Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel sad DH expects me to be happy about this?

319 replies

stepmoa · 11/10/2021 20:44

After not meeting DSD's maternal family in all the time that I've known her (6+ years), largely driven by her grandparents refusing to accept that DH moved on after her DM (their DD) died when she was a young child, some relatives have now decided they want to meet me. They've asked to come to our house and DH has arranged the first date we are all free.

For context, DSD and I have a great relationship now and I treat her like my own DD but in the early years it was complicated as she couldn't understand why her other family and I were entirely separate. It's only as she has got older age has she realised that it was their choice and she and I now have a strong bond.

DH doesn't understand why I'm upset that after being shut out for years I am not only expected to have to meet them but to host as well. I will do it for DSD but it is not the start of a great relationship when it's taken so long and he is defending them about it. I feel they've let DSD down as this could have happened years ago and saved the poor girl a lot of sadness.

YANBU - it's reasonable that you are upset and DH should be more sensitive to this
YABU - they've done nothing wrong and are within their rights to invite themselves

OP posts:
LovePoppy · 11/10/2021 23:13

@Thatsplentyjack

*Have you every been in DSDs shoes? I was.

People who were unkind to my stepmother, the woman who raised me, are not part of my life*

Have you ever lost a child and then had your grandchild kept from you because her dad like to keep contact to a minimum and if you did get to see her you were do meet at a service station to collect her?

Have you?

Children shouldn’t be the adults in those situations, but they often are.

Children are too busy comforting everyone around them that they grow up over night. People think ‘children are resilient, they get over it’. Then, when they present as though they do, they are berated for not grieving forever.

These grandparents let their daughter And granddaughter down.

She is the biggest loser.

If her visits were anything like mine she’d come home a mess for not performance grieving properly for relatives.

My father never kept me from them, my stepmother begged them to see me. I wish they’d kept me further from them.

Their performance grief damaged me even more.

Fraine · 11/10/2021 23:11

@Thatsplentyjack

*Have you every been in DSDs shoes? I was.

People who were unkind to my stepmother, the woman who raised me, are not part of my life*

Have you ever lost a child and then had your grandchild kept from you because her dad like to keep contact to a minimum and if you did get to see her you were do meet at a service station to collect her?

You’ve made all that up Hmm
Fraine · 11/10/2021 23:09

@MadameMonk

All this chat about grief is a red herring in my book.

Whatever the reason for the past estrangement, this ‘hosting them’ proposal is the wrong way to solve it.

It just seems to break some key human dynamic observances- love it or hate it we do have good instincts for what is a good or bad way to do things in our own culture.

Them coming to you is precedent setting, and it’s not a great precedent. It smacks of a ‘royal visit’ where the important people deign to allow you to do the hard work (emotionally and practically). It creates a scenario that puts them in the judges seat (again) and OP as someone to be judged worthy of being grudgingly accepted into the family. Not to mention that the aunt and uncle went through the DH again to organise this meetup- the exact behaviour that was problematic and hurtful in the beginning and for years. It’s really just a continuation of the disregard of OP by them. And evidence that her DH still doesn’t get it.

All that would definitely put me off the encounter. Perpetuating that dynamic into the future does DSD no favours.

Had they reached out personally to OP and DSD, suggested regret (if not a full-blown apology) and shown some goodwill by inviting everyone to theirs (as family does) then that would be a different story.

This current proposal is all kinds of wrong. I’d treat it with the disdain it was offered in. I’d tell DH that he’d got it all backwards, and needed to think more carefully about a new proposal having discussed it with DSD and OP rather than barrelling over everyone’s legitimate feelings. If he cares at all about building relationships then he has to base his actions on relationships, and not half-baked bright ideas that could easily make things worse.

Very well said
AveryGoodlay · 11/10/2021 23:08

I wouldn't say active hostility but I would email them about school events and they would only ever forward my email to DH and reply to him, that kind of thing. Why on earth did you do that? My stepsons mother is alive but chooses to only see him once a month or so. He lives with us. My stepsons dad informs his parents of anything school related he'd like them to know.

You choosing to do that makes it almost seem like you were running it in their faces or something. Very strange behaviour.

Joystir59 · 11/10/2021 23:08

Just let the past go and embrace them. This will be a positive new start for all of you. It's very positive. Don't put up barriers now.

stepmoa · 11/10/2021 23:08

Sorry I missed a lot of comments.

I don't think DH has always got it wrong for what's it worth, he's done his best at the time and I should clarify he's minimised HIS contact with the GPs not DSD's time with them. They haven't been limited to occasional visits on our terms with a service station handover, to DH's (dis)credit he pretty much lets them call the shots with everything.

To a PP, yes it has made me feel better because it's clearly a divisive and contentious issue. Hypothetically I'd be devastated if I was dead and gone and my family behaved like this towards my children and DH. To the kind posters who gave said lovely things about my relationship with DSD I am very grateful. I haven't jumped in to replace her Mum at all, she's part of the parcel with DH but I love her independently. I'm really proud of her and I hope she knows that I will always be there for her.

OP posts:
Fraine · 11/10/2021 23:07

@Thatsplentyjack

*Clearly not, as you would have seen my comment was in response to a poster asking why OP is dragging her feet about meeting an aunt and uncle who were cruel enough to cancel days out with their niece simply because OP would be the one doing the 2 minute drop off.

Nowhere did I say the DSD isn’t bothered about seeing her grandparents*

Now who isn't reading the OPs posts. It was the grandparents cancelling, not the aunt and uncle.

The aunt and uncle also cancelled a visit at the behest of the grandparents.
Thatsplentyjack · 11/10/2021 23:07

You have no idea how OP and her DH organised their lives.

Organise their lives? It's sending a message, it's not difficult. It can be done from most places on the planet.

StartupRepair · 11/10/2021 23:06

You clearly really love your dsd and your anger with her relatives is on her behalf. I would try to get through this social occasion for her sake. Light and breezy and show her that adults can move past poor behaviour and rebuild relationships. Everyone will feel weird and nervous so just do your best to show dsd what is possible.

ivykaty44 · 11/10/2021 23:06

If I was to die leaving a daughter motherless and my parents wouldn't see my daughter du to a nw girlfriend dropping her off at a service station - id be dissapointed in my parents attitude

MadameMonk · 11/10/2021 23:05

All this chat about grief is a red herring in my book.

Whatever the reason for the past estrangement, this ‘hosting them’ proposal is the wrong way to solve it.

It just seems to break some key human dynamic observances- love it or hate it we do have good instincts for what is a good or bad way to do things in our own culture.

Them coming to you is precedent setting, and it’s not a great precedent. It smacks of a ‘royal visit’ where the important people deign to allow you to do the hard work (emotionally and practically). It creates a scenario that puts them in the judges seat (again) and OP as someone to be judged worthy of being grudgingly accepted into the family. Not to mention that the aunt and uncle went through the DH again to organise this meetup- the exact behaviour that was problematic and hurtful in the beginning and for years. It’s really just a continuation of the disregard of OP by them. And evidence that her DH still doesn’t get it.

All that would definitely put me off the encounter. Perpetuating that dynamic into the future does DSD no favours.

Had they reached out personally to OP and DSD, suggested regret (if not a full-blown apology) and shown some goodwill by inviting everyone to theirs (as family does) then that would be a different story.

This current proposal is all kinds of wrong. I’d treat it with the disdain it was offered in. I’d tell DH that he’d got it all backwards, and needed to think more carefully about a new proposal having discussed it with DSD and OP rather than barrelling over everyone’s legitimate feelings. If he cares at all about building relationships then he has to base his actions on relationships, and not half-baked bright ideas that could easily make things worse.

Fraine · 11/10/2021 23:03

@Thatsplentyjack

*What, even when the DH was off travelling for business?

Stop being simplistic.*

Yes, there's these things called mobile phones, laptops and even before that landlines that people use to contact other people. There no need to do it in person anymore, but then you must know that as you're obviously using one of these devices at the moment. Your actually contacting a stranger on one Hmm, and I'm simplistic.

You have no idea how OP and her DH organised their lives.

In any case, it’s not OP’s fault, all she was trying to so was arrange for her DSD to see her family.

So yes, you are being simplistic.

SuperCaliFragalistic · 11/10/2021 23:01

Or maybe you'd be disappointed that your "D"H found you so easily replaceable? I agree the grandparents haven't helped anything though.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 11/10/2021 22:59

I'm just thinking about your dsd's dm's POV. If something happened to me and my dh remarried, and my dp's let their emotions around that woman stand in the way of their relationship with my dc I'd be so disappointed in them.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 11/10/2021 22:58

Has this thread been helpful, OP?

I would never, in a million years, start a thread on here about something I felt genuinely upset about, because I know the many inevitable posts telling me I’m being unreasonable, would make me feel so much worse. Hurt, unheard, defensive. Set back in my processing of it.

Perhaps it has been helpful for you, though. I hope so.

I cannot even begin to imagine losing my DD as a young mother, and seeing my grandchild being raised by someone else - and I do see myself as an empathetic, considerate person.

Some things are just inconceivable, though.

