Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sexual contact when asleep - abusive?

112 replies

Level75 · 13/10/2021 10:50

Just listened to an interesting item on Woman's Hour about people initiating sexual contact with their partner when their partner is asleep. The interviewee said all contact in this manner is without consent and therefore technically sexual assault. AIBU in agreeing with her? Loads of people contacted the program to say it wasn't an issue and some even gave blanket consent for their partner to have sex with them whilst asleep. I just thought that was a bit grim.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ConstanceGracy · 14/10/2021 13:54

@FaceForRadio1973

I ask, because at the time, I thought that I was doing something pleasurable for her. I now realise that although it was well received, I am seriously wondering that maybe I shouldn't have done it in the first place.

As for wank fodder? Really?

I can't think of anything less erotic then cracking one out over this forum...

Oh, hang on, I'm a man, aren't I. Of course, I have a porn and gaming addiction.

Yes really, you wouldn’t be the first or the last ..
LampLighter414 · 14/10/2021 10:09

Horses for courses. Each to their own etc.

If you don't like it, say, if it continues then that's bad.

For some couples this is normal behaviour and is enjoyed/appreciated.

FaceForRadio1973 · 14/10/2021 09:50

I ask, because at the time, I thought that I was doing something pleasurable for her. I now realise that although it was well received, I am seriously wondering that maybe I shouldn't have done it in the first place.

As for wank fodder? Really?

I can't think of anything less erotic then cracking one out over this forum...

Oh, hang on, I'm a man, aren't I. Of course, I have a porn and gaming addiction.

ConstanceGracy · 13/10/2021 15:26

@FaceForRadio1973

Oh, I think it's safe to say that prior consent is there...
Because?? Why did you ask then? Unless you’re one of those who trawls mumsnet for wank fodder.
WhiskyXray · 13/10/2021 14:47

I would hate it, but ask your wife.

LizzieW1969 · 13/10/2021 14:14

I would absolutely hate it. I get triggered easily because of suffering from PTSD as a result of childhood SA, so it would be a big no from me.

dottiedodah · 13/10/2021 14:08

I guess for some people its OK if they have agreed to it.I would personally hate it,I dont like being woken up anyway . Surely its only kindness to wait until partners awake!

FaceForRadio1973 · 13/10/2021 13:38

Oh, I think it's safe to say that prior consent is there...

thelegohooverer · 13/10/2021 13:37

I think it’s very dangerous to presume consent.

For what it’s worth I had no issues with dh initiating sex while I was asleep but I would definitely wake up. I can’t imagine sleeping through that. Dh enjoys it when I do it too.

However, there have been times where sleep has been a priority, and lately where sex is completely off the table for the week before my period because I’m peri menopausal. And on more than one occasion I’ve sleepily pushed him away or rolled away and that’s also taken as a no.

I feel like it’s a special privilege I afford to dh. I might not feel like that with a different partner.

I think it’s important to start from the point of “only positive, enthusiastic consent” and then allow couples to figure out their own comfort zones.

We shouldn’t judge couples for what they do in privacy if it’s safe, sane and consensual but it’s even more important that people don’t make others feel wrong for the boundaries and limits that they do have.

FluffyBooBoo · 13/10/2021 13:35

@FaceForRadio1973

Holy sh*t

I am genuinely mortified that's how it could have been construed...

I wouldn't be too concerned about what some stranger online thinks.

What's more important is what your wife thinks. If you know that she's happy to be woken up with you going down on her, then that's consent. If you continue despite her having changed her mind, that's abuse.

FaceForRadio1973 · 13/10/2021 13:27

Holy sh*t

I am genuinely mortified that's how it could have been construed...

FaceForRadio1973 · 13/10/2021 13:26

Holy sh*t

I am genuinely mortified that's how it could have been construed...

FoamBananas21 · 13/10/2021 13:26

@ComtesseDeSpair

It depends what was meant by “initiating”, surely? Being startled awake because your partner has already climbed on you and inserted his penis = unacceptable. Being awoken by your partner kissing and nuzzling you = I’ve generally assumed this is normal for most couples and is one of my favourite ways to wake up.
Couldn't agree more.
bigred22 · 13/10/2021 13:24

Legally, these are the points which have to be proven for sexual assault by touching - I would imagine blanket consent for people who enjoy this covers the "reasonably believes" point.

Personally, I don't think one person can just decide what is and isn't assault when everyone will have their own boundaries in their relationship.

Sexual contact when asleep - abusive?
Level75 · 13/10/2021 13:23

@FaceForRadio1973 in my view, yes.

