like carbon offsetting but with babies.......... Grin

bogeythefungusman · 14/10/2021 08:50

Lazylinguist
'That could only be argued if that's the reason they're not having children. Otherwise it's got literally nothing to do with caring about the issue.'

It doesn't matter which way you slice and dice it, the very fact that people don't have children will impact the environment, whether it was the defining reason or had nothing to do with the decision. It's a happy unintended consequence of someone deciding to remain child free.

rainbowmash · 14/10/2021 08:48

This isn't really a question, is it?

It's a dog-whistle with the purpose of implying some very nasty things about child-free people without saying them out loud.

EnterFunnyNameHere · 14/10/2021 08:46

[quote Blankspace4]@EnterFunnyNameHere I totally get that. For the avoidance of doubt I’m not saying I DON’T care, but that the rhetoric maybe needs to change a little.

I also don’t think the people blocking the m25 are really helping matters. If anything, they are turning people off??[/quote]
Sorry @blankspace4, didn't mean to sound like biting your head off!

For what it's worth, I do see your point, but the "please won't somebody think of the children" rhetoric has been used as a tool in so many arguments over the years, i don't see it stopping. Arguably, it actually is pertinent in climate change compared to things like ""gay marriage/no fault divorce/enter crazy statement here" will destroy the family unit - won't somebody think of the children " hysteria...

Plus, to be honest, I know LOTS of people (mostly with children) who simply don't care about the environment. I don't mind what tools are used for try and get those people to at least engage in the debate!

But, as others have said, personal choices will only get us so far - and probably not far enough...

Cluelessasacucumber · 14/10/2021 08:36

YABVU. I dont have kids BECAUSE I care about climate change.

I would love to have kids but made an active decision not to based on what I know. The world doesnt need more people and I couldn't live with the guilt of bringing a person into this world under current climate and ecological projections. Many of my colleagues and friends have made the same choice. Not having children is the biggest and most significant action I can take personally to combat climate change. If I'm completely honest, I often wander if those with large family's actually give a f*, or maybe they're just in denial.

jonhammsmistress · 14/10/2021 08:36

@jonhammsmistress

Personal choices that effect your contribution to climate change
Sorry not v clear image, but No 1 is "have one fewer child".
jonhammsmistress · 14/10/2021 08:33

Personal choices that effect your contribution to climate change

If you don’t have kids, do you care about climate change?
anthurium · 14/10/2021 08:27

I'm currently pregnant so will have a child soon.

I don't really care about recycling/and didn't before I became pregnant. I've often associated it as being a middle class preoccupation..poor people have more immediate issues to think about... I'll 'model' the more sociably responsible behavior in front of the child though....

As a side point, I've never thought about not having children because if the environment. I was and am more concerned about having meaningful connections in my life over whether or not I'll be polluting the planet further by having children.

Hummingbirdcake · 14/10/2021 08:18

There seem to be many people who do have children who don’t care about climate change.

Brefugee · 14/10/2021 08:16

pp made a good argument about the things we worried about in the 70s (ozone layer, acid rain) and how individuals, industries and governments developed strategies to mitigate the damage we do.

So continue to recycle - and if you're all "meh it's going to landfill anyway" how about
a) finding alternatives
2) lobbying your local council to improve their recycling facilities
iii) lobbying manufacturers about their packaging?

Plenty of manufacturers here in Germany use 90% recycled plastic packaging, that's a good start.

JorisBonson · 14/10/2021 08:14

@grapewine

YABU. I'm childfree not sociopathic.
This.
Butchyrestingface · 14/10/2021 08:14

I don't have kids. I care about climate change. The two things are entirely unrelated.

I find this OP rather bizarre. How can you care about the future of the planet if you don't have kids? Confused

Easily. Because I am not a stone cold machine. Just like I care when I watch the news and see images of men, women and children - all complete strangers to me - dying of drought, famine, treatable disease and war in far-off countries.

silentpool · 14/10/2021 08:11

OK OP, I will give you a pass on this because I thought it was one of the childfree are monsters/why are they on MN type of comments.

