Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that wages have gone down A LOT in the past 20 years or so

188 replies

Poetrypatty · 13/10/2021 18:29

I'm looking at some roles where the amount offered is probably what would have been offered for that job, or possibly even less, than what you'd have got paid in about 1999. And that's often for graduates where you wouldn't have needed a degree back then and you do now. That's not even taking into account inflation or house prices.

I'm talking started and mid level office roles in particular rather than NMW jobs. I do think at the higher end wages have gone up, managers etc. For those who are old enough to remember, AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
comingintomyown · 20/10/2021 11:19

YANBU OP I was shocked when I was job hunting 4 years ago for a fairly basic admin/customer service role thinking £24k ( suburb of London) would be achievable. Almost all were around £21k or less and any higher paid roles required a huge list of skills and experience. I remember when I contacted one of the agencies I was registered with for an update them telling me nothing had come in “ for the kind of salary you are looking for “

Jmaho · 20/10/2021 10:49

@Ibelieveinghosts

Mod level professional service role c £50k in 2007, c£50k 2021.

There seems to have been a narrative since the 2008 crash that professionals should be glad to have a job. So coupled with a 15 year pay freeze they are being worked into the ground expected to work 24/7and be grateful -covid has been a wake up call to many and now everyone is leaving and forms struggling to fill vacancies.

My company take this stance too, that we should be grateful to have a job. I work for a bank. Most of the people I work with have years of experience and our roles are constantly changing and we are expected to take on more and more. Learning new policies and supporting other areas. We either don't get payrises or get a very small one as a token gesture. Haven't had any sort of bonus for 10 years. No shares, no preferential rates. Crap pension. No paid overtime. No healthcare etc. You bank hours but are never able to take them as its always so busy. They made loads of compulsory redundancies a while ago. Lost 2000 staff across the business and the rest of us are stretched even thinner. We see the annual profit figures. They are making millions. When they do have to recruit they offer a low amount and no one applies so they have to offer more so often new starters are being paid more than people who have been here for years and we're training them and more often than not they can't do the job and end up having to leave as don't pass the performance reviews. Problem is every other bank seems to be the same. I see job adverts for my role but they want someone senior so with qualifications and years of experience in certain areas. They are offering around 30k a year which is ludicrous. The only way to increase salary is to apply for a management role and I'm done it before. The pressure and long hours just aren't worth the extra 10k a year.
rigkiuowbskjs · 20/10/2021 10:45

I have no idea what I am going to tell my kids, especially as things have changed so much since I let uni twenty years ago. At the time, there were hardly any IT jobs and public sector jobs were very attractive. We never assumed that we'd make real money but they were seen as professional career jobs. Who knows what will be the right thing to do when they make that decision in 15 years time. Perhaps everything will be automated and only certain jobs will remain.

I find that it's not just the change but also the lack of foresight. My parents keep telling me that I could have become a lawyer or a banker if I wanted to make money, which is all true. But I decided to become a civil servant instead precisely because I wanted to contribute to society. I wasnt to know that 2008 plus a decade of Tory government was going to hit us. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

PickUpAPepper · 20/10/2021 10:34

[quote phlebasconsidered]@motherrunner me too- an nqt will soon catch me up and i have almost 20 years in the job. Experience counts for nothing. Still, at least it means I won't be seen as comparatively expensive for long! And there might soon be jobs that are not just advertised for nqt's.[/quote]
The only trouble with this is that the NQT is expected to do the same job as a senior teacher, and are held to the same standards. Why shouldn't they have the same wage, especially after a few years? If you want a better wage then you need to take on extra responsibilities, the same as in every other sector.

PickUpAPepper · 20/10/2021 10:30

I was brought up in the days when you were told "work hard at school, college and university and there will be rewards". Then the house prices went up. It was a total lie.

Gettingthereslowly2020 · 20/10/2021 07:25

What do we tell our children? "Work hard at school, college, and university and you'll be able to just about manage" - it's not very encouraging, is it?

Nat6999 · 20/10/2021 00:32

I left the Civil Service in 2011, my salary for full time was 18785, the pay for the same grade & increment level now is 20400, I sold my 3 bed ex council house for £64000 in 2011, that house has just sold for £115000, wages aren't keeping up with house prices & when you consider how much utilities, petrol & food etc have gone up over the last year due to the pandemic, in real terms wages have gone down.

thismumismad · 19/10/2021 23:43

Nmw has meant that people don't get what they deserve to be paid and it's been a race to the bottom. Gone are the unions to negotiate a real wage, nmw is an excuse to pay the least they can get away with.

Poetrypatty · 19/10/2021 23:23

It all makes for depressing reading doesn't it. I despair for our kids and wouldn't want mine to have to move to Australia, even though that sounds better. HGV driving, plumbing, roofing, and other trades seem to be a good move at the moment, and University education an expensive thing but also seemingly necessary for the most basic office jobs. There's no answer in sight for any of this either is there?

OP posts:
moimichme · 19/10/2021 14:34

This article seems relevant to the topic, albeit not entirely happy reading for those who aren't already at the top income wise:

bylinetimes.com/2021/10/18/taking-jobs-or-creating-jobs-the-impact-of-brexit-on-wages/?fbclid=IwAR2uPPFRh_nuocUnA_30ZHjzPWqh2vrJk82uVDa6fKeIkuDsV0MW0S9UtL8

Dbank · 19/10/2021 11:51

YANBU, but it's really not that unexpected, we've had 20 years of increased supply in the labour market, with a growing population driven by immigration.

There might be some short term adjustment post Brexit / covid, but I fear this will be swamped by the impact of automation and AI.

Tax 'n' spend won't fix it either...

phlebasconsidered · 19/10/2021 11:08

@motherrunner me too- an nqt will soon catch me up and i have almost 20 years in the job. Experience counts for nothing. Still, at least it means I won't be seen as comparatively expensive for long! And there might soon be jobs that are not just advertised for nqt's.

AlphabetAerobics · 19/10/2021 09:22

It’s not all unicorns and rainbows in the EU either - and I know this because I was there when the euro was introduced and during 2008.

When the euro came into play literally everything doubled overnight - except wages natch.

My salary went up a few thousand over 15 years and my spending power went from “buying anything I fancied” to scraping around for pennies.

My pension was decimated with the double whammy of having our contributions increase to cover current liabilities AND our own expectations were greatly lowered.

My holidays were cut 25%.

Houseofvelour · 19/10/2021 07:56

DH's profession has been hit hard over the last 10-20 years. Each year they get paid less and their fees increase.

MP's however earn a shit ton more than they used to.

TheWestIsTheBest · 19/10/2021 07:45

I am constantly boggled by the UK wages I read about on here, and I am very glad I left a long time ago! My first proper job was graduate trainee accountant, I started on 13660 UKP in 1991, and within four years as I qualified I was on over 25k (can't remember exactly). I left London (and the UK) in 2003 and I was on around 37k. So seeing some of the figures on here just blows me away, especially considering house prices.

As a contrast, here in Western Australia, two sets of friends have just built lovely 4 bedroomed houses, a short drive to the beach. One couple is a hairdresser and a decorator the other a butcher and an admin clerk. Each have two cars and a very comfortable life. All my friends teenage kids are working in the usual jobs, fast food, supermarkets etc. My 20 year old son's basic wage is $21 an hour, with more for evening and weekends, he gets over $30 an hour for working Sundays, and over $40 for public holidays. A friend of his works full time as a delivery driver, he earns $70k pa, I told him that in other countries this is piece work that pays badly, he couldn't believe it when he googled!

I have no idea really why there is such a massive disparity between the two countries. I understand the economic theory that high wages lead to high prices, and yes, a lot of things do appear to be more expensive than in the UK, especially if you are here on holiday spending your UK wages, and making the conversion in your head when you spend. But they are comparatively cheaper if you are on an Aussie wage. I am not trying to turn this into a n Oz is better thread as I know I would get crucified but I really think something has gone badly wrong in the UK, whether it is the Tories, or Brexit, or what else, who knows?

Gettingthereslowly2020 · 19/10/2021 07:07

@WholeClassKeptIn

Getting there - that's really interesting! What did you go onto do instead (currently looking!) Im teaching such a wide variety of courses it's so interesting but ultimately a lot of work for so very little pay and I can't sustain it. It wouldn't even satisfy UC/tax credits or whoever. Crazy. So many quite well qualified people working for the odd £50 a session here or there and it just isn't possible to do as a real job.
I got a full time job working for a charity on an unrelated role. I started as a trainee and worked my way up over the past 3-4 years. Permanent contract, 35 hours per week right from the start. I'm still only on 24k now. After tax, NI, student loan deduction, childcare, and travel costs, I worked out that I'm only actually around £10 per week better off than I would be not working and claiming benefits.

It's sad that I couldn't stay in teaching. I'm really disappointed. I worked so hard to get my degree, my teaching qualification, and the voluntary teaching placement. I really thought that teaching would be a solid career choice and would create a brighter future. I knew I wouldn't be rich but I thought I'd be able to get a stable job and maybe afford a holiday each year.

dapplegreypony · 19/10/2021 06:52

This is the case in my job. Also public sector roles in my area now pay a lot more with a lot more benefits than the private sector which didn't used to be the case. It's a shame and very difficult to live. I'd like to buy a house but every year my salary is worth less, I haven't had a payrise in 3 years and I don't even get sick pay outside of statutory!

MythicalBiologicalFennel · 19/10/2021 06:43

Reasons I can think of...

The general, worlwide trend of favouring shareholders over everything in private companies - including the long-term future of the company, let alone investing in training and productivity or paying decent wages...

Many years of tory governments and cuts to the public sector. That's where I work and in 15 years my wages (qualified technical job in a regulated industry) have never kept up with inflation.

The UK never really recovered from the 2008 recession.

The UK is an unequal society - the newest addition to this toxic pot is intergenerational inequality. Successive governments have been happy to stoke this fire and to set groups against each other for short-term gain. In the meantime, margins become tighter, standards are lower, conditions are poorer and job perks are cut.

People are understandably frustrated. Brexit was one the pressure valves for this frustration but IMO it's only moving things in the same direction, i.e. worse for the vast majority.

I would love to know what the solution is. I have family living in EU countries and their standard of living, public services and disposable incomes have gone up in the last 20 years - so it can be done.

Snoods · 19/10/2021 06:38

In 2001 I started an admin role on 15.5k a year. In 2004 I moved to another company for higher pay and closer to home. In 2011 I was made redundant, and went to another admin role for 15.5k. So the same money and similar role as I started on 7 years previous.

motherrunner · 19/10/2021 06:30

I’ve been teaching for 22 years so have suffered over a decade of pay freezes. I try not to dwell on it too much but two weeks ago I was 😳 when Boris announced new teachers would earn 30k. I can’t believe that next year’s NQT will be earning not much less than me. Why isn’t experience values anymore?

Pigeontown · 19/10/2021 05:58

In 1997 most of my friends got entry level office jobs in London with average salary of £15k, in 2000 I was on £26k felt like a lot. Had amazing benefits and we had a lot of company jollies too.
Similar job now would be about £30k. I don't know anyone on that wage who travels abroad, has expenses, lunches out etc. I was so so lucky! Early 2000s were great for a lot of those without responsibilities in good jobs. My salary rose to £50k by mid 2000s. This was good in my industry. Sadly I wasn't one of the ones who benefited from buying property.
Due to my childcare responsibilities over last 12 years I'm now on a job that's £25k pro rata (so about 14k). Have been unable to progress at all. Know plenty of women in same position. I look at jobs regularly and yes salaries are now in many cases lower. Especially regional jobs for national organisations. My role hasn't had a pay increase for new starters for 5 years and I've had a few hundred pounds in that period increase. No performance pay. Food and fuel has doubled. The only reason I'm a bit better off is that my dc no longer need wrap around childcare as that was crippling. But flip side was we wanted a bigger house to fit us. But bigger house cheaper than 2 in nursery...I spent 5 years working to cover childcare costs.

WholeClassKeptIn · 19/10/2021 05:38

Getting there - that's really interesting! What did you go onto do instead (currently looking!) Im teaching such a wide variety of courses it's so interesting but ultimately a lot of work for so very little pay and I can't sustain it. It wouldn't even satisfy UC/tax credits or whoever. Crazy. So many quite well qualified people working for the odd £50 a session here or there and it just isn't possible to do as a real job.

PickUpAPepper · 19/10/2021 02:41

It seems to me that any work requiring education is now a mug’s game - requiring debt for the training, experience to get the jobs, frequently unpaid, and then not well paid on top.

AlphabetAerobics · 18/10/2021 22:22

I had the well-paid IT career - fucked it off when I was asked to indicate on my holiday sheets whether I’d only be available by phone - or “working as normal”.

Er… Hmm

Gettingthereslowly2020 · 18/10/2021 21:22

@WholeClassKeptIn

Gettingthere - it seems to be similar across adult ed. I love it but need to find better paying work. It does seem to be middle class "wives" or early retired that can afford to do it. It is so wrong. Ive prepped half of today (unpaid) for a 2.5 hour session tomorrow...
Incidentally, in my department they were all men and it was their wives who had the well paid career but the same applies, middle class husbands who don't really need to work so just doing it more as a hobby and to keep busy.

I don't miss the unpaid lesson prep or the unpaid time spent marking work but I really enjoyed teaching in general, maybe one day I'll become one of the middle class wives and can get back into it.