Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to feel sad DH expects me to be happy about this?

319 replies

stepmoa · 11/10/2021 20:44

After not meeting DSD's maternal family in all the time that I've known her (6+ years), largely driven by her grandparents refusing to accept that DH moved on after her DM (their DD) died when she was a young child, some relatives have now decided they want to meet me. They've asked to come to our house and DH has arranged the first date we are all free.

For context, DSD and I have a great relationship now and I treat her like my own DD but in the early years it was complicated as she couldn't understand why her other family and I were entirely separate. It's only as she has got older age has she realised that it was their choice and she and I now have a strong bond.

DH doesn't understand why I'm upset that after being shut out for years I am not only expected to have to meet them but to host as well. I will do it for DSD but it is not the start of a great relationship when it's taken so long and he is defending them about it. I feel they've let DSD down as this could have happened years ago and saved the poor girl a lot of sadness.

YANBU - it's reasonable that you are upset and DH should be more sensitive to this
YABU - they've done nothing wrong and are within their rights to invite themselves

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 13/10/2021 16:06

@Lunde Thank you.

Rosscameasdoody · 13/10/2021 14:27

@Lunde. Thanks for clarifying. I really don’t understand how PPs have confused the issue to the point where the OP is getting the blame for the rift and has been labelled a ‘punitive’. That one post alone confirms that the OP has tried to facilitate the GPs seeing their GD in the past and has had it thrown back in her face. Despite this, she’s trying to deal with her own feelings to allow the child to have the best chance of reconnecting with her family. The grandparents are the punitive ones here. They’re punishing their SIL for moving on with his life and they haven’t stopped to consider his, or their GD’s grief. As I said in a post upthread somewhere, only the bereaved person knows when they’re ready for a new relationship - it’s a difficult thing to do for all sorts of reasons and having people sitting in judgement does no one any good, as is all too evident here.

Lunde · 13/10/2021 12:52

[quote Zilla1]@Rosscameasdoody I read it the same way as you. Was there was a post about cancelling a meeting with the 'D'GD once the OP rather than the DGC's father would have to facilitate the contact.

It is difficult to be certain about the future but I would hope that in similar circumstances, the DGD's needs would be front and centre and I would want family to prioritise the DGD if I passed and DP moved on.[/quote]
It was this post where the GPs chose to cancel and upset their GC rather than meet OP for a brief handover

stepmoa Mon 11-Oct-21 21:22:57 - They cancelled a few weekend visits with her if he was suddenly away on business travel and couldn't facilitate a handover rather than meet me, so I often had to deal with the fallout of her disappointment of not seeing them and with her dad away. I think that is what has affected me, feeling that pain she had

Zilla1 · 13/10/2021 12:01

@Rosscameasdoody I read it the same way as you. Was there was a post about cancelling a meeting with the 'D'GD once the OP rather than the DGC's father would have to facilitate the contact.

It is difficult to be certain about the future but I would hope that in similar circumstances, the DGD's needs would be front and centre and I would want family to prioritise the DGD if I passed and DP moved on.

Rosscameasdoody · 13/10/2021 10:41

DarlingFell

Bluntness100
I’m not sure you’re being fair, they lost a child and struggled to see her replaced in their eyes. I don’t understand your desire to be punitive snd make it worse for your step daughter,

Totally agree with this

Just wow. I’ve read and re-read the OP’s posts and can’t find any evidence of a ‘desire to be punitive’ in anything she’s said. In fact it’s PIL who are being punitive - punishing their SIL for moving on with his life, without a single thought for their grandchild. And before I get my ass handed to me, I know they are bereaved and devastated at the loss of their daughter, but they’ve kept up this behaviour for eight years and have actively discouraged other members of the family from becoming engaged with the her. In the meantime the OP has formed a loving relationship with the child and has provided the support her grandparents found so easy to withdraw. It’s unreasonable and unrealistic to expect the surviving partner to live a lonely life of grief and to those blaming the DH for withdrawing from his PIL and thus distancing them from their GD - I think they’ve rather done that themselves.

smoko · 13/10/2021 10:35

The DP sounds like a right catch.

He's left his new GF to do the parenting & hasn't even considered her when making these plans. Oh now she'll be hosting as well, so there's the work that goes along with that.

While I think the OP overstepped by emailing them about SD's school stuff, it sounds like piss poor parenting from the Dad that has led to the OP stepping up.

Dropping the daughter off at a servo, could they not have met in a park?

I don't blame the OP for not wanting to meet them, but the fault lies with the partner for being selfish & lazy.

MiddleAgedLurker · 13/10/2021 10:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Shedbuilder · 13/10/2021 09:35

@twoandeights

What a terribly sad situation. I’m wondering why you need to be involved? They can come see the child and your DH but surely you don’t need to be there? Your step child isn’t a baby. They can have a relationship without you being involved? There is no responsibility here. No expectation. This all seems OTT and onerous. It’s not clear why anyone is expecting you to be involved. They don’t pay you or employ you. You are an independent adult with the ability to decide what you want to do with your free time. Say no. Say thanks for the offer but you want to be able to decide for yourself what you do with your free time. You are more than happy to make yourself scarce for the day (go to a spa).
What a flat-footed response. Have you not read the posts from other women in this situation who are raising another woman's child as if it was their own? Getting up in the night when they're sick, shouldering the burden of school runs, loving and caring for them, fostering strong relationships and still being treated like pariahs, years later, by the extended family.

The OP isn't a family servant who can be given a day off when someone comes to call. What message does that send to the child she loves and who loves her? She needs to be acknowledged as an important, loved member of the family unit.

Lockdownbear · 13/10/2021 09:16

2 sides or not, I'd still want to meet the woman who's step-mum to my sisters kids.

callmeadoctor · 13/10/2021 08:55

As always on here, there are 2 sides to every story...................

Lockdownbear · 13/10/2021 08:42

@twoandeights I think it would be natural to want to know the woman who is helping raise your niece. The girl obviously has a very loving relationship with Op.
At what point are they going to meet, at the girls wedding, funeral?

It's a long overdue meeting, they can't stay apart forever. And if they don't meet sooner or later the girl may well decide not to have contact with family who shun the lady who has in every sense of word become mum, raising her, wiping her tears, helping with homework, and a million other things mums do.

DarlingFell · 13/10/2021 08:37

@Bluntness100

I’m not sure you’re being fair, they lost a child and struggled to see her replaced in their eyes

I don’t understand your desire to be punitive snd make it worse for your step daughter,

Totally agree with this
twoandeights · 13/10/2021 08:30

What a terribly sad situation. I’m wondering why you need to be involved? They can come see the child and your DH but surely you don’t need to be there? Your step child isn’t a baby. They can have a relationship without you being involved? There is no responsibility here. No expectation. This all seems OTT and onerous. It’s not clear why anyone is expecting you to be involved. They don’t pay you or employ you. You are an independent adult with the ability to decide what you want to do with your free time. Say no. Say thanks for the offer but you want to be able to decide for yourself what you do with your free time. You are more than happy to make yourself scarce for the day (go to a spa).

Lockdownbear · 13/10/2021 08:29

Op one thing that I'm sure you and DH have considered but just incase you haven't is should something unfortunately happen to him has he made a will with directions for custody for his DD?
I just think she could end up being centre of a bitter and sad custody battle.

mumtoallbhoys · 13/10/2021 07:40

Probably the mailing about school things was a bit hurtful for them but to be honest you could have just got DH to do the mailing knowing it was a bit insensitive. The replying to him only was a bit unnecessary though?

The not collecting her because they would have to see you is outrageous in my opinion. The poor child missing the event. Could they not grin and bare it for the handover which could be done in 5 mins?

arrangeyourface · 13/10/2021 06:51

I suspect there are a lot of people on this thread projecting their feelings as if it was them who passed away and their DH met someone else who became stepmother to their children.

TatianaBis · 12/10/2021 23:22

They might have a very different shortly to tell and might feel that they were a significant part of their granddaughters life until he "moved on".

And yet they’re the ones who disappointed DSD by cancelling her weekend rather than meet OP for pickup.

Rainbowsew · 12/10/2021 23:08

I think it's a shame they haven't been more accepting of you for their dgd sake as even a little bit of thought as to her feelings they could have realised she would have struggled with. Although I appreciate their difficulties seeing you in their daughters role.

The cancelling of weekends just because they don't want to see you in a car park was unforgivable just for the hurt they caused their dgd and shows very little regard for their dgd as a person I wonder what their dad would think of it. They or the aunt could have at least received her from you with a handover letter from her dad with news/instructions in.

The fact that they influenced their other child not to contact you makes me think they're rather controlling or least judgemental. They can't change the situation however much they disagree with it and it will have an effect on the relationship with their dgd even if they haven't realised it yet Sad

I'd go for mutual ground for the first meet and build up slowly so no pressure on either side.

billy1966 · 12/10/2021 22:18

@HebalGerbil

I completely agree.

God forbid anything happened to me, my dearest wish if my husband met someone, she would love and care for my children as the OP has done.

I really think it is awful that the grandparents have put their feelings ahead of a little child.

Dreadfully selfish behaviour to cause unnecessary additional grief to a child.

AnneLovesGilbert · 12/10/2021 21:23

I’m with you @HebalGerbil

It’s not waffle, it’s perfectly sensible.

DoraMaude · 12/10/2021 21:21

Apologies Herbilgerbil. I incorrectly read you as describing the grandparents as wallowing in grief.

DoraMaude · 12/10/2021 21:15

Some of the comments here about the grandparents are disgraceful. Anyone who has ever lost a child knows that it is an all encompassing grief that takes time to learn to live with. Describing it as 'wallowing in grief' is abhorrent.

HebalGerbil · 12/10/2021 20:31

Why is the sentiment of the deceased woman's parents, and wider family, that of OP being "the other woman". Their subsequent behaviour is that of grandparents whose daughter's husband cheated and left her for someone else.

A lot of the sentiments and language of other respondents is similar, as if @stepmoa was some sort of overstepping other woman who stole DSD's dad away from their mum. Not only the husband either, as plenty of accusations of overstepping seem to insinuate she's trying to steal the child's heart too.

The child's mother is dead. Are the husband and child supposed to wallow in grief forever, performance grieving the parent who passed away to the grandparent's satisfaction or they are being disloyal to her memory. The grandparent's seem to think they are basically cheating on her with OP.

All the understanding in these replies for the deceased mother's family, I can't fathom why their feelings trump everyone else's, especially those of the little girl who lost her mum and found love and care from someone else who was kind and willing to be a loving mother figure to her.

To be honest, I am not entirely sure of what I am waffling on about. It's just OP's treatment has made me feel like she is being woefully misjudged and treated like shit by an awful lot of people.

As someone who lost both parents at a young age, I would have liked to have someone like OP to have been there for me.

LovePoppy · 12/10/2021 18:09

@spudinmysock We are cooking , cleaning , washing , school runs, loving , comforting , providing and all of the other donkey work (and nice the bits) that come with raising children we didn't plan for and we are still the shits not matter what we do . I will always be in the shadow of my DH's late wife based on what others think she would or wouldn't have done in any given situation.

To the people who matter, your children, you are their everything and they are grateful to you.

I owe so much to my ‘step’ mother. She truly raised me, and took it on the chin from those who kept telling her how wrong she was. She means the world to me, and as soon as I had a voice I was defending her.

Thank you for doing all the work

billy1966 · 12/10/2021 17:46

The grandparents behaviour has gone on for years to the detriment of their grandchild.

I believe their behaviour to be extremely petty and unkind to their grandchild to have continued for years in refusing to see their grandchild simply because due to circumstances, her stepmother was required to step in to do the handover.

Very petty.

IMO they in no way honoured their daughters memory by continuing this position for years.