Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shit. I think I have a zoom meeting with my childhood bully.

608 replies

TheRealAnnabelleBronstein · 12/10/2021 13:21

I’m not in the UK so hope this won’t be outing. Have changed details for privacy.

Imagine my name is Eleanor Smyth but I changed my name when I married and am now Eleanor Johnson. Imagine also that I’m the Head of Finance for a huge organization.

A company who sells financial services software has been contacting me for quite a while now asking for me to meet with them for a product demonstration. We’re now in a position where we’re going to stop using our existing product so doing demos with several organizations. The successful company will also be given a piece of work to prepare our related systems for integration and testing and training so there’s a project element as well as a product. The budget for the project is roughly $15m and then the product will be roughly $2m/year so it’s a big piece of work.

The Relationship Manager let me know that the call would be led by one of their sales people who he referred to as (name changed), Edwina Craig. All good and a zoom meeting was arranged.

I’ve just looked at the Zoom invite and can see that Edwina Craig is actually on there as Edwina Craig-Dyson.

Edwina Dyson was the school bully. Thoroughly unpleasant person who made my time at second level very difficult. She was so insidious. She wouldn’t physically bully but it was constant picking and awful comments. When I was in school, a classmate killed herself. I remember one day Edwina and some of her gang surrounded me after school and she basically told me that nobody liked me and everyone was upset that the other girl died and not me. Awful stuff to try and get your head around at 15. It was constant and draining snd, in hindsight, I’m just glad it all happened before social media and mobile phones so at least I could go home and get a break from it.

I finished school, moved to a city 400 miles away and haven’t thought of her since.

I googled Edwina Craig to see her LinkedIn profile picture and found one, but I can’t make out if it’s her or not- I haven’t seen her in over 20 years. I think it is. The location also makes sense.

So, if you were me and it is her, how would you play it? Ultimately, if they have the best product for the best price, we’ll go with them, but I don’t want it to be a walk in the park for her if she really is who I think she is.

I don’t think she’ll know I’m me, if you get me. My name isn’t uncommon and I’m based on a different city than where we grew up so I don’t think she’d make the link.

OP posts:
10yearwarranty · 12/10/2021 15:21

How do you get to head of finance for a huge organisation and not know how to deal with this?

10yearwarranty · 12/10/2021 15:20

Some of the replies on here are really funny. Grin

KingsleyShacklebolt · 12/10/2021 15:19

Completely agree, @JesusIsAnyNameFree. Some of the responses are just batshit crazy. The sort of thing that you'd expect to see in some really shitty "Real Housewives" style tv show, or created as drama in Eastenders or similar. Or on a made up MN thread which finishes "and then everyone stood up and applauded".

Totally unprofessional.

Hardbackwriter · 12/10/2021 15:18

God, this thread is a great example of why never to ask questions about work on MN, especially during the standard working day. About 70% of people commenting seem to have never actually had a job.

anon12345678901 · 12/10/2021 15:18

Some people on here have not grown up since high school. It's a job, not a social setting. You act professional.
And yes, I was bullied relentlessly for years.

SofiaMichelle · 12/10/2021 15:18

@PrivateHall

I think some of the posters replying perhaps haven't been severely bullied before. The priority here is to protect yourself. I was in a very similar position recently and confided in a colleague, who discreetly ensured I never had to set eyes on her. I didn't think it was necessary at the time, but after, when I heard how difficult and unpleasant she had been with my colleagues, I was incredibly relieved that I didn't have to face her again. Scars from bullying run deep, I think you should be led by whether you want to be face to face with her (even on Zoom!). It really isn't nice having those traumatic memories dredged up and anyone who dismisses it just because it was 20 years ago has clearly never experienced anything as bad as you did.
Absolutely this.

I'm actually quite appalled reading some of these dismissive posts, saying things like "people change...", "it's a long time ago..."

Do some of you not realise that some people carry the mental scars childhood bullying throughout most of their lives?

Actually, you'll probably reply with something about how she needs counselling or some other flippant, off-the-cuff dismissal of her feelings.

OP is under zero obligation to forgive and forget and has every right to handle this however she likes, and if that's to take advantage of her position of power over this bully then great.

butterpuffed · 12/10/2021 15:18

@FallingStar21

I'd go on the call if other people (especially from her company) are also present, then verify if it's her through a few innocuous questions. If it is indeed her, I'd say "oh yes, I know you. You used to do/say x (insert horrible thing she's done or said). You were a vile bully back then". And wait for her to respond / wish the ground to swallow her in embarrassment in front of you and the other attendants Grin Afterwards just politely and professionally watch the demo.
Everyone on the zoom call would think OP was crazy Shock
RobinPenguins · 12/10/2021 15:17

@HarrietsChariot

I'd play along, make sure she wastes as much time and energy on the demo and presentation as possible. Even if they're the best deal do everything in your power not to go with them. But string them along for as long as you can.

Ultimately she's a vile piece of work, and it doesn't reflect well on the company that they'd hire her. Presumably your business has a policy on ethics and bullying? If so, you can't use them - even if on paper they're the best option.

You really think someone’s behaviour as a teenager decades ago reflects badly on a company that employs them at, presumably, at least 20 years down the line? To do what you suggest would be really unprofessional and paint the OP’s company in a bad light - suppliers talk to each other too and companies can get a reputation as someone they don’t want to provide services to.

I wasn’t a bully but I was an annoying little shitbag at 15. It has zero bearing on my performance in my job now, or my organisation’s decision making for hiring me.

Wisteriac43 · 12/10/2021 15:15

I had the chance recently to make someone feel VERY awkward (similiarish situation to the above) and I'm really pleased that I didnt. Try and see that she was a very damaged child. I know friends whose parent actively encouraged them to bully ('oh Sandy you are so witty') only realising as adults that it was nasty and not funny

You also have no idea what is going on in this woman's life - you could be kicking her when she is down

MrsRobbieHart · 12/10/2021 15:15

@Morgan12

Fuck being professional. If this were me and my bully I'd be milking every single second and loving it.

And if I did go forward with her company I'd make sure she wasn't on the team. And I'd give her a big fucking smile right in her ugly bitch face.

This is OPs job. You know, how she pays her bills and her retirement in years to come? Are you fresh out of school?
RobinPenguins · 12/10/2021 15:14

@Quartz2208

Yes I think recuse yourself or play it completely as if she isnt that person.

Anything else puts YOU at risk for being unprofessional

Absolutely this. Massively unprofessional to let teenage behaviour influence a procurement decision.
Waternoice · 12/10/2021 15:11

@nc87651

Honestly, I'd move past it. This must have happened what, 20+ years ago? I'd assume the bully had done some growing up by then. And god knows what her home life must have been like as a teen to be such a nasty person.

Let it go. Be an adult. Treat this meeting as any other.

This, in spades, and besides you may be wrong and even if you are right, she may move off to pastures new or you may never actually deal with her again after the sales pitch.
MrsRobbieHart · 12/10/2021 15:11

@chocolateorangeinhaler

You own the situation like a boss from the off is what you do.

So you come on all smiles and "Oh hey Edwina is that you? It's been 20 years now. Oh you don't recall me? I recall you. Let me tell everyone. Everyone, Edwina used to bully me relentlessly at school and was the school bully. But it's good to see she's moved on and managed to grow. How exciting that you want to pitch something to me. So come Edwina. Would be great to see if I feel we could work with you if it's the right fit".

She will feel awful if it was her and still have to do a presentation and hope you like it.

Revenge is a dish most definitely best served cold...very cold.

😂

You’ve never worked in a professional environment, have you?

MsTSwift · 12/10/2021 15:10

Chocolate have you ever worked in an office in a senior professional role? That seems like a scene from one of those cringey Christmas films I watch with my teens. Everyone would think you were utterly mental if you came out with that.

Iris2020 · 12/10/2021 15:07

@Justajot

If you're that senior, can you ask if she's who you think she is and then ask for a different sales person for your call. They won't want to lose the sale, so will probably swap her out.
Yes absolutely. I think that's the way to go.
FreshFreesias · 12/10/2021 15:07

If it is her I wouldn’t want to work with her. I don’t think bullies change much and they certainly shouldn’t be rewarded.

saraclara · 12/10/2021 15:07

@FallingStar21

I'd go on the call if other people (especially from her company) are also present, then verify if it's her through a few innocuous questions. If it is indeed her, I'd say "oh yes, I know you. You used to do/say x (insert horrible thing she's done or said). You were a vile bully back then". And wait for her to respond / wish the ground to swallow her in embarrassment in front of you and the other attendants Grin Afterwards just politely and professionally watch the demo.
Posts like this have me shaking my head in disbelief.
Morgan12 · 12/10/2021 15:06

Fuck being professional. If this were me and my bully I'd be milking every single second and loving it.

And if I did go forward with her company I'd make sure she wasn't on the team. And I'd give her a big fucking smile right in her ugly bitch face.

lurkingfromhome · 12/10/2021 15:06

@chocolateorangeinhaler

You own the situation like a boss from the off is what you do.

