Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is bu

36 replies

CountingMyChickens21 · 13/10/2021 18:42

DC is 15 months old.

I'll try and keep this as brief and neutral as possible.

Parent 1 does not want DC to be left with parent 2's sister and partner mostly because they don't agree with their parenting style regarding things such as discipline. Although there has never been cause for concern with their DC, neither have done anything wrong but wants their sister to be able to look after DC.

Parent 2 agrees that they have different parenting styles from their sister and partner but is willing to let both sisters look after DC if they ask, but if there's anything that raises concern to stop any outings. Parent 2 has said if Parent 1 is not willing to let their sister look after DC then they will support this, although they disagree but will not allow either sister to look after DC.

Who is bu here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CountingMyChickens21 · 13/10/2021 22:54

@Triffid1 no backstory. My sister is very different from me, but she does things her way and I do things mine. But I do know that she loves my DC and would look after him as though he was hers.

@TheChip obviously when it comes to school we'll have to cross that bridge. Of course there has to be boundaries even with family.

OP posts:
User3579 · 13/10/2021 22:49

Ok with that information your DH is definitely BU

TheChip · 13/10/2021 22:40

What's going to happen when the children go to school and the school do things differently?

People do things differently. Aunties are not supposed to parent your child, but if they are looking after them, then you should expect their to be rules and boundaries that work for them.

Triffid1 · 13/10/2021 22:31

Honestly, your DH is being completely over the top precious. Unless there's some huge backstory about your sister behaving badly/taking the piss/doing something that you/DH have specifically asked her to, it's hard to get my head around him refusing to let her do fun stuff with your DC because she puts her children on time out!?

Your DH is being ridiculous and I'd be concerned about what the next OTT, unfounded "rule" he's planning to put in place is.

CountingMyChickens21 · 13/10/2021 22:27

@Pinkspecs definitely! Although my own DC is still small. I have never disciplined my sister's children aside from asking them not to do something if my sister is not around. I think it's a non-issue. We are lucky to have two auntie's willing to take our DC out ocassionally but won't favour one over the other when there is no danger to my child.

OP posts:
Pinkspecs · 13/10/2021 22:18

Your DH is being ridiculous, doesn't want your sister to have your child unsupervised because she puts her own kids in time out 🤦🏼‍♀️

Can I just also say that being a parent is very different to being an auntie I have never disciplined my siblings children and I never would.
All this drama over a time out that hasn't even happened to your own child.

Hopefully your sister won't find out as she's likely to be pretty offended that she apparently isn't capable of being left unsupervised with your child.Confused

CountingMyChickens21 · 13/10/2021 22:15

@arethereanyleftatall we are a long way off from that but I suppose it would be completely dependent on what DC was in trouble for.

@Anonymous48 both DH and me have a sister. DH is saying he doesn't want my sister to look after DC. Both my sister and DH's sister have expressed wanting to take DC out for days out, but hasn't got very strong reasons for saying no to my sister. So I have said if that's how you feel, fine but we haven't been given any reason to doubt that DC would be safe with my sister as her and BIL have never done anything to concern us about them looking after DC. So I have said either both of our sister's can take DC out if they ask or neither. Obviously if there was any reason to doubt either sister, then it won't happen again.

OP posts:
Dojacatpaws · 13/10/2021 22:06

Does it really matter either way, it's not for life, just a brief period, surely the kids will cope

Anonymous48 · 13/10/2021 21:52

@CountingMyChickens21

Oops I didn't mean to enable voting. Blush

I don't think time outs are strict as such, just not either of our styles. @Tal45 Exactly my point about time outs, very unlikely they would ever feel the need to put our DC in a time out. When the time comes, we would rather look at other ways in terms of punishment. There would definitely be a punishment when needed. For whatever reason DH doesn't want them looking after DC unsupervised and there is no real need at the moment anyway. I just feel it's unfair to allow one and not the other without good reason.

What do you mean by one and not the other? You aren't being clear. Do you each have a sister and he's ok with one babysitting and not the other?
arethereanyleftatall · 13/10/2021 21:24

Timeouts are fairly standard parenting strategies.
What are your plans for if eg a teacher has cause you tell your child off?

CountingMyChickens21 · 13/10/2021 20:41

Oops I didn't mean to enable voting. Blush

I don't think time outs are strict as such, just not either of our styles. @Tal45 Exactly my point about time outs, very unlikely they would ever feel the need to put our DC in a time out. When the time comes, we would rather look at other ways in terms of punishment. There would definitely be a punishment when needed. For whatever reason DH doesn't want them looking after DC unsupervised and there is no real need at the moment anyway. I just feel it's unfair to allow one and not the other without good reason.

