Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to be involved in my birthday plans?

34 replies

HereIAm0 · 12/10/2021 10:49

My 30th birthday is a couple of months away and my family have asked me a few times what I want to do. I've always replied that I don't really know, will have a think, but I don't want a party or any big surprises.

I became aware a couple of days ago there there is a group chat happening between my Husband, Mum and a couple of friends, discussing my 30th. (I saw it pop up on his phone, I'm not supposed to know). Straight away I panicked as I was worried what they were planning/discussing. Probably daft to react that way, but I did.

Last night I started talking about my birthday with my husband and suggested a couple of places we could go. He seemed uninterested in the conversation so I kept going, until he eventually said 'Your 30th is being sorted so just leave it'. I asked what he meant and said I have already told him/others that I don't want surprises so if something is being organised I want to be involved.

He got quite annoyed by this and said he wanted to plan it but fine he'd leave it all to me, it will take the nice surprise out of it but fine carry on, and said I was miserable.

I know my friends and family are only trying to make it special, but it's not what I want. AIBU or should they understand?

Thanks in advance.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Time2Move · 13/10/2021 06:56

Make a plan of your own asap (I suggest spa day and posh lunch. Or horse riding. Or speedboat on Thames. Or Goape then pub.) Communicate this plan to everyone. If they’ve made alternative plans they can quietly cancel it, this is not your problem.
This. I'm astonished by the number of people saying OP is being unreasonable.

Ednadidit · 13/10/2021 06:27

I was secretly pleased that covid meant that no-one could make me do anything for my 30th last year. My mum always made such a fuss of birthdays. Now she can never make a fuss of me again because she suddenly died. You never know when your last celebration is coming.

I’m somewhere in between YABU and NBU, because although it’s not exactly what you want, they’re doing it because they love you and want to surprise you 🤷🏻‍♀️ I wish I could have my time again.

Skysblue · 12/10/2021 21:41

Yanbu OP. You said you wanted to have a think about what to do, and then you had a think.

Meanwhile they started planning a surprise party, which is very specifically the one thing you said you did NOT want. They’re being selfish and not listening.

Make a plan of your own asap (I suggest spa day and posh lunch. Or horse riding. Or speedboat on Thames. Or Goape then pub.) Communicate this plan to everyone. If they’ve made alternative plans they can quietly cancel it, this is not your problem.

ProudMaiasaura · 12/10/2021 18:17

YABU a little bit. You've clearly articulated what you don't want so trust that your husband understands that and whilst it might be a 'surprise' as in you don't know what's planned - it doesn't necessarily mean it's a "Surprise!" with a reaction expected.

My husband got really arsey with me about his 40th birthday because I'd planned a 'surprise' knowing exactly what would make him happy.

It was never going to be an on the day thing, I just wanted to wait until pretty close to his birthday before outlining all the plans so he could prepare and get excited. But he decided to act like a complete brat, throwing his toys out of the pram and complaining/making passive aggressive digs so I ended up flinging part one of his birthday gift in his face and asked if it was such a terrible surprise (tickets to see Liverpool vs Manchester City in a league game...virtually had to sell a limb to get them!)

He was absolutely gutted that he'd ruined my plans. He admitted that the gift was perfect no shit sherlock and that being told a few days before as I planned would have been much nicer. I asked if he wanted to know all the other plans I'd made, but oddly enough he decided that I really did want him to have a memorable and wonderful 40th so trusted my judgement on what part two would look like it was awesome

You're basically making it crystal clear that you don't care what your husband and family might have planned because you aren't involved in the planning. A gift can't be dictated, it's given freely or it's not a gift.

Anordinarymum · 12/10/2021 17:57

@HereIAm0

My 30th birthday is a couple of months away and my family have asked me a few times what I want to do. I've always replied that I don't really know, will have a think, but I don't want a party or any big surprises.

I became aware a couple of days ago there there is a group chat happening between my Husband, Mum and a couple of friends, discussing my 30th. (I saw it pop up on his phone, I'm not supposed to know). Straight away I panicked as I was worried what they were planning/discussing. Probably daft to react that way, but I did.

