Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel sad DH expects me to be happy about this?

319 replies

stepmoa · 11/10/2021 20:44

After not meeting DSD's maternal family in all the time that I've known her (6+ years), largely driven by her grandparents refusing to accept that DH moved on after her DM (their DD) died when she was a young child, some relatives have now decided they want to meet me. They've asked to come to our house and DH has arranged the first date we are all free.

For context, DSD and I have a great relationship now and I treat her like my own DD but in the early years it was complicated as she couldn't understand why her other family and I were entirely separate. It's only as she has got older age has she realised that it was their choice and she and I now have a strong bond.

DH doesn't understand why I'm upset that after being shut out for years I am not only expected to have to meet them but to host as well. I will do it for DSD but it is not the start of a great relationship when it's taken so long and he is defending them about it. I feel they've let DSD down as this could have happened years ago and saved the poor girl a lot of sadness.

YANBU - it's reasonable that you are upset and DH should be more sensitive to this
YABU - they've done nothing wrong and are within their rights to invite themselves

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 11/10/2021 22:46

*Have you every been in DSDs shoes?
I was.

People who were unkind to my stepmother, the woman who raised me, are not part of my life*

Have you ever lost a child and then had your grandchild kept from you because her dad like to keep contact to a minimum and if you did get to see her you were do meet at a service station to collect her?

Chickychoccyegg · 11/10/2021 22:45

I dont really understand why you're angry or upset?
I don't really get why you feel you need to have a relationship with dsd maternal grandparents? especially when they made it clear they weren't ready.
Grieving for your child is the worst pain imaginable, it'll be heart breaking for them to see you where they feel their dd should be.
Be kind,and welcoming, dsd loves you, and them,and wants you all to meet and get on

callmeadoctor · 11/10/2021 22:45

@MelKarnofskyCrane

There’s a lot of expectation to be perfect on here, I think. To react to everything perfectly. To always say and do the correct thing.

No, your husband perhaps hasn’t handled things well. But being widowed with a young child is difficult and messy and who always gets it right?

No, emails from you probably weren’t particularly appropriate with hindsight. But you were feeling your way through a difficult situation and I imagine did what you thought was best at the time.

The family have treated you badly. Probably down to their grief at the time, and then the longer these things go on, the harder it is to reverse them. Too much pride, too much water under the bridge. They didn’t get it right.

But maybe it’s time for everyone to show a little humanity and forgiveness.

Excellent post x
Thatsplentyjack · 11/10/2021 22:43

*Clearly not, as you would have seen my comment was in response to a poster asking why OP is dragging her feet about meeting an aunt and uncle who were cruel enough to cancel days out with their niece simply because OP would be the one doing the 2 minute drop off.

Nowhere did I say the DSD isn’t bothered about seeing her grandparents*

Now who isn't reading the OPs posts. It was the grandparents cancelling, not the aunt and uncle.

ShaneTheThird · 11/10/2021 22:43

@Loveshelly

DH sounds the selfish one. He open only said he would rather have less contact. He nominated his new girlfriend to send school email details. He drops her off in a service station. He got together with someone 2 years after his wife died, and she wasn’t even the first girlfriend! I mean I know it’s common for men to move on, but I still find it really distasteful. As the dead woman’s parents still do I would imagine.
Op said the emails occured about 4 years into her relationship, she wasn't a new girlfriend.

This is a classic anti step mother MN thread.

So many posters projecting their own fear of their DHS moving on without them and their own kids getting step mothers, especially if they die.

LovePoppy · 11/10/2021 22:41

@Thatsplentyjack

Because maybe dsd isn’t even bothered now? She has her family unit.

I think that might be one of the most callous things I've read on here.

Have you every been in DSDs shoes? I was.

