Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel sad DH expects me to be happy about this?

319 replies

stepmoa · 11/10/2021 20:44

After not meeting DSD's maternal family in all the time that I've known her (6+ years), largely driven by her grandparents refusing to accept that DH moved on after her DM (their DD) died when she was a young child, some relatives have now decided they want to meet me. They've asked to come to our house and DH has arranged the first date we are all free.

For context, DSD and I have a great relationship now and I treat her like my own DD but in the early years it was complicated as she couldn't understand why her other family and I were entirely separate. It's only as she has got older age has she realised that it was their choice and she and I now have a strong bond.

DH doesn't understand why I'm upset that after being shut out for years I am not only expected to have to meet them but to host as well. I will do it for DSD but it is not the start of a great relationship when it's taken so long and he is defending them about it. I feel they've let DSD down as this could have happened years ago and saved the poor girl a lot of sadness.

YANBU - it's reasonable that you are upset and DH should be more sensitive to this
YABU - they've done nothing wrong and are within their rights to invite themselves

OP posts:
MelKarnofskyCrane · 11/10/2021 22:24

There’s a lot of expectation to be perfect on here, I think. To react to everything perfectly. To always say and do the correct thing.

No, your husband perhaps hasn’t handled things well. But being widowed with a young child is difficult and messy and who always gets it right?

No, emails from you probably weren’t particularly appropriate with hindsight. But you were feeling your way through a difficult situation and I imagine did what you thought was best at the time.

The family have treated you badly. Probably down to their grief at the time, and then the longer these things go on, the harder it is to reverse them. Too much pride, too much water under the bridge. They didn’t get it right.

But maybe it’s time for everyone to show a little humanity and forgiveness.

eeek88 · 11/10/2021 22:24

Everyone is sad and they have every right to be. It’s a sad situation. You now have to decide whether to make the situation a bit better or a bit worse.

I think in your situation I’d be most nervous about what you’re all going to talk about and do, so I might suggest something centred around your SD that distracts you all and gives you a neutral focal point for the first meeting, eg museum or park or an activity of some kind. I can understand your reluctance to host because they might judge you/your house, but also it might be awkward. I can’t really sympathise with your undertones of ‘they didn’t make me feel welcome so why should I make them feel welcome’, due to the exceptional circumstances.

Why2why · 11/10/2021 22:23

Why must the simplest things become a battle? Making compromises in situations like this isn’t a bad idea. It seems you want to create a drama where there really is no need for one.

Redjumper1 · 11/10/2021 22:23

Losing a child must be the most painful experience anyone can ever experience. I can't even imagine it. It must be excruciating.

I would suggest neutral ground for the first meeting. It will be difficult for everyone.

BoredZelda · 11/10/2021 22:21

I’m not sure you’re being fair, they lost a child and struggled to see her replaced in their eyes

I’m sure OP is well aware of the issues given she will have been living with the shadow of a mother/wife who has died. After all this time she will be well versed in treading that fine line.

I don’t understand your desire to be punitive snd make it worse for your step daughter,

Where has she even hinted she will do that?

Thatsplentyjack · 11/10/2021 22:20

@Fraine

But if she didn’t invite them she’d be accused of keeping them away from their dgd. Step-mothers can’t win.
Hmm not true, she just didn't need to be the one doing the inviting. Stop projecting.
Loveshelly · 11/10/2021 22:19

Of course you have the right to chose how you spend your time. But if you take over from a dead woman. You must have some comprehension of how that makes others feel

Graphista · 11/10/2021 22:19

It's an incredibly difficult situation to be in.

My brothers 2nd wife is basically in your position the only difference being that brother and 1st wife were already divorced when she died.

Grief can hit people in odd ways. My late sil family when new sil came along also struggled and didn't feel able to meet her straight away.

When they did, I have to say they went out for a meal so they were on neutral ground? It also meant there was something of a time limit as you don't stay for hours in a restaurant after you've eaten as you might at home.

I think that did make it easier for everyone. Especially if you are living in the deceased mum's former home?

I think in your shoes I would say to dh that you think it would be easier for all concerned if a neutral spot for a meal were chosen.

I know they're an mn hated thing but possibly a "family" pub with a play area attached if dc are going to be there (do they have dc too? Is this because they've recently become parents themselves?)

That would allow for the odd moment at least for just the adults to talk or even that first meeting could be adult only an evening meal?

I think baby steps would be good here.

I'm afraid I do think that while I understand their raw grief at the beginning/early stages their behaviour since has been poor and not prioritising your dsds needs above their sensitivities.

Another relative of mine was "widowed" young (they weren't married living together) and her "in laws" behaved appallingly - they basically booted out of her family home and they never had contact with her or the dc after the father died awful situation!

People can be very strange at times

And I think you all (you, dh and dsd if she is involved/knows) need to be prepared for them potentially backing out again too

Dh doesn't seem to have put much thought into this at all has he?

Fraine · 11/10/2021 22:18

But if she didn’t invite them she’d be accused of keeping them away from their dgd. Step-mothers can’t win.

