Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that in the UK we love to hate rich people?

194 replies

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 11/10/2021 17:18

Looking at a few threads here it seems that there is a definite trend that sees a lot of us in the UK loving to hate rich people. Why is that? Why do we resent them? Sure, I'd love to have lots of money and not need to worry but I don't resent those who do have it.

And yet there is so much vitriol on MN directed at people with money. Odd when without their tax money we'd be in a lot of trouble... Enlighten me please. Because I'm almost embarrassed IRL to admit I'd actually love to be rich!

OP posts:
ojojojoja · 12/10/2021 10:04

I don't think its hatred, it's more that there's such stark inequality in this country. You're either a have or a have not, for example getting on the housing ladder in many parts of the country virtually impossible unless you have a highly paid job and rich parents / inheritance. Instead you're forced to rent at a much higher rate than a mortgage would ever cost. Making money is much easier when you have money to start with. It's really skewed towards the rich. So people don't always feel comfortable with it. Also there's a lot of snobbery against poor people or people who rent or whatever.

Poppitt58 · 12/10/2021 10:04

I’d rather live in a society with higher wages, higher taxes and excellent public services rather than a society that has low wages for the poorest and massive wages, bonuses etc for the richest.

It upsets me that someone who works full time can’t afford to heat their home, or access basic services such as consistent medical treatment due to absolutely brutal cuts.

Blossomtoes · 12/10/2021 10:02

@mustlovegin

If their work is selling, someone appreciates it

The taxpayers are lumbered with monstrosities like these and we have to pay for the privilege. It's scandalous what people call 'art' these days.

But probably that rant is for another thread Grin

So it’s only public art you have an issue with? It’s interesting that you chose such an obviously problematic example.
onlychildhamster · 12/10/2021 10:00

@fournonblondes I wouldn't say its not right but unearned wealth to me irritates me but money through having a good education/working your way up the corporate ladder/setting up your own business doesn't. I guess cos there was some effort involved in the latter! Unless you are Gaddafi's son, you actually have to write your thesis!

I am privileged in the sense that even though my parents didn't give me any money post university and will never give me any money, my MIL let me stay rent free in her house but I did have to work hard to save the money unlike DH's friends who lived rent free in their parents' houses plus their parents funded their deposits.

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 12/10/2021 09:58

*OP, landlords don't provide housing. They stockpile it. This prevents other people from buying a home.

Rich people stockpile money and resources. It's taking the money and resources out of circulation that's the killer.

The movie In Time illustrates why we hate the rich. They cause poverty by stockpiling.*

Completely agree. Thanks for the film recommendation @SoundBar, haven't seen it but will look it up.

fournonblondes · 12/10/2021 09:54

@ all onlychildhamster if somebody give you the money for your deposit I guess you will say not right?

mustlovegin · 12/10/2021 09:53

onlychildhamster watch out, you will be vilified for your 'privilege' or something

mustlovegin · 12/10/2021 09:51

If their work is selling, someone appreciates it

The taxpayers are lumbered with monstrosities like these and we have to pay for the privilege. It's scandalous what people call 'art' these days.

But probably that rant is for another thread Grin

CounsellorTroi · 12/10/2021 09:50

Of course we haven't shaken off class in this society. I was taught that class is only a matter of money. I don't know if I agree.

If class was only a matter of money the term “nouveau riche” would never have come into existence.

onlychildhamster · 12/10/2021 09:49

How would you define rich?

For me, it's someone who has at least £1 million in wealth excluding their place of residence.

I have rich parents but they worked their way up from nothing (not through exploiting people; mum is senior management in an investment bank and she worked her way up from a trainee accountant at Big 4; dad was an engineer who formed a partnership with his ex boss and they develop properties together with the seed capital ex boss provided; I think they were lucky in some respects i.e. having parents who did all their childcare for them so they could work lots). So I don't hate rich people per se but people like the Duke of Westminster who never worked for their wealth do irritate me. Just like I guess people whose parents gave them deposits for their london houses do irritate me when I had to save up for my flat

Blossomtoes · 12/10/2021 09:43

@mustlovegin

You don’t think art contributes to society? How incredibly depressing

I'm depressed to see so many self-proclaimed 'artists' charging extortionate fees for what some call 'art' today - see below

www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/7561904/glasgow-festival-park-legs-raped/

Also some 'art galleries' today and their 'exhibitions' take the p**s

If their work is selling, someone appreciates it. It’s ridiculously hard to make a living from selling your art. I’m hugely impressed by someone with the guts and determination to do it. Whether you like it or not is immaterial.
mustlovegin · 12/10/2021 09:40

You don’t think art contributes to society? How incredibly depressing

I'm depressed to see so many self-proclaimed 'artists' charging extortionate fees for what some call 'art' today - see below

www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/7561904/glasgow-festival-park-legs-raped/

Also some 'art galleries' today and their 'exhibitions' take the p**s

vivainsomnia · 12/10/2021 09:38

And yet there is so much vitriol on MN directed at people with money
MN is not the UK, far from it.

There is a difference between the very rich and those who just do well, but still need to make choices and watch their spend to some extend.

Sadly, the two are often put into the same box. The resentment towards landlords, IE. those clearly rich enough to be able to afford another property, even when this might be an inherited asset and make little income is quite astonishing.

Also hate the inevitable assumption that those who do well have just had everything handed to them rather than through choices and sacrifices that those not as well off didn't want to make despite the same opportunities.

DogsandCatsB4u · 12/10/2021 09:31

They take the piss out the poor once they made it

Isitsixoclockalready · 12/10/2021 09:27

@InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest

Looking at a few threads here it seems that there is a definite trend that sees a lot of us in the UK loving to hate rich people. Why is that? Why do we resent them? Sure, I'd love to have lots of money and not need to worry but I don't resent those who do have it.

And yet there is so much vitriol on MN directed at people with money. Odd when without their tax money we'd be in a lot of trouble... Enlighten me please. Because I'm almost embarrassed IRL to admit I'd actually love to be rich!

I think that this is way too much of a generalisation.
Blossomtoes · 12/10/2021 09:24

@mustlovegin

But there's more ways to contribute to society than financially, it's just that many people don't see there's any worth in that

It depends on the so called 'contribution'.

If it's a dodgy 'artist' or someone spouting divisive 'ideologies' I would say there's no worth at all.

If it's a nurse, key worker, etc, of course what they do is valuable

You don’t think art contributes to society? How incredibly depressing.
Maverickess · 12/10/2021 09:23

@mustlovegin

But there's more ways to contribute to society than financially, it's just that many people don't see there's any worth in that

It depends on the so called 'contribution'.

If it's a dodgy 'artist' or someone spouting divisive 'ideologies' I would say there's no worth at all.

If it's a nurse, key worker, etc, of course what they do is valuable

That's the rub isn't it though? They're all lumped into the same group because of their financial worth.
mustlovegin · 12/10/2021 09:15

But there's more ways to contribute to society than financially, it's just that many people don't see there's any worth in that

It depends on the so called 'contribution'.

If it's a dodgy 'artist' or someone spouting divisive 'ideologies' I would say there's no worth at all.

If it's a nurse, key worker, etc, of course what they do is valuable

Maverickess · 12/10/2021 09:00

Surely we want contributing members of society?

Yes we do. But there's more ways to contribute to society than financially, it's just that many people don't see there's any worth in that, to the point where people contributing in this way are told they're lazy, uninspired and make the wrong choices, despite the fact that their contribution makes a huge difference.
That and people know when they're being exploited, and they speak up about it, and others don't want to hear it because it may well expose flaws in themselves and the attitude that money is all, that it's the only thing or contribution that matters and the measuring stick by which a good or bad person should be measured.

amusedtodeath1 · 12/10/2021 02:55

I don't think it's that people hate the rich in general, specific rich people who because they have money think they're better than everyone else, yes, but that's because of their attitude.

I think it's more that people are angry that the system is so clearly not working for so many.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/10/2021 01:52

It's impossible to become rich without exploiting the labour of people poorer

By and large, I think that's true, but there are significant exceptions.

I always think that it's not having the money or enjoying/making use of it that's the problem - it's when you get to the point of worshiping it, obsessing over it, thinking it's the only mark of your (and by extension, everybody else's) worth or lack thereof - that's when it really becomes pointless.

By way of analogy, we're not on a water meter - it's rateable (band B) value, so this means that we could take thousands of Olympic-sized swimming pools-worth of water each day. But, guess what: we have no need for more than the tiniest micro-fraction of that, so there would be no point or benefit in our taking it anyway and stockpiling it; thus we take what we need and ignore all the rest that we don't need.

I think the saddest thing about most of the mega rich is that their money consumes their whole life and, instead of being a tool to make it nicer and easier, it becomes its purpose. A poor person worries intensely about where they can get the extra £20 they need for new school shoes or to put the heating on when it's freezing (I've certainly been there); but ironically, so many multi-millionaires and billionaires will spend much of their lives protecting what they have, fretting about investments, growth, capital share, maintaining their position in next year's ST Rich List etc. - so in one way of looking at it - their sense of inner peace - they aren't even any better off than those with barely anything.

Whatever the source of their wealth, it's largely their attitude to it that matters and, indeed, how they treat their employees and others much poorer than them (as well as paying their FAIR dues - not just what their accountants can get away with). Mike Ashley and John Timpson are both very rich men; I'm not saying that either of them is perfect, but my opinions of them both could barely be wider apart.

BasicDad · 12/10/2021 01:34

@savvy7

The system is broken. The government should have brought in a higher tax band instead of increasing Ni across the board. But then they receive lots of donations from wealthy billionaires and the like.
Why would wealthy billionaires lobby and donate to avoid a higher tax band that would never affect them in the slightest anyway?
DinosaurDuvet · 12/10/2021 00:05

When I see people do well for themselves I’m happy for them and I use it as motivation to try better myself 🤷🏼‍♀️

SoundBar · 11/10/2021 23:47

OP, landlords don't provide housing. They stockpile it. This prevents other people from buying a home.

Rich people stockpile money and resources. It's taking the money and resources out of circulation that's the killer.

The movie In Time illustrates why we hate the rich. They cause poverty by stockpiling.

thefourgp · 11/10/2021 23:46

I agree with what you said @LaetitiaASD

I also think a person’s health and the health of their family has a huge impact on their lives which directly impacts their ability to earn money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread