Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shit. I think I have a zoom meeting with my childhood bully.

608 replies

TheRealAnnabelleBronstein · 12/10/2021 13:21

I’m not in the UK so hope this won’t be outing. Have changed details for privacy.

Imagine my name is Eleanor Smyth but I changed my name when I married and am now Eleanor Johnson. Imagine also that I’m the Head of Finance for a huge organization.

A company who sells financial services software has been contacting me for quite a while now asking for me to meet with them for a product demonstration. We’re now in a position where we’re going to stop using our existing product so doing demos with several organizations. The successful company will also be given a piece of work to prepare our related systems for integration and testing and training so there’s a project element as well as a product. The budget for the project is roughly $15m and then the product will be roughly $2m/year so it’s a big piece of work.

The Relationship Manager let me know that the call would be led by one of their sales people who he referred to as (name changed), Edwina Craig. All good and a zoom meeting was arranged.

I’ve just looked at the Zoom invite and can see that Edwina Craig is actually on there as Edwina Craig-Dyson.

Edwina Dyson was the school bully. Thoroughly unpleasant person who made my time at second level very difficult. She was so insidious. She wouldn’t physically bully but it was constant picking and awful comments. When I was in school, a classmate killed herself. I remember one day Edwina and some of her gang surrounded me after school and she basically told me that nobody liked me and everyone was upset that the other girl died and not me. Awful stuff to try and get your head around at 15. It was constant and draining snd, in hindsight, I’m just glad it all happened before social media and mobile phones so at least I could go home and get a break from it.

I finished school, moved to a city 400 miles away and haven’t thought of her since.

I googled Edwina Craig to see her LinkedIn profile picture and found one, but I can’t make out if it’s her or not- I haven’t seen her in over 20 years. I think it is. The location also makes sense.

So, if you were me and it is her, how would you play it? Ultimately, if they have the best product for the best price, we’ll go with them, but I don’t want it to be a walk in the park for her if she really is who I think she is.

I don’t think she’ll know I’m me, if you get me. My name isn’t uncommon and I’m based on a different city than where we grew up so I don’t think she’d make the link.

OP posts:
AmandaHoldensLips · 12/10/2021 13:53

I'd love to be in your position... "Oh wow! I know who you are! We went to school together, remember? Have you managed to become a better person or are you still a vile bully who picks on vulnerable people?"

(don't care if I get sacked - totally worth it)

SleepingStandingUp · 12/10/2021 13:51

@PitchImperfect

I'd call someone higher up in her company & explain the situation. Tell them you're the one making the decision & you wouldn't want their bid to be unfairly influenced by her past behaviour & that could happen whether you deal with her or if someone else were to do it because you wouldn't have given each competitor the same opportunity to impress you personally.

It might be a bit passive aggressive to highlight her previous bullying to her company but it'd be my compromise - what I'd really want to do is string her along with no intention of giving it to her!

You're honestly suggesting calling her boss and telling them she was horrid when she was 15 so your business isn't working with their business??
minipie · 12/10/2021 13:48

I think I’d go with Haffdonga’s approach

I am amazed how many on this thread seem to think it’s possible to forgive and forget intensive bullying or think “oh well she may have changed”. I couldn’t. I genuinely couldn’t work with someone who’d done that to me, however long ago it was.

whosaidtha · 12/10/2021 13:44

I can not believe some of these responses. You can't not go with a company because one employee was a bully 20+ years ago. And making her squirm/waste time and energy wouldn't paint you as much better and you're a grown adult.

PitchImperfect · 12/10/2021 13:43

I'd call someone higher up in her company & explain the situation. Tell them you're the one making the decision & you wouldn't want their bid to be unfairly influenced by her past behaviour & that could happen whether you deal with her or if someone else were to do it because you wouldn't have given each competitor the same opportunity to impress you personally.

It might be a bit passive aggressive to highlight her previous bullying to her company but it'd be my compromise - what I'd really want to do is string her along with no intention of giving it to her!

AramintaLee · 12/10/2021 13:42

If it's been over 20 years... do you not think she might have changed? Perhaps she's mortified and embarrassed by her behaviour when you were younger?

Either way, take the higher road and be professional. The best revenge is how successful you are now. You don't need to do anything else.

ChorizoJacketPotato · 12/10/2021 13:42

Well I think we all did things when younger we aren’t proud of, and she herself may not remember what a vile cow she was.

But I do think you should fake enthusiasm and say ‘oh wow! I know you and your name - did you go to x school?’ And if she confirms, say ‘oh yes. I definitely remember you’. Hopefully she will become flustered. Maybe you’ll even get a better deal.

SilentPanic · 12/10/2021 13:42

This is horrible and I understand how you feel, but happy children don't bully. She might have had absolutely horrible things going on that you know nothing about. That's no excuse for the way she treated you, but just remember how young she was.

JassyRadlett · 12/10/2021 13:42

Ultimately she's a vile piece of work, and it doesn't reflect well on the company that they'd hire her. Presumably your business has a policy on ethics and bullying? If so, you can't use them - even if on paper they're the best option.

For something that happened over twenty years ago when the person in question was a minor? That’s a ludicrous statement.

titchy · 12/10/2021 13:41

And remember she needs you more than you need her at the moment. So if she does recognise you - smile! "Hello Janice I wondered whether it was really you. How are you these days?" The power dynamic is in your favour, as is the fact that it's Zoom and not face to face.