Thatsplentyjack · 11/10/2021 22:18

Fraine, no perfectly capable of reading thanks. Nowhere does it say that the child isn't bothered about seeing her grandparents anymore, and to say that's because now she has her "family unit" is awful.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/10/2021 22:18

I had a similar experience after losing my husband to cancer some years ago. It wasn’t his family who were the problem though, it was mostly mutual friends who took the view that I was being disrespectful when I met and started dating the man who is now my husband. After 6+ years, I don’t think their continuing resentment of you is entirely down to grief, especially if they’ve actively interfered when other family members have wanted to meet you, and without much consideration for your DSD’s feelings. Your DH is probably finding it difficult to navigate the issues and I can tell you from experience that ‘moving on’ inevitably involves a sense of guilt - even though you know it’s misplaced - and even now, their attitude may serve to reinforce this, so you need to understand his point of view. As others have suggested, maybe meeting somewhere neutral would be better at first. It will take the pressure off you if you don’t have to play the host, and can concentrate on getting to know them and maybe build bridges. You sound very caring and I’m sure with an open and honest conversation you can work it out between you.

Loveshelly · 11/10/2021 22:17

And your DH couldn’t find anyone other than you to hand over,
Honestly. I think you need to get a bit of a grip. And I think you’re DH is really unreasonable, he actually actively wished he saw his dead wife’s family less. I’m sure they felt that.
Just put your big girl pants on and be a better human. Stop thinking it’s about you.

Ozanj · 11/10/2021 22:17

The only thing you can do is suck it up and pretend to be ok for your SD. You have no idea how the GP have portrayed the situation to her and as she gets older and naturally starts wanting to know more about her mum, and that side of the family, she may well start blaming you if your behaviour isn’t encouraging.

Thatsplentyjack · 11/10/2021 22:16

They lost their daughter, they've had to live with the knowledge that someone else is doing all the things their daughter should have been doing with their granddaughter. I can only imagine how heartbreaking and difficult that would be for them.
You emailing them to invite them to things for their grandchild is ridiculous actually. That should have been down to her dad. It's not your place to invite them.

Fraine · 11/10/2021 22:15

@Thatsplentyjack

Because maybe dsd isn’t even bothered now? She has her family unit.

I think that might be one of the most callous things I've read on here.

Have you followed the exchange or are you just inferring your own incorrect interpretation?
stepmoa · 11/10/2021 22:14

@SuperCaliFragalistic it's about my feelings now because I have a right to choose how I want to spend my time. I don't know what it feels like to lose a child but I have sat and cuddled DSD when her weekend with her grandparents has been cancelled because they refuse to meet me in a service station car park when DH couldn't go. So yeah, I don't have much time for anyone who would do that to a child.

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 11/10/2021 22:13

Because maybe dsd isn’t even bothered now? She has her family unit.

I think that might be one of the most callous things I've read on here.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/10/2021 22:12

I also think meeting on neutral ground would be more sensible.

Yanbu to feel upset about the years that have gone by, but of course it must have been hard for them, having lost their own daughter.

Fraine · 11/10/2021 22:12

It’s never been about OP’s feelings though, has it?

Couchbettato · 11/10/2021 22:11

Yanbu. I think going out for something to eat where you can chat and relax and get to know each other would be better than in your home where you feel like you've got your back against the wall.

If you suggest this to DH what does he say?

SuperCaliFragalistic · 11/10/2021 22:11

@Bluntness100

I’m not sure you’re being fair, they lost a child and struggled to see her replaced in their eyes

I don’t understand your desire to be punitive snd make it worse for your step daughter,

These are my feelings about the situation. Why are you so emotional about this? These people lost their daughter/sibling and you have merrily stepped into her shoes expecting them to be fine with it. And now it's all about your feelings?
Fraine · 11/10/2021 22:10

[quote stepmoa]@callmeadoctor DH has backed away from the parents not the sibling, he hasn't seen much of the sibling as they've been busy doing their own thing for the last few years[/quote]
And as they’re settling down, they’ve decided that they’d quite like to be waited on and hand foot by you.

Feedingthebirds1 · 11/10/2021 22:09

@stepmoa

I've not met the grandparents, this is her aunt and uncle wanting to visit (who previously backed out a few years ago seemingly at the request of the grandparents)
Do you think that if/when they find out, the grandparents might put pressure on to back out again? I only ask because if there's a risk of that it might be better not to make too much of the visit in front of DSD.
stepmoa · 11/10/2021 22:09

@callmeadoctor DH has backed away from the parents not the sibling, he hasn't seen much of the sibling as they've been busy doing their own thing for the last few years

OP posts:
ABCeasyasdohrayme · 11/10/2021 22:09

I'm 23 years on from my sons death.

He was still little, so didn't have a child, but, even this far on from his death things still cut like a knife.

Even on my children's birthdays, however happy I am, there's always a pang of sadness because my son never made it to that age, when they pass exams, or start work or any other milestones I am so very proud, but it also reminds me exactly what I have lost.

I can absolutely imagine how difficult it would be to see someone else taking my sons place and raising his child. It wouldn't matter who that person was, it would still sting, it wouldn't be personal on any level, but when your child dies you have to go into self protection mode just to get through each day to begin with, slowly it moves to each week and month then it's when you know there will be something that can trigger you.

Sadly you being there is that trigger for them, but they are now trying, and it will have taken a lot for them.

Your feelings are absolutely valid here and you sound like you've been amazing in your dsds life, it would be really amazing if you could give them a chance.