Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sexual contact when asleep - abusive?

112 replies

Level75 · 13/10/2021 10:50

Just listened to an interesting item on Woman's Hour about people initiating sexual contact with their partner when their partner is asleep. The interviewee said all contact in this manner is without consent and therefore technically sexual assault. AIBU in agreeing with her? Loads of people contacted the program to say it wasn't an issue and some even gave blanket consent for their partner to have sex with them whilst asleep. I just thought that was a bit grim.

OP posts:
Lammysaurus · 13/10/2021 11:40

@Queenie6655

I'm so confused with this guys

Also - what if someone says - I DONT THINK IT S A GOOD TIME

husband goes ahead

Wife feels too scared to speak up

What is that??

😢😢😢😢

Rape.
ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 13/10/2021 11:38

Very early on I let DH do this with me. It wasn't long before I realised how violated it made me feel, and luckily he stopped. Friend discovered her DP was raping her in her sleep, as she used to have to take medication that knocked her out, then would find tissues and condoms in their en suite bin with no memory of it. Absolutely disgusting.

Runciblespoonandaring · 13/10/2021 11:37

Also - what if someone says - I DONT THINK IT S A GOOD TIME
husband goes ahead
Wife feels too scared to speak up
What is that??

Assuming that this is all one event, where the wife isn't up for it and says so, the husband goes ahead, and the wife is too scared to speak up - well that's rape I'm afraid.

Even if you had given blanket consent to let him have sex whilst you sleep, you said it was not the right time on that occasion, therefore the blanket consent doesn't apply that day. I'm not sure legally how that would stand up, but no reasonable person would ignore what you said and continue.

Assuming you have not given blanket consent, then this is rape clear and simple. It doesn't matter that you were subsequently too scared to speak up. You did not consent in any way to this. Being too scared to speak/move away is the freeze response. When scared people fight / flee / freeze, and all are valid responses. Sometimes your brain decides that the best way to survive this is to freeze. And freezing absolutely does not imply consent.

This is why the threshold for consent should not be a coerced 'yes', a nagged 'yes', or a lack of response. The lack of response, lack of 'no' or fight can be because the person is too scared to do anything but stay still. The threshold for consent should be enthusiastic consent.

OneTC · 13/10/2021 11:37

I'd never do it to oh, because she'd not like it

She would do it to me though, because I do like it

Abhannmor · 13/10/2021 11:36

@WhiskyXray

I assume women who give such blanket consent actually hate sex with their partners and can't face it awake, sober etc.

If it happens when you're asleep/drunk/stoned, then it's easier to dissociate from it and pretend it's not happening.

It sounds to me like a nightmarish kind of sex life to have.

That is one very large assumption.
EmotionalSupportBear · 13/10/2021 11:36

depends.

if you have given consent, or the 'initiating' is waking them up with kissing or caressing their stomach or thigh...etc, then i think its ok.

If you're doing what my ex was doing and undressing/groping, trying to penetrate them when they're asleep or pushed you off them once and pulled their pjs back up, moved away from you, or categorically told you not to do it again, then its assault/rape.

FluffyBooBoo · 13/10/2021 11:32

@MsFogi

I think the which all tees seem to have been shown is great and covers sex with someone who is sleeping!
It doesn't cover whether someone has said they are happy to be woken up with a cup of tea though. And some people are.
OttilieStonelady · 13/10/2021 11:32

@Queenie6655

I'm so confused with this guys

Also - what if someone says - I DONT THINK IT S A GOOD TIME

husband goes ahead

Wife feels too scared to speak up

What is that??

😢😢😢😢

Rape
fournonblondes · 13/10/2021 11:31

Only abuse if they were not given consent. Crystal clear. Wherever you think of the women or men who like this is up to them.

Getyourownback · 13/10/2021 11:30

some even gave blanket consent for their partner to have sex with them whilst asleep

If a partner could happily get his rocks off by shagging an unresponsive person, I’d be deeply concerned. Fuck. What is happening?

Porcupineintherough · 13/10/2021 11:29

I'm totally happy for dh to wake me up in a sexual manner because, for us, that means stroking or kissing. I wouldn't want to be woken up by him trying to jam it in but that's not our style so Ive never had to spell it out.

girlmom21 · 13/10/2021 11:27

I agree that it depends on every couple independently.

For me, sexual contact when I'm asleep is a boundary that I would end a relationship over but I know that lots of people would be perfectly ok with being woken up in certain ways that would freak me out personally.

MsFogi · 13/10/2021 11:26

I think the which all tees seem to have been shown is great and covers sex with someone who is sleeping!

RuncibleSpoonandaRing · 13/10/2021 11:24

Really depends.

DH has given blanket permission (and repeats this blanket permission periodically), but what usually happens is he's waking up by the time it gets beyond cuddling, kissing, stroking. If he was drunk or sleeping and unresponsive to the initial stages, then I would stop there (despite permission).

