Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sexual contact when asleep - abusive?

112 replies

Level75 · 13/10/2021 10:50

Just listened to an interesting item on Woman's Hour about people initiating sexual contact with their partner when their partner is asleep. The interviewee said all contact in this manner is without consent and therefore technically sexual assault. AIBU in agreeing with her? Loads of people contacted the program to say it wasn't an issue and some even gave blanket consent for their partner to have sex with them whilst asleep. I just thought that was a bit grim.

OP posts:
Bouldghirl · 13/10/2021 12:55

I’m really in two minds on this one. I can see both sides of this. Personally I’m happy to be woken by a kiss or a gentle touch. I’m not that heavy a sleeper! In the unlikely event that I stayed asleep I’d find it a bit creepy to say the least if a partner continued beyond that stage.

LaetitiaASD · 13/10/2021 12:54

@Moneysavvymam

I don't know, it depends on the couple. My partner works very late and if we didn't 'wake eachother up' we would never get chance to do it. I would be upset if I said I was too tired and he didn't stop. I think its a personal decision and somebody labelling me and my partner sexual assulters for our how we initiate our love making is a bit grim in itself.
I completely understand the premise of the programme (consent is not possible to give whilst not awake!) I have to say that your perspective is also valid. The idea that one person - before they go to sleep - cannot consent to being woken up by intimate touching seems to me to be ludicrous.
grey12 · 13/10/2021 12:51

DH likes it when I initiate sex in the middle of the night Grin I will touch him and if if doesn't want it then it ends there but he is always happy about it tbh and has said many times he wants me to do it whenever I feel like it Wink

WhiskyXray · 13/10/2021 12:50

[quote Queenie6655]@WhiskyXray
I thought so

Police said no I'm not correct
That I should have said something again during intercourse !!

Was too afraid to
I initially didn't give consent [/quote]
I'm very sorry this happened to you and that your courage in reporting it was met with such a woeful, and wrong, police response.

It is unsurprising, however.

FluffyBooBoo · 13/10/2021 12:50

@CaveMum

It doesn't cover whether someone has said they are happy to be woken up with a cup of tea though. And some people are.

@FluffyBooBoo, but again there is a big difference in waking someone up with a cup of tea (which they are entitled to accept or reject at will) and pouring the tea into their mouth while they are still asleep.

I haven't said otherwise. And I believe that's covered in the video.
MadsMikkelsensWaterBottle · 13/10/2021 12:50

My abusive ex would get thrills doing this to me, I ended up wearing tucked in clothing, leggings and inaccessible trousers etc towards the end because I'd wake up with him assaulting me.
One of his many threats was to 'kill me then have sex/sodomize my body', absolute monster as he is.

TheEponymousGrub · 13/10/2021 12:48

Yes the interviewee's position was that any sexual contact with a sleeping person, ever, is sexual abuse. She deliberately makes no distinction between (A) waking a sexual partner in a sexual way, to see if they want sex on that occasion, and (B) penetrating someone who’s unconscious.

Unfortunately, the difference between A and B includes the really crucial part: consent! Calling scenario A rape, provides rape apologists with evidence that some people would cry “rape” at the drop of a hat, and so it dangerously undermines the valid complaint of anyone who has been abused in their sleep.

I think it was a really poor decision of WH to let this interviewee her damaging argument without closer consideration. I think that most people are happy with scenario A. I wonder if most of the "blanket approvals" are referring to that, rather than to Scenario B.

CaveMum · 13/10/2021 12:47

It doesn't cover whether someone has said they are happy to be woken up with a cup of tea though. And some people are.

@FluffyBooBoo, but again there is a big difference in waking someone up with a cup of tea (which they are entitled to accept or reject at will) and pouring the tea into their mouth while they are still asleep.

peboh · 13/10/2021 12:47

As a general rule of thumb, yes it absolutely would be assault. However some couples make have boundaries they've discussed in which consent is fully given in these instances, though it's difficult to really state that it wouldn't be, because consent can be revoked at anytime and how can one revoke consent when sleeping.

highlighta · 13/10/2021 12:45

@ConstanceGracy

Actually it was 3 times, one has literally just slammed back into my memory 😞
I completely get this. I too brushed off occasions when it happened, and afterwards did a..............hang on a minute.

I think there is quite a big difference between being kissed awake on or around the time you would wake anyway which may or may not lead on to having sex. I woke up to my tampon being removed, and worse, which is absolutely not the in same category.

So I don't think there is a yes or no reply to this. It depends on a few different factors.

Queenie6655 · 13/10/2021 12:45

@Runciblespoonandaring

*Also - what if someone says - I DONT THINK IT S A GOOD TIME husband goes ahead Wife feels too scared to speak up What is that??*

Assuming that this is all one event, where the wife isn't up for it and says so, the husband goes ahead, and the wife is too scared to speak up - well that's rape I'm afraid.

Even if you had given blanket consent to let him have sex whilst you sleep, you said it was not the right time on that occasion, therefore the blanket consent doesn't apply that day. I'm not sure legally how that would stand up, but no reasonable person would ignore what you said and continue.

Assuming you have not given blanket consent, then this is rape clear and simple. It doesn't matter that you were subsequently too scared to speak up. You did not consent in any way to this. Being too scared to speak/move away is the freeze response. When scared people fight / flee / freeze, and all are valid responses. Sometimes your brain decides that the best way to survive this is to freeze. And freezing absolutely does not imply consent.

This is why the threshold for consent should not be a coerced 'yes', a nagged 'yes', or a lack of response. The lack of response, lack of 'no' or fight can be because the person is too scared to do anything but stay still. The threshold for consent should be enthusiastic consent.

Thanks

Well according to the met it's not !!!!!!!

Any wonder women don't report these things

Queenie6655 · 13/10/2021 12:41

@WhiskyXray
I thought so

Police said no I'm not correct
That I should have said something again during intercourse !!

Was too afraid to
I initially didn't give consent

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/10/2021 12:38

If you’ve said, please do wake me up by starting to have sex with me, and by all means continue if I’m asleep, whenever you want. I guess that is consent. All be it I find it hard to imagine someone giving something so blanket.

I’ve always made it clear to partners myself that I’m not to be woken unless the house is on fire.

BodgertheJogger · 13/10/2021 12:34

Surely if you have a discussion between you as a couple with no blurred lines and reach a unanimous decision that is stuck to then it's not abusive.

WhiskyXray · 13/10/2021 12:33

@ftw163532

If someone describes being assaulted or raped, I am not going to pretend it's a-ok and go along with their denial.

Have you not seen how many women in desperately abusive relationships will describe extreme abuse (so no possible scope for any of the minimising bullshit to be valid) but insist that it's normal and fine? Some women have never experienced a non-abusive relationship.

Engaging in a protective coping mechanism based on denial/normalisation or having been brainwashed into believing it is ok does not actually change the nature of what is occurring.

I agree with you. I used to be wholly on the "every relationship is different" train, but years and years of hearing women explain away abuse have brought me round to the view you express here.
ConstanceGracy · 13/10/2021 12:31

@nadiamumoftwo

There’s a difference between waking your partner up to suggest sex and sexually abusing someone who is asleep
Exactly.
SickAndTiredAgain · 13/10/2021 12:27

@FatAnneTheDealer

The woman on the radio specifically stated that it was not possible to give blanket, or prior, consent. I.e. even in a relationship where one partner has said specifically that it is okay to be woken up with sexual touching, that consent was not valid and it was still an assault.

Since you can’t give anything but prior consent if you are asleep, that means she was saying in every case without exception this is assault.

I think it is on the whole unreasonable (and deeply patronising) for one person to insist to another person that they have been assaulted, when they don’t think they have!

I’d agree with your last sentence definitely. If DH wakes me up by kissing/stroking which I am totally fine with, I object to someone saying “no actually, he sexually assaulted you”
ftw163532 · 13/10/2021 12:27

If someone describes being assaulted or raped, I am not going to pretend it's a-ok and go along with their denial.

Have you not seen how many women in desperately abusive relationships will describe extreme abuse (so no possible scope for any of the minimising bullshit to be valid) but insist that it's normal and fine? Some women have never experienced a non-abusive relationship.

Engaging in a protective coping mechanism based on denial/normalisation or having been brainwashed into believing it is ok does not actually change the nature of what is occurring.

TurnUpTurnip · 13/10/2021 12:26

[quote smoko]@CornishGem1975. Easy, you're sleeping on your side. They lick their hand, push your undies aside & are in there before you can realise what's happening.

In my experience it was mostly digital penetration, but it's very easy to start having sex with someone while asleep if they're positioned on their side.

I guess if you were a very light sleeper perhaps you'd find it hard to imagine how easy that is...[/quote]
Yes it is that easy, my ex use to do this to me when I was pregnant like I said never realised it was considered wrong until I came onto MN

Severntrent · 13/10/2021 12:26

And also that ltd contact while I'm asleep is fine. As long as he refers to first rule.

Severntrent · 13/10/2021 12:25

I think it is on the whole unreasonable (and deeply patronising) for one person to insist to another person that they have been assaulted, when they don’t think they have! this. People have different boundaries and I think part of a good relationship is understanding and respecting these. So for some contact while sleeping would be fine and others need verbal consent before each contact- also fine if that's your wish.
My dh would know NEVER wake me up.

CornishGem1975 · 13/10/2021 12:24

[quote smoko]@CornishGem1975. Easy, you're sleeping on your side. They lick their hand, push your undies aside & are in there before you can realise what's happening.

In my experience it was mostly digital penetration, but it's very easy to start having sex with someone while asleep if they're positioned on their side.

I guess if you were a very light sleeper perhaps you'd find it hard to imagine how easy that is...[/quote]
Yes, I think that's why I struggle to comprehend it, I totally believe it happens but I can't imagine it - I am an incredibly light sleeper - someone could walk into the room, or if DP just rolls over in bed, I wake up.

TurnUpTurnip · 13/10/2021 12:22

Women definitely do it to, it’s not only a man thing

nadiamumoftwo · 13/10/2021 12:21

There’s a difference between waking your partner up to suggest sex and sexually abusing someone who is asleep

gogohm · 13/10/2021 12:20

Depends on the couple of course, my ex loved the idea of me waking him up that way, others do not consent. As long as everyone is happy there is no issues

Swipe left for the next trending thread