She might consent when she wakes up but I don't see how she can consent to this when asleep.

Going down on someone is, to me, a step beyond kissing/stroking in the hope they'll wake up and want sex (the latter being less problematic in many people's eyes).

OP posts:
FatAnneTheDealer · 13/10/2021 13:18

@TheEponymousGrub

*Yes the interviewee's position was that any sexual contact with a sleeping person, ever, is sexual abuse. She deliberately makes no distinction between (A) waking a sexual partner in a sexual way, to see if they want sex on that occasion, and (B) penetrating someone who’s unconscious.

Unfortunately, the difference between A and B includes the really crucial part: consent! Calling scenario A rape, provides rape apologists with evidence that some people would cry “rape” at the drop of a hat, and so it dangerously undermines the valid complaint of anyone who has been abused in their sleep.

I think it was a really poor decision of WH to let this interviewee her damaging argument without closer consideration. I think that most people are happy with scenario A. I wonder if most of the "blanket approvals" are referring to that, rather than to Scenario B.*

Totally agree. As for @ftw163532 I absolutely understand that a person can be in an abusive relationship without fully realising it. That’s why I said on the whole it is unreasonable and patronising to tell someone they have been assaulted if they don’t think they have.

I am largely referring to scenario A (woken up with sexual touching) above, because I find it difficult to imagine scenario B (woken up with PIV), mostly because I find it difficult to marine that happening.

What I don’t find it difficult to imagine is that some - possibly even most - women would find A unacceptable. If that was all the interviewee was talking about, I probably would be in broad agreement.

I also don’t find it difficult to imagine that some - possibly many - women would find B absolutely okay, especially if prior, awake permission had been given.

In that case it is outrageous for some other person to insist that she has been assaulted (sub text: she is too oppressed or too stupid to understand that she is in an abusive relationship)

GitsandShigggles · 13/10/2021 13:15

@seaandsandcastles

Don’t be ridiculous. In a loving, trusting committed relationship this is just exciting and passionate.

I love it when DH wakes me up this way and I do it to him too. What has the world come to 😂

Yes - exactly this! But it seems most of the posters here are in relationships of convenience where bills, chores and children are the priority and everything else is a once annual birthday treat (as long as there is recorded written consent of course).
seaandsandcastles · 13/10/2021 13:07

Don’t be ridiculous. In a loving, trusting committed relationship this is just exciting and passionate.

I love it when DH wakes me up this way and I do it to him too. What has the world come to 😂

Peace43 · 13/10/2021 13:06

We have blanket consent but the idea of the sexual contact is to wake the other person to join in. The assumptions is that the other person would be keen to join in. I don't consider it assault but it is something we have specifically discussed. It wouldn't be ok for me if it hadn't been discussed. We have never got to penetration without the other person being fully awake and participating. I (and he) would not feel at all uncomfortable to wake up and say no we don't fancy it. The other person wouldn't be at all put out at being rejected and we'd just have a quick cuddle instead.

FaceForRadio1973 · 13/10/2021 13:05

I apologise if this is too much information, but a couple of times now, I've woken my partner up by going down on her.

Yes, she enjoyed it, but because she was asleep, I didn't actually ask for consent. I just guessed that she would enjoy it.

Was this abuse?

jay55 · 13/10/2021 13:03

The problem with blanket consent, is you cannot withdraw it if you don't wake up. And the person having sex acts performed on them should always have the ability to withdraw consent.

FluffyBooBoo · 13/10/2021 12:58

no he didn't

Yes, he did. I was there and I don't remember you being part of that conversation. But I knew someone would think that they knew what went on better than me.

You, however, are free to think what you like.

Queenie6655 · 13/10/2021 12:57

@MadsMikkelsensWaterBottle

My abusive ex would get thrills doing this to me, I ended up wearing tucked in clothing, leggings and inaccessible trousers etc towards the end because I'd wake up with him assaulting me. One of his many threats was to 'kill me then have sex/sodomize my body', absolute monster as he is.
I'm so so sorry 😞
Queenie6655 · 13/10/2021 12:56

@WhiskyXray unsurprising

Why should they care!!!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/10/2021 12:56

but again there is a big difference in waking someone up with a cup of tea (which they are entitled to accept or reject at will) and pouring the tea into their mouth while they are still asleep.

^^this is a good way of looking at it!

Unless they’ve specifically said “I love tea poured into my mouth whilst asleep, please go for it”

Swipe left for the next trending thread