Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should giant held-back-a-year child be allowed to play rugby out of year group?

172 replies

Onthetrain75 · 11/10/2021 17:40

There is a child in my son’s year 7 who would technically be a year 8 but has been held back for academic reasons. He’s a sturdy big child, I would say around 5ft 6 and 10 stone.

He’s a keen rugby player and is playing down a year to be with his class mates. But I’ve heard rumblings from other schools that parents aren’t happy he is playing under 12s when he should be under 13. Mostly I think they are concerned about safety of the other kids though I think they probably would also prefer the scores if he didn’t play.

I don’t know whether to say anything to his mum about the bad feeling that I know this is causing. What do you think?

YANBU - let him play with his mates
YABU - given his size and age he should be playing under 13s.

OP posts:
HireStarter · 11/10/2021 19:53

And the FA are changing their rulings over this. As more kids join different cohorts clubs are loosening up on the rules (as they should).

Age is arbitrary. If anything, they should go by size.

Murraysmum · 11/10/2021 19:52

5'6" doesn't sound particularly giant for year 7. My son hit 6ft at year 8 and is now in year 11 and is 6ft 4 and still growing. I personally would say nothing.

HireStarter · 11/10/2021 19:52

Whats the problem? Is age or size?

Would you make a large kid in the correct cohort play in the year above?

Or a small child play in the year below?

They should give over and let him play with his friends. If it's a health and safety issue then the coach should raise it with the child's parents.

RestingPandaFace · 11/10/2021 19:52

At this age kids vary so much in size so it probably does t matter too much, but as a principle in a school team he should play by age group not year group.

GrouchyKiwi · 11/10/2021 19:50

@Porcupineintherough

In more enlightened rugby playing countries they sort players by height and weight rather than age for precisely this reason. I wouldn't say anything to his mum but neither would I be happy about my child playing against him if he were much smaller and lighter - but Id take that up with the school.
Yes, exactly this. It's beneficial all around: safer for the smaller children, develops skills better because you're playing against like, and a better competition since there's not that one massive child to boulder down the rest of the team.

It's one reason why NZ is so far ahead of other countries with regards to rugby skills and depth.

Standrewsschool · 11/10/2021 19:49

If he has an August birthday, then he may be closer in age to the September born children in the year below than those born in the follow summer.

My db has a late August birthday. One of his best friends was over 11 months older than him, both in the same school year.

HermioneAndRoger · 11/10/2021 19:49

@PiesNotGuys

The three male family members or friends of mine who are male and 12-13yo are 6’3, 6’3 and 5’10

They all tower over me. Why would 5’6 be considered a problem?

A 13-year-old boy measuring 167cm / 5ft 6in is on the 91st centile for height. A boy on the 99.6th centile of the same age would be 176cm, or 5ft9. A 13-year-old at 190cm is an exceptionally unusual outlier.
Helenluvsrob · 11/10/2021 19:47

Helm have to pay his age group out of school anyway and that’s not an exceptional size. My January birthday son was 5 foot 7 on leaving primary

AyeAyeMister · 11/10/2021 19:44

I'm also curious about the circumstances as I've never heard of a child in the UK being held back a year for academic reasons.
But anyway. 5'6" and 10 stone is not unusual for a year 7. My DS was shocked when he got to secondary and saw how huge some of the other boys (and girls) were. They all grow at different rates there's a huge height / weight range over the first few years of secondary. In DS's footy team, the small kids are chest height to the taller ones Shock

saraclara · 11/10/2021 19:42

No you shouldn't warn the mum. If you know there are rumblings (or you genuinely think there's a safety issue) then suggest that the rumbling parents contact the coach and reference the safety concerns.

If you're not one of the rumbling parents, then just keep your nose out.

flippertyop · 11/10/2021 19:41

He should play in his age group absolutely. There are age groups for a reason. His intelligence levels are irrelevant

MadeOfStarStuff · 11/10/2021 19:39

Obviously for things like PE it’s done in classes so difficult for him to join another group he’s the right age for.

But for playing on a team it should be purely by age. Yes there are kids of all shapes and sizes within an age group but that’s life. What’s not fair is a child who’s a year older, bigger and stronger playing against younger children

But you can’t speak to his mum, what do you expect her to say?! If you’re concerned raise it with whoever organises the team, if you have a child who’s affected.

SoupDragon · 11/10/2021 19:39

@2boys21

How can you have am under 12s team but also an under 13s team? Maybe I have misunderstood. I have never heard of a child being held back a year either even if they are behind
"U12" basically means "the season in which you turn 12"

You can play up a year but not down.

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 11/10/2021 19:35

I strongly suspect that the OP has got her facts wrong here. If that is not the case then yes I feel that she should approach the school/ club as the rules are very clear that this is not allowed. (Any competent PE teacher should know this.)

HermioneAndRoger · 11/10/2021 19:33

If he’s U13 he shouldn’t be playing with U12s. I don’t see that it’s your place to tell his mother unless you are the coach, in which case you should have enforced the rules long ago.

Regardless it will resolve itself; the rumblings will simply turn into open challenge. It’s not unheard of for coaches to carry proof of age for unusually big children who are nevertheless playing in the correct category.

silverbubbles · 11/10/2021 19:32

I would leave this to the coaches - they will be aware of the issues

SoupDragon · 11/10/2021 19:32

If he's under 13 still then of course he can play - it's split by age, not year group.

Y7 is U12 I think. Which this boy isn't as he is a year too old - you yourself said "it's split by age not year group".

Gwrach · 11/10/2021 19:30

There's probably a few inches and a few kg different between him and the biggest boy in year 7 to be honest

Rugby although a contact sport and physical once they get to puberty it's like a pick and mix, who's sprouting, who's putting on weight who isn't and before you know it they are all 18+ and in the men's team where your winger is about 1.7m and 80kg and your tighthead prop is 1.9m and 126kg.

Just the way it is.

PiesNotGuys · 11/10/2021 19:30

The three male family members or friends of mine who are male and 12-13yo are 6’3, 6’3 and 5’10

They all tower over me. Why would 5’6 be considered a problem?

Barbie222 · 11/10/2021 19:29

Is he 12, or 13? That would seem to be the deciding factor on whether you play in an under -12s match.

SoupDragon · 11/10/2021 19:29

What's the relevance that he's been held back a year?

He is a year too old for the team.

Children the same age come in all shapes and sizes.

He is not the same age.

gogohm · 11/10/2021 19:28

Dd played, we had to provide a copy of her passport to prove her age. You can't play in the wrong year group for inter school or club

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 11/10/2021 19:28

It’s a shame for him but it’s about the other children’s safety. Otherwise they could just play in ability groups rather than age groups.

Toooldforthis321 · 11/10/2021 19:25

What's the relevance that he's been held back a year?

Children the same age come in all shapes and sizes.

I'd leave the poor mum alone to be honest. She probably has enough in life to deal with, without you describing her son as 'giant' and thinking that him being held back a year is relevant to this.

ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 11/10/2021 19:23

''Held back for academic reasons' is unusual in the state system, unless he is an August born and was permitted to defer back in Reception.'

Maybe this is true of the state schools in England, but it's perfectly normal and common in the state schools of Scotland for children within 3 months of the age boundary to be invited to stay back a year and develop their maturity. We prefer our children to be five, or very close to it before they start school.