Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby clothes - strange

62 replies

Chocchoc88 · 11/10/2021 18:45

Friend told me this story and I’m confused and pissed off for her! A mutual friend of ours dropped off a big bag of baby clothes (some new, with tags, some not) a while back saying ‘your baby is bigger than mine so the clothes will fit them sooner, do you want them?’ My friend said yeah, accepted and took the bag off her. Fast forward a few months and our mutual friend is now asking for the bag of clothes back, saying ‘my baby will fit into them now, can I have them back?’ My friend is worried that she’s just mixed all the clothes in the wardrobe and drawers together etc and has to now try and remember what was in the bag and give it all back.

YABU - my mate should have kept the clothes to one side and given them back when asked
YANBU - she’s right to feel uncomfortable about it and it is a bit strange?

OP posts:
JLQ1020 · 11/10/2021 21:29

Nah its odd. My sister has given me baby stuff but has said she woukd like it back when (if) she falls pregnant again which is reasonable.. I think if she wanted it back she should have made it clear.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/10/2021 21:25

*typo or autocorrect

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/10/2021 21:23

I think 'die' was a very unfortunate typo and should have said 'fit'.

Yeah the stairgate is weird, I scrolled back to what she originally said when she was giving it away and she said ‘free to a good home if anyone wants it!’ So again, really nice thing to do but nothing about it being a temporary loan

It's very odd to give away something that you would normally expect to last for months, if not years - rather than clothes which are only of use for a limited time. Wouldn't you normally query somebody with a tiny baby giving away baby/toddler things that she would need very soon - at a time when most parents are starting to gather them, though?!

Gardenista · 11/10/2021 21:09

I don’t think this is strange at all - the original lender was very generous to lend the clothes out before her own baby used them - but baby clothes get used for a matter of weeks/months so it’s sensible to not be wasteful and kind to lend new things.
I’m past the baby clothes stage but my daughter revives lots of books as gifts that are too old for her . I happily lend them to her older friends brand new - they will only be read once BUT I would be upset if not returned to me for her to use in her time. I also lend out good quality hand me downs we have been gifted but are too big and would like them back for our turn - party dresses/ waterproof trousers etc - they can be used for several children so why wouldn’t you? If someone complained to me that it was too much trouble to keep track of who gave what then I absolutely wouldn’t lend again - by lending you are saving them a lot of money. If you don’t appreciate it either refuse or leave in a bag unused and return in a few months.

Noeuf · 11/10/2021 21:02

Wait, is this a reverse ? It’s so obvious the clothes were on loan…

SickAndTiredAgain · 11/10/2021 20:57

A mutual friend of ours dropped off a big bag of baby clothes (some new, with tags, some not) a while back saying ‘your baby is bigger than mine so the clothes will fit them sooner, do you want them?’

I think this comment makes it clear that she wanted them back once they fit her baby.

MyMabel · 11/10/2021 20:56

Me and SIL do this with our children, she passes them to me from her eldest, my DD wears them, then I pass them back for her youngest to go through.

Tbh, I can never remember what she did and didn’t have, so I bag up everything that no longer fits DD, mine and hers included and we’ve agreed to keep what we like and sell and split the money form what gets sold. Works for us Smile

ittakes2 · 11/10/2021 20:54

It sounded to me like they were on loan until her baby grew. I would have then put a mark on the label. my sister swaps clothes with another mother. They have three children each and the clothes go back and forth depending on ages.

Coffeey · 11/10/2021 20:40

Stairgate is really weird

AwkwardPaws27 · 11/10/2021 20:29

Maybe your friend could just give her all the clothes her baby has outgrown (apart from any special outfits she wants to keep)? That way nothing goes to waste & it saves the stress of sitting through it all - unless she is planing another soon?

Bonnytoon · 11/10/2021 20:19

@AwaAnBileYerHeid

To me, "your baby is bigger than mine so the clothes will fit them sooner" sounds as though she's saying 'do you want to use them first before my baby?'. I would therefore assume that she wanted them back after your friends baby had used them.
Agree with this post.
Chocchoc88 · 11/10/2021 20:14

@Fraine she is bundling them up and giving them back (or what she can at least). I don’t know what you’re talking about about ‘if she knew her friends baby was going to die’ - what are you on about?

OP posts:
Sparklybanana · 11/10/2021 20:06

I would get annoyed and say if I knew she wanted them back then I would have said no or at least kept them separate- and no you can't have the stair gate back until we've finished with it as you didn't give the strong impression you were giving away. I would have just bought one had I known so we wouldn't end up with loads of different holes in the wall.
I've given away stuff and leant stuff and the latter I've made it abundantly clear that I'm expecting it back.

Noeuf · 11/10/2021 20:02

Sorry I’m usually of the opinion you give stuff and lose it, but honestly ‘giving friend’s’ baby had never worn this stuff. Why did your friend think her mate was giving her a load of clothes she’d never used? Did your mate think the friend was just going to go out and replace them all?

ChateauMargaux · 11/10/2021 20:01

Re clothes: has her baby now grown out of the clothes? If so then it's no big deal if she gives a bag of clothes back the other friend and a few others slip in. (Is she planning on having more children or would she be passing on all outgrown clothing anyway? The answer would determine whether she will need to try to remember roughly what quantity was in the bag or just be generous)

It is a weird thing to do though..

As for the baby gate... she should scroll back and reference the original message.. and say, Jill, when you offered the baby gate free to a good home, I presumed it would be ok to fit it to the wall.. but heh ho.. no stress, give me a few days to get a new one and I will bring yours round. Junior is climbing on everything these days!!

LettertoHermoine · 11/10/2021 20:00

Never heard of this before. Why not just keep them until your own child fits into them rather than giving them away, letting another child wear them and then asking for them back? Unless the other friend he gave them to was in dire need of baby clothes, this does not make any sense. I am going with weird as fuck.

Fraine · 11/10/2021 19:56

@Chocchoc88

Oh and another thing she’s just told me. Mutual friend also asked us all if anybody wanted a baby gate, my friend said yeah she will have it if it’s going? And she’s asked for that back too now? My friend has it fitted at the bottom of her stairs
Yes she needs to give it back, given the clothes fiasco.
Fraine · 11/10/2021 19:55

I think your friend is BU.

If she knew her friend’s baby was going to die in then in a few months time then she shops have made a note / taken pics of those clothes with a view to giving them back.

She doesn’t need to feel uncomfortable or strange, she should just attempt to gather up as many of those clothes as possible and give them back.

Chocchoc88 · 11/10/2021 19:53

Yeah the stairgate is weird, I scrolled back to what she originally said when she was giving it away and she said ‘free to a good home if anyone wants it!’ So again, really nice thing to do but nothing about it being a temporary loan

OP posts:
Chocchoc88 · 11/10/2021 19:51

Oh not ‘anger’ more just bewildered! I’m new to the world of mums so I wasn’t sure if that was a common thing. Yeah, I’m sure it was a nice thing do, I’m not saying it wasn’t. But I’m trying to imagine if someone left a bag of stuff with me, and said here do you want this? I’d go, yeah sure, then I’d pick out the bits I’d like and would want etc and then donate the rest perhaps? To me she’s given them, with no mention of wanting them back - and that’s the bit I’m talking about really

OP posts:
NigellaSeed · 11/10/2021 19:50

Never heard if this. If she had to keep track of these clothes amongst all the other clothes, hat seems like a problem not a gift.

I would only hand things down, not up Confused

geojellyfish · 11/10/2021 19:44

The baby gate is weird though!

geojellyfish · 11/10/2021 19:43

But you describe yourself as feeling pissed off, which implies anger with the mutual friend, who by the sounds of it, thought she was doing a nice thing?

Chocchoc88 · 11/10/2021 19:43

Oh and another thing she’s just told me. Mutual friend also asked us all if anybody wanted a baby gate, my friend said yeah she will have it if it’s going? And she’s asked for that back too now? My friend has it fitted at the bottom of her stairs

OP posts:
Chocchoc88 · 11/10/2021 19:39

Because she’s now going through all her baby’s stuff panicking and I feel for her as a mate as that’s stressful

OP posts: