Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please tell me I did the right thing not giving change to this man.

207 replies

Kaceya2230 · 11/10/2021 13:58

I've heard many times that people have had other people approach them in the street asking for money for a train fair or what not and often it's a scam. Never experienced it myself until today... possibly!

In a town centre, I popped into boots and I noticed a man sitting on the bench outside. I only took notice because he had a super cute dog with him. The guy looked pretty normal. As I left the shop he asked if I could help him - he was £2 short on a train fair and asked if I could spare a pound. I said no I'm sorry I don't carry change.

I did have change but in my purse I had money from my grandma for something. Some money for other things. I was worried if I opened it and he seen the notes I had I may be a target. I don't actually usually carry any cash but today I did have some on me for once!

But he was really nice. He just saying okay thank you and I went on with my day. He wasn't persistent or pressuring. Have I just ruined someone's day by not giving him any money?

To add the train station is quite a distance from where he was sat down so didn't sound convincing.

Would you have given change?

OP posts:
SpiderinaWingMirror · 11/10/2021 16:43

Nah.
My sister had a boyfriend back in the day who did that, amongst many other similar things. Bus/train/ etc
Bloody scam. Give money to homeless charity instead.

BoredZelda · 11/10/2021 16:43

Meh. I’d have given him it. If someone is short of change it helps them out, if they are desperate enough that this is their only option for cash, it helps them out.

You can decide for yourself whether you do or not.

Ijustreallywantacat · 11/10/2021 16:42

I most often don't have actual change with me, but I'll give people the odd few pound and donate to Shelter and Pathway. There's a lovely lady who sells the Big Issue in Paddington.

I know the theory that it does more harm than good, but ĺI'm a bleeding hearted liberal. I feel awful walking past holding £2 in my hand when someone could be so desperately in need - I'd probably just spend it on a Costa.

AGreenerShadeofKale · 11/10/2021 16:38

I've given people small amounts of money when it's obvious for m being behind the in the queue that they have just realised they haven't got quite enough, or need to pay for the loo or in the old days when they'd ask for change for the phone and offer you the pound.
This is none of those things.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 11/10/2021 16:38

I just think if it's genuine then I've helped someone get home, and if it's not then what does it really matter? The person is still usually desperate and it doesn't harm me to handle over a couple of quid

This ^^

I remember the look of relief and gratitude when I gave the man the loose change from my pocket, and the way he thanked me so whole heartedly.

It didn’t really matter at that point whether he needed it to get the bus home, or to buy a coffee, or to put some change in his heating meter. The fact is he needed a handful of 20p coins I didn’t need, and I was able to help him out of whatever tight spot he was in.

It’s highly likely he needed it for a bus, but it was also a bitterly cold winter’s day. If he spent it on a hot drink or soup or used it towards something that made his day feel a bit less awful, I don’t think anyone should judge.

LittleMysSister · 11/10/2021 16:36

@Kaceya2230 You can never really tell but if it's a matter of pennies or a few pound coins that the giver can afford, does it really matter?

AGreenerShadeofKale · 11/10/2021 16:35

It used to be 20p for the bus.
That's inflation for you.

Kaceya2230 · 11/10/2021 16:34

@Upsky

I always keep a few coins in my pocket for rough sleepers and buskers. I just think they are all someone's son or daughter.
How can you honestly tell? High homeless rate in said town, those who sleep in shop doors are harmless, never beg, never expect anything and I would happily give to them. Yet this guy did not give the impression he was homeless (who knows though)!
OP posts:
Hoolihan · 11/10/2021 16:32

@VladmirsPoutine agree. People trying to convince themselves that beggars are all scammers or have homes to go to or are 'undeserving' are just looking for excuses for that fact that they don't care/do nothing/look the other way/vote Tory. Its the 'could never happen to me' crowd who also think that families visiting food banks have never heard of lentils and people on benefits shouldn't have have a telly.

Kaceya2230 · 11/10/2021 16:31

Thanks all! I'm all for helping people in need but I wasn't sure if it was a scam. I've actually heard of it lots in the town I was visiting and other places nearby. I don't actually live there, I live in a village nearby but never happened to me before anywhere.

It is a quiet town where everyone speaks to each other there but that doesn't mean there's no crime. In fact, crime has increased. I think social media doesn't help. My local town has been listed as this nice safe area to live in newspapers, Facebook etc which encourages people to come to the area and commit crime in now recent years almost like we weren't expecting it. I'm not saying in any way this man was a criminal. He actually seemed very well spoken (first impressions) but in general terms crime isn't non existent in small towns!

OP posts:
couchparsnip · 11/10/2021 16:30

I do a direct debit donation once a month to a local shelter. I feel less guilty for saying no to people begging for money because I know I'm probably helping them indirectly anyway.

Vanuatu · 11/10/2021 16:30

Sorry @hoolihan

Stupid auto correct

Vanuatu · 11/10/2021 16:29

@hooligan
Thank goodness for some empathy at last.

If I have change I will always give what I can and I am far from well off.

Who are we to judge?

GoodnightGrandma · 11/10/2021 16:28

I wouldn’t have given it.
We’ve got lots of people begging in town and they’ve got ‘pimps’ that take the money off them.
They also share a dog that sits there all day.

MajesticallyAwkward · 11/10/2021 16:27

YANBU, genuine or not you're never obliged to give anyone money.
I'm a little suspicious of anyone approaching me to ask for money, I've heard of people being robbed when they take purses out to give money or phones snatched when asked for the time. I think it's a small minority but it does make you a bit more cautious.
Where I live there is a well known group of beggars that aren't homeless or needy in any way, they arrive in town in their very nice cars and set up near the parking machines asking for change because if you're paying for parking you have change.

nocluewhattowritehere · 11/10/2021 16:26

It was only £2, not that serious. If I could have spared it then I would have given it

Upsky · 11/10/2021 16:25

I always keep a few coins in my pocket for rough sleepers and buskers.
I just think they are all someone's son or daughter.

Kaceya2230 · 11/10/2021 16:22

@keepingmumred

He's not going to attack you for your purse in a busy street. So yes yabu
I didn't necessarily mean him at all but I'm just not used to carrying cash. Makes a bit edgy at the best of times! I'm usually cashless tbh!
OP posts:
LittleMysSister · 11/10/2021 16:22

@SirenSays

I'd have given him the change but I'm probably in the minority that would here on MN, judging by how these threads usually go.
If I have it, I always give change when people ask me for train fair. I am not usually carrying loads of notes for anyone to spot though, so that's not a concern.

I just think if it's genuine then I've helped someone get home, and if it's not then what does it really matter? The person is still usually desperate and it doesn't harm me to handle over a couple of quid.

Also I'm mentally scarred from almost missing a flight home when younger because my dad's wallet had been stolen whilst on holiday (last day), and the rest of us didn't have any cards/cash. We had to go around the other passengers on our flight asking them to lend money to pay the country's exit tax so that we could board & transfer it back to them straight away when we got home, and almost everyone said no and wouldn't help at all. Luckily one man was kind enough to help us and my dad paid it back to him asap when we arrived home. It was so stressful and awful, so now I always help when I can. Paying it forward!

Kaceya2230 · 11/10/2021 16:20

@Fraine

I had this last week, a homeless man asked for change quite nicely and when I said I didn’t have any, he said he will accompany me to a cash machine (Hmm) and when I said I didn’t have my bank card, he just gave me a dirty look and stormed off.
Oh god, that's awful! There is a high Amount of homeless men and woman (mainly men though) in my nearest town (actually live in a village) and I've always found them to be lovely and never expect a thing! I'm sure the guy you had the experience with is just in the minority!
OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 11/10/2021 16:18

This thread again demonstrates perfectly why the country is in the state it's in. People would rather demonise the homeless asking for a bit of change than consider how structural imbalances in other words poverty leads to people scouring the streets begging for one or two pounds.

Kaceya2230 · 11/10/2021 16:18

@Tilltheend99

You are being reasonable to not give any change if you didn’t want to but you are being unreasonable to assume that if he sore your notes he was going to rob you.

He probably didn’t need change for the bus as wasn’t near a bus stop. A few times I have come across people genuinely needing money for train/bus over the years some examples are tween/teens, people with learning difficulties, elderly woman. Would hope people would use common sense as there are times when people genuinely need a helping hand.

I didn't necessarily mean him. I just wasn't happy getting my purse out with substantial money in it in the town! I don't usually have cash either!
OP posts:
FluffyWhiteBird · 11/10/2021 16:17

@ilovesooty

Plenty of compassion for those who deserve it

How would we manage without arbiters of who deserves a bit of charity? Hmm

but that doesn't include drug addicts

Oh well. At least your judgemental attitude is transparent.

There is no "we". I manage my own affairs, make my own choices and hold my own opinions. Other people are free to think and act differently, that's the beauty of living in a free country.
Theunamedcat · 11/10/2021 16:16

I tend to keep a few bits of change in my pocket for people like this but only because some have got aggressive with me when I haven't had a clear exit so I developed a strategy if I can clearly get away/around them I say sorry no and carry on with my day if I can't then I give them the cash saying sorry its all I've got

Hoolihan · 11/10/2021 16:14

@icedcoffees I have and I've discovered that you're full of shit, lol

Swipe left for the next trending thread