Last night I started talking about my birthday with my husband and suggested a couple of places we could go. He seemed uninterested in the conversation so I kept going, until he eventually said 'Your 30th is being sorted so just leave it'. I asked what he meant and said I have already told him/others that I don't want surprises so if something is being organised I want to be involved.

He got quite annoyed by this and said he wanted to plan it but fine he'd leave it all to me, it will take the nice surprise out of it but fine carry on, and said I was miserable.

I know my friends and family are only trying to make it special, but it's not what I want. AIBU or should they understand?

Thanks in advance.

With respect. You are behaving like a spoilt child.

All you need to know really is what to wear !

HereIAm0 · 12/10/2021 17:56

@aSofaNearYou - I thought I’d made it clear, but perhaps I didn’t and like you say they might be taking the whole ‘no surprises’ to mean yeah but everyone says that….but my husband knows I’m a control freak so perhaps he should know better Grin

My 21st was pretty awful which my family planned, they tried their best but a mixture of snow/restaurant cancellations etc meant it was crap. I also hated not knowing where we were going, what we were doing. So I think all of that mixed together makes me nervous about any surprises.

OP posts:
HereIAm0 · 12/10/2021 17:54

@Fraine I 100% do want to plan it myself. When initial conversations were happening it was very much my family asking ‘what are we doing’ not ‘what are we planning’ so when I said I don’t know I’ll think, but no surprises I thought that would be enough for them to know that meant no surprises.

OP posts:
vincettenoir · 12/10/2021 17:42

If you don’t like surprises, you don’t like them. My dh is the same - he hates them.

However from the sounds of it, something is well underway in the planning. You have missed the boat in taking charge of it yourself.

I think a compromise on both sides is achievable here. I don’t think you can reasonably expect your dp to reveal all or aim to steer the way things are heading now. But perhaps you can ask your dp or a family member to give you notice of what is going on a couple of days in advance. It’s very possible they have factored this into the planning anyway, as you don’t like surprises.

Fraine · 12/10/2021 17:14

She wants to! She asked for time to do so and has had the rug pulled from under her feet.

I don't think she does, as she says she has made suggestions. She hasn't said she wants to organise it.

aSofaNearYou · 12/10/2021 17:14

I think it depends on how much of an established thing you not liking surprises is, and how you expressed it. The way you've written it here just sounds like a bashful, nonchalant "oh I don't need a big fuss", which tbh I don't think would be an unreasonable thing to not take that seriously. It would be different if you are the sort of person who hates surprises and they know that.

But ultimately, it does sound like they are just trying to do something nice for you. Is there a reason you don't feel you can just sit back and enjoy it?

DappledThings · 12/10/2021 17:13

@Fraine

Just organise it yourself then. You can't have your birthday cake and eat it too!
She wants to! She asked for time to do so and has had the rug pulled from under her feet.
Member984815 · 12/10/2021 17:13

I hate surprises, other people's idea of a nice surprise could be your idea of hell.

Fraine · 12/10/2021 17:11

Just organise it yourself then. You can't have your birthday cake and eat it too!

SoniaFouler · 12/10/2021 17:09

@DroopyClematis

I agree *@mumofmunchkin*

For my last three big birthdays I didn't want any fuss, certainly not a surprise party. My husband knew this and wouldn't have dreamed of organising one.

I never knew what I wanted to do but eventually came up with modest suggestions eg a weekend away, a fabulous restaurant etc...

The way I see it is 'my birthday, my choice.'

Planning surprise dos are , generally, for the organisers benefit. If the recipient does not want a fuss then family and friends should leave it be.

Yes but if she wants even just a “fabulous restaurant” on her birthday, which is in the month of December, and also when we are moving out from a lockdown so places are not accommodating as many patrons but are more, or as still as popular than ever, AND considering it will be Christmas so places will be fully booked soon, if not already two months beforehand, then it does have to be booked and planned now.
HereIAm0 · 12/10/2021 17:07

Thanks all for your opinions.

I don’t want to be ungrateful but it does feel they’ve done the opposite of what I asked them to do.

@mumofmunchkin think you’ve hit the nail on the head, I’m supposed to be having a think about what I want to do (struggling for ideas won’t lie) and they’ve gone ahead and started discussing/planning it anyway.

OP posts:
MilduraS · 12/10/2021 17:03

I hate surprise parties so I'd be annoyed. Thankfully my husband has the good sense not to plan anything. I think yours is being a dick trying to force you to enjoy something just because it's what he wants to do.

DroopyClematis · 12/10/2021 17:00

I agree @mumofmunchkin

For my last three big birthdays I didn't want any fuss, certainly not a surprise party. My husband knew this and wouldn't have dreamed of organising one.

I never knew what I wanted to do but eventually came up with modest suggestions eg a weekend away, a fabulous restaurant etc...

The way I see it is 'my birthday, my choice.'

Planning surprise dos are , generally, for the organisers benefit. If the recipient does not want a fuss then family and friends should leave it be.

mumofmunchkin · 12/10/2021 16:38

@ChimChimeny

Apathetic person who can't give any suggestions for their birthday when asked

Maybe the OP doesn't have suggestions because she doesn't want to do anything?!

But the OP has now suggested a couple of options and been told tough shit we're doing what we want now

This, the OP said she would have a think, not that she didn't want to do anything, but please don't plan a surprise.

Then when she comes up with some ideas she's dismissed, and it's clear they're organising a surprise. If you know someone doesn't want a surprise, the thing to do would be to say, x, y and I have come up with this fab idea for your birthday, are you happy if we go ahead and organise it?

Not everyone likes surprises. A surprise party means you don't get any of the fun anticipation, and build up, it's just thrown on you all at once.

ChimChimeny · 12/10/2021 16:32

Apathetic person who can't give any suggestions for their birthday when asked

Maybe the OP doesn't have suggestions because she doesn't want to do anything?!

But the OP has now suggested a couple of options and been told tough shit we're doing what we want now

SoniaFouler · 12/10/2021 16:28

@DecadentlyDecisive

Apathetic person who can't give any suggestions for their birthday when asked gets narky when someone else arranges something....

And narky when they don't even know what it is!!

Come back after the event & moan by all means, but at the moment - given that you have no idea what is going on - YABU

Exactly, can’t believe any one is supportive of the OP, she would probably be fuming if it came to her birthday and nothing was done on it
DecadentlyDecisive · 12/10/2021 12:20

Apathetic person who can't give any suggestions for their birthday when asked gets narky when someone else arranges something....

And narky when they don't even know what it is!!

Come back after the event & moan by all means, but at the moment - given that you have no idea what is going on - YABU

BubblinTrouble · 12/10/2021 12:12

I don’t think you are being unreasonable. You’ve said you don’t want a surprise and want to be involved in the plans. He should listen to that I think.

Toodlydoo · 12/10/2021 11:54

I don’t know, I would have been quite happy. I ended up in fucking starbucks for my birthday. Let it go, they love you and are trying to do something nice for you. If it bothers you just put a stop to it and plan your own birthday how you like it.

Sorry probably a bit grouchy because my own was a monumental let down.

billy1966 · 12/10/2021 11:47

"He got quite annoyed by this and said he wanted to plan it but fine he'd leave it all to me, it will take the nice surprise out of it but fine carry on, and said I was MISERABLE."

He doesn't sound very nice to be calling her MISERABLE just because she has said she doesn't want surprises.

He doesn't sound very nice to get annoyed with her for dismissing what she has said she DOESN'T want to happen on HER birthday.

SoniaFouler · 12/10/2021 11:23

@billy1966

He doesn't sound very nice.

I am not a surprise party person either, though I have been to a few.

Most people don't like them in my experience.

Perhaps speak to your mother.

But speak up for sure.

The whole big celebration for birthdays has past me by a bit.

I like low key celebrations.

“He doesn’t sound very nice”

Only on MN could you find someone calling a husband involved in organising a party for his wife as not sounding very nice Hmm