I may not have children but I have nieces and nephews. I have lived in very polluted Asian cities so yes, I do care about breathing clean air - as I sounded like a 100 ciggies a day smoker when I left.

A better argument is that we need to use resources better - we've all got very wasteful and indulgent and don't really think about the cost to the environment or to others. Its also much better for our own health and our back pockets to simplify our lives and waste less. Whatever argument works though!

I do a lot of things but most people around me do whatever seems to be easiest, so it's all a bit futile.

torquewench · 14/10/2021 08:09

I concluded that I'm wasting my efforts at recycling when I saw a manufacturing order for one type of plastic bottle, for one non edible product, for one retailer - 2.65 BILLION bottles. Not a chance in hell that they'll all be recycled.

Mrbob · 14/10/2021 08:08

@CityMumma78

I’m not spending my time worrying about something out of my control! I do what I can but won’t be going to extreme lengths! I eat meat but also have meat free days, my husband and I have cars, we want to fly away once a year on holiday, we also recycle are mindful of what we buy and have created wildlife sanctuaries in our front and back gardens (ponds, hibernaculums etc). Until the super rich change their ways flying in private jets, powerful cars, mansions with multiple rooms that require heating and lighting, swimming pools (er and Bezos superpollluting by playing with space rockets) start to show some consideration and the mega polluting countries like China, India and Brazil show more consideration then why should I make further sacrifices!!
Oh FFS. This is the problem isn’t it. So selfish
AllHailTheGreatGoddess · 14/10/2021 08:05

I wouldn't. I figure humanity is just getting whats coming to it.

Unfortunately I figured this out AFTER I had two humans I deeply care about.

So I am obliged to care and to TRY.

Brefugee · 14/10/2021 08:03

I've finally identified what annoys me most about the OP. And it is this: when we ask men not to catcall (for eg) often the argument is "what if it were your daughter/wife/mother/sister" and it reduces women to being only of any worth if they are somehow related to a man.

This is the same. It's as though the only way anyone can relate to the planet or future generations is if there is some direct bloodline that we might have to it.

To PP who said "places were already supposed to be underwater" maybe not the Houses of Parliament, but some Pacific islands are already in deep trouble and places like The Netherlands are taking rising sea levels very seriously.

Indoctro · 14/10/2021 08:03

Quite sad to read this today

www.eveningexpress.co.uk/fp/news/local/scotlands-sphinx-could-melt-before-the-week-is-out/

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 14/10/2021 08:02

Is there an option for those who do have kids but don't give a damn about climate change? As I know lots of people like this.

CityMumma78 · 14/10/2021 08:00

I’m not spending my time worrying about something out of my control! I do what I can but won’t be going to extreme lengths! I eat meat but also have meat free days, my husband and I have cars, we want to fly away once a year on holiday, we also recycle are mindful of what we buy and have created wildlife sanctuaries in our front and back gardens (ponds, hibernaculums etc). Until the super rich change their ways flying in private jets, powerful cars, mansions with multiple rooms that require heating and lighting, swimming pools (er and Bezos superpollluting by playing with space rockets) start to show some consideration and the mega polluting countries like China, India and Brazil show more consideration then why should I make further sacrifices!!

jonhammsmistress · 14/10/2021 07:58

Young people’s climate anxiety revealed in landmark survey
Children worldwide worry about the future and feel let down by governments, a huge study on attitudes towards climate change has found.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02582-8

Mrbob · 14/10/2021 07:58

I imagine people without children have the space to care about climate change. It takes a fair amount of cognitive dissonance to have children while knowing that within their lifetime their planet will be fucked AND the act of having them will make it worse

(I don’t have kids and yes I really really care about the world my nieces and nephews will live in)

Swipe left for the next trending thread