If there is no blanket permission in place, then it's absolutely assault.

If there's blanket permission in place but you've fallen out, then I'd say assault too because I would assume the consent is conditional - that if it's something the other person probably wouldn't consent to at that time if they were awake, then it's out of bounds. So that would include going through a bad patch/a fight/other person being particularly tired, or ill.

Personally, even with blanket consent, I wouldn't be willing to do this with someone who wasn't responding at all, but that may be different for someone else, and requires detailed negotiation.

I, OTOH, have not given blanket permission to DH for the other way round, and that's fine.

Sunshineandflipflops · 13/10/2021 11:23

I'm a sleepy morning sex person and my ex husband used to wake me up sometimes in the morning with kisses and strokes and I would like it. If I didn't I would have told him and he wouldn't have done it/stopped.

If someone has said they don't like it and the other person does it anyway then that's not ok though.

Zerogravity · 13/10/2021 11:21

What is that??
Sounds like an abusive relationship that you don't want to be in. Being scared of your partner is awful.

FluffyBooBoo · 13/10/2021 11:21

Oh - I just want to clarify, when I said sometimes I was into it, sometimes not - if I wasn't into it, we both just went back to sleep.

If he had persisted, that would have been assault. But he never did.

BashfulClam · 13/10/2021 11:21

I think it depends. My husband sometimes starts touching me when I’m asleep (stroking my back or kissing me). If I say ‘get off let me sleep!’ He stops immediately, if I am happy to get involved then I do. He never forces the issue, stops if I ask him to etc.

mamaweebeastie · 13/10/2021 11:20

About a year before I split with my ex, he started waking me up for sex by touching & fondeling. I'm not a good sleeper & once I'm awake I can't get back to sleep. I asked him not to do it. But Every so often he would try it. It made me feel disgusting & we talked about it again & he said he understood. He tried a few weeks later but this time got angry when I brushed his hands away & stormed out the room and I ended up with the silent treatment for a few days. I was then told in a blazing argument after the silence I was masterbateing so I must have been up for it. Long story short a few weeks later the police removed him from my flat & he was charged with domestic assault. Over a year later I'm on strong antidepressants & getting counselling and therapy due to his years of domestic abuse which could have led to full on sexual abuse if I hadn't left.
Waking someone up for sex is not consensual.

Derbee · 13/10/2021 11:20

I think it very much depends on the couple. DP and I have discussed it, and agreed that we both have given total consent for being woken up in a sexual manner, if one person wants to initiate sex, having come to bed later etc.

Clearly in our agreement, having sex with a completely comatose person would be strange/wrong. It would also be wrong to continue if the person woken up didn’t want to. But I don’t think there’s anything wrong with agreeing that it’s ok to initiate sex, and see if the other is up for it.

It’s all about boundaries and consent. Respecting boundaries, with consent, sexual touching is fine. Pushing boundaries, making people uncomfortable clearly not fine.

Queenie6655 · 13/10/2021 11:17

I'm so confused with this guys

Also - what if someone says - I DONT THINK IT S A GOOD TIME

husband goes ahead

Wife feels too scared to speak up

What is that??

😢😢😢😢

Twobirdsinatree · 13/10/2021 11:16

I think its key to discuss it between you as well..
I would say its always sexual assault if your partner never even asked you and also took pains not to wake you as in, he's just had sex with you whilst you were completely unconscious the entire time without ever asking you if he could and hoping you didn't wake... that is grim

But like I said some people like to initiate sex when they are both half asleep. And if both partners are fine with that I dont view it as assault.
Also if you have someones prior permission I dont view it as assault.

Lammysaurus · 13/10/2021 11:14

The interviewee said all contact in this manner is without consent and therefore technically sexual assault. AIBU in agreeing with her?

Loads of people contacted the program to say it wasn't an issue and some even gave blanket consent for their partner to have sex with them whilst asleep.

Blanket consent is consent, so these people are speaking up about something that doesn't impact them. But I also understand how the interviewee's words, the way you've stated them, imply that there's something wrong with people who consent to do this. That isn't fair or true.

FluffyBooBoo · 13/10/2021 11:06

@WhiskyXray

I assume women who give such blanket consent actually hate sex with their partners and can't face it awake, sober etc.

If it happens when you're asleep/drunk/stoned, then it's easier to dissociate from it and pretend it's not happening.

It sounds to me like a nightmarish kind of sex life to have.

I think I understand this differently to you.

'initiating sexual contact while asleep' isn't the same as 'having sex with someone that's asleep'.

ComtesseDeSpair · 13/10/2021 11:06

It depends what was meant by “initiating”, surely? Being startled awake because your partner has already climbed on you and inserted his penis = unacceptable. Being awoken by your partner kissing and nuzzling you = I’ve generally assumed this is normal for most couples and is one of my favourite ways to wake up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread