Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry my 8 year old hasn’t had chickenpox?

167 replies

Wannakisstheteacher · 12/10/2021 20:05

Talking to a friend today reminded me DS3 hasn’t had chickenpox. His elder siblings had it before he was born. Is this something I should worry about, or maybe pay to have him vaccinated against now as he’s unlikely to catch it at this point? Having asked a few other friends DS is the only one not to have had it 😱

OP posts:
Frazzled2207 · 13/10/2021 08:08

I wouldn’t worry at age 8. An 8yo I know just got it and wasn’t unduly bothered. I’d probably try and get them vaccinated as a teen if still not had it

Fwiw my mother is adamant that I had never had it. When I was pregnant with DS2 I went and asked gp about vaccine because DS1 had narrowly avoided catching it at nursery and obviously having pox when pg is not good. She said that it was unusual to get to adulthood without having had it and ordered an antibody test, after that she was going to recommend a vaccine. Antibody test was positive, I had had it! Just apparently didn’t get any spots!

CazM2012 · 13/10/2021 08:04

I would get him the vaccine, my DH hadn’t had chicken pox until our DC caught them and he was almost hospitalised with pneumonia, it is the worst I’ve ever seen him, it was all 100x worse than the DC symptoms.

1dayatatime · 13/10/2021 08:00

Please please get him vaccinated, on average 25 people a year die of chicken pox , 20 % of which are under 16. Plus as a previous poster said the later you get it the more likely you are to get shingles complications later in life.

I find the whole concept of just let them get it and acquire natural resistance to be barbaric., no other civilised country does this. Why would you knowingly allow a child to become infected with a virus that can cause scaring, shingles and even death when there is a vaccine available.

JassyRadlett · 13/10/2021 07:26

(Apols, saw you subsequently posted the same study, I missed it on my first read of the thread.)

JassyRadlett · 13/10/2021 07:23

The vaccine increases the likelihood of shingles in toddlers, unfortunately, otherwise it'd be an open and shut case for me. I've got a one year old DS and hoping he makes it past toddlerhood without catching it so I can have him vaccinated against it. DD unfortunately had it at 11 months old.

In the study that found the association, it was only in one year olds, wasn’t it? The increase disappeared by age 2.

CharleyMarley · 13/10/2021 06:44

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@CharleyMarley and others saying the vaccine doesn't wane....

I had the vaccine ( 2 doses on the NHS) and caught Chicken Pox 18 months later.

Did nothing for me so if I had to pay privately not sure I would have bothered tbh.[/quote]
Also @Willyoujustbequiet, we know for sure (based on real-world data) that the chickenpox vaccine gives AT LEAST 10-20 years protection for most people. So if you caught it as early as 18 months after the vaccine, it is most likely the protection you received didn't wane, but that was the full impact of your immunity, and what you suffered was breakthrough disease (ie the unlucky 1% who didn't get full immunity)

CharleyMarley · 13/10/2021 06:39

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@CharleyMarley and others saying the vaccine doesn't wane....

I had the vaccine ( 2 doses on the NHS) and caught Chicken Pox 18 months later.

Did nothing for me so if I had to pay privately not sure I would have bothered tbh.[/quote]
@Willyoujustbequiet

This is a very rare scenario. However you will have probably had a mild version. Two doses of the vaccine gives 100% protection against severe disease and >90% against contracting chicken pox. So breakthrough disease can occur - but rarely.

I also know someone who has caught chicken pox and she still isn't immune. She had it very badly as an adult and the got it again (but more mildly)

MRex · 13/10/2021 06:37

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@CharleyMarley and others saying the vaccine doesn't wane....

I had the vaccine ( 2 doses on the NHS) and caught Chicken Pox 18 months later.

Did nothing for me so if I had to pay privately not sure I would have bothered tbh.[/quote]
The NHS doesn't offer the chickenpox vaccine for children and only offers or to those adults who are not immune and are in close contact with people who have weakened immune systems. Did the person you were caring for also catch chickenpox? Were they ok?

There will be some who have been vaccinated and catch chickenpox; someone has to be the 1% who it doesn't work for; similarly there are also people who catch chickenpox more than once, but that's rare too. There are also people whose immune systems don't work very well due to illness or medication; they are at particular risk of catching chickenpox even if they've had it before or been vaccinated.

NeverForgetYourDreams · 13/10/2021 06:25

Vaccine works best before they are 13

We waited til DS was 12 and then vaccinated him

I was a late catcher (21) and I shall just have to remember to get him a booster every 10 years! Even when he's an adult he will need reminding probably

Cost us £200

CovidIsADick · 13/10/2021 06:20

Get him vaccinated if you can. I caught it at 19 and I was horribly ill. I was struggling to breathe and ended up being rushed to A&E. I had a CT scan and it had spread to my lungs. Every breath felt like daggers. I spent a week in hospital.

SylvanasWindrunner · 13/10/2021 06:04

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@CharleyMarley and others saying the vaccine doesn't wane....

I had the vaccine ( 2 doses on the NHS) and caught Chicken Pox 18 months later.

Did nothing for me so if I had to pay privately not sure I would have bothered tbh.[/quote]
That is pretty unusual and you almost certainly got a much milder version than you would have otherwise.

Two vaccines reduces the risk of catching CP by more than 90%.

SylvanasWindrunner · 13/10/2021 06:00

DD was vaccinated at 11 months. Check smaller local pharmacies, OP. Ours was cheaper than Boots.

Dogsandbabies · 13/10/2021 05:38

Does should have been died.

Dogsandbabies · 13/10/2021 05:38

Please don't listen to anecdotal Mumsnet data. Do your research using scientific data.

My DD had chicken pox twice. My eldest DS had the vaccine and has not caught chicken pox during 3 outbreaks at nursery. My colleague's DD does from catching chicken pox (tragically they actually encouraged her to catch it by exposing her - I can't begin to imagine how they are doing). But of course that doesn't mean that death is common or reinfection post natural infection.

You can't make a decision on the basis of my evidence. There are huge studies from the US you can read. Based on my research getting the vaccine is better. It is safer, lasts for a good while and reduces the occurrence of shingles.

Katyy · 13/10/2021 05:12

Am I missing something here, surely if she hasn’t had chicken pox she won’t get shingles when she’s older. Shingles can be very painful and even cause eye problems. My mum suffered horribly with them and still has pain two years later. I’m in my 60s and never had chickenpox even though all my classmates did.

ThirdElephant · 13/10/2021 04:28

www.scientificamerican.com/article/two-for-one-chickenpox-vaccine-lowers-shingles-risk-in-children/

'The authors found that one dose of vaccine reduced shingles infection by 78 percent—except in young toddlers. Shingles rates were significantly higher in vaccinated one-year-olds than unvaccinated ones, although this increased risk for vaccinated children vanished by age two. The authors suspect the higher risk in toddlers “could be related to the developing immune system in very young children,” says lead study author Sheila Weinmann, a senior investigator at the Center for Health Research, Kaiser Permanente Northwest in Portland, Oregon.'

They go on to say that they still think it's 'probably' better to get them vaccinated at one because of the risk of catching the wild virus if you delay u til age two, but I'm not sure if I want to risk shingles so will probably wait until two. I don't know much about the severity.

LoveFall · 13/10/2021 04:23

Please may I have a reference for the assertion that the risk of shingles is increased? If correct, that is of course a consideration in when to vaccinate.

Is the reported shingles severe? I have seen horribly painful and long-lasting shingles in otherwise healthy adults. Preventing it seems very wise indeed.

Ericaequites · 13/10/2021 04:21

Get the vaccine. My siblings both had it as adults and were very ill indeed. It’s much easier for both of you to not have it in the house.

ThirdElephant · 13/10/2021 04:17

@LoveFall

I despair.

Shingles. Shingles. Shingles.

Is there anything more one can say?

Get the chicken pox vaccine. Don't get chicken pox. And then, don't get shingles however many years later.

Shingles can happen in young people, I assure you.

And really, do you not care about how your child is in old age? Or if weakened and immunocompromised because they are sick?

There is no need for children to have chicken pox and thus no need for anyone to have shingles.

The vaccine increases the likelihood of shingles in toddlers, unfortunately, otherwise it'd be an open and shut case for me. I've got a one year old DS and hoping he makes it past toddlerhood without catching it so I can have him vaccinated against it. DD unfortunately had it at 11 months old.
LoveFall · 13/10/2021 04:15

I despair.

Shingles. Shingles. Shingles.

Is there anything more one can say?

Get the chicken pox vaccine. Don't get chicken pox. And then, don't get shingles however many years later.

Shingles can happen in young people, I assure you.

And really, do you not care about how your child is in old age? Or if weakened and immunocompromised because they are sick?

There is no need for children to have chicken pox and thus no need for anyone to have shingles.

Anon778833 · 13/10/2021 03:50

I had chicken pox at 13 and it was horrible - I had spots in my mouth & throat which led to an infection. I'm going to arrange for dd4 to get vaccinated against it. My older children all caught it under the age of 3 and luckily it was mild for them.

foxgoosefinch · 13/10/2021 01:03

My daughter had the vaccination at three because of a severely immunocompromised relative who she couldn’t see if there was any risk she could have chickenpox.

It’s on the routine vaccination schedule in many countries in the EU and in the US and is very effective. It’s a shame it isn’t here - I was told by a GP that a few years ago the NHS was poised to introduce it - and then had to scrap the idea because of the pertussis outbreak and MMR uptake dipping. Because they didn’t want to increase vaccine hesitancy by introducing too many vaccines at the same time.

I’m always horrified by the cavalier attitude towards chickenpox and chickenpox parties. Yes most kids get it relatively mildly but lots don’t, and it can be a nasty illness - my niece was really very ill with it, spots inside her throat and other places. Some children can have very serious reactions - I vividly remember being on a live thread on here years ago where the OP couldn’t wake her young child; and when he was rushed to A&E they found he was having a very serious encephalitic reaction to chickenpox. I think about that poster every so often and hope her child is okay.

ThirdElephant · 13/10/2021 00:33

@cabbageking

Never caught chicken pox as a child. Never caught it when my children and those in school caught it. Never had a vacine. Not even sure they existed then. Some people just don't seem to catch it.
They reckon that if you're like this you've probably had it so mildly you've not realised you had it.
Gingersay · 13/10/2021 00:32

I'm 42 and never had chicken pox despite sharing a bed with my elder sister when she had them at 9 she gave them to my dad who had a terrible time. Both my kids had them 2 weeks apart when they were 9 and 7 I still never got them.

ThirdElephant · 13/10/2021 00:31

[quote Wannakisstheteacher]@MRex I’m wavering because I’ve always felt it would be better to get it ‘naturally’ as it stimulates the lifelong immune response. The vaccine isn’t 100% effective so I guess I’ve just been hoping he’d eventually have it like his siblings.[/quote]
To be fair, natural immunity isn't 100% either, and the vaccine protects against shingles better.