Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - crap gifts?

39 replies

Stresssssedout · 13/10/2021 20:48

Need someone to tell me to give my head a wobble because I know I’m probably over reacting by being upset. My birthday is next week and DP has been asking me for a while what I’d like. There’s nothing really in particular but I told him a few things I thought were nice and told him one thing I definitely did not want.

I told him this because I’ve mentioned in passing it was nice and was worried he would buy it me. I didn’t say this because of the price or anything I just don’t want it. He was just showing me a screenshot of something on his phone and I swiped back and it was a screenshot of the order number for the thing I told him not to buy me. I’m just feeling like he’s just not bothered listening to me here at all. He’s only just bought it as well so this was after I told him I didn’t want it. I know I should feel grateful for any gift it just feels like a cop out. I haven’t told him I saw the screenshot.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Flowiththego · 15/10/2021 19:58

I think the "sticks in the mind but the 'I don't want it'' bit goes right over the head' is right. Ages ago SIl asked me what I was buying DH (her Dbro) for Christmas. When I told her, she asked very specific questions (what size it was, what colour, etc) and then went and bought him the exact same thing! I don't think she was being a bitch cos she's not like that - she didn't know what to buy him and the fact that she knew I was buying it sort of escaped her.

blobby10 · 14/10/2021 14:55

My otherwise wonderful DP bought me a painting last Christmas - we had been in an art gallery and my dad had just bought me a painting (seascape) by a particular artist that I had admired and there were 5 other paintings of wild animals - absolutely amazing - I loved the lion, DP loved the black panther but they were far too big for my house. Christmas morning he turns up with this MASSIVE painting of the panther- well over a metre square!! Its far too big for my house and totally dominates the room where it hangs although it is lovely. But I preferred the lion. And said it was too big! He even bought it the same day we were in there so can't say he forgot what I said . I've come to the conclusion that even those who love me the most just don't listen most of the time Grin

pussycatlickinglollyices · 14/10/2021 14:43

This is why a gift should come from a shop or a business - so you can return it when your DP fucks it up and gets the wrong thing.

CuteGirlsWatchMeEatEther · 14/10/2021 14:37

Please can’t you just tell us what it is?

Stresssssedout · 14/10/2021 14:27

I’d eat my hat if he bought someone else the present because it really is that specific. I’ve calmed down a bit today, thanks guys. Looks like I’ll be stuck with it so I’ll probably have a word with him but nothing else I can do!

OP posts:
shakehandswithdanger · 14/10/2021 10:50

I usually have sympathy for people who aren't wonderful gift-givers, because it's something I struggle with myself, to come up with the perfect gift. However, given that you had a recent conversation specifically explaining that you didn't want this (apparently unique) item, it does seem odd that he should go right out and order it!

Does he have a bad memory or become easily confused? I'm assuming not, but even if so, you'd expect him to to remember a recent conversation where you told him, "Please don't buy me X!"

I don't think it's unreasonable to frustrated, under these circumstances, particularly if it can't be returned.

Highflyingadored · 14/10/2021 02:21

OP you dont have to accept it....

I am really bad for buying something I collect and saying to my husband... oh I will give it to you to wrap for me cause at least I get the one I want... well he told me off the other day and said that perhaps he would like to actually look for a present for me and make the decision.... I now worry about what I will get but will trust he will try to get me something i will like and appreciate.

I would love to know what he has got you though.... I don't come across stuff that I like but wouldnt want to own .....

PyongyangKipperbang · 14/10/2021 02:08

My ex would do this. All that would go into his head was the mention of the item and the "I do not want that item" would sail right on over. So for his birthday I bought him a thing that he absolutely hated, having mentioned it several times. I said "Oh.....I just remember you mentioning it" and oddly enough, I got a much better gift for my birthday 2 months later. Mind you, that was after Lawn Mower Gate......

SarahBellam · 14/10/2021 01:57

@HuhWhatNow

Don't these men have jobs? Surely you need some level of cognitive ability to remain in employment?
This with spades on.

These men are supposed to be fully functional adult human beings. They hold down jobs, sometimes they even manage people/systems/processes. They'd not get something like that wrong at work. Why do they think it's ok to be lazy/demonstrate such a lack of care at home?

Ionlydomassiveones · 14/10/2021 01:38

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Flamingoose · 14/10/2021 01:35

Is this a one-off OP? Is he usually kind and thoughtful but he's made a mistake this one time? Or is this typical of him?

I'm also desperate to know what it is.

steff13 · 14/10/2021 01:14

@MoreThanAnOffDay

Am I the only one wondering what the present is?
No. I too am wondering what is it and what's wrong with owning it.
BubbleCoffee · 14/10/2021 00:58

Could he have placed a bid on the item before you'd said you didn't want it?

Newmumatlast · 14/10/2021 00:12

@Flowiththego

Sorry, I shouldn't have posted that. Was a (crap!) joke.
It is what popped into my head too, actually
fourandnomore · 13/10/2021 23:54

Because it’s a whole week away I think I’d be honest and say look I saw the confirmation of the order of my birthday present and it’s the thing I told you I didn’t want, why? I’d feel disappointed with this.

Cryalot2 · 13/10/2021 23:51

That is horrid op.
Men !, dh tried to buy me x for my birthday last week but he got adult dd to buy online. It was something I wanted, but they both never realized American sizes are different. This was the wrong size and my size is not available. He had got dd to have specific flowers from a specific florist. But to be honest I felt like bashing him over the head with them .
So it can be so disappointing op. Have a cry as it will help .and happy birthday in advance.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 13/10/2021 23:46

Is he otherwise thoughtful and kind? My abusive ex would intentionally buy gifts i'd said i didn't like/want, but that would seem really thoughtful to outsiders.
For example, i had mentioned many times i hated my birthstone and didn't want jewellery of it. He got me a childrens sized birthstone necklace for christmas, and it was broken! He didn't even wait for confirmation i'd opened it on christmas morning, before saying "i got it because it's your birthstone".
Another time was when i'd been really disappointed by a videogame from my favourite franchise that was a bit of a spin off, i played it once, hated it and never took it out of the box again. Told him it was awful and disappointing and i definitely did not want the sequel. Guess what i got that year for my birthday?
Third time, he bought us custom necklaces that had our names and nicknames on, they joined together to form a heart, and came needing you to bend and break the metal yourself to separate them. Only he told me he didn't want them to be split and his half sending back, so it was a useless bit of metal sat in a box.
Nothing tops my 21st though. For his 21st i gave him £100, and we weren't even dating then but just friends. For my 21st 3 years later (and "engaged") i got..... a card with barely anything written in it, and the £1 price sticker still on it. It was 4 months after my mums death and had a whole family meal to celebrate, and i got asked loudly what he had gotten me, and had to tell the truth. It was majorly embarrassing and when i brought it up with him i got a mouthful of abuse that a card "should be enough" and it was "the sentiment that counts". This just 3 months after he "borrowed" £300 from me and later announced he was having it as his birthday present off me, despite my not agreeing.

Onlinedilema · 13/10/2021 23:35

When you open the present say "Why did you buy me the thing I specifically told you not to?"
Then don't say anything see what he says.
Then tell him you don't want it.

MoreThanAnOffDay · 13/10/2021 23:28

Am I the only one wondering what the present is?

Stresssssedout · 13/10/2021 23:24

@Flowiththego

I really hope he hasn't bought it for someone else, as in Emma Thomson/Alan Rickman in.Love Actually ;)
Lol I’m almost certain he didn’t but I’ll report back next week Grin I’m debating bringing it up to him but I need to calm down because I’ve wound myself up and if we end up rowing he’ll think I’m being a brat. It’s not about the present, it’s the lack of thought and I need to convey that properly if I bring it up.

I did have a look at previously sold for the item on eBay and it’s one of two that I’ve seen. Neither were sold by a business though so no chance of returning it.

OP posts:
HuhWhatNow · 13/10/2021 22:57

Quite frankly I would ask why he has bought something you specifically told him you DIDN'T want. He clearly has given no thought to OP's feelings so why should she be the "be kind" conditioned female, feign happiness and quietly get rid of it later?

Buffoonborisisatwat · 13/10/2021 22:48

@Stresssssedout

Not particularly expensive no- about 1/2 of what we’d usually spend on each other. I even said to him “I know I said that’s nice but please don’t actually buy it me because I would hate to own it for x reasons”.

He’s bought it from a seller on eBay too so I don’t think he can even send it back?!

Thank him for the gift, leave it in a cupboard for a while then re-sell it on ebay
Ijustreallywantacat · 13/10/2021 22:21

I did exactly the same thing to my mum once. She mentioned she would love a certain smelly product. What I failed to hear was '...but I'm allergic'

Luckily I kept the receipt!

Don't be saddened OP. Have a laugh about it and tell him that you love the thought but you'd like something else, can you return/swap.

Sparklfairy · 13/10/2021 22:12

@GoWalkabout

He's just tuned in to the thing and missed the don't want bit...never name the not wanted thing, birthday list rules 101.
This. Its a psychological fact -like when someone says don't panic and everybody panics Grin
JollyAndBright · 13/10/2021 22:08

He should listen - it's not a reasonable excuse to say he's just heard the name of the thing and tuned out the rest of what you said. It's not setting the bar especially high to expect a partner to actually pay attention.

This with fucking bows on.

I hate this "aw bless the silly 'ickle menz and their inability to hear a full sentence! They can't help it!”

100% this.

It’s just laziness.
Tell him to cancel the order because you don’t want it, you specifically told him you didn’t want it, and he’s wasting money buying it.

It was my birthday last week. DP asked for idea, I gave him a few; and he chose brilliant gifts.
It’s not hard, even if you are someone that finds gift shopping difficult, when someone gives you ideas they are taking all of the hard work out of it.

It’s pure laziness to fuck it up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread