Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that wages have gone down A LOT in the past 20 years or so

188 replies

Poetrypatty · 13/10/2021 18:29

I'm looking at some roles where the amount offered is probably what would have been offered for that job, or possibly even less, than what you'd have got paid in about 1999. And that's often for graduates where you wouldn't have needed a degree back then and you do now. That's not even taking into account inflation or house prices.

I'm talking started and mid level office roles in particular rather than NMW jobs. I do think at the higher end wages have gone up, managers etc. For those who are old enough to remember, AIBU?

OP posts:
flowersmakeitbetter · 17/10/2021 10:14

@simkin38

Anyone got an idea what to do about this?

I feel trapped in the £80-90k band work all hours, high housing & childcare overheads. dH works 12h a day.

Thought it was worth living in London to be newr work as assumed salaries would rise.

Was thinking yesterday for the 11h a day and half of Sundays I work, would I be better off working 2 different jobs to cover same hours?

Consultancy is client-based so might not be long term. Not sure what else to do to increase pay.

No, I don't think you would be better off because the overwork is affecting everyone at every level. The higher up the chain the more control you will have.

How many times on these threads do people suggest delegating down?

I have a couple of friends doing admin jobs who are completely run ragged. They're not even well paid!

There is an assumption that the jobs at the bottom carry no stress whatsoever. That might have been true back in the day but considering there are literally no support staff and some job descriptions are 'say yes to whatever you are asked to do' then you can potentially be a lot worse off with a 'less responsibility' job.

DespairingHomeowner · 17/10/2021 09:40

@simkin38: are you thinking 2x 40k jobs would be easier? They’d probably be less stressful but hard to find employment flexible emough to make it work

Do you want think that 11h day + few hours on weekend expectation is the same for all your peers?

Maybe one way is to set up on your own if your career allows that

Iwab82 · 17/10/2021 08:04

Yes, I am getting paid similar wages now for similar job I did in 2000. Only difference is workload is massive now.

simkin38 · 17/10/2021 07:22

Anyone got an idea what to do about this?

I feel trapped in the £80-90k band work all hours, high housing & childcare overheads. dH works 12h a day.

Thought it was worth living in London to be newr work as assumed salaries would rise.

Was thinking yesterday for the 11h a day and half of Sundays I work, would I be better off working 2 different jobs to cover same hours?

Consultancy is client-based so might not be long term. Not sure what else to do to increase pay.

DespairingHomeowner · 16/10/2021 11:27

@flowersmakeitbetter

Just speaking to a friend about this and her CEO's total pay package has risen from just under £1m to almost £4m in 15 years.........

Meanwhile her pay has gone up about £15k. She's his PA. Angry

Maybe I will get flamed for this, but I haven’t got £1k a year rises for doing the same job (if the responsibilities haven’t increased?)

I’m getting paid what I was in 2015, now doing my bosses job & managing 2 people who were doing the job I did back then…

ronkey · 16/10/2021 10:57

There's also been a move where those at the top have seen huge gains in their packages which obviously leaves less to go around for the staff as in @flowersmakeitbetter example.

I also think the whole "you should be grateful for a job" rhetoric hasn't helped & is incredibly reductive. Unfortunately it's still very much in existence.

Camomila · 15/10/2021 20:52

I saw a social scientist role advertised for 20-22k the other day, I was really surprised at that (I didn't apply).
My straight forward admin job doesn't pay much less fall time.

ThePriceOfSugar · 15/10/2021 20:49

An acquaintance started his grad position at a law firm on NZ$47,000 in 2001.

I started my grad position at the big 4 at exactly the same amount in 2020.

MEDIAN house cost in Auckland is over $1 million.

I moved countries.

Kendodd · 15/10/2021 20:12

I wonder how much of it I'd due to the decline in union membership?

flowersmakeitbetter · 15/10/2021 19:43

Just speaking to a friend about this and her CEO's total pay package has risen from just under £1m to almost £4m in 15 years.........

Meanwhile her pay has gone up about £15k. She's his PA. Angry

Ibelieveinghosts · 15/10/2021 19:43

Mod level professional service role c £50k in 2007, c£50k 2021.

There seems to have been a narrative since the 2008 crash that professionals should be glad to have a job. So coupled with a 15 year pay freeze they are being worked into the ground expected to work 24/7and be grateful -covid has been a wake up call to many and now everyone is leaving and forms struggling to fill vacancies.

KittyBurrito · 15/10/2021 19:29

This is such an enlightening thread (although a very depressing one). Do any of the economists on this thread know why this has happened?

CorianderAndCream · 15/10/2021 12:24

@Oldgoat2021 😂 you got more per hour to transcribe media work in 2003 than I'm paid to be the media today

onlychildhamster · 15/10/2021 11:43

@Crumble012

www.theguardian.com/business/2021/oct/15/foreign-lorry-drivers-to-be-allowed-to-make-more-uk-deliveries-cabotage

Rod McKenzie, the managing director of policy and public affairs at the Road Haulage Association, told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “We don’t want cabotage to sabotage our industry.”

He said: “I spoke to some of our members last night, they were appalled. Ridiculous, pathetic, gobsmacked were some of their more broadcastable comments.

“The government has been talking about a high-wage, high-skill economy, and not pulling the lever marked ‘uncontrolled immigration’, and to them this is exactly what it looks like: allowing overseas haulage companies and drivers to come over for perhaps up to six months on a fortnightly basis to do unlimited work at low rates, undercutting UK hauliers who are facing an acute driver shortage, rising costs, staff wages.

“This is about taking work from British operators and drivers and giving it to Europeans who don’t pay tax here and pay peanuts to their drivers.”

So much for high wage britain. Whats the betting that they will do the same for many industries- bring over the low wage to ease the labour shortage. At least in the past when Eastern Europeans came over, they paid taxes here.

PinkCricket · 14/10/2021 21:57

Im considering an admin job at 20k pro rata. It is so hard to change jobs at the moment. This is consideravly less than I earnt 15 years ago 😭

Oldgoat2021 · 14/10/2021 19:28

Just a few figures to contribute as I tempted quite a bit in the 2000s.

In 1999-2001, I was paid £7.50 hour doing PA/secretarial work in London, e.g. at Channel 4.

In 2003-2006, I got between £14 to £21 an hour doing audio transcription work for media and corporate clients. I was freelancing for a small company who got the work and paid me £7 per 1000 words. Didn't get any benefits or sick pay though.

In 2006/7, I got £18 an hour as legal secretary reporting to one lawyer (who was on seven figures, but couldn't type at all). Once did overtime all weekend (e.g. catching up on filing) for double-pay, £36 hour.

It all ended in 2008 though.

PaperMonster · 14/10/2021 19:12

At my old employer, 22 years ago the part time job I did on a casual contract was paid £18 per hour. We could also claim meeting allowance of £10 per hour. The meeting allowance has long since gone. There were many years where we received £5 per hour worked for holiday pay. This has now gone. The workload has doubled. The hourly rate is still £18 per hour.

onlychildhamster · 14/10/2021 19:08

@Crumble012 Also now that there is so much media buzz about the high salary for HGV drivers- there are still inadequate numbers of Britons who want the job. I have 2 sisters-in-law who receive UC but none are willing to do the lowly paid jobs. 1 has a masters degree and is going abroad to do an unpaid internship (she got a grant to do this). Even when the internship is over, she would never take on a job in a supermarket or as a HGV driver or in a warehouse, she can stay rent free at her mum's house in London until she finds the right role. Her other sister has no GCSEs and can stay at her mum rent free too.

Even if they started paying supermarket assistants 35k, neither of my SILs are going to work as supermarket assistants. They are just not interested, they would rather not work than do something that they aren't interested in. And I can't even criticise them cos there was a time in my DH's life after he graduated that he stayed at his mum's house and applied for jobs until he found a graduate job that paid £46k (which enabled us to buy our flat in London) so you can see why this kind of thinking is not entirely flawed and its also why my DH has never worked in a minimum wage job despite being from a fairly poor background. Locals have options, immigrants don't. This is true for most economically inactive Britons (unemployment rate is 4.5% and probably includes people in between jobs), and only 22% of the economically inactive population wants a job. How many of those are actually suited to a labour intensive job with long hours in a warehouse or driving a HGV remains to be seen; a lot of them probably have caring obligations/don't have the skills/ex-criminals etc etc.

This is why this country needs immigrants. I am an immigrant too but from a country that is richer than the UK so I would sooner go back to my country (and take DH with me) than work for minimum wage so arguably I am not of much importance to the UK given that we need more essential workers driving HGVs/in the slaughter houses/strawberry picking so that our supermarket shelves stay stocked. So yes we do need these immigrants from poor countries until we can automate a lot of the processes.

onlychildhamster · 14/10/2021 18:54

@Crumble012 immigration also means more businesses, more innovation, more consumers.Its not a zero sum game. Like the situation now is that there are fewer Europeans competing for the jobs but at the same time, employers cannot expand their business due to supply and staffing issues.

Crumble012 · 14/10/2021 18:49

@onlychildhamster

Anyone who understands the law of supply and demand can see that an unlimited supply of Labour (especially from poorer countries, with workers happy to take low pay and poor conditions, in order to send money home) is going to depress salaries. The only people who benefit from this are the business owners.

onlychildhamster · 14/10/2021 18:11

@ILoveAllRainbowsx the data shows that immigration has a negligible effect on wages.

fullfact.org/immigration/immigration-and-jobs-labour-market-effects-immigration/

I am surprised that this hasn't been mentioned but outsourcing is a big reason. Many jobs have moved from the UK to cheaper jurisdictions which depresses wages.

The fact now with the EU workers leaving is that the British workers are not willing to take those jobs and this has led to the collapse of the supply chain. So we would have stagflation (increase in inflation due to supply shocks) but not necessarily wage increases. If there are wage increases, they would be in very specific sectors like hospitality and HGV driving.

Actually the low wage earners have seen a rise in their incomes due to increases in minimum wage; the biggest affected group are the lower middle class. This is because of over supply of graduates have kept the starting salaries low.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 14/10/2021 17:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

NandJ · 14/10/2021 15:10

@Poetrypatty

Not sure all the blame can be placed at Labour's door since we've had a Tory government for the last 11 years Hmm I wish Labour would come up with policies to fix this if they ever got in power though.
The stagnation begun under Labour, and I say this as a leftie (though I never voted for Blair).
CasparBloomberg · 14/10/2021 14:02

@RandomLondoner
Sorry hadn’t finished. In answer to your comment about benefits, I don’t link the two as the benefit system isn’t always involved. Someone losing one job and entering another might not even be using benefits system. Some of the jobs where people claim tax credits are highly qualified jobs, these aren’t just the jobs that people take because theyre forced off benefits. They’re jobs wanting experience and qualifications that someone who just lost their job might move to. Those salaries have eroded irrespective of benefits.

Well that’s my perspective. Have never been on benefits or tax credits but now looking at the job market at highly experienced and qualified jobs that you can’t get with a few GCSEs and no experience.

CasparBloomberg · 14/10/2021 13:53

@RandomLondoner
The reason I say tax credits cause salaries to reduce is that they allow someone to take a low paying job knowing it will get topped up a bit more. If before the wage was too low to pay for their needs they wouldn’t have done it and the employer would have offered a higher salary to attract them. The tax credit therefore allows an employer to reduce the salaries they offer and yet still get takers for them.
If the entry level jobs are now at a lower rate, the supervisor role for them can be at a lower rate as usually comes from promoting a lower employee who sees the increase as a benefit, but is still lower than it should be or used to be …. And so on.

Basically it’s like giving bad employers free cash to pay their employees less and thereby manipulating the market. By making something cheaper (an employee) it changes the dynamics in the long term so now all employers can do it as there becomes an established going rate for a role.