OP posts:
Tal45 · 13/10/2021 20:23

It was impossible to vote until we knew which parent you were. I think that's why you have so many YABU.

Time outs are not unreasonably strict, not my style but if it works for them. Will you just let your dc just do whatever they want without any consequences? I doubt they'd do time out with your child anyway, it would be a very difficult thing to do with someone else's child that is not accustomed to it and at 15 months would be ridiculous. I think both sisters should spend time with the child, the more people they have love from and bond with the better but your lo is very little so why not have them spend time with you there too until they are a bit older.

ChangeAndHelp · 13/10/2021 20:15

Safety concerns aside, it’s important to realise that your child will have its own relationship with the world and people in it. Looking after it taking a child out does not equate to replicating the parental relationship and following a set behavior that a parent would. In fact it’s damaging to a child to try and ‘mimic’ that. Or of parents to expect that.
The child needs to learn about different people and family members are the first port of call to find that people are different.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 13/10/2021 20:13

So your DH doesn’t want to leave your DC with your sister? Is that right….?

LJAKS · 13/10/2021 20:07

If dc goes to a school/nursery setting that uses time outs are they going to home educate?

Gimlisaxe · 13/10/2021 20:06

I think you are both being unreasonable and neither are thinking of your child.

Not being allowed to different parenting styles is not going to help your child later on. So that is UR

Then you have come along with a tit for tat situation. Also UR

Anonymous48 · 13/10/2021 20:03

YABU for making it so confusing and vague! Even with your update I'm still confused. Is there one sister or two? And do you consider giving time outs overly strict?

WorriedGiraffe · 13/10/2021 19:57

What’s wrong with time outs? They don’t sound strict at all to be honest.

RavingAnnie · 13/10/2021 19:55

@CountingMyChickens21

So I'm parent 2.

To give more context my sister and BIL use time outs for their children and are just generally stricter than us, but they have never been strict with our child and I don't think they would be. No shouting or smacking. So I'm of the mindset that whilst our approaches are different, there is no need to say no. Both aunts want to take DC out, this would be the odd day out here and there, no childcare arrangement.

Parent 1 is being v unreasonable if that's all the difference is. It's good for your child to be exposed to different people, have different relationships, and have different experiences.
CountingMyChickens21 · 13/10/2021 19:53

So I'm parent 2.

To give more context my sister and BIL use time outs for their children and are just generally stricter than us, but they have never been strict with our child and I don't think they would be. No shouting or smacking. So I'm of the mindset that whilst our approaches are different, there is no need to say no. Both aunts want to take DC out, this would be the odd day out here and there, no childcare arrangement.

OP posts:
freelions · 13/10/2021 19:46

Is there any reason why either sister needs to have unsupervised access to DC? Were you planning to use them as childcare? It obviously wouldn't be appropriate to employ anyone as a childminder if either parent doesn't agree with their parenting methods

If you are just talking about meeting up for family gatherings etc then surely one or other parent will be around anyway so the access wouldn't be unsupervised??

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 13/10/2021 19:44

You’re clearly parent 1.

But until you give us more details, or confirm which parent you actually are - how can people vote…?

AnneLovesGilbert · 13/10/2021 19:40

Can you be more specific?

Not letting the better aunt care for the baby is nonsensical. If you’re lucky enough to have several people offering free childcare, that you want to take up, you don’t cut your nose off to spite your face.

And with such a young child you don’t wait for your concerns to come to pass in the interests of perceived fairness. Babies are people, not play things for people to have a go with.

TumtumTree · 13/10/2021 19:35

The vote is meaningless because we don't know if you're parent 1 or parent 2.

Assuming we're talking about the odd occasion, I think parent 1 is BU. It doesn't really matter about small parenting differences and it's not fair to treat the aunts differently.

If you're talking about regular childcare, my response would be different.

User3579 · 13/10/2021 19:31

Post is to vague but it reads like I want my sister to look after DC but not my DS’s sister. I see this often with my friends where they view the parenting style they grew up with as normal (and their sister is similar due to common upbringing) but their partners parents parenting style as “wrong”. I reacted this way myself inside but we agreed that we would trust each other’s family and that had worked out fine. Leaving them with my FIL filled me with terror as I did not know him as well as my parents and he always seemed a little less concerned but now they have a wonderful relationship with him and he has become the most involved grandparent which has been brilliant

Swipe left for the next trending thread