Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To point out IR35 is a major factor in the lack of HGV drivers

59 replies

mikedyson · 11/10/2021 19:14

As this well researched (for once) article in the i points out =

inews.co.uk/news/hgv-driver-shortage-tax-change-ir35-lorry-crisis-uk-europe-1239313?ito=email_share_article-top

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1497207191 · 13/10/2021 11:18

@mikedyson

It’s mainly inertia from HMRC - simplified tax would hurt them (and their lawyers) the most.
And bias. These days, HMRC seem to have an "agenda" against some groups of people. Just look at the covid support schemes were certain groups were unfairly excluded on the flimsiest of reasons/excuses.

The next fiasco made by HMRC is making tax digital for income tax, where all but the tiniest of landlords, sole traders etc will have to use software for their book-keeping and submit quarterly returns on top of the yearly returns. HMRC havn't been able to come up with any logical reasoning for this and, again, are coming up with flimy "reasons" why it's apparently necessary and beneficial, none of which hold water. Just another "agenda" where they won't reveal the true reasons.

takenforgrantednana · 12/10/2021 14:18

yeah for the likes of me most of it seem to be about teaching me how to suck eggs! 35 hrs worth of doing it on the initial course!

so once gain i need the cpc to gain amployment, but i cant get employment without having the cpc first! im not the only driver in that situation, plenty of us around and way back in 1995 when i first started driving them there was 50,000 drivers short back then and nothing has ever changed, its just a dangerous job, one you can be attacked while sleeping, or severly injured while doing it

mikedyson · 12/10/2021 13:59

It’s mainly inertia from HMRC - simplified tax would hurt them (and their lawyers) the most.

OP posts:
forinborin · 12/10/2021 13:55

We've come a long way from the old days when everyone worked fixed regular hours in "jobs for life". Nowadays, huge swathes of the employment market are flexible.
Oh yes. I personally wouldn't mind paying higher tax overall, but in a more flexible and fair system, that would recognise that employment can be both precarious and lucrative at the same time. And there's absolutely no reason why it cannot be done, apart from the political will.

mikedyson · 12/10/2021 13:51

@user1497207191

At the end of the day, HMRC needs to sort out the tax system as it's not fit for purpose. It's crazy that someone self employed as a sole trader has a different set of tax rules (relieves, rates, etc) compared to an identical self employed person operating as a limited company doing the exact same work. Yet, as each government comes and goes, as each Treasury minister comes and goes, they make it worse, not better with their continual faffing around the edges rather than actually addressing the inherent issues.
^100% agree
OP posts:
mikedyson · 12/10/2021 13:49

@takenforgrantednana

Thanks for the detail on CPC.

Dunno why they haven’t scrapped it though as it was an EU requirement. No-one I know who has done it seems to think it’s actually useful - mostly common sense of stuff you’d already know.

Of course for a driver running his own limited company, at least some of those costs would be legit business expenses - something else that’s been abolished overnight by the risk-averse response of companies to the IR35 changes.

OP posts:
mikedyson · 12/10/2021 13:42

Employers don’t want permanent staff for a variety of perfectly valid reasons.
Like many others I was happy taking the risks and paying for my own sick time, pension etc. Companies paid me to do a single project that took less than a year using my knowledge. My services were expensive compared with an employee but cheaper than having it done wrong.
There is almost no chance they could pay an attractive salary for the work but paying for the services they need could be justified.
The real roots of the issue lie in the overly complex tax system and company incorporation regime.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 12/10/2021 13:41

@jgw1 Why do employers not want permanent staff?

One aspect is the same reason that supply teachers, locum doctors, and agency nurses exist. It's to cover staff absences, peak demand, and particular short term projects. Not to mention where the "permanent" jobs simply aren't popular and never get many applications, or where there are seasonalities.

We've come a long way from the old days when everyone worked fixed regular hours in "jobs for life". Nowadays, huge swathes of the employment market are flexible.

Unfortunately, the tax rules aren't keeping up with the modern working life, hence stupid damaging rules like IR35 which arose in 2000 because of stupid damaging employment rules in the 90s, and so it goes on.

Of course, not helped by Gordon Brown encouraging people to set up limited companies with all the tax breaks he created in the early noughties which only applied to limited companies, so caused huge numbers of sole trader window cleaners, electricians, dog walkers, etc to convert to limited companies!

Woeismethischristmas · 12/10/2021 13:31

I’ve said this before but top whack for HGV drivers is 12.50 where I am, awful hours, crappy conditions sleeping in the truck etc. They need to pay better money. Obviously don’t want to increase wages for existing staff so offering 1-3k joining/retention bonus.

takenforgrantednana · 12/10/2021 13:25

[quote mikedyson]@takenforgrantednana

Cpc is 35 hours over five years isn’t it?

It’s odd they haven’t dropped the driver CPC now at least for UK drivers as it was an EU requirement.[/quote]
no thats not quite right, once you have already done the cpc and passed you then have a further 5 years to do to keep it up to date, so its an ongoing expense, the original cpc will cost approx £500 and in my case i also need a photo drivers licence (30) a medical (£200) digi tacho card (£30) so i would need £750 before i even applied for any work which is money i havent got

forinborin · 12/10/2021 13:22

Why do employers not want permanent staff?
Surely that is the problem not HMRCs rules?

No, it is quite normal. There are many projects at all skill levels where hiring permanent staff just does not make a lot of sense. From seasonal work, to one-off restructuring / innovation projects. Also, not all workers necessarily want permanent jobs either - when my children were smaller, I preferred working at 200% pay for 6 months (even though the projects were very intense) instead of at 100% pay for 12 months. Some people just like the constant change of environment and new challenges, know a couple like that.

It was a fair trade before, both for employer and the employee. Now I am paying roughly the same overall tax as before (not paying corporate tax anymore, instead paying a slightly higher income tax and NI), but additionally also paying the employer's taxes and the profit margin (that goes to private pockets). Nothing else has changed - I am still expected to provide my own tools of trade, in my case - pay for software licenses / professional membership fees / training and certification as unpaid time etc. Holidays, maternity, sick leave are all limited to statutory minimum / calculated based off min wage.

I'd be really interested to see the dry financial analysis of how successful IR35 has been once the dust settles. From my perspective I can only see a complete shitstorm that does not actually lead to higher overall tax revenues (well, on a very limited sample of me and a couple other contractors I know).

VanGoghsDog · 12/10/2021 13:16

Why do employers not want permanent staff?

Endless reasons. Seasonal work, short term projects, cover maternity/other types of leave, need a specific skill but only for a short time, restructuring, rapid growth, problems recruiting.... honestly, there are so many reasons!

My current role, ironically, only exists because of Covid.

VanGoghsDog · 12/10/2021 13:13

[quote user1497207191]**@ExtraOnions* Wanting all the tax breaks of being self employed, with none of the risk*

Self employment has fundamental inherent risks, such as lack of entitlements to holiday pay, statutory sick/maternity pay, lack of rights for statutory redundancy/notice periods, etc. The whole point of self employment is the "risk" of being let go at short/no notice, with no employment protections.

Just look at covid - that shows the "risk", i.e. the vast majority of self employed using their own companies will have received minimal covid support grants, so that's another massive financial hit which proves the inherent risk that they bear.

But beyond that, they're often required to provide their own professional indemnity and other insurances, pay for their own training and licences and health examinations, etc.[/quote]
I got nothing, because I work in a mix of self employed and employed roles, short term. Tax year 19/20 I was employed. Dec 20 started a contract role, was due to be until July, then in Feb they were talking about extending to Dec, then in May they terminated due to Covid cancelling a number of projects. As I had not submitted self employed income in the previous tax year there was no grant for me. And as I was not employed by anyone (I had chosen not to employ myself via my Ltd co and took no salary) I could not claim furlough.

Luckily, I am aware that this model has risks and I have savings to cover downtime, plus I do separate consultancy work, and got a new role in September. But it does show the risks people who work on contracts take.

Clymene · 12/10/2021 13:11

I can't answer for everyone @jgw1 but for me it's because I provide a specialist service which companies don't need full time.

I don't want to work full time because I have caring commitments which means full time work doesn't work very well for me. Those caring commitments obviously are things that are taking some of the burden off the state. But there is no joined up thinking.

VanGoghsDog · 12/10/2021 13:03

@GurtBusty

"IR35 came in April.

I think you've misunderstood that graph"

I think you've misunderstood IR35 - it became law in 2000. It has been around a long time.

What changed in April 2021 was that in the private sector, the client became responsible for determining the employment status of the worker. This change happened earlier in the public sector (2017)

I absolutely have not misunderstood IR35, it's part of my job. I was (quite clearly) talking about the changes this year which is what this thread is about. They point being "April" if you look at what I was responding to.

I don't have any skin in the game here so there's no need to correct me, I was just pointing out that the point that poster thought they were making about that graph didn't make sense and that it looked as if they had misunderstood the graph.

jgw1 · 12/10/2021 12:58

@forinborin

I am very confused. The article that the OP linked to seemed to indicate that lorry drivers were leaving because being directly employed meant a pay cut. Are you saying the article is wrong? Let me use my own example, not sure how it works with the haulage industry (I am in IT/finance). I am now employed not by my own limited company, but by an "umbrella" that additionally takes a ~10% margin from my gross pay for their services. The very reason why clients use contractors is because they don't want permanent staff, so that hasn't changed. I still have zero employment protection - I am on min wage with the umbrella, zero hours, and my actual net pay is paid to me as a "bonus" every month. In addition, they take their NI and compulsory pension contributions (their duty as an employer) from my gross pay. Any of my holidays are paid on min wage. And the HMRC warns me that I am responsible to ensure that this umbrella company is actually paying the correct amount of tax in my name, and not using any dodgy schemes.

So yes, had I been employed like a "normal" employee, yes it probably would be marginally more beneficial net (assuming the same gross, which is never the case). The issue is that I am still not a "normal" employee, I am paying the employers contributions too, as well as the intermediary's profit margin.

Quite honestly, this looks like the contractors loan scheme scandal in the making all over again.

Why do employers not want permanent staff?

Surely that is the problem not HMRCs rules?

Jangle33 · 12/10/2021 12:51

YANBU OP. It’s hit a lot of industries hard.

A bit of foresight from the government given Brexit and Covid would not have gone amiss.

Lot of companies are taking a risk averse stance but it’s not surprising given the huge admin burden involved.

mikedyson · 12/10/2021 12:51

This. I don't have much sympathy with the IR35 bleating, whatever the sector.
Fine, just don’t bleat about supply chain issues or IT problems.

OP posts:
mikedyson · 12/10/2021 12:49

@takenforgrantednana

Cpc is 35 hours over five years isn’t it?

It’s odd they haven’t dropped the driver CPC now at least for UK drivers as it was an EU requirement.

OP posts:
forinborin · 12/10/2021 12:48

I am very confused. The article that the OP linked to seemed to indicate that lorry drivers were leaving because being directly employed meant a pay cut. Are you saying the article is wrong?
Let me use my own example, not sure how it works with the haulage industry (I am in IT/finance). I am now employed not by my own limited company, but by an "umbrella" that additionally takes a ~10% margin from my gross pay for their services. The very reason why clients use contractors is because they don't want permanent staff, so that hasn't changed. I still have zero employment protection - I am on min wage with the umbrella, zero hours, and my actual net pay is paid to me as a "bonus" every month. In addition, they take their NI and compulsory pension contributions (their duty as an employer) from my gross pay. Any of my holidays are paid on min wage. And the HMRC warns me that I am responsible to ensure that this umbrella company is actually paying the correct amount of tax in my name, and not using any dodgy schemes.

So yes, had I been employed like a "normal" employee, yes it probably would be marginally more beneficial net (assuming the same gross, which is never the case). The issue is that I am still not a "normal" employee, I am paying the employers contributions too, as well as the intermediary's profit margin.

Quite honestly, this looks like the contractors loan scheme scandal in the making all over again.

takenforgrantednana · 12/10/2021 12:34

@jgw1

Ironically, they'd pay less tax if they were employed directly by the haulage firms as then the haulage firm would be responsible for the employers NIC, apprentice levies and other "employment" costs.

I am very confused. The article that the OP linked to seemed to indicate that lorry drivers were leaving because being directly employed meant a pay cut. Are you saying the article is wrong?

the article is totally wrong! they are not leaving because of the tax situtation, they are leaving because of how they are treated, the pay they get, the conditions they have to work under, until you have done the job you will never understand what it is like. even prisoners cells are bigger than the cabs we had to sleep in and live in! you try sleeping/ relaxing/cooking/dressing/washing in the space of your average family bath tub! for 5 nights a week
jgw1 · 12/10/2021 12:17

Ironically, they'd pay less tax if they were employed directly by the haulage firms as then the haulage firm would be responsible for the employers NIC, apprentice levies and other "employment" costs.

I am very confused. The article that the OP linked to seemed to indicate that lorry drivers were leaving because being directly employed meant a pay cut. Are you saying the article is wrong?

takenforgrantednana · 12/10/2021 11:45

[quote mikedyson]As this well researched (for once) article in the i points out =

inews.co.uk/news/hgv-driver-shortage-tax-change-ir35-lorry-crisis-uk-europe-1239313?ito=email_share_article-top[/quote]
absolute rubbish, coming from an ex hgv 1 driver! i can give you many many reasons why drivers are leaving, and the only time any of us bring up the tax issue is the fact that once again we are treated unfairly with the payment for having to sleep out in the truck being taxed yet a sale rep getting a proper hotel bed paid for by the company doesnt pay any tax on that at all.

the one main reason that drivers are leaving is down to the cpc requirements, like with me i simply cant afford to do it. i cant get a job without it and i cant afford to do the course without a job!

add to that the conditions we work under and are forced to live in it would take a lot more than £70k to get me to go back and risk my life for very little gratitude

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 12/10/2021 11:43

@jgw1

So, haulage companies and hgv drivers were trying to dodge tax and national insurance and now they can't. Might it not make more sense for the haulage companies simply to pay employees properly?
This. I don't have much sympathy with the IR35 bleating, whatever the sector.
user1497207191 · 12/10/2021 11:42

At the end of the day, HMRC needs to sort out the tax system as it's not fit for purpose. It's crazy that someone self employed as a sole trader has a different set of tax rules (relieves, rates, etc) compared to an identical self employed person operating as a limited company doing the exact same work. Yet, as each government comes and goes, as each Treasury minister comes and goes, they make it worse, not better with their continual faffing around the edges rather than actually addressing the inherent issues.

Swipe left for the next trending thread