Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To point out IR35 is a major factor in the lack of HGV drivers

59 replies

mikedyson · 11/10/2021 19:14

As this well researched (for once) article in the i points out =

inews.co.uk/news/hgv-driver-shortage-tax-change-ir35-lorry-crisis-uk-europe-1239313?ito=email_share_article-top

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 12/10/2021 11:39

@ExtraOnions Wanting all the tax breaks of being self employed, with none of the risk

Self employment has fundamental inherent risks, such as lack of entitlements to holiday pay, statutory sick/maternity pay, lack of rights for statutory redundancy/notice periods, etc. The whole point of self employment is the "risk" of being let go at short/no notice, with no employment protections.

Just look at covid - that shows the "risk", i.e. the vast majority of self employed using their own companies will have received minimal covid support grants, so that's another massive financial hit which proves the inherent risk that they bear.

But beyond that, they're often required to provide their own professional indemnity and other insurances, pay for their own training and licences and health examinations, etc.

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 12/10/2021 11:34

When IR35 was first announced in the early 2000s (Dawn Primarolo & Steven Timms) targeting IT contractors, we banded together to fight it.

As I said in a post yesterday, we’ve always had to have public & personal indemnity & liability insurance, don’t get holiday or sick pay, have to fork out for additional accountants, pay for our own equipment etc., none of which a permanent staff member needs to do. And yet we have to pay as if we are permanent employees of our clients! If we multi contract, it can be considered outside of IR35, but in reality, especially on a longer (and more secure financially) contract we get taxed to the hilt - all of the above plus, if we have a limited company, we have the corporation tax to factor in, plus other company expenses (annual returns etc), employer NI & pension contributions.

Multiply that to other sectors & I’m not surprised in the slightest that it’s contributing to a deficit in HGV drivers.

I’m happy to pay tax, of course it’s important, but us contractors in all sectors are forced by clients to be self employed via a limited company, don’t have the benefits of holidays, sick days or other ‘perks’ (unless we raise our rates to compensate for that, which make us less desirable to clients versus offshore developers - although the amount of work we’ve picked up fixing off shore disasters is huge).

My husband was fortunate enough to get a well paid permie job this year, with pensions & private healthcare and 9-5:30pm hours & no faffing!) as, after 20 years & multiple iterations of contracting via our own limited companies, self employment etc (whatever the client requested, it’s been a clusterfudge of a decade or two) he’d had enough.

Im still using my limited co for a new era & utterly different endeavour, working for myself, but it’s refreshing (even living off meagre savings) to not be treated by a client as a permanent member of staff with none of the benefits.

I hate this govt with a passion. HGV drivers are worse off as they can’t multi contract as easily due to driving time legislation.

IR35 needs to die a horrible, horrible death as it kills competition v overseas staff, doesn’t actually protect the contractor at all, just are covers the client.

user1497207191 · 12/10/2021 11:34

@Ibelieveinghosts

Despite apparently constantly striving towards the simplification of tax it just gets increasingly complex and difficult for the average man in the street to understand. I’ve worked in tax for 20 years. My legislation books are now double (at least) in size to what they were then.

Ignoring the moral rights and wrongs of what went on before. Anyone now caught foul of IR35 ( and let’s not forget it’s been around in one way or another for a long time) will effectively have had a cut in net pay. Anyone facing a pay cut is going to look round for alternative employment with either better money or conditions. It was stupid to do this at the same time as Brexit.

Well said. Changing the IR35 rules in the middle of a pandemic and just after Brexit was incredibly stupid.

They've only changed the rules because the whole thing is flawed. It was flawed back in 2000 when first introduced and it's still flawed because HMRC havn't addressed the fundamental flaws.

They've now just passed the burden and responsibility to the "employer" in the hope that lots of people will get caught despite not actually being caught, just because they hope the "employers" will be too lazy to do proper IR35 evaluations.

forinborin · 12/10/2021 11:31

I do these assessments for IT contractors, a lot of people have avoided a lot if tax by taking the benefits of being a company, with none of the risk.
While I was contracting, I was let go of twice American-style. As in, you come in the morning, and are given 2 hours to pack your things and leave. No redress, no severance pay, no warning. And that's it, you don't have any income any more. And if you can't find a contract, you will be very ill advised to take a PAYE role in the same tax year, as you'd get hit by an extra rate of tax on dividends already drawn in the year.

It definitely wasn't the low risk way. Yes, the net was higher (not outrageously higher, by the way), but it came with significant risks attached.

Now what happens is that the intermediation switched to "umbrella" companies where you are paying more than what you would as a PAYE employee - as you are paying the employers NI and pension contributions too.

user1497207191 · 12/10/2021 11:30

@jgw1

So, haulage companies and hgv drivers were trying to dodge tax and national insurance and now they can't. Might it not make more sense for the haulage companies simply to pay employees properly?
I see you've fallen for the HMRC propaganda.

For a lot of them, it was nothing to do with "dodging" tax and NIC. A lot of drivers were genuinely self employed (in accordance with long established case law, not HMRC's wishful thinking!).

IR35 has forced the burden of both employee and employer NIC onto the driver, plus apprentice levies and agency fees.

Ironically, they'd pay less tax if they were employed directly by the haulage firms as then the haulage firm would be responsible for the employers NIC, apprentice levies and other "employment" costs.

As said, HMRC have been repeatedly warned by numerous professional bodies and trade bodies that IR35 would cause a shortage or workers. It's exactly what happened a couple of years ago when IR35 was enforced on the public sector, causing a shortage of "self employed" doctors, consultants, GPs etc. Trouble is that the HMRC clowns don't understand and don't listen to the reality.

CSJobseeker · 12/10/2021 11:17

@ExtraOnions

IR35 is a pretty straightforward test to show if you should be treated as an employee. If you can’t use a substitute, get told what you need to do (as well as when, and how), and aren’t at much financial risk… you are probably inside. I do these assessments for IT contractors, a lot of people have avoided a lot if tax by taking the benefits of being a company, with none of the risk. If you are truly self-employed, you won’t be found to be inside … How many companies would allow a haulier to send a substitute - that they have no right to interview, and no right to reject ?
I agree, and also have experience of doing these assessments. Genuine freelancing shouldn't be a problem (although some companies are taking a very risk averse stance), but a lot of the haulage industry does not fall in that category.
GurtBusty · 12/10/2021 11:12

"IR35 came in April.

I think you've misunderstood that graph"

I think you've misunderstood IR35 - it became law in 2000. It has been around a long time.

What changed in April 2021 was that in the private sector, the client became responsible for determining the employment status of the worker. This change happened earlier in the public sector (2017)

TeenTitan007 · 12/10/2021 11:08

I heard a Polish truck driver on
LBC a few days ago - he said that IR35 was one of the main reasons for drivers leaving UK. They saw a steep drop in their income - his words "from £1300 a week to £700".

This has definitely been underplayed by the media.

VanGoghsDog · 11/10/2021 22:17

[quote SudokuWillNotSaveYou]@VanGoghsDog So, reverse the words (sorry I bollocksed it). Either way, you have a graph where IR35 isn’t the determinate. The steep rise seems to have started around Brexit or even April of “Brexit year” (Brexit plus the 90 days some workers might have been allowed to stay?) and IR35 only came in when it was already halfway up.

Point: The graph shows a steep loss of drivers starts before IR35 and IR35 is just another pile of shite on the way.[/quote]
IR35 came in April.

I think you've misunderstood that graph.

Ibelieveinghosts · 11/10/2021 20:49

Despite apparently constantly striving towards the simplification of tax it just gets increasingly complex and difficult for the average man in the street to understand. I’ve worked in tax for 20 years. My legislation books are now double (at least) in size to what they were then.

Ignoring the moral rights and wrongs of what went on before. Anyone now caught foul of IR35 ( and let’s not forget it’s been around in one way or another for a long time) will effectively have had a cut in net pay. Anyone facing a pay cut is going to look round for alternative employment with either better money or conditions. It was stupid to do this at the same time as Brexit.

LondonLife3 · 11/10/2021 20:43

The news dare ever point out that the issue is IR35. Even some posters on this thread clearly don’t understand its not a tax dodge .. I’m truly self employed as an IT consultant, I provide all my own licences and equipment yet some of my clients were to risk adverse to place me outside or they have a blanket assessment. I believe blank assessments are quite common for HGV drivers.

GurtBusty · 11/10/2021 20:40

@jb7445

As a lawyer working in this area for a major employer (yes, employer because they are employees!) of HGV drivers, as well as other contractors in IT etc. - yes it was a tax dodge and yes the big companies are currently doing everything they can do to get around it.

IR35 really isn't complex. If you're an employee in law then employment taxes need to be paid by both employees and employers.

But the employers don't pay employment taxes under IR35 - the contractor usually gets hit for both employers and employees NI.
mikedyson · 11/10/2021 20:35

@jb7445

Clymene, you are clearly not an employee based on what you're saying. It's not IR35 that's bollocks (although it has been a massive pain in the arse for many companies), it's just that your client doesn't understand it...
HMRC has deliberately created a regime that is complex and hard to understand, and has companies running scared because they cannot take to risk of an HMRC costing thousands and taking many years.

This has led to the destruction of a highly flexible sector, for no benefit.

OP posts:
SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 11/10/2021 20:35

@VanGoghsDog So, reverse the words (sorry I bollocksed it). Either way, you have a graph where IR35 isn’t the determinate. The steep rise seems to have started around Brexit or even April of “Brexit year” (Brexit plus the 90 days some workers might have been allowed to stay?) and IR35 only came in when it was already halfway up.

Point: The graph shows a steep loss of drivers starts before IR35 and IR35 is just another pile of shite on the way.

mikedyson · 11/10/2021 20:32

HMRC has a "tool" (CEST) that is supposed to allow you to work out if IR35 applies. In about 20% of cases it can't decide - why would that happen if it's simple?

Also according to CEST, around 49% of the cases it's used for show the contract is outside IR35 - but the level of advertised outside IR35 contracts is running at about 26%.

It's a very complex area.

OP posts:
Clymene · 11/10/2021 20:29

@jb7445

Clymene, you are clearly not an employee based on what you're saying. It's not IR35 that's bollocks (although it has been a massive pain in the arse for many companies), it's just that your client doesn't understand it...
My client is enormously risk averse. And a lot of big companies are. I've no doubt that there are some companies that avoided treating people as employees as a way of getting round paying them benefits. The problem is that the legislation is so broad that it's made a lot of businesses very nervous.
ExtraOnions · 11/10/2021 20:23

@mikedyson

If IR35 isn't complex why does it take several years and thousands of pounds to get a final decision when HMRC challenges someone?

It's actually very, very complex.

For a vast majority of cases it’s simple, but like all rules it gets challenged and needs working through. These cases take time, and we learn every time there us a judgement.

People used the old legislation to avoid paying tax …. Wanting all the tax breaks of being self employed, with none of the risk …

mikedyson · 11/10/2021 20:18

If IR35 isn't complex why does it take several years and thousands of pounds to get a final decision when HMRC challenges someone?

It's actually very, very complex.

OP posts:
ExtraOnions · 11/10/2021 20:17

@Clymene

IR35 is bollocks. I am self employed and one of my clients insist I fall under IR35 rules because they make me sign an annual contract. Last year I billed them 34 hours and this year I've billed them 19. There is a huge amount of paperwork and it pushes my accountancy fees up.

I won't be working for them next year which is a shame because they've been a client for 10 years. But it's just a pain in the arse now.

The rules are not just about being able to use a sub @ExtraOnions - that's a very simplistic interpretation

I am aware it’s not just about substitutes … but that is one of the determiner questions in the assessment.
jb7445 · 11/10/2021 20:17

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

jb7445 · 11/10/2021 20:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

shouldistop · 11/10/2021 20:12

Yanbu

Clymene · 11/10/2021 20:11

IR35 is bollocks. I am self employed and one of my clients insist I fall under IR35 rules because they make me sign an annual contract. Last year I billed them 34 hours and this year I've billed them 19. There is a huge amount of paperwork and it pushes my accountancy fees up.

I won't be working for them next year which is a shame because they've been a client for 10 years. But it's just a pain in the arse now.

The rules are not just about being able to use a sub @ExtraOnions - that's a very simplistic interpretation

ExtraOnions · 11/10/2021 20:08

IR35 is a pretty straightforward test to show if you should be treated as an employee. If you can’t use a substitute, get told what you need to do (as well as when, and how), and aren’t at much financial risk… you are probably inside. I do these assessments for IT contractors, a lot of people have avoided a lot if tax by taking the benefits of being a company, with none of the risk. If you are truly self-employed, you won’t be found to be inside …
How many companies would allow a haulier to send a substitute - that they have no right to interview, and no right to reject ?

VanGoghsDog · 11/10/2021 20:04

@SudokuWillNotSaveYou

Well I mean yes, IR35 didn’t “help” keep foreign drivers, but look at his own graph. It shows that the first HUGE dip happened before IR35. He even has to label that IR35 isn’t the enormous nosedive - it’s that little second dip. In fact, the enormous nosedive, which IR35 didn’t take the industry half back down to, happened at the beginning of 2020… you know, same time as Brexit.
That's the rate of vacancies though - it shows the vacancies going UP after the IR35 rules came in.