Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Maternity records GDPR Breech

34 replies

LittleGungHo · 13/10/2021 16:03

AIBU to be cynical as to why my maternity records have gone missing and what can I do about it?

I have a rubbish birth with my DS in Jan this year. My womb collapsed and I was rushed into surgery post birth. The ballon they fitted worked and was removed but they left the 'packing' inside me.

I applied for my maternity notes last month and they should have been with me tomorrow but I was told yesterday 'we can't find them, the consultant does not have them, they may have been intercepted'.

I was meant to have a consultant appointment tomorrow to have a birth debrief and to find out if I can safely have more children. This has now had to be postponed until they find the notes.

Is this a GDPR breech?
Have they 'lost' them on purpose as there is significant medical negligence?

Help!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LittleGungHo · 14/10/2021 09:45

So they have sent me a Notice of Delay letter but they have emailed to say the notes are missing and they have contacted all departments. The letter said they are 'in use' so can not be sent.

I have asked for the letter to be amended to say they are currently missing not 'in use' and a timeline on when they will next be in touch.

OP posts:
HappyDays40 · 14/10/2021 03:59

Its not acceptable to just lose notes. I don't just "lose" my service user casnotes. They need to get off their bottoms and start searching. Its personal highly sensitive information do not accept loss. Kick up a fuss and act coz its not acceptable its not the kind of thing you want in the hands of the publc. I'd be bollocked for that.

Scirocco · 14/10/2021 00:27

If they're paper notes, the likeliest scenario is that someone has just failed to fill in the tracking system correctly, so when someone else has gone to retrieve them the notes haven't been where they should be according to the tracking system. It's not acceptable, but it almost certainly won't be personal. If they aren't able to reassure you and give you the information you need when you next speak with them, you can raise it as an issue with the hospital as this would constitute a data breach as previous posters have said. Hospitals should take data breaches seriously and do a thorough search to locate the notes; it could also help other people if through looking into your case someone identifies an issue with their tracking system or data handling processes, as the hospital would then need to address this.

I hope you get some answers. It's an awful feeling to be left waiting for an explanation.

Squaddielife · 13/10/2021 23:56

My guess is they haven't been "lost" per se, they just haven't been located yet.

When there's questions to be answered around a case/incident/complaint/report etc it can involve numerous departments and consultants, each of who will require the notes for review. Assuming they're not digital of course.

The department (probably the legal dept) who deals with your request for copy records will have raised it internally and all involved will be checking their areas. Medical records will likely also be involved to track and trace them down.

In my experience (working in legal) it is very rare that notes are never found. It can just take some time.

I would expect that you should be receiving regular updates as to where the search is up to. If this isn't happening you can escalate it to the Information Governance Team or customer care. I'd go IG first as most CC teams are swamped with backlog atm.

Hope you find the answers you're looking for and receive an informative de-brief

Heronatemygoldfish · 13/10/2021 22:46

@LittleGungHo All Incidents entered into the Toolkit have to have a declaration of whether your rights and freedoms have been infringed. In this case I'd say they would have been as you have been seriously inconvenienced and it could have long-standing repercussions if they don't magically turn up, as then there would be no record. If that's the case the Toolkit may report onwards to the ICO.

ICO possibly won't do anything, but the IG team would be also be obliged to report the Incident to the Trust Board who, if it also comes with a formal letter of complaint, might have to do an investigation. If the ICO does decide to do something, the maximum penalty for a reportable breach is £17.5million. OK that's more likely for "someone losing an unencrypted laptop full of personal medical information for hundreds of people on a train" sort of thing. But any fine is an embarrassment.

Oh and they have 72 hours to do the investigation and report once they've realised they have a breach. Including weekends.

sallywinter · 13/10/2021 19:31

My maternity notes went missing but it turned out a consultant had pulled them as i’d requested a debrief and had seen her the day before for some postnatal care - she was being proactive. I think the PALS lady was as shocked as me. Even then the record keeping hadn’t been good during labour so some key questions remain unanswered but the consultant was very helpful nonetheless.

If you haven’t already, write up your memories of the birth and ask your husband to do the same. The notes were one part of the picture but our memories were important during the debrief too.

LittleGungHo · 13/10/2021 19:09

@MilduraS no offence taken at all. You gave me a good perspective 👍

OP posts:
LittleGungHo · 13/10/2021 18:46

@Heronatemygoldfish

Information governance person here.

There are three types of breach: confidentiality (where info is lost, stolen, goes where it's not supposed to or is seen by unauthorised persons) availability (when it's not there when needed) and integrity (where the data is wrong).

Yours is a classic availability breach: the NHS is obliged to report these to the NHS Digital Data Security and Protection Toolkit. This is what the guidance says:

"Availability breach example
Unauthorised or accidental loss of access to, or destruction of, personal data - In the context of a hospital, if critical medical data about patients are unavailable, even temporarily, this could present a risk to individuals’ rights and freedoms; for example, operations may be cancelled. This is to be classified as an availability breach."

This is useful.

What is the impact of reporting it on the hospital?

OP posts:
MilduraS · 13/10/2021 18:45

@LittleGungHo Please don't think I'm suggesting your case is minor. My comment was an attempt to reassure you that it's far more likely to be human error rather than a deliberate loss. There's still hope that the notes will turn up when someone finally gets round to a clear out in the place they've been left.

namechanging564 · 13/10/2021 18:44

Yes it's a personal data breach, whether it's been accidentally deleted or lost somewhere, it's a data loss. Complain, state the legislation and see what they come back with, they should take it seriously because if it was the only copy of your notes that's potentially quite dangerous to you if there's no other record of your medical history at that time which impacts your rights and freedoms as an individual and thus triggers the threshold to be self-report to the ICO.

(I don't know enough about medical records to know if there's only one copy but that's how I'd interpret it if you, nor anyone else, could account for your pregnancy and birth, if there's a duplicate it won't be as serious although depends what their investigation found in terms of where they could be)

onthinice · 13/10/2021 18:41

Not sure how helpful they'll be, but the HV service may hold electronic copies of things like post natal summary. Ask them.

Heronatemygoldfish · 13/10/2021 18:40

Information governance person here.

There are three types of breach: confidentiality (where info is lost, stolen, goes where it's not supposed to or is seen by unauthorised persons) availability (when it's not there when needed) and integrity (where the data is wrong).

Yours is a classic availability breach: the NHS is obliged to report these to the NHS Digital Data Security and Protection Toolkit. This is what the guidance says:

"Availability breach example
Unauthorised or accidental loss of access to, or destruction of, personal data - In the context of a hospital, if critical medical data about patients are unavailable, even temporarily, this could present a risk to individuals’ rights and freedoms; for example, operations may be cancelled. This is to be classified as an availability breach."

BoredZelda · 13/10/2021 18:39

I asked for a copy of a report for my daughter but was told I couldn’t have it due to data protection, I’d have to fill in a form to get it. I was at the assessment and saw them do it and talked to them about it but I wasn’t allowed to see it written down. Then I asked who it had been sent to and they couldn’t tell me because the report hadn’t stated who it needed to go to, just the department. It had been posted but they had no record of it being received. The person who should have received it never did and couldn’t request a copy because one had already been sent. I questioned how they were protecting my daughters data by not giving the report to me, but by issuing it to a random department with no name on it. It is shocking how poor hospital records can be dealt with.

LittleGungHo · 13/10/2021 18:38

@MilduraS

I used to work in clinical negligence. I've been supplied with detailed notes that proved fatal and obvious cases of negligence. I've also had more minor cases from the same hospitals where the notes have been missing. Based on my experience, I've never suspected notes had been deliberately lost. If they were willing to "lose" them, it would have been better to lose notes for the £1m+ claims rather than the £20k claim.

I did have a few cases where lost notes were found months (in one case 3 years) after they were requested and they were promptly disclosed. It was usually in completely the wrong place in a huge storeroom or left in an office or cabinet that's no longer used. For the 3 year case they openly admitted they'd been found behind the radiator in the consultant's office after he'd retired.

Thank you for your logical head wobble. You are right there are 'better' notes to lose than mine. My issue is that though it is routine and process to the hospital to me it personally and impacts my future 😞
OP posts:
yippyyippy · 13/10/2021 18:35

I took photos on my phone of all my birth notes In hospital as I’ve heard so many accounts of other people’s ‘going missing’

LittleGungHo · 13/10/2021 18:33

@Dixiechickonhols

I found my birth debrief with specialist midwife very helpful after traumatic delivery so I hope you can still have that. My scan records ‘went missing’ - I know they were destroyed deliberately but obviously couldn’t prove it. My dc was born with a missing limb undetected on scans (well it’s there according to typed record note of scan but obviously wasn’t!)
Goodness me that sounds like a lot of failures and big trauma. They are going to call me next week (when they have hopefully found the records) to reschedule the debrief
OP posts:
MilduraS · 13/10/2021 18:32

I used to work in clinical negligence. I've been supplied with detailed notes that proved fatal and obvious cases of negligence. I've also had more minor cases from the same hospitals where the notes have been missing. Based on my experience, I've never suspected notes had been deliberately lost. If they were willing to "lose" them, it would have been better to lose notes for the £1m+ claims rather than the £20k claim.

I did have a few cases where lost notes were found months (in one case 3 years) after they were requested and they were promptly disclosed. It was usually in completely the wrong place in a huge storeroom or left in an office or cabinet that's no longer used. For the 3 year case they openly admitted they'd been found behind the radiator in the consultant's office after he'd retired.

Dixiechickonhols · 13/10/2021 18:11

I found my birth debrief with specialist midwife very helpful after traumatic delivery so I hope you can still have that.
My scan records ‘went missing’ - I know they were destroyed deliberately but obviously couldn’t prove it. My dc was born with a missing limb undetected on scans (well it’s there according to typed record note of scan but obviously wasn’t!)

wigglerose · 13/10/2021 18:05

If the personal data is no longer available (i.e. they gone and bloody lost the notes which are chock full of your personal data), then it's very likely a breach of the security principle of GDPR.

I found data protection in hospitals to be woeful when using perinatal services. Every scan I attended I could easily see the personal data of the previous patient on the screen. Files were left on reception desks open where anyone could see (or steal) them etc etc.

1FootInTheRave · 13/10/2021 18:01

The usual reason behind this is that someone has them in an office and hasn't tracked them to that area.

Another issue is that historical paperwork may be filed in a past volume of notes that are stored off site. Archived if you will. Still accessible but not as easy as the ones (most up to date volume) kept in your local trust.

Hope this makes sense.

LittleGungHo · 13/10/2021 17:23

@VillanellesOrangeCoat

They will be undertaking a massive search - we have to check every room, desk, cabinet, shelf, drawer etc etc when a set of medical notes go missing. It won’t be personal Flowers
This fills me with hope. The lady I having been speaking to side not seem concerned in the slightest. The consultants PA was more encouraging but still seemed to be shrugging (it was a phone call but had that tone).
OP posts:
VillanellesOrangeCoat · 13/10/2021 17:03

They will be undertaking a massive search - we have to check every room, desk, cabinet, shelf, drawer etc etc when a set of medical notes go missing. It won’t be personal Flowers

ancientgran · 13/10/2021 16:44

I hope they find them for you. My tale of lost records is police related rather than health, I worked in police admin and every year we had cadets on placement in various department. I was working with court files at the time so I would prepare Crown Court files, e.g. make sure all statements included, photos, charge sheet copies etc.

Well we had a big search as the files for next days court were missing. We eventually found them, the cadet had filed them under first names rather than surnames. About 100 files, did we have a panic until we found out what had happened. I wouldn't have liked to face the judge when he found out we had no file.

LittleGungHo · 13/10/2021 16:44

@Onairjunkie

I hope it’s not personal. My friend was left I n Labour for nearly 90 hours before she then nearly died from huge complications. The physical and mental health fall out for her was huge. Her notes were conveniently ‘lost’ too. Don’t stop pursuing it.
At the moment I am in a positive place mentally but there is definitely trauma. This appointment was my next step and now feeling a bit lost.
OP posts:
Onairjunkie · 13/10/2021 16:39

I hope it’s not personal. My friend was left I n Labour for nearly 90 hours before she then nearly died from huge complications. The physical and mental health fall out for her was huge. Her notes were conveniently ‘lost’ too. Don’t stop pursuing it.