I think what you’ve done for your DSD is quite remarkable, for what it’s worth.

ivykaty44 · 11/10/2021 22:58

I do think 2 years after the death of your partner (presumably the relationship was happy) is quite quick to get over it and move in with another woman

its incredibly common for.a male to do this and the average is a shorter span of time than for a woman who takes 3-5 years

Ellie56 · 11/10/2021 22:56

[quote stepmoa]@SuperCaliFragalistic it's about my feelings now because I have a right to choose how I want to spend my time. I don't know what it feels like to lose a child but I have sat and cuddled DSD when her weekend with her grandparents has been cancelled because they refuse to meet me in a service station car park when DH couldn't go. So yeah, I don't have much time for anyone who would do that to a child.[/quote]
How unbelievably cruel and quite frankly unforgivable.That poor little girl. I don't understand how anyone could do that to a child either.

Yes they lost a daughter, but their daughter's child lost her mum FGS. They should have put her first.

I think in your shoes I'd feel the same.

ivykaty44 · 11/10/2021 22:54

Whilst its incredible tragic to lose an adult child, its tragic to lose a parent as a small child and then have grandparents make your life more difficult than it needed to be through putting their feelings as adults before those of a child. For so many years, a year or two but 6

SuperCaliFragalistic · 11/10/2021 22:54

I do think 2 years after the death of your partner (presumably the relationship was happy) is quite quick to get over it and move in with another woman. My Great Grandfather did this because he couldn't face bringing up his kids on his own. His actions had a lasting effect and my Grandmother still talks about her mum being so easily replaced. I think the onus was on the DH here to maintain the relationships and he failed and OP needs to recognise this - him asking her to "host" a small get together is neither here nor there compared with his other failings as a parent.

Loveshelly · 11/10/2021 22:51

Why do men move on so easily. It’s interesting actually.
I lost someone I loved, I couldn’t move out of the fug of grief for a good few years. Let alone think about fucking someone else

TatianaBis · 11/10/2021 22:51

I don’t really see why DSD and you should have had to bear the brunt of their grief. It’s so selfish. It’s neither of yours faults that DH moved on - what feels like fast to them. Did they not consider that he wanted help bringing up his DD? Some men find it harder than women to parent alone. Punishing DSD and you won’t bring his ex back.

If he’s arranged the date I’d expect him to cook. (He can cook can’t he?)

niceandsimple · 11/10/2021 22:48

Having been the dd in this situation, I think you should just accept it for her sake. You do not have to be close to them, but don't make it about you, because it is not.
It was very hard for my maternal grandparents when my father moved on, and although they did meet his new wife (after the wedding only) they became very passive aggressive around, her. This was totally out of character for them, but grief is not something that is rational.
The other family members will want to keep everyone happy, which is an impossible situation.
They want to meet you now - take it as a step forward and an opportunity to fix things.

Hadtocomment · 11/10/2021 22:48

You know I think some of the posts are truly unreasonable here. For one thing it's actually horrible for people to tell the op she is just stepping into shoes likes she is a cypher. She is her own person. She does not have to sit imagining herself into everyone else's heads. She is worthy of being treated properly and with respect. She did nothing wrong. She has in fact brought love and stability into the grandchild's life. I can see they might be traumatised. Maybe one of the grandparents fell into a depression and the others acquiesced or didn't want to upset them or something. All of which could be understandable but people here telling the op she "merrily" walked into another's place etc. I actually find that a disgusting thing to say.

surely the granddaughter deserves to love again (and the father too!). Surely the way of making things easier and not putting guilt on the granddaughter was to meet and accept her stepmother who was looking after her and part of her everyday life. All those emphasising how OP must imagine this and that and that she doesn't count only their grief. No actually. She is a separate person. She did nothing wrong. She did nothing to deserve poor treatment. Unless there is more that hasn't been said. She doesn't have to wallow trying to imagine anything. She can just continue to be a decent person. I hope she can approach it with an open mind. But there are some posts here that sound like she's done something wrong. I can't see it at all. Even the emailing...no I don't see that. And someone saying how awful the thought of her cuddling the granddaughter. Surely this this is exactly why she has done such a good thing that deserves support and respect not shunning?

FancyLampshade · 11/10/2021 22:47

@Brollywasntneededafterall

Well surely dh hosts them? He can cook and boil the kettle. Dsd can entertain them. You can sit in the wings and drink tea...
I feel like I'd rather be busy if it was me!
Loveshelly · 11/10/2021 22:46

@ShaneTheThird
I’m not anti step mum
Fine, I should have simply said girlfriend.
I’m just sitting here imagining how GPs must have felt that their son in law was dating so soon after their daughter died.