Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School chores?

134 replies

LyricalBoudicca · 13/10/2021 17:08

At my daughter's school the y6 children have various jobs allocated to them on a rota. One of the jobs involves scraping all of the half-finished lunch plates of all the younger children into the bin. She is now looking for excuses not to go in on the day on which this job is allocated as it makes her feel sick. Pondering on this and assessing if she was being 'precious' I seem to remember picking up litter/tidying up the library as jobs I used to at primary school do but nothing as yukky as what her class is being made to do. Apparently, she is not the only child disgusted by this but she wouldn't want to be the only one to complain. Part of me thinks a few chores is a good training for life but there are yuk limits at that age. Is this fairly standard in schools or is her school asking a bit too much?

OP posts:
sammylady37 · 13/10/2021 18:22

Because it's not just one plate of food. Its hundreds

So? That doesn’t make it grim or gross. It’s a simple chore, just on a larger scale than at home.

LaetitiaASD · 13/10/2021 18:19

@BluebellsGreenbells

Aged 10 my grandmother was sent to the yard to select a chicken - strangle it and then pluck it.

She’d laugh at scraping plates.

Bring back the cane, that's what I say. Fucks sake, the kid should be grateful she's not shoved up chimneys from 6am to 10pm 7 days a week.

FFS

DroopyClematis · 13/10/2021 18:12

New YrR children often have no idea of what scraping a plate clean means as they often don't do it at home. An older pupil can help them. And why not?

Why do some people find plate scraping disgusting?

itsgettingwierd · 13/10/2021 18:00

@Rocketpants50

Yes I remember litter picking to, we didnt have any of those fancy litter picker things either. Not nice. Plate scraping, why can't the younger ones do it themselves, surely that's how they will learn how to do it. Maybe a y6 could monitor to encourage and guide them instead - worth suggesting? All children do it themselves at my DC's school. I think there are a few broken plates!
This.

Although I wouldn't have a problem with it there is no reason each child cannot scrape their own plate and be supervised.

Same with litter. I don't think having people to pick it up is a good lesson for others - having people supervise them pick their own dropped litter however is!

whatsthecraic91 · 13/10/2021 17:59

I wouldn't want my child doing this. Why can all the children not scrape their own plate? I remember doing my own at school primary & secondary. Usually the lunchtime supervisors helped the younger ones.

DriftingBlue · 13/10/2021 17:55

At my DD’s school, kids aren’t even allowed to approach the trash at lunch anymore. An aide brings it around and kids place the trash in the bin one by one, being careful not to touch anything and keeping socially distanced. Not a chance would I let my child be touching the used lunch trays.

Skysblue · 13/10/2021 17:54

Some children have extremely sensitive noses and find it difficult to lean over a bin full of rotting food for more than a few seconds without feeling sick. Certainly J knwo children like that and was that way when young myself, I still hold my breath when scraping plates.

I would not accept this as an appropriate job for a child, anymore than I would accept her having to clean the toilets. Some jobs like tidying are appropriate, and some are not. If this is causing her anxiety and distress regarding her school experience then her school has made an error of judgement which you should ask them to correct.

CoronaPeroni · 13/10/2021 17:54

I wouldn't have a problem with it (my own dds did this 20 years ago) if the jobs are on a proper rota regardless of sex. If girls are doing canteen duties and boys are doing games equipment duties I WOULD have a problem!

MakingM2 · 13/10/2021 17:53

I'd be expecting all of the children to scrape their own plates tbh - that's a reasonable expectation and a good habit to develop. I seem to recall being expected to scrape my own food waste into the bin at school and at home.

I don't see why one child should have to do that for all of the children, no. That's not a chore to prepare them for life...unless they are planning on working in hospitality.

Waspsarearseholes · 13/10/2021 17:53

Children shouldn't be missing their playtimes to do the job of MDSAs. Children can and should be taught from 4 that they scrape their own leftovers into the bin before they go out. I have no issue with children doing 'jobs' but not when they're doing the job of someone the school should be paying to do it. The headteacher should be helping at lunchtimes if they're that short staffed. My head does lunchtimes every day.

Hellocatshome · 13/10/2021 17:52

I caught Hepatitis by doing that job
How on earth did you catch hepatitis from washing dishes?

BluebellsGreenbells · 13/10/2021 17:51

Aged 10 my grandmother was sent to the yard to select a chicken - strangle it and then pluck it.

She’d laugh at scraping plates.

Hottubtimemachine · 13/10/2021 17:51

We used to have to do this in the 80s- we called it ‘being on slops’! It’s not a nice job and I would tell the school my child isn’t doing it.

LaetitiaASD · 13/10/2021 17:48

@Seemssounfair

My ds when 10 years old picked up his dogs poo when out, so scraping food plates would be no problem for him and as long as they get the opportunity to wash their hands after I would encourage her to do it. It is a chore to contribute to the school, she is being a bit precious.
No, it's either a chore because the school is underfunded and under-staffed, or it's being done for the benefit of the kid. I fail to see it as a particular benefit.

The fact that we need to teach kids that some people have to do menial, unpleasant and lowly paid jobs, and those jobs are as valuable if not more so than most office jobs, is an entirely separate matter.

ZenNudist · 13/10/2021 17:47

I wouldn't mind dc mucking in at say girl guide camp but you just know this is a chore in school due to budget cuts and not paying dinner ladies. I'd object to using the kids to do a paid adult job.

sillysmiles · 13/10/2021 17:47

Definitely being precious. It's just leftover food.

It's not rancid and I assume the bin is fresh everyday, so the bin isn't rancid either.

So long as all children are on the rota - fire ahead. Get on with it.

Anonymous48 · 13/10/2021 17:45

@Orangejuicemarathoner it wasn't my choice for them to use disposable plates. It's just the norm here.

LaetitiaASD · 13/10/2021 17:45

@sammylady37

What on earth is grim and gross about scraping leftovers from a plate into the bin? It’s food that has been served up, so not rancid and crawling with maggots.
Well for one it could be part chewed. For two it could be covid-infested. For three OPs kid could be a vegan and she find meat as disgusting as I do.
LaetitiaASD · 13/10/2021 17:44

@DeepaBeesKit

Why are cleaning jobs "disgusting"?

These are normal parts of every day life. Thousands of cleaners and service workers and parents and waitresses clear up and clean up waste food every day. You do the job then you wash your hands and they are clean again. This is normal life.

I'm now realising all you lot are probably the tossers who dont pitch in washing the tea mugs at the office and dont tidy their own food trays into the bin in fast food restaurants "because its disgusting" but ok for someone else to do it as long as it's not you.

Driving is a normal part of life, but we don't ask primary schoolchildren to drive when they should be learning or playing.
CareerConcerns1999 · 13/10/2021 17:42

@sammylady37

What on earth is grim and gross about scraping leftovers from a plate into the bin? It’s food that has been served up, so not rancid and crawling with maggots.
Because it's not just one plate of food. Its hundreds.
PlanDeRaccordement · 13/10/2021 17:42

@DeepaBeesKit

Why are cleaning jobs "disgusting"?

These are normal parts of every day life. Thousands of cleaners and service workers and parents and waitresses clear up and clean up waste food every day. You do the job then you wash your hands and they are clean again. This is normal life.

I'm now realising all you lot are probably the tossers who dont pitch in washing the tea mugs at the office and dont tidy their own food trays into the bin in fast food restaurants "because its disgusting" but ok for someone else to do it as long as it's not you.

That’s unfair. I think everyone should scrape their own plate, clean up own food waste. It’s the most hygienic because you’re not causing another person to share the germs of 150 others. As for work, insisted on installing dishwashers in office kitchens...again hygiene.
Rosebel · 13/10/2021 17:40

Can't see a problem but I think all the children should be doing their own plates. The children at the nursery I used to work at did it themselves from 3 so I'm sure a child of 4+ could manage.

sammylady37 · 13/10/2021 17:39

What on earth is grim and gross about scraping leftovers from a plate into the bin? It’s food that has been served up, so not rancid and crawling with maggots.

PlanDeRaccordement · 13/10/2021 17:39

While at university, I worked as a dishwasher. So scraped a lot of dirty plates. It’s not just gross, it is a hygiene hazard. I caught Hepatitis by doing that job and it was scraping the dirty plates where I caught it from.

So my child would not be doing it in a million years.

NoNayNever · 13/10/2021 17:36

I don't think it's necessarily unreasonable to ask children to help but I don't understand why the younger ones aren't clearing their own plates.

I do lunch duty at my school and the new Reception children are taught how to do this from the very first time that they have school dinners.

It would make slightly more sense to have someone supervising the little ones until they get the hang of it but just doing it for them isn't really doing them any favours in the long run. They need to learn.