Haffdonga · 12/10/2021 13:41

I'd go to the presentation and ask searching questions (as you would anyway) without appearing to recognise her. If her company looks likely to win the bid then disclose to your team that you have a personal connection with her and that you would find it difficult to work with her. Step back from the decision process and if her company wins anyway then make it clear you won't deal with her but her manager.

They'll be quite happy to ditch her if it will help them win a big contract

Hairwizard · 12/10/2021 13:41

I would have to ask if she went to such and such school at whatever time frame and make sure she knew who i was without actually mentioning the shit time she gave me all in a very nice 'jees such a small world' kind of way and then carry on with call while secretly hoping shes sweating like fuck thinking shes blown it.

JaneW70 · 12/10/2021 13:41

Work is not personal. As traumatic as your bullying was if you can't detach from your school life 20 years ago, you need to seek help.

girlmom21 · 12/10/2021 13:39

I would be completely professional and disregard the child that she was 20 years ago, personally...

Unless she recognises you and tries to act like you were friends. Then I'd make it very clear you're happy to be civil on a work level and don't want to discuss anything other than this project.

AChickenCalledDaal · 12/10/2021 13:38

If at all possible get someone else to handle the meeting. Quite apart from how you would feel, you are not in a position to run a transparent and fair procurement process.

I disagree that your organisation's bullying policy is relevant. Not many of us would be happy about our behaviour as a teenager being used to deny us millions of pounds worth of business now.

titchy · 12/10/2021 13:38

Presumably your business has a policy on ethics and bullying? If so, you can't use them - even if on paper they're the best option.

Seriously?! "Hi Chief exec. Yeah Acme we're by far the cheapest and best product but the sales person was a bit of a bully as a school child so I decided not to appoint" Hmm

Deep breath, put your shared childhood out of your mind, stick a pin in a doll under the desk if you have to. But you're a professional. Childhood events (whether yours or someone else's) must NOT enter into your professional dealings with others.

roses2 · 12/10/2021 13:37

@CrumpleHornedSnowcack

I would outright ask her if she went to blabla school & if she says yes tell her you remember her with a stern look on your face
I would do this plus make it as difficult and drawn out as possible. But then I'm a really petty person.
whosaidtha · 12/10/2021 13:37

Im sorry she was so horrible to you. Being bullied is awful.
But I'm of the mind that people change a lot. It's been 17years since I was 15 and I'm a completely different person (I was never a bully though) and I'd hate people to judge me for who I was.
You have to take the high road. Treat her as if you don't know her. Hope she doesn't say anything. Anything less would be unprofessional and likely lead to a complaint that you unfairly didn't give her the work due to past grudges.
Good luck.

SleepingStandingUp · 12/10/2021 13:37

How old were you / are you?

If you can't be professional then be upfront with work and get out of it. If she twigs who you are, deflect/deny and refocus back on work.

As for it doesn't reflect well on the company that they'd hire her, what?? It doesn't reflectg well in a company that they don't know someone they possibly hired in their 30s or 40s was a little shit several decades ago?? Do you give childhood scho references to every job you go to @HarrietsChariot?

steponthetightrope · 12/10/2021 13:36

Make her squirm, and enjoy it, then bin her!

Noeuf · 12/10/2021 13:36

Get someone else to do it if you can’t put a 20+ year old grudge aside. Same advice if you are traumatised but your ‘walk in the park’ comment suggests not. Spite has no place at work.

Northernsoullover · 12/10/2021 13:35

Surely it's a conflict of interest? You need to establish if its the same person and go from there.

10yearwarranty · 12/10/2021 13:35

@HarrietsChariot

I'd play along, make sure she wastes as much time and energy on the demo and presentation as possible. Even if they're the best deal do everything in your power not to go with them. But string them along for as long as you can.

Ultimately she's a vile piece of work, and it doesn't reflect well on the company that they'd hire her. Presumably your business has a policy on ethics and bullying? If so, you can't use them - even if on paper they're the best option.

They aren't hiring her, they are taking presentations from companies who can offer them a software solution. No, you really can't decide the outcome of a tendering process based on allegations of bullying by one of their employees while they were at school. Op - let your manager know about this, leave them to decide if they want you to be part of the process or not. I'm assuming that you won't be the sole decision maker.
Hoppinggreen · 12/10/2021 13:33

@HarrietsChariot

I'd play along, make sure she wastes as much time and energy on the demo and presentation as possible. Even if they're the best deal do everything in your power not to go with them. But string them along for as long as you can.

Ultimately she's a vile piece of work, and it doesn't reflect well on the company that they'd hire her. Presumably your business has a policy on ethics and bullying? If so, you can't use them - even if on paper they're the best option.

I was bullied at school as was DD more recently and while I would like to see them all rot in hell (bollocks to forgiveness etc) how would the company know this person used to bully OP? I doubt it was on her CV If I were you OP I might even enjoy it, I wouldn’t let in I knew her but I would give her a really hard time over her pitch and ask lots of very difficult questions. IF the solution is the best for your company go for it but don’t make any of it easy for her
nc87651 · 12/10/2021 13:33

Honestly, I'd move past it. This must have happened what, 20+ years ago? I'd assume the bully had done some growing up by then. And god knows what her home life must have been like as a teen to be such a nasty person.

Let it go. Be an adult. Treat this meeting as any other.