Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have I failed my son?

64 replies

ohdeerdolly · 13/10/2021 21:13

Ds is coming up 10 and still can't do a few really basic things. He is left handed and can't tie his shoelaces Blush this is partly my fault as I've always got him Velcro or slip on shoes. We have been practicing lately but when he can't do something he gets really angry and gives up. I try to encourage him to keep going but it's painful for everyone involved.

More worryingly we are having the same issue with him riding a bike. He just can't get his balance. We have been practicing for years and he's even been to cycling schools but he still can't do it and again, he ends up getting really frustrated and emotional.

He's very clever and isn't delayed in any other ways but it bothers me that he's finding such basic life skills so tough. He's also getting to the age where he is wanting to go out with friends and be a little more independent and I'm worried these things are going to hold him back and single him out.

It's not that I haven't tried but maybe I haven't pushed enough? I still can't help feeling I've failed somehow in instilling these basic skills in him before now. Has anyone got any advice? I'm at the point where I think we literally just have to sit and practice until he can tie the lace or ride the bike.

Are these things that he will just 'get' one day?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Maray1967 · 14/10/2021 13:56

Another one with a left hander - and also a right hander, neither of whom managed to tie laces before 10 - but by then it became an issue as the trainers they wanted had laces so we persevered.
Bike riding - not essential. Both of mine can, but DS2 decided last year at 12 that he hates it and won’t do it any more. I never learned - it doesn’t bother me.

gannett · 14/10/2021 09:39

I remember being a late developer to tying my shoelaces and I still can't ride a bike in my late 30s. I can't get my head around the balance. As a child I couldn't really deal with the fear of falling off and hurting myself (or with the idea that I couldn't do it perfectly first time) so never learned properly. It wasn't anyone's fault apart from mine, I point-blank refused.

Genuinely can't remember how I eventually learned to do laces but I did. I also managed to get on a bike and cycle it around the park during lockdown last year, which was a step forward, but being able to do it with other people around still seems out of reach.

Anyway in the long term I don't think you need to worry. I am a klutz with no manual dexterity whatsoever but I've still muddled along well enough.

Coffeeisnecessary · 14/10/2021 08:11

My 10 year old also can't tie shoelaces, it's totally my fault as I've always just got him velcro shoes! Must teach him before secondary but I'm not looking forward to it as I don't find it that easy myself!! Bike riding, my 8 year old has only just grasped it after 1 to 1 lessons with a cycling teacher as he just refused to listen or trust us. Children are all different, I wouldn't worry too much just keep trying!

stilldumdedumming · 14/10/2021 08:02

But if he wen to cycling schools then it isn't your lack of teaching him that means he struggles with these things. I wonder if you can help him see that in the grand scheme of things, and that these things might come later on but in the meantime get better at the things he can do and enjoys.

My son is 20. He can nearly tie his laces. He also cannot ride a bike, throw or catch a ball or anything sporty. He is dyspraxic as others have said. Oh and his handwriting is like a 9 year olds.

He is very clever and funny. Great with words and got As in his A levels without going to school. He is a fantastic networker and will do just fine. He can play guitar and piano. He can also swim (apparently good for dyspraxia).

It might be helpful however to look at therapy for this. My bot also was able to use a laptop in school exams which was great.

PaperMonster · 14/10/2021 07:06

My ten year old can’t do either of those either. Well, she did briefly ride her bike but won’t because she’s too scared of falling off. And she can’t tie laces because she won’t wear any shoes with laces - but this is a sensory thing. I wouldn’t worry.

Gilly12345 · 14/10/2021 07:04

My Daughter is 21 and right handed and still struggles with shoe laces and tying a tie (she has needed to wear a tie for waitress job), also not brilliant using scissors.

However she is clever with a 2:1 degree.

Nearlytheretrees · 14/10/2021 07:04

I cannot tie laces the 'normal' way and have always done bunny's ears so maybe give that a go. Dh had to teach the DC and they all do it the normal way

Newnormal99 · 14/10/2021 07:00

Round by me their is a guy that teaches people to ride bikes - 1 lesson was enough for my daughter. I think you also probably need another leftie to help him with the laces.

Enterifyoudare · 14/10/2021 06:54

I'm 41 and never learned to ride a bike. I don't believe that it has hindered me in anyway.

I have two left handed children. There are lots of things their peers can do that they have struggled with due to being left handed. I suspect with 8YO DS there is more to it than just being left handed, but he is being assessed.

romdowa · 14/10/2021 06:43

My brother is left handed but not dyspraxic. We could never teach him to tie his laces, in the end we had to ask another left handed person to do it 😅 I think he also had difficulty riding a bike too but he got there in the end.

Keladrythesaviour · 14/10/2021 06:38

I'm left handed, can tie shoelaces fine but can't ride a bike at the grand old age of 32. Not saying it's connected Grin I've often wondered if I have mild dyspraxia.

Left learning is a real thing though, I could never work out knitting because my mum and nan could only ever teach it right handed. So it could just be the way you are teaching him to tie laces can't click for him. I'd definitely recommend you tube videos. He can do it in his own room away from the pressures of prying eyes. I think they also say to learn forwards first - so looking at a shoe (as if you are trying someone else's) before you tie your own. He will get there! Except maybe with the bike, who knows. But it hasn't caused me too much trouble.

spanieleyes · 14/10/2021 06:35

My son is 27 and STILL can't tie shoe laces. He really struggled when younger and became very frustrated so, like you, we went down the Velcro/slip on route and he never got out of it. It hasn't hindered his life though! He has a degree and a very responsible job but just wears slip on shoes😁

trappedsincesundaymorn · 14/10/2021 06:27

I don't know anything about Dyspraxia, but trying to teach a "leftie" how to tie their laces is something I do have experience of. DD is left-handed and the way I taught her was to have her sitting opposite me and copying copying the way I tied mine. Because she was facing me and mirroring what I did she found it easier. If you haven't already tried doing it that way, give it a go. It might work better for you.