So you come on all smiles and "Oh hey Edwina is that you? It's been 20 years now. Oh you don't recall me? I recall you. Let me tell everyone. Everyone, Edwina used to bully me relentlessly at school and was the school bully. But it's good to see she's moved on and managed to grow. How exciting that you want to pitch something to me. So come Edwina. Would be great to see if I feel we could work with you if it's the right fit".

She will feel awful if it was her and still have to do a presentation and hope you like it.

Revenge is a dish most definitely best served cold...very cold.

Jesus. I'm actually dying inside reading that. The OP is CFO of an organization with a multimillion dollar budget for this software product and you honestly think she should do THIS?

This isn't a squabble between Shaz and Trace who've got a Saturday job down the fruit & veg shop.

FreedomFaith · 12/10/2021 15:03

@minipie

I think I’d go with Haffdonga’s approach

I am amazed how many on this thread seem to think it’s possible to forgive and forget intensive bullying or think “oh well she may have changed”. I couldn’t. I genuinely couldn’t work with someone who’d done that to me, however long ago it was.

Yes it's amazing how many just think a teenager close to being classed as an adult is ok to bully another student and tell them to kill themselves. That's totally normal and ok according to the adults on here. Dread to think what they were like in school and what their kids are like. Hmm

If it was my decision and my company would back me up, I would tell the other company that I will not work with them while she is on the project.

There's making mistakes as a teenager, and there's showing what a nasty person you are. I don't remember anyone in my school ever saying to someone to go kill themselves, and that includes the bullies. Kids make mistakes, but no matter what background you come from, nothing excuses that.

FallingStar21 · 12/10/2021 15:02

I'd go on the call if other people (especially from her company) are also present, then verify if it's her through a few innocuous questions. If it is indeed her, I'd say "oh yes, I know you. You used to do/say x (insert horrible thing she's done or said). You were a vile bully back then". And wait for her to respond / wish the ground to swallow her in embarrassment in front of you and the other attendants Grin Afterwards just politely and professionally watch the demo.

Pantsomime · 12/10/2021 15:01

OP it’s a 2 stage process - first you must find out if it is her before the meeting, if it’s not great. If it really is you have to declare a conflict of interest and either excuse yourself which may be hard given your role, or get her substituted. Can you imagine if her firm got the contract, the losers could, if they found out about the connection, say it was down to nepotism - went to school together will quickly translate to favouritism and jobs for your old pals ( which couldn’t be more wrong in this instant). Irrespective of your personal trauma which is at the fore here, professionally it’s not a good idea for you, your company or any of the bidders

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 12/10/2021 15:01

@chocolateorangeinhaler

You own the situation like a boss from the off is what you do.

So you come on all smiles and "Oh hey Edwina is that you? It's been 20 years now. Oh you don't recall me? I recall you. Let me tell everyone. Everyone, Edwina used to bully me relentlessly at school and was the school bully. But it's good to see she's moved on and managed to grow. How exciting that you want to pitch something to me. So come Edwina. Would be great to see if I feel we could work with you if it's the right fit".

She will feel awful if it was her and still have to do a presentation and hope you like it.

Revenge is a dish most definitely best served cold...very cold.

Do you realise how fucking unprofessional this would be?

Honestly, a vast majority of these responses make me think people don't know anything about these sort of settings. You may be able to get away with these childish behaviours when working in a shop or a salon but it certainly isn't acceptable in a job like OPs. She won't be cheered on and told how brave and amazing she is. She will make everyone else feel really uncomfortable, she will be talked about and not in a good way and good luck ever getting another job, because this shit spreads like wildfire. No one needs someone who can't keep their personal life away from work in high level positions. It's the exact opposite of what anyone wants.

PartyStory · 12/10/2021 15:01

Anyone who tells you to rise above it and be the bigger person had obviously never been badly bullied

I gave this advice and I have been bullied. I have actually played out some petty revenge fantasies on people who bullied me but I was surprised to find that after the initial rush, it didn’t make me feel better, only worse. It meant the bullies preoccupied my time that I could have spent doing more valuable things and it felt petty, even if it was “an eye for an eye”. I also feel uncomfortable knowing that someone else might find out how I handled the situations.

When a similar situation presented itself again, I wrote a long unsent letter that I then deleted and felt a whole lot better for it. I now feel proud that I was able to mentally distance myself from that person.

Etinoxaurus · 12/10/2021 14:59

@ftw163532

but I don’t want it to be a walk in the park for her if she really is who I think she is.

I'm sorry you had a difficult time but that would be both immoral and unprofessional.

Ah bollocks! She deserves to be strung along. Play it cool op, don’t go all Julia Roberts, ‘big mistake’. Also be prepared for her to recognise you and don’t panic. You did nothing wrong. “I remember you very clearly”
Swipe left for the next trending thread