People who were unkind to my stepmother, the woman who raised me, are not part of my life

Lunde · 11/10/2021 22:40

@SuperCaliFragalistic

But you have jumped into a dead woman's life and expected her parents and siblings to be alright with that. Maybe they haven't always put DSDs feelings first (and they should have tried) but can't you understand that they are probably very shocked at how easily their daughter was replaced? Your DH should have dealt with this issue better but you could at least be supportive of them trying to make amends now.
But it's been over 8 years (OP met her DH 2 years after dsd's mum died and they've been together 6+ years) - hardly "jumping in"

it seems to little too late to pick up now in many ways

Thatsplentyjack · 11/10/2021 22:38

@Loveshelly

DH sounds the selfish one. He open only said he would rather have less contact. He nominated his new girlfriend to send school email details. He drops her off in a service station. He got together with someone 2 years after his wife died, and she wasn’t even the first girlfriend! I mean I know it’s common for men to move on, but I still find it really distasteful. As the dead woman’s parents still do I would imagine.
Yup, very good points.
Thatsplentyjack · 11/10/2021 22:36

*What, even when the DH was off travelling for business?

Stop being simplistic.*

Yes, there's these things called mobile phones, laptops and even before that landlines that people use to contact other people. There no need to do it in person anymore, but then you must know that as you're obviously using one of these devices at the moment. Your actually contacting a stranger on one Hmm, and I'm simplistic.

Lunde · 11/10/2021 22:33

Just to clarify - it's been 8+ years since dsd's mum died and the aunt/uncle, after blanking you for 6+ years, have only now decided that they want to meet you and want to come to your house and for you to host them?

riotlady · 11/10/2021 22:33

@SuperCaliFragalistic

But you have jumped into a dead woman's life and expected her parents and siblings to be alright with that. Maybe they haven't always put DSDs feelings first (and they should have tried) but can't you understand that they are probably very shocked at how easily their daughter was replaced? Your DH should have dealt with this issue better but you could at least be supportive of them trying to make amends now.
OP’s husband met someone new a couple of years after losing his wife. I can see how that’s deeply upsetting for his wife’s family, but I don’t think it’s fair to talk about “jumping into a dead woman’s life” or her being “easily replaced”. Was he supposed to be sad and single forever? Put his life on hold? I wouldn’t want that for my husband
Loveshelly · 11/10/2021 22:33

DH sounds the selfish one. He open only said he would rather have less contact. He nominated his new girlfriend to send school email details. He drops her off in a service station.
He got together with someone 2 years after his wife died, and she wasn’t even the first girlfriend! I mean I know it’s common for men to move on, but I still find it really distasteful. As the dead woman’s parents still do I would imagine.

NoSquirrels · 11/10/2021 22:31

They've asked to come to our house

Regardless of anything- if you ignore history etc - it’s rude for anyone to invite themselves to your house. Accepting an invitation that’s offered is not the same as expecting to be welcomed.

So approach from that angle. Change the venue. That will allow you to feel better about it.

LovePoppy · 11/10/2021 22:31

@StaplesCorner

I think the missing point here is that the cost of their behaviour has been paid by the little girl, the child of the daughter/sister they loved and lost - does such a loss justify that? No it doesn’t. Grief Isn’t an excuse for shitty behaviour. And wtaf did you do wrong OP?! Nah, I’m not buying the lamenting family. Why didn’t they put that child first?
Absolutely.

They sound very selfish to me

Loveshelly · 11/10/2021 22:31

@NeverDropYourMooncup
Hit the nail on the head.
Too busy to forward an email. Yeah ok

Fraine · 11/10/2021 22:29

@LovePoppy

hat shouldn’t matter.

My father remarried after a year.

Instead of supporting us kids, my favourite people from my mothers side disappeared. They complain now that we aren’t close, but they chose to let their resentment and grief come between us.

Adults need to be the adults

Well said LovePoppy.

NoSquirrels · 11/10/2021 22:28

If you’re expected to “host”, there is absolutely nothing to say that has to be in your home, fully catered etc.

You can “host” them in a pub, a restaurant etc.

