Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please tell me I did the right thing not giving change to this man.

207 replies

Kaceya2230 · 11/10/2021 13:58

I've heard many times that people have had other people approach them in the street asking for money for a train fair or what not and often it's a scam. Never experienced it myself until today... possibly!

In a town centre, I popped into boots and I noticed a man sitting on the bench outside. I only took notice because he had a super cute dog with him. The guy looked pretty normal. As I left the shop he asked if I could help him - he was £2 short on a train fair and asked if I could spare a pound. I said no I'm sorry I don't carry change.

I did have change but in my purse I had money from my grandma for something. Some money for other things. I was worried if I opened it and he seen the notes I had I may be a target. I don't actually usually carry any cash but today I did have some on me for once!

But he was really nice. He just saying okay thank you and I went on with my day. He wasn't persistent or pressuring. Have I just ruined someone's day by not giving him any money?

To add the train station is quite a distance from where he was sat down so didn't sound convincing.

Would you have given change?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ALongHardWinter · 14/10/2021 18:58

A few months ago,I was sat with a friend in my local high street. A scruffy looking woman approached us, practically in tears,and said she'd been mugged,could we give her a fiver so she could get the train home? My friend very kindly gave her a five pound note. She took it, quickly walked away and joined a man who'd been standing in a nearby shop doorway. She waved the fiver at him,saying 'Result!',and they both hurried off laughing.

Owl55 · 13/10/2021 20:00

Same thing happened to me , nice polite man said he was short of train fare , I gave him a fiver as I had nothing less , he then ran to the betting office across the road!🤷‍♀️

CityMumma78 · 13/10/2021 09:17

You’re not obliged to give a stranger money, plus like you said you had notes in your purse and were on your own which made you feel more vulnerable. Don’t worry, you’re not a bad person.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 13/10/2021 08:59

Remembered another one, I was scammed by a lady who asked for change. Took my purse out and gave her a note as I didn't have change.
Go to buy something later and all my notes are gone!!! Literally did it I front of my eyes, still don't know how.
So won't open my purse now. For those saying they always give, try living in a busy part of London, you'd be broke in no time as there are so many.
I was a documentary about homelessness but can't remember the name. The guy stayed in the streets for some weeks and befriended a lot of the homeless people. Turned out a lot of them weren't homeless at all. A few were travelling to London daily to beg. I remember a guy who had a house in Leeds and travelled from there. There was a guy who owned a house in London, Fulham who said he couldn't earn what he makes begging in a proper jobs and liked the flexibility.
There are genuine cases but there are places for them to go, there are places to get food, a lot of Churches are also open to sleep in.
Enabling them to stay on the streets by giving them money doesn't encourage them to change.
To OP, YANBU at all.

If I was walking with a friend and she decided to give, I wouldn't stop her but I also wouldn't expect her to ask me to give. It's a personal choice.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 13/10/2021 08:59

There are always the same beggars in our town centre - very obviously of non-local origin, and all having the same placard with exactly the same wording, in the same handwriting.

I’m afraid don’t give them anything. Having some time ago seen a TV prog. about it, I’m pretty sure they’re run by gangmasters from Eastern Europe. The programme - incidentally presented by a Romanian national - was about Romanian gangmasters, and included shots of some of their palatial villas in Bucharest.

For years there was a home grown beggar, with dog, always there in the High Street. I often gave him a couple of quid - until the local paper revealed that he had his own flat - owned, not rented - and plenty of cash in the bank.
He was never seen there again.
I do give regularly to homeless charities such as the Sally Army, Crisis, and St Mungo’s. But never on the street any more.

A dd once bought a burger for a man in central London, with a ‘Homeless and Hungry’ placard.
He told her to fuck off, he wanted money.

One story I liked, though, was of the police station where a homeless man often sat outside. He was there as usual on Christmas Day - one of the police took him out a Christmas dinner from their canteen on a tray, plus a packet of fags.
Some sanctimonious prick objected to the fags - they shouldn’t be ‘encouraging’ the poor sod to smoke.

Pythonista · 13/10/2021 08:38

Why are people making it about having a go at the homeless. This is about the scamming cunts who have hijacked the generosity of the public

SpidersAreShitheads · 13/10/2021 02:39

Orla1970
*Some of the language on here describing fellow human beings is truly awful. Many many people end up on the streets and with a drug/alcohol issue because of significant trauma in their life. Not many people think when I grow up I’d like to have a heroin addiction and be homeless. Often it’s a combination of complex factors.

If you don’t want to give people money that’s your personal decision of course but all the names and derogatory language is unnecessary. This assumption that everyone is a scammer is way off too. If you don’t want to help. That’s your choice. Just try to be kind. Kindness costs nothing
This.

And often the same people who talk about needing a glass of wine / gin after looking after their kids or a long day at work. They "deserve" the gin and a bit of pleasure but the poor sod sleeping rough with maggots in his feet* somehow doesn't.

He doesn't deserve any money because he'll only spend it on wine. [{ here's your mirror }]

seen with my own eyes on a young guy with absolutely no hope left in his body through years of abuse and neglect

@MeredithGreyishblue and @Orla1970 - completely agree with both of you. These threads always break my heart.

People who say they won't give them money because they'll drink/buy drugs and won't ever get out of the cycle - what, you think without your crappy £2 they're going to magically get clean and go to rehab? Addiction just isn't like that. And personally when someone is sleeping rough on the freezing cold and dangerous streets, I don't begrudge them having a can of cider if that's what their addiction needs right now.

I worked as a volunteer at a food shelter for a considerable time and homelessness and addiction are so complicated. In our area, the shelters would only help people out with ongoing accommodation if they were willing to get clean right away. Some addicts just aren't able or ready to do that, and there are so many reasons for this. We had one of our older gents freeze to death outside the cathedral in the winter. I cannot tell you how utterly fucking sad homelessness and addiction are. He could have had a long-term place but wasn't able to consider stopping drinking, so all we could offer were the temporary overnight shelters which are massively oversubscribed every night.

There was a woman at the shelter, a heroin addict and as I got to know her I found out we were the same age. Her story was so sad, so much trauma, and she'd made a series of relatively trivial bad choices that ultimately led to addiction. Her bones were crumbling and she looked like a pensioner. She'd lost a child. A decade on and I still think of her sometimes - the phrase of "there but for the grace of god go I" has never been more appropriate. I'm not a big drinker, and a don't take drugs. I'm about as far from an addict as you'll find as I don't like the loss of control - but I still think that it only takes a couple of wrong turns in life, some twists of bad luck, and anything really could happen.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with not giving money to someone who asks. I don't judge anyone for that. But at the same time, try and consider what someone sleeping rough or even in a shelter might be experiencing. A little compassion goes a very long way.

Mamanyt · 13/10/2021 01:33

This is what my father told me, and it's been my guide since then (although I never give what I cannot afford)..."Better, in the end, that it is on his conscience to take what he did not need than it be on mine that I did not give what I easily could have."

But not everyone one feels like that.

And, @jimmyhill , it isn't odd at all. Too easy to say, "I don't HAVE 20 pounds. Most people will have 2. You ask for what is easy to give.

PrincessFiorimonde · 12/10/2021 23:59

@VladmirsPoutine

I give a bit of change as and when I can. It's not for me to police what homeless people do with the money I give them. If I were homeless I'd probably want to buy a drink too.
Haven't RTFT, but this is my feeling too.
Pythonista · 12/10/2021 23:19

@Dnaltocs

I’d have to give them whatever I had just in case it was genuine. I was thinking what I’d do if I was short of money or in a situation where I did genuinely need money. We constantly hear of folk needing soup kitchens, food banks etc Life is not good for some people. I’m sure their ambition was not to be begging.
That's fine, just know that whilst you are being kind, you are adding to the problem of people being harassed by these scammers
Dnaltocs · 12/10/2021 23:15

I’d have to give them whatever I had just in case it was genuine.

I was thinking what I’d do if I was short of money or in a situation where I did genuinely need money. We constantly hear of folk needing soup kitchens, food banks etc
Life is not good for some people. I’m sure their ambition was not to be begging.

Bertiebiscuit · 12/10/2021 23:01

Tbh I never give to beggars, there are so many in London I would be cleaned out in a week, they all have mobile phones cigarettes and booze - which I can't afford, and I think men have a cheek asking any woman for money when we earn less, also I've had some very nasty experiences with abusive men who wobt leave me alone or call me names, why would I reward such toxic male behaviour - I give them all a wide berth

Pliudev · 12/10/2021 22:43

I once came over all Lady Bountiful and bought a sandwich for a young woman who was begging. I thought she might be veggie so got cheese and salad. She opened the bag, sniffed and said'I prefer ham' and gave it back to me.
Taught me a lesson. I don't give money to beggers now.

HeartsAndClubs · 12/10/2021 22:12

Let's hope one of you who do not give ever end up where these people are. Begging is a criminal offence so they have to ask for something that doesn't seem like vegging. Bus or train fare is an obvious answer. Giving 50p is a, way towards a, hot meal, a up of coffee or a bed for the night. And doesn't break the bank. I worked for moew than 25 years with homeless people Inc rough sleepers. Many are clean and well spoken, some have dogs. But a kind word and a small token should never be too much to ask. A tiny minority may be scamming you. The majority only want what you have and may be trying really hard to get there. They do not need a kicking. and it’s this kind of attitudes that helps scammers to prosper.

And the scammers really are the majority not the minority.

Every town has homeless shelters where the homeless can get a bed for the night. Often people offer to buy food which is rejected in favour of cash.

Nobody should be giving cash and thus fuelling the drugs trade and everything which goes hand in hand with that.

It’s sad that anyone has become dependent on drugs, but we shouldn’t be contributing to it.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 12/10/2021 22:09

I've had a few of these. One asked for £5 for the tube as she was short. Gave her 10 and she literally went to the person right next to me and did the same. Felt so foolish.
Another was begging on the district line, a lady opposite me gave him a few coins and he say "come on, you can do better than that". I kid you not, she got a note out of her purse for him. Then came over to ask me and got nothing.
Another one was a guy being dropped off from an audi outside Sainsbury's by his partner, gave her a kiss, went to the boot and took out an old worn coat and sat down by the entrance to beg as she drove off.
Helping is one thing, being taken advantage of is another.

Maskless · 12/10/2021 22:01

PS in my more naive days I gave £20 to a woman begging and she must have followed me home without me noticing, because after that she kept banging on my door demanding more money.

Maskless · 12/10/2021 21:58

OP, you sound very young. So here's some helpful advice.

Never, ever give money to homeless or beggars in the street. If they look genuine, cold, hungry etc offer to buy them a takeaway cup of soup, a Big Mac, a sandwich or whatever is available at a nearby shop.

Every town has a homeless project which supplies them with everything they need. They beg in the street mainly to collect enough money to get a "hit" of some toxic drug, which only perpetuates their poor situation in life, or booze, then they get drunk and either hurt themselves or create an unsafe atmosphere for lone women walking past.

If it's on your conscience donate a few pounds a month to the local homeless charity.

Dojacatpaws · 12/10/2021 21:54

I give money if its easy to get out

Ddot · 12/10/2021 21:50

Buy the dog a treat next time, that's what I do

Ddot · 12/10/2021 21:48

Similar thing! apparently he had lost his train ticket. I had a bus tripper ticket but was almost home, id just got off the bus and decided to walk the rest of the way, so offered him the ticket not really legal but nobody would have known. I then had to endure a verbal rather blue tongue lashing by the little shit. He then asked someone else and was offered another bus ticket, he stormed off most perturbed

Cantstopthewaves · 12/10/2021 21:31

@Mirw

Let's hope one of you who do not give ever end up where these people are. Begging is a criminal offence so they have to ask for something that doesn't seem like vegging. Bus or train fare is an obvious answer. Giving 50p is a, way towards a, hot meal, a up of coffee or a bed for the night. And doesn't break the bank. I worked for moew than 25 years with homeless people Inc rough sleepers. Many are clean and well spoken, some have dogs. But a kind word and a small token should never be too much to ask. A tiny minority may be scamming you. The majority only want what you have and may be trying really hard to get there. They do not need a kicking.
I don't want my 'small token' to be the £2 that, after begging all day, affords them that bottle of whiskey that kills them.
liveforsummer · 12/10/2021 21:31

The cute dog was probably stolen and kept in horrible conditions when not begging. We had a huge ring if beggars last year that kept the dogs (expensive fluffy pedigree types) locked in trailers on the back of their mobile homes (not homeless either) when not at their post but as they were provided with food and water the SSPCA couldn't act. Keep your money on your pocket

Pythonista · 12/10/2021 21:21

@Mirw

Let's hope one of you who do not give ever end up where these people are. Begging is a criminal offence so they have to ask for something that doesn't seem like vegging. Bus or train fare is an obvious answer. Giving 50p is a, way towards a, hot meal, a up of coffee or a bed for the night. And doesn't break the bank. I worked for moew than 25 years with homeless people Inc rough sleepers. Many are clean and well spoken, some have dogs. But a kind word and a small token should never be too much to ask. A tiny minority may be scamming you. The majority only want what you have and may be trying really hard to get there. They do not need a kicking.
And the one who followed me around town demanding £20 because I had been stupid enough to give her a couple of quid a few times?
Mirw · 12/10/2021 21:12

Let's hope one of you who do not give ever end up where these people are. Begging is a criminal offence so they have to ask for something that doesn't seem like vegging. Bus or train fare is an obvious answer. Giving 50p is a, way towards a, hot meal, a up of coffee or a bed for the night. And doesn't break the bank. I worked for moew than 25 years with homeless people Inc rough sleepers. Many are clean and well spoken, some have dogs. But a kind word and a small token should never be too much to ask. A tiny minority may be scamming you. The majority only want what you have and may be trying really hard to get there. They do not need a kicking.

NewlyGranny · 12/10/2021 21:04

I'll buy people food or a hot or cold drink rather than give money, but I always ask what they want first. If they only want cash I usually decline. One guy wanted a sandwich but he wanted me to eat with him, so we had lunch in a Pret together and shared stories of our families. He was headed for Gregg's but I steered us into Pret.

Swipe left for the next trending thread