Newuser82 · 14/10/2021 06:11

@ohdeerdolly

Having looked up the symptoms of dyspraxia I can't see anything else to ring alarm bells. I'm more worried that I simply haven't taught him well enough or consistently enough and I've maybe been too easy to give in when he's gotten frustrated.

He's very athletic - plays rugby and football, swims well, is into dancing and his movement overall isn't a concern to me. He's very independent. It's just these two random things that he seems to really struggle with. I wonder if the laces is a left handed issue as he watches us all do it the opposite way around.

My son is left handed (he also has dyspraxia ) but I thought the same as you, he is watching us tie laces the wrong way round. If you haven’t already done so have a look on you tube at different ways to tie laces. My son doesn’t do it the way we do but has learnt a different way to tie laces which works for him. Just an idea. Good luck
UncomfortableSilence · 14/10/2021 05:08

No you haven't failed him. It's just a couple of things, all kids develop and learn these skills at different times.

DD11, also left handed, has only recently managed to tie her laces, before that she got by just with the bunny method. Riding her bike was a long slog, she can do it now but still not confidently. She has no other problems with movement or co ordination and doesn't tick any of the other signs of dyspraxia.

WTF475878237NC · 14/10/2021 05:00

Ah bless him that must be frustrating if he wants to and can't.

PermanentTemporary · 14/10/2021 04:46

No you haven't failed your son and you don't have to bash him harder to prove yourself as a parent.

Do you think the YouTube video will help? Sounds like the simplest place to start.

Theonewiththecandles · 13/10/2021 23:48

As a left handed child of right handed parents, I still can't tie my shoes in the "normal" way and I'm 27!
I do the two bunny loops and tie them together.
I'm also not very good at riding a bike, I can't really turn corners very well and learnt quite late on.
I also used to cry on my driving lessons I found it so difficult and stressful!
It's never held me back, see if he can pick up the bunny ears method because I only ever heard of that watching the film Big Daddy and never actually saw it in practice and was able to do it straight away.
Riding a bike.. not a deal breaker, if he isn't interested now he probably won't be but I know some charities etc do lessons which might be good?

FloofersGonnaFloof · 13/10/2021 23:45

My daughter is 12 and learned how to tie shoelaces just in time to go on to secondary school! I found a great cheat, where you stick the aglets (hard bit at the end of the lace) in to the top shoelace hole on the same side. This creates two loops. Then it's easy to do a simple knot to tie them up.

She can't ride a bike either. Tried and failed a few times when she was 6/7/8 and has point blank refused to try again ever since. She doesn't care 🤷‍♀️.

Neither of these issues were dyspraxia related for her; more that I hadn't spent the time to teach her/pushed her to try them. I wondered if I'd failed her too, but then she just 'got' it when I showed the the shoelace technique. I have given up bikes as a lost cause though...

Just found a link to the shoe lace trick:

Cryalot2 · 13/10/2021 23:37

Like others dyspraxia jumped out at me. The memories of ds and his shoes! He is an adult now and wears lace shoes at weekends.
It is frustrating for you both .
Try get an assessment to see if this is indeed so .

JesusWeptLady · 13/10/2021 23:37

@ohdeerdolly I had the same with my son and also blamed myself. He is now 15 and has no trouble tying his laces but could not do it for the longest time (or ride a bike) he still cannot use a skipping rope correctly.

And he inherited these traits from me. It is a mild case of dyspraxia or dyscalculia - which affects sense of direction / following dance moves / being good at mathematics (again, all traits he got from me, his non-diagnosed mum).

Try not to beat yourself up. He's not the only one in his class, so that's something. Have you thought about getting one of those "tie your laces" practice boards?

Twilight7777 · 13/10/2021 23:36

Sounds like me, have had dyspraxia all my life but only became aware of it being a condition and not just ‘me’ as I got older

Learnthroughplay3 · 13/10/2021 23:32

Can I ask anyone who has any experience with dyspraxia can you have this but be good at football basketball throwing catching? We have been told they believe my child has this from a guides leader but they are really good at these sports

Graphista · 13/10/2021 23:12

You haven't failed him you're encouraging him you just maybe need to get further support if he does have a disability and maybe tips from other left Handers on that aspect I'm sure there will be loads of tips online

Even aside from possible disability and the left handed aspect I think it's still good to teach kids to be persistent to keep at it to learn a skill/piece of knowledge.

Indeed kids with other challenges may need this trait more than others!

My dd has a disability that affects her co-ordination and balance and so makes her more accident prone generally, this made things like learning to ride a bike, swim, roller skate etc harder...and more risky...than it was for others, we actually didn't know the dx until she was almost 12 I just knew she was more accident prone.

But we together took appropriate precautions (tons of padding some of which was created by us when it couldn't be bought! The bum pad for the skating was a particular source of hilarity!) and spent a lot of time practicing and persevering and I do think encouraging that aspect of her personality has stood her in good stead.

When we did get the dx I felt guilty initially for pushing her so hard! But when we spoke to the experts turns out we did things more or less as they'd have advised

I get it's hard, and frustrating and even scary!

But long term I think it is for their own good.