Tell your DH this would be best - somewhere with something else going on that makes it less awkward for you all. Plan a trip somewhere with things to see/do and plan for a meal whilst there.

Redburnett · 11/10/2021 22:27

Given the circumstances you describe I would find it very difficult to be friendly with these relatives. They have left it too long. I would be polite, civil and distant and do nothing to encourage any further family meetings. DSD will soon be old enough to make her own decisions about who she sees and when. Personally I could never forgive the nonsense of refusing to see DSD because only you were able to do the handover, thus hurting both DSD's and your feelings. Nor could I forgive the relatives who allowed themselves to be so influenced by the GPs. Let them build a relationship with DSD when she is old enough to travel independently if she wants to see them, but don't feel obliged to get involved yourself. Your DH should be supporting you in all this. Why he should expect you to be happy after years of snubs is a mystery.

Fraine · 11/10/2021 22:27

@Thatsplentyjack

Hmm not true, she just didn't need to be the one doing the inviting. Stop projecting.

What, even when the DH was off travelling for business?

Stop being simplistic.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/10/2021 22:26

[quote stepmoa]@SuperCaliFragalistic it's about my feelings now because I have a right to choose how I want to spend my time. I don't know what it feels like to lose a child but I have sat and cuddled DSD when her weekend with her grandparents has been cancelled because they refuse to meet me in a service station car park when DH couldn't go. So yeah, I don't have much time for anyone who would do that to a child.[/quote]
Sounds more like her father did that. Through 'moving on'. Through having handovers in petrol stations. Through assuming that they'd be fine seeing somebody else being Mummy or doing the grunt work of dropoffs because he's happy.

I wouldn't normally do this, but I think it's actually potentially useful; try to imagine one of your own DC has died. Now imagine that your DH has left and is with somebody else - somebody else's DC is in their place, playing with your DC's toys, having cuddles with your DH - and he says 'why can't you accept that I've moved on?' and sends his girlfriend/new wife to drop off the remaining DC to you at a motorway service station and to contact you about sports days because he says he's too busy to do it himself or it wouldn't occur to him to let you know about things relating to the surviving one.

No, it isn't quite the same - but even a moment's thought about that might give you an idea of the pain they may be feeling, exacerbated by your DH's treatment of them.

SuperCaliFragalistic · 11/10/2021 22:26

But you have jumped into a dead woman's life and expected her parents and siblings to be alright with that. Maybe they haven't always put DSDs feelings first (and they should have tried) but can't you understand that they are probably very shocked at how easily their daughter was replaced? Your DH should have dealt with this issue better but you could at least be supportive of them trying to make amends now.

Fraine · 11/10/2021 22:25

@Thatsplentyjack

Fraine, no perfectly capable of reading thanks. Nowhere does it say that the child isn't bothered about seeing her grandparents anymore, and to say that's because now she has her "family unit" is awful.
Clearly not, as you would have seen my comment was in response to a poster asking why OP is dragging her feet about meeting an aunt and uncle who were cruel enough to cancel days out with their niece simply because OP would be the one doing the 2 minute drop off.

Nowhere did I say the DSD isn’t bothered about seeing her grandparents Hmm

LovePoppy · 11/10/2021 22:24

@MichelleScarn

What was the time between her passing away and you meeting DH?
That shouldn’t matter.

My father remarried after a year.

Instead of supporting us kids, my favourite people from my mothers side disappeared. They complain now that we aren’t close, but they chose to let their resentment and grief come between us.

Adults need to be the adults.

Hadtocomment · 11/10/2021 22:24

Loveshelly I think your comments are getting unreasonable now.

BoredZelda · 11/10/2021 22:24

Stop thinking it’s about you.

They are coming to meet her for the first time, after rejecting her for years. Of course it is about the OP. If she is to present herself in a way that doesn’t make them run off again, she should feel comfortable with the situation. For DH to just arrange it without consulting her